Read Manhattan murder mystery with its analysis


See Full Analysis here

Scene 1 -  Manhattan Murder Mystery
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 9
  • Plot: 7
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 9
MANHATTAN MURDER MYSTERY



Screenplay by

Woody Allen & Marshall Brickman




NOTE

Most of the sequences in this production are filmed using a
hand-
held camera or a Steadycam. These very mobile cameras move
around
the set, and get constantly closer and further from the
characters. Still, we'll be using the usual technical terms,
such
as «long shot» or «full shot» or «medium shot» here and
there to
give the reader an idea of the location of the camera at the
beginning of each sequence. And then we'll mention the
movements
of the camera.


TRISTAR LOGO
Winged white horse flying over clouds


BLACK SCREEN

CREDITS IN WHITE LETTERS ON BLACK SCREEN

We hear jazz music during the credits.

END OF CREDITS

NEW-YORK - AERIAL VIEW - EXTERIOR NIGHT

While the camera is flying over New-York, we keep on hearing
the
jazz music.

The camera reaches a round building that looks like a
stadium and
starts moving around the building.
HOCKEY GAME - INTERIOR NIGHT

Long shot on the skating rink. A hockey game is in progress
on the
rink. The camera follows a player, and then pans on the
audience.

The camera stops on a medium shot of Larry and Carol, a
couple in
their early fifties. Larry seems fascinated by the game, but
Carol
seems to find it boring. She looks at the ceiling, and then
puts
her hand over her mouth to suppress a yawn. Larry turns
toward
her.

LARRY
Come on.

CAROL
What?

LARRY
You promised to sit through the entire hockey game without
being bored and I'll sit through the Wagner opera with you
next week.

CAROL
I know, honey, I promised. I know.

LARRY
I already bought the earplugs.

CAROL
Yeah. Well, with your eyesight, I'm surprised you can see
the puck.

The crowd starts yelling and we guess that one of the
players has
done something really good. Carol mockingly claps her hands.

CAROL
Yay, hooray.

Then she raises her eyes to the ceiling, seeming more bored
than
ever.

LARRY'S BUILDING - LOBBY - INTERIOR NIGHT

A nice-looking apartment building in New-York.
Full shot of the lobby. We see the street through the glass
door.
An uniformed attendant is standing near a counter, on which
he is
writing on a book.

Larry and Carol are coming from the street and entering the
building. He is carrying some shopping bags, and she is
reading a
newspaper, the «Daily News».

LARRY
God. I can't wait to get into bed and stretch out.

CAROL
Yeah.

The attendant slightly turns around and bows to them. They
bow
back to him. He goes back to his book-keeping, and the
couple
keeps on walking through the lobby.

LARRY
You know, there's a Bob Hope movie on television later.

CAROL
know. Can you believe this guy in Indiana ? Killed twelve
victims, dismembered them and ate them.

LARRY
Really ? Well, it's an alternative lifestyle.

CAROL
Yeah, I'll say.

They reach the two elevators. Larry presses the call-button
on the
wall between the two elevators.

LARRY'S BUILDING - ELEVATOR - INTERIOR NIGHT

Medium shot inside the cabin of the elevator. The inner door
slides open. Carol enters first, still reading her
newspaper.
Larry enters behind her and presses a button on the control
panel.

PAUL (voice over)
Hold the elevator.
LILLIAN (voice over)
I'm coming.

Hearing people's voices, Larry puts his hand on the edge of
the
door to keep it from closing.

PAUL (voice over)
Hold the elevator.

Paul and Lilian enter the elevator. They are a middle-aged
couple.
He is bald and tall, and very smily. She is small, with grey
hair.

LILLIAN
That's right.

PAUL
Thank you.

Lilian has a broad smile when she recognizes Larry and
Carol. The
elevator door slides shut. Lilian looks at Carol.

LILLIAN
I, uh, I see you at the gym sometimes.

CAROL
Oh, you do ?

LILLIAN
Yeah, we live in the apartment down the hall.

CAROL
Oh, well, I go whenever I have the discipline.
LILLIAN
It's important to put that time in. It does wonders.

CAROL
Oh god, yeah. I agree with you.

LILLIAN
Exercising changed my life.

CAROL
Well, geez...

LARRY
I prefer to atrophy. I'm not a very exercise person.

PAUL
We bought a treadmill last week.

CAROL
Oh, well, we had one. But you know, we got rid of it
because it was just taking up too much space.
LILLIAN
Oh, it-it-it...

LARRY
Because you have to turn it on and get on it once in a
while. That was her problem.

LILLIAN
Hey, I... exactly, I... and it's so confusing, with all
those buttons and computerized programs. I'm just never
gonna get that.

LARRY'S LANDING - HALLWAY - INTERIOR NIGHT
Genres: ["Comedy","Drama","Mystery"]

Summary Larry and Carol are a couple in their early fifties who become embroiled in a murder mystery. The scene opens with the couple at a hockey game, and then follows them as they return to their apartment building and ride the elevator with a friendly middle-aged couple.
Strengths "The witty dialogue and humorous exchanges between characters establish a lighthearted tone that draws the viewer in from the start. The setting is also well-established through the use of New York City landmarks and locations."
Weaknesses "The scene lacks significant plot or character development, instead serving to set the tone and introduce the characters. Some viewers may find the slow pacing or lack of action unengaging."
Critique The scene sets up the characters and their relationships well and establishes the setting effectively. There is a good use of dialogue to reveal character traits and give insight into their personalities. The conversation flows naturally, and the lines are delivered convincingly. The use of the camera is also well done, with the handheld and Steadycam shots creating a sense of immediacy and intimacy. Overall, the scene works well and sets up the story effectively.
Suggestions Overall, this scene sets up the characters and their relationships well, but there are a few suggestions to make the scene more engaging and visually interesting:

1. Add more movement to the camera during the hockey game. Rather than just panning to the audience after following a player, the camera can move around the rink to create a sense of action and excitement.

2. Give the characters more action during the elevator ride. Instead of just standing still, they could shift their weight, adjust their clothing, or fidget in some way to create more visual interest.

3. Consider adding more sound design to the scene. In addition to the jazz music during the credits, there can be more ambient noise in the hockey game and elevator to create a more immersive experience.

4. Rewrite the dialogue in a more natural, conversational tone. Some of the lines feel a bit stiff and rehearsed, so adding more pauses, interruptions, and overlaps can make the dialogue feel more authentic.



Scene 2 -  The Invitation
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 7
Full shot of a very sober and modern hallway. Creme-colored
walls,
grey carpeting, dark wooden doors.

We hear the elevator door opening and Carol comes out,
followed by
Lilian, Larry and Paul. They all talk together and we can
hardly
understand the following dialogue.

CAROL
Oh, I know. It's late.

LILLIAN
It's so wonderful, meeting.

CAROL
Oh, well, yeah.

PAUL
It is just like New York. You have neighbors. You never
meet them... You guys...

The following line, said by Lilian, is clearer and we
understand
it better.

LILLIAN
... I've seen you so many times in the hallway, you know...
and I've always wanted to come up and say hallo.

PAUL
Well, anyway... good night.
Larry and Carol walk away from Lilian and Paul, who remain
near
the elevator.

CAROL (voice over)
Good night. Such a lovely couple. You know that...

Paul bends down to pick up something on the carpet. Lilian
walks
one step in Larry's direction.

LILLIAN
Oh, uh, say, hello ?

Paul starts opening his apartment door, just across the
hallway
from the elevator.

CAROL (voice over)
Huh ? Yeah ?

LILLIAN
Huh, listen... why don't you come in for a-a-a second and
have a drink with us ? I mean, we'd really love that.

The camera pans around toward Larry and Carol. Larry makes a
negative sign with his hand.

CAROL
Oh, oh well that'd be fine...

PAUL (voice over)
She makes great Irish coffee.

Mute conversation between Carol and Larry. Larry evidently
doesn't
want to accept Lilian's invitation, but Carol wants to.

LILLIAN (voice over)
Oh, please ? Uh uh, I want you to give me a treadmill
lesson.

LARRY
There's a movie on television I want to watch.

Carol starts walking toward Lilian and Paul's apartment,
followed
reluctantly by Larry.

The camera pans around during Carol's next line, and we see
Carol
entering Lilian an Paul's apartment.

CAROL
Oh, about the tread... oh, well, if I can figure it out,
then believe me, anybody can.

She laughs, and Larry, entering the apartment behind her,
utters a
forced laugh.
PAUL'S APARTMENT - BEDROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT

The cosy apartment of middle upper-class people. The
decoration
looks like them.

Medium shot of Lilian walking across the bedroom toward the
large
double bed. She walks near the famous treadmill.

LILLIAN
Have a look at the instructions. They drive me crazy. You
know ? I don't know what I'm doing at all. Let's look...

CAROL (voice over)
No. Please, it's easy.

Lilian picks up a book on a table near the bed.

LILLIAN
Wonderful book they've given me. Now I'm at level five.

CAROL (voice over)
What ?
LILLIAN
That I know.

CAROL (voice over)
You're that advanced ?

LILLIAN
Well, yeah.

CAROL (voice over)
God, I only got to level two.

Lilian brings the book to Carol.

LILLIAN
Look at these diagrams. Do you believe this ?

CAROL
That's amazing.
She is standing near the treadmill. Lilian shows her one of
the
diagram in the book.

LILLIAN
I can't understand this even.

CAROL
Let me see.

LILLIAN
Yeah, well. See this ?

CAROL
Okay.

PAUL'S APPARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT
One of the wall could be a bay window, but, for the moment,
it is
entirely covered by a beige drape.

Medium shot of Paul bringing a stamp book to Larry.

PAUL
Now, let me show you a mint 1933 airmail. Very rare... and
very beautiful.

Larry is seated near a small table, on which Paul puts the
book
down. Paul sits down next to Larry.

LARRY
Yeah.

Paul picks up a special philatelist magnifying glass and
puts it
in front of the stamp, for Larry to have a better look at
it.

PAUL
Look at that. And this plate block is quite unique because
it has a flaw in the engraving. See if you can see it.
Larry, who is not interested in philately at all, scratches
his
head.
LARRY
Uh, it's hard for me.

PAUL
Actually I'll give you a little hint. Right down here in
the corner.
LARRY
That tiny thing there ?

PAUL
Interesting, yeah.

LARRY
Ah, you have a really...

PAUL
That makes it quite valuable, you see. And I just got a
commemorative set of issues that are going to be quite
valuable, too.

He picks up a transparent envelope inside which are several
stamps.

LARRY
Yes.

PAUL
Look at the color, right there. All these are gonna become
a real f...

Larry stands up.

LARRY
Well, listen... we're probably keeping you up, right ?
PAUL
Oh, no-no-no. This is wonderful.

LARRY
I should be going.

PAUL
What do you do, if I may ask ?

LARRY
Me ? I'm in book publishing. I work up at Harper's.

PAUL
Are you really ?

LARRY
Yeah.

PAUL
I own an old, uh, cinema. Having it redone.
Genres: ["Mystery","Drama","Comedy"]

Summary Larry and Carol return to their apartment with a friendly couple, Lilian and Paul, and are invited to their apartment for a drink. Carol wants to accept, but Larry doesn't. In Paul's apartment, Lilian shows Carol a book with diagrams of her treadmill while Paul shows Larry his stamp collection. Eventually, Larry insists on leaving.
Strengths "Well-written dialogue that adds dimension to the characters."
Weaknesses "Lack of clear plot progression or tension."
Critique Overall, the scene has good structure and provides clear descriptions of settings and character actions. However, the dialogue is somewhat unclear and may be challenging for actors to perform convincingly. Some of the lines feel forced and lack natural flow. Additionally, the scene lacks a clear conflict or driving force, which may make it less engaging for viewers. More emphasis on character motivations and relationships could help build stronger emotional stakes within the scene.
Suggestions Here are some suggestions to improve the scene:

1. Start the scene with a clear establishing shot of the hallway and elevator to establish the location and time of day.

2. Use shot reverse shot technique to make the conversation clearer and easier to follow.

3. Add more action and blocking to the characters to make the scene more dynamic and interesting to watch.

4. Rewrite the dialogue to be more natural and relevant to the characters and their relationships.

5. Add more character development and exposition to make the audience care more about the characters and their situation.

6. Use lighting and color to create a mood and tone that helps to convey the emotions of the characters and the scene.

7. Use sound design and music to enhance the mood and tone of the scene and to convey information and emotions that are not explicitly stated in the dialogue.



Scene 3 -  Stamp Collections and Dinner Plans
  • Overall: 7.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 6
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 8
LARRY
Oh.
PAUL
Used to have a string of three, but, you know, business is
not what it used to be.

He picks up some more stamps from the table.

PAUL
Now, look at these presidentials. Look at the color work.
Even the perforations are still intact.

LARRY
Where's Carol ?

PAUL
All the...

LARRY
Because I should really be going, actually.

PAUL
Oh, really ?

LARRY
Yeah. I mean, so, we...

In the background, behind Larry, we see Carol and Lilian
entering
the room.

LILLIAN
Coffee's ready !

LARRY
Oh, coffee. I forgot coffee.

He turns around to face the women.
PAUL (voice over)
Good. We can get back to this later. Come on in.

We see Paul's hand on Larry's shoulder, pushing him toward
the
centre of the room.

A little later.

Full shot of the room. They are all seated around a low
table,
Larry and Carol on the sofa, Paul and Lilian on two
armchairs.
They've just finished their coffee.
LILLIAN
Well, we've never had any children, but it's easy to
empathize. Oh, um, uh, what college does your son attend ?

CAROL
Brown.

LILLIAN
Oh.
PAUL
Nice color.

They all laugh.

LILLIAN
Paul never attended college. He's self-made.

PAUL
Always regretted it. I think knowledge is the second most
important thing. First is health, then knowledge, then
money.

Larry puts his cup down on the low table.

LARRY
You know, it's amazing how time, we,... we'll just...

LILLIAN
And, do you work ?

Larry stands up.

CAROL
Huh ? Do I ?

LILLIAN
Yes.

Larry looks at Carol and sits back on the sofa.

CAROL
Oh, well, I actually, um, I used to work at an ad agency,
but that was many years ago.

The camera moves closer to Carol and Larry.

CAROL
But... You know, I've been seriously thinking of starting a
little restaurant. But, well, Larry, he's trying to talk me
out of it.

LARRY
Oh, she's a great cook, though, really. Her duck and fennel
omelette on a bed of scallops and Hollandaise sauce with
truffles and sweetbreads'll make you snap into a fetal
position and have you in bed screaming for a month.

CAROL
He loves to tease me, but actually, he really loves exotic
food.

LILLIAN
My weakness is any rich dessert, cream, butter, anything
with fat.

CAROL
Oh, really ? Oh well, let... listen... I'll fix you a
dessert that'll make your eyeballs roll up. You'll have to
exercise for a month to work it off.
LILLIAN
Yeah.

PAUL (voice over)
We're going to Le Cirque for our anniversary.

CAROL
No, really ?

The camera moves around, away from Larry and Carol, to Paul.

LILLIAN (voice over)
Yes. Twenty-eight years. November.

CAROL (voice over)
Really ?

PAUL
Well, what do you buy the woman who buys everything ?

The camera moves around backward, away from Paul and back to
Larry
and Carol.

LILLIAN
We already have twin cemetery plots.

LARRY
Well, it's... I always think a Bentley is in good taste.
You know, or you can go the route that I went with her. On
her twentieth, I got her some very lovely handkerchiefs.

CAROL
Yeah. Oh no. But, you know, they had my initials on them.
LARRY
Yeah, it was a very, very high-class item. I didn't even
know her size. I'm going over.
Carol bursts out laughing.

Black screen. Actually, we are in :

LARRY'S APARTMENT - FRONT HALL - INTERIOR NIGHT

Carol and Larry's apartment is quite different from the one
we've
just left. It is the apartment of a couple of New-York
intellectuals, with nice, artistic furniture. We hear a door
opening.

LARRY
Jesus, couldn't you keep the conversation going a little
longer in there ?

Lights are switched on.

Full shot. We see only part of the hall, the camera being in
a
corridor, and the walls of the corridor concealing part of
the
hall.
Carol enters the apartment, and Larry holds the door for
her.

LARRY
I was signaling you frantically.

Larry closes the door.

CAROL
I was just trying to be neighborly.

LARRY
Neighborly ? If this guy showed me his stamp collection one
more time... I mean, my favorite thing in life is to, you
know, look at canceled postage.

The camera follows Larry walking in the corridor toward :

LARRY'S APARTMENT - BEDROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT

Actually there are two large beds in the bedroom, the room
being
divided by a partition set between the two beds. The
partition is
only a half wall. There is a opening, without door, at each
end of
the partition, to go from one section of the room to the
other.

CAROL (voice over)
Oh, come on, Larry. It was sweet. They, you know, they're
looking forward to their anniversary.

Medium shot of Larry taking his jacket off. He puts it on a
chair.

LARRY
Oh, and I'm looking forward to seeing that Bob Hope movie.
I don't know why they put it on so late.

The camera turns back to the corridor and Carol, still in
the
front hall.

CAROL
You know, do you think that's gonna happen to us ?

LARRY (voice over)
What ?
Genres: ["Drama","Mystery"]

Summary Larry and Carol socialize with their neighbors Paul and Lilian, revealing some personal information about themselves. Larry becomes increasingly annoyed with the conversation and eventually insists they leave.
Strengths
  • Well-written dialogue
  • Good character development
Weaknesses
  • Lack of plot development
Critique As a screenwriting expert, I would start by saying that this scene seems to lack a clear objective or conflict. It feels like a conversation designed to showcase the characters and their personalities, rather than drive the story forward.

Additionally, the scene contains a lot of unnecessary detail, such as the discussion about stamps, desserts, and anniversary gifts. While these details might add some nuance to the characters, they feel disconnected from the main story and risk losing the audience's attention.

Finally, the dialogue feels a bit stilted and forced, with characters delivering lines that don't come across as natural or realistic. Overall, the scene could benefit from more conflict and direction, as well as tighter, more naturalistic dialogue.
Suggestions My suggestion would be to add more action and depth to the scene. Maybe Larry can have a more defined goal or conflict that he is trying to achieve or overcome. This could add tension and make the scene more engaging for the audience. Additionally, it would be helpful to give the scene some context and background to make it more meaningful for the overall story. For example, why is Larry and Carol's relationship important to the plot? How does their conversation with Paul and Lillian impact the story? Adding in these elements can make the scene more impactful and relevant to the film as a whole.



Scene 4 -  Date Night and Neighborhood Chats
  • Overall: 7.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 6
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
Carol walks in the corridor, toward the bedroom.

CAROL
Well, that we'll become like them ? You know, just another
dull aging couple, you know, with our little walks, you
know...

She walks into the bedroom.

LARRY (voice over)
We are a dull aging couple.

CAROL
Our TV, our lox and bagels. And... and our twin cemetery
plots ?

Larry is seated on his bed. Carol looks at some pills
bottles on
the night table.

LARRY
No, we should be as lucky as them. To, you know, to be in
their physical shape, at their age ? They look great. Did
you see the dumbbells this guy lifts ? If I lifted
dumbbells like those, I would get a hernia the size of the
San Andrea's Fault.

CAROL
How often do you think they make love ?

She goes out of the main part of the room, and the camera
follows
her.

She sits down on the other bed and starts taking her shoes
off.

LARRY (voice over)
Oh, you know, probably more than we do, in their shape. You
know, I'm sure as much as once a week.

CAROL
Larry ?

LARRY (voice over)
I'm exhausted. What ?

CAROL
Do you still find me attractive ?

LARRY (voice over)
Of course. What kind of question is that ? Of course I do.

Carol stands up from the bed and moves across the room. The
camera, still located in the main part of the room, follows
Carol,
so we don't actually see her walking, but we see the
partition and
the large clock on it.
CAROL (voice over from behind the partition)
Yeah, but we're not turning into a pair of comfortable old
shoes, are we ? Do you think ?

Carol reappears on the other side of the partition.

LARRY (voice over)
Never comfortable.

CAROL
No ?

Larry's head appears in the forefront of the shot. He is
still
seated on the bed.

LARRY
I don't think you have to worry about that.

MARKET PLACE - EXTERIOR DAY
Long shot on a large outdoor antique market place in New-
York.
The camera pans along the stands in the market, showing
sellers
and customers.

LARRY (voice over)
How you guys doing ?

SY (voice over)
We're fine.

MARILYN (voice over)
We're good.

SY (voice over)
We like that. We're gonna get this one.

MARILYN (voice over)
That's very nice, actually.

LARRY (voice over)
So, actually...

MARILYN (voice over)
Listen, are we going to see you at Elaine's Thursday ?

CAROL (voice over)
Oh, no. Thursday's our Wagner opera.

Medium shot on a stand around which Larry, Carol, Sy and
Marilyn
are standing. Sy and Marilyn are a couple about the same age
as
Carol and Larry.

MARILYN
Uh...hum. You know... Ted's coming to Elaine's with us.

CAROL
Ted.

MARILYN
Yeah.

CAROL
How is Ted ?

MARILYN
He's... he seems to be doing well. I mean, I... I actually
think he's glad... I think he's glad he's divorced.
SY
Well, I don't think he's... no, he's not doing... Come on,
he's not doing well at all. He's not used to it.

MARILYN
Well he looks... I think he looks, you know, like he's
glad.

Sy looks at some of the antique displayed on the stand.

SY
Yeah, yeah. This.
LARRY
So what do you want to do ? you guys gonna browse, or...

SY
No, we're gonna go to a movie.

MARILYN
Yeah, we're gonna go see «Double indemnity».

CAROL
Oh, really ?

MARILYN
Yeah.

SY
Why don't you come with us ?

MARILYN
It starts in a little while.

MOVIE THEATER - INTERIOR NIGHT

Full shot of the screen of the theater, on which the film
«Double
Indemnity» is shown. And under the screen, in the dark, the
back
of some of the spectator's heads.

This film is a very famous 1944 film directed by Billy
Wilder, and
referred by the Library of Congress as one of the hundred
best
films of the Twentieth Century. The term «double indemnity»
refers
to a clause in certain life insurance policies that doubles
the
payout in cases when death is caused by certain accidental
means.
BARTON KEYES (played by Edward G. Robinson)
I'd have the police after her so fast, it'd make her head
spin. They'd put her through the wringer. And brother, the
things they would squeeze out.
WALTER NEFF (played by Fred MacMurray)
They haven't got a single thing to go on, Keyes.

BARTON KEYES
Oh, not too much, I guess. Just twenty-six year
experience... All the percentage there is, and this hunk of
concrete in my stomach.

The third character in the sequence, Phyliss Dietrichson,
played
by Barbara Stanwyck, is half-hiding behind a wall.

NEW-YORK - LARRY'S RESIDENCE STREET - EXTERIOR NIGHT

Full shot of the street, where Larry's apartment building is
located. The camera is set near the entrance of the
building, and
Carol and Larry are walking toward us.

CAROL
God, that movie was great, wasn't it ?

LARRY
Yeah, I... I... it was one of my favorites.
CAROL
I loved it.
Genres: ["Comedy","Romance"]

Summary Larry and Carol watch a movie and chat with their neighbors about Ted's divorce and upcoming events.
Strengths "Good character development and dialogue."
Weaknesses "Lack of plot development and low stakes."
Critique
Suggestions 1. Increase the stakes of the scene: While the dialogue is naturalistic, it lacks a clear sense of urgency or purpose. Consider what the characters need in this moment and what obstacles are in their way. What is at risk if they don't get what they want?

2. Use visual storytelling: The scene is heavy on dialogue and light on action or description. Consider how you can use the camera to tell the story visually and show us what the characters are feeling. For example, instead of having Carol simply walk into the bedroom, show us her body language, the way she's hesitating or moving with purpose.

3. Cut out unnecessary dialogue: Some of the dialogue feels repetitive or doesn't add anything new to the scene. Consider trimming any lines or exchanges that don't advance the plot or reveal something important about the characters.

4. Add more conflict: The scene could benefit from more tension or conflict between the characters. What are they fighting for, and what's at stake? Consider introducing a new source of conflict that will add complexity and interest to the scene.

5. Make the dialogue more specific: The dialogue often feels clichéd or generic. Consider making the lines more specific to these characters and their unique personalities and perspectives. For example, why does Carol worry about turning into a "comfortable old shoe?" What experiences or memories inform that fear?



Scene 5 -  Unexpected Tragedy
  • Overall: 7.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 7
LARRY
It just... they were all so wonderful, in the picture.

CAROL
You know, who could we fix Ted up with ? I mean, there must
be somebody in your office.

LARRY
Ted ?

CAROL
Yeah.

LARRY
Well, I don't know. Ted... I always thought Ted had a crush
on you.

CAROL
Me ?
She laughs. They have reached their building. The camera
turns
around to follows them inside the building. Larry puts his
hand on
Carol's back to guide her inside the building. We see an
ambulance
revolving light reflected in the glass door of the building.

LARRY
Yeah. Why are you so stunned ? I think that...

CAROL
Please. I mean, you know, I adore him, but you know, he's
like a girlfriend to me.

LARRY
Uh. Now he's divorced, you know ?
CAROL
Do I detect a note of jealousy ?

The camera is still on the sidewalk near the entrance of the
building and we see Carol and Larry walking toward the
elevators.

LARRY'S LANDING - HALLWAY - INTERIOR NIGHT

A short black screen, which actually is just a close shot on
the
outer door of the elevator. This door slides open, and we
get a
medium shot of Larry and Carol inside the elevator.

They seem surprised by what they see on the landing. There
is a
gathering of neighbors, which we don't yet see. But we hear
their
voices.

NEIGHBOR (voice over)
I had to come up here and call nine-one-one.

ANOTHER NEIGHBOR (voice over)
So what's the trouble ?
ANOTHER NEIGHBOR
Oh, is that the-that the E.M.S.

ANOTHER NEIGHBOR (voice over)
That guy's so excited.

ANOTHER NEIGHBOR (voice over)
The doctor and the E.M.S.
The camera follows Larry walking toward the group of
neighbors.
Paul's door is wide open.

LARRY
What's the matter ? What's going on ? What happened ?

He is answered by a tall male neighbor.

TALL NEIGHBOR
She had a heart attack.

CAROL (voice over)
Oh my God !

TALL NEIGHBOR
Sh-She's dead.

The camera turns around to show us inside the apartment.
There is
a stretcher standing in the corridor. On the stretcher, a
body -
Lilian's body - is covered by a white sheet. Three men are
standing near the stretcher, one of them wearing green
gloves and
writing on a clipboard, another one carrying a black leather
case
(he is evidently a doctor).

LARRY (voice over)
She-she's dead ?

CAROL (voice over)
Dead ?

NEIGHBOR (voice over)
They're giving Mr. House a sedative right now. He's running
around like crazy.

The camera turns back to the tall neighbor standing near the
front
door. A policeman enters the apartment.

TALL NEIGHBOR
I called E.M.S. and they got here as soon as they could,
but it was too late.

LARRY
Sh-We just met her last night.

The camera turns back inside the corridor. The doctor is
coming
toward the front door.

OLD FEMALE NEIGHBOR (voice over)
Awful, just awful.
LARRY (voice over)
What happened ?

DOCTOR
Well, it was a classic coronary. She just went like that.

The camera turns back toward the group of neighbors.

CAROL
Is there anything we can do ?

LARRY
Oh, my God.

DOCTOR (voice over)
You can be good neighbors. You know, we calmed him down,
uh...

LARRY
Th-Th-Th-The first time we saw them was last night. We just
met them. W-We had... They invited us in for coffee.

TALL NEIGHBOR
Such a... S... Such a nice lady.

OLD FEMALE NEIGHBOR
Nice lady.

NEIGHBOR WITH A MOUSTACHE
Sweet person.

NEW-YORK - LARRY'S RESIDENCE STREET - EXTERIOR NIGHT

Full shot on the entrance of Larry's building. Larry and
Carol are
coming out. They are very elegantly dressed, Larry wearing a
suit
and a necktie.

CAROL
God, okay.

LARRY
You look wonderful.

Paul is coming down the street toward the entrance of the
building. He is carrying some grocery in a paper bag.
CAROL
Oh, hallo.

PAUL
Hi.

CAROL
Hi, Mr. House, so... sorry.

PAUL
Thank you so much for those wonderful flowers.

Paul seems very relax. He smiles a lot, which could be
surprising,
when we understand he put his wife in the grave only a
couple of
days ago.

CAROL
Oh.

PAUL
It was quite nice of you.

CAROL
That's... sure.

LARRY
If there's anything we can do. You know, anything you need,
just tell us and we'll...

CAROL
No, anything. Anything at all. I mean, God, it's just such
a shock when anyone... It was just so sudden. I mean, she
seemed so... God, well, healthy.

LARRY
Yeah.

PAUL
She had a heart condition.

CAROL
She did ? She never mentioned it... It... that she was...

LARRY
Ah.
Genres: ["Mystery","Drama"]

Summary Larry and Carol return to their apartment building to encounter a gathering of neighbors, and discover that one of the friendly couple they'd just met earlier, Lilian, had died of a heart attack.
Strengths "This scene effectively creates an emotional impact and sets up the mystery element of the story."
Weaknesses "There are no major weaknesses in this scene."
Critique This scene is well-written and effective in creating a sense of shock and sadness. The dialogue is natural and realistic, with some moments of humor that help to lighten the mood before the grim reality is revealed. The character's reactions to the news of Lilian's death are believable and nuanced, with Larry and Carol initially stunned and then trying to offer comfort to Paul. The camera work is also effective, with the use of sound to create an off-screen presence for the other neighbors and the ambulance. The only critique would be that some of the dialogue could be trimmed down to make the scene tighter. Overall, a strong scene that effectively sets the tone for the rest of the story.
Suggestions One suggestion to improve this scene would be to add more emotional depth to the characters' reactions to Lillian's death. Larry and Carol seem relatively unaffected and their conversations about fixing Ted up or whether or not he had a crush on Carol feel out of place in the context of the scene. Adding more genuine shock and sadness to their reactions would make the scene feel more authentic and relatable to the audience. Additionally, adding more visual cues to the setting, such as showing Lillian's home décor or personal effects, could help establish her as a character and make her death feel more impactful.



Scene 6 -  Desserts and Dreams
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 9
PAUL
She wouldn't have.

CAROL
No. Right. Well...
LARRY
If there's anything we can do.

CAROL
Yeah, anything. Really.

LARRY
You know, if you need anything, if you are lonely, come by.
You know.

PAUL
Thank you. You know, you owe me a wonderful French dessert.

CAROL
Oh, no, no, no. I know, I haven't forgotten. Believe me, I
haven't forgotten.

PAUL
Well, have a nice time. You seem all gussied up.

CAROL
Yeah. Oh, I know. We're going to the opera.
PAUL
Oh, enjoy.

LARRY
My favorite, my favorite.

PAUL
Goodnight.

He walks away toward the entrance of the building, still
smiling a
lot and looking very happy. Carol looks at him with a
question on
her face.

LARRY
Goodnight.

CAROL
Goodnight.

LARRY
Come, we're gonna be late.

THE METROPOLITAN OPERA HOUSE - EXTERIOR NIGHT

Long shot on the Met building.

We hear the music from Wagner's The Flying Dutchman.
The camera slowly tilts down. We don't see Carol and Larry
yet,
but we hear their voices.

CAROL (voice over)
The deal was, I sit through the ice hockey game and you
watch the whole opera.

The camera is now on ground level, and we see Carol and
Larry
coming out of the Met.
LARRY
I can't listen to that much Wagner, you know. I start to
get the urge to conquer Poland.

They cross the esplanade in front of the Met.

ELAINE'S RESTAURANT - INTERIOR NIGHT

Elaine's is a cosy place, like there are many around
Greenwich
Village.

Carol and Larry are eating at Elaine's with Sy, Marilyn and
Ted.
Ted is a quite handsome man in his forties.

We get a medium full view of the party, with a very mobile
camera
moving around the table and going from one person to
another,
getting closer to one person, then moving slightly away.

SY
I'll tell you something. I think it's weird. I mean, listen
to this. One night she's having coffee, and the next night
they are carrying her out in a rubber bag.

CAROL
Oh, I know, I know. And she did not look like she was ready
to go.

TED
Maybe this guy killed her, you know ? Like, he's got, like,
a young tootsie stashed someplace, or something.

LARRY
No, no, not this... you gotta, you gotta see this guy. This
guy gets his jollies from licking the back of postage
stamps. He's a-a boring old...
TED
Well, I can see that. Yeah, depending on whose picture is
on the stamp.

CAROL
She never once mentioned that she had a heart condition.

LARRY
Well, what is she gonna say ? Oh, yeah, hello, I'm Mrs.
House and I have a bad heart.

CAROL
Well, she had no problem telling me about her hysterectomy
in the first five minutes.

SY
It is much easier to talk about a hysterectomy than it is
to talk about a heart condition.

TED
You said she liked... she liked eating high cholesterol
desserts. Is that what you said ?
LARRY
So, she had one too many.

CAROL
No. No ! She wasn't on a diet. We discussed diets.

LARRY
So she wasn't on a diet. But...

TED
This would be a really great way to kill somebody.

SY
How ?

TED
You clog their arteries with whipped cream, chocolate
mousse, butter. They go like that.

Carol is laughing very heartily at Ted's joke.

SY
That's great.

LARRY
I like a... It's disgusting.

TED
you know what I mean ?
LARRY
It's disgusting, but a... It's fatal.

TED
Wouldn't that be great ?

MARILYN
I'd like to French-pastry myself to death right now.

SY
I'll help you.

MARILYN
I really would.

SY
All right.

MARILYN
In fact, I'd like another piece of pie, right after this.
Do I dare ? I like yours better than this.

TED
Are you gonna start a restaurant ? Are you serious about
that ?

MARILYN
You really should. you're a great cook.

TED
Because, if you do, count me in. I wanna be part of that.
Really.

LARRY
Really ?

MARILYN
You should.

CAROL
No. Well, I don't know. I mean, you... Are you serious ?

TED
Yeah. Oh, oh, God, it'd be wonderful.

LARRY
What are you encouraging her for ? It's so...

TED
She's great. She's a great cook.

LARRY
I know, but...

CAROL
Well, it's thanks to you, actually. I mean, it was his
idea. The cooking lessons, so I mean...

TED
Yes, I had...

SY
Yes, but a restaurant is a serious business. I mean, you
just can't take that lightly. You can't be cavalier about a
restaurant.

CAROL
I'm not being cavalier about it.

LARRY
Do you know how time-consuming it is ? Yeah. You have to be
there every night.

SY
Absolutely.

LARRY
You'd be stuck there, you know.

TED
Wait. Look, look.

LARRY
They steal from, if you're not... You gotta be hap...

CAROL
But it's bi... it's what I do. It's-It's what I do, Larry.

TED
She'll cook... She's great. She's-She's a pro. She's a pro.
She'll be cooking... She'll be cooking in the kitchen. I'll
be at the front, running the joint like Rick, you know, in
«Casablanca».
Genres: ["comedy","drama"]

Summary Larry and Carol socialize with their neighbors at a restaurant where they speak about personal matters and Ted's recent divorce. They return home to find that one of the couples they met earlier, Lilian and Paul, had encountered tragedy.
Strengths "The dialogue is witty and engaging and captures natural human interactions."
Weaknesses "The scene lacks a clear sense of direction and overall plot purpose."
Critique Overall, this scene showcases natural dialogue and character interactions, but there are some areas for improvement. Firstly, it's unclear what the scene is trying to accomplish, as it seems to be a collection of different conversations without a clear focus. The transition from the Met to Elaine's could also be smoother, as the audience has to infer that the group is heading to the restaurant. Furthermore, the camera movements could be more purposeful, as they currently seem random and without direction.

The scene also lacks subtext and conflict. Each character seems to be interacting with one another in a friendly, carefree manner without any underlying tension or purpose. It would be beneficial to add some conflict to the dialogue to create a more engaging and dynamic scene.

Additionally, the descriptions of the scene are lacking, relying mostly on dialogue without much visual detail. This makes it hard for the reader to envision the setting and fully immerse themselves in the story. The scene could benefit from more descriptive language and sensory details to enhance the reader's experience.

Overall, while the dialogue is realistic and natural, the scene could use more focus, subtext, and descriptive language to make it more engaging and immersive.
Suggestions Here are a few suggestions to improve the scene:

1. Give the characters more distinct personalities and voices. Right now, they all sound too similar.

2. Tighten up the dialogue to make it more engaging and interesting. Cut out any unnecessary small talk.

3. Add more conflict or tension to the scene. Right now, it feels too light and breezy.

4. Consider adding more visual elements to the scene to keep it visually interesting, especially during the long dinner sequence.

5. Make sure there is a clear purpose to the scene and that it contributes to the overall story.



Scene 7 -  A Night of Conversation and Tragedy
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 7
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 9
SY
It's not that easy.

MARILYN
You do it anyway. Right as well get paid for it.

LARRY
Right. Directs...

TED
I'm set, I'm serious about it. I don't... I mean, it's not
like a hobby. I mean, it's gotta be a serious thing.

SY
I'll be the first customer.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - BEDROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT
Medium shot of Carol coming out of the bathroom. She
switches the
bathroom light off. She is wearing a pink night dress.

The camera turns toward Larry's bed, in which Larry is
already
lying. He has a book in his hands.

LARRY
You know, I was thinking of fixing Ted up with Helen Dubin.
You know, I figured they would just, you know, get into an
argument over penis envy, or something.

CAROL
Oh.

LARRY
The poor guy suffers from it so...

Carol puts something on the night-table on her side of the
bed.

CAROL
Did he seem a little too cheerful ?

She looks at some pills bottles on the night table.

LARRY
No, he seemed like his regular self to me, but-but, uh,
when you brought up the notion of the restaurant... the guy
lit up like Mr. Glowworm.

CAROL
The restaurant ?

She picks up a hair brush.

LARRY
Yeah. He sees himself as, uh, you know, as Humphrey Bogart
in Casablanca. I-I see him more as Peter Lorre, wringing
his hands.
Carol starts walking toward the other section of the room.
The
camera follows her.
CAROL
No, no, no. No, no, no. I mean, Mr. House, Mr. House.
Didn't seem a little too cheerful to you ?

LARRY (voice over)
Mr. House, our next-door widower ?

Carol stops in front of a large mirror set on the wall in
one
corner of the room.

CAROL
Yes. Yes. I mean, there's... Well, you know. I mean, didn't
he seem too compose for a man whose wife just died. Don't
you think ?

LARRY (voice over)
Well, Jesus. What do you want the guy to do, walk down the
street sobbing hysterically ?
Carol starts brushing her hair.

CAROL
Well, I don't know. All I know is, they were supposedly
looking forward to their, you know... anniversary, and,
and, and, you know, uh-uh, i-i-if... I suddenly dropped
dead... wouldn't you sob for months, or-or years, if I...
You know...

LARRY (voice over)
Hey, don't make those kind of jokes, okay ? I don't like
those remarks. And, meanwhile, I'm the guy who needs a
physical check-up.

CAROL
Oh, I don't know.

LARRY (voice over)
Uh, uh.

Carol walks to a chest of drawers, on top of which she drops
the
hairbrush. Then she switches the lights off in the other
section
of the bedroom, and walks back to the bed.

CAROL
I mean, to me he just seemed a little too perky. You know ?
Now, suddenly he wants his French desserts, and, «Have a
nice time, you know, at the opera». And, my God, «We're
certainly dressed up». I mean, you know. This guy should be
a wreck.
She sits down on her side of the bed, and takes her socks
off.
While talking, Larry puts the book and his glasses on the
night-
table. Carol switches the light off on her night table and
gets
into the bed.

LARRY
Right. Meanwhile, I can't get the-the Flying Dutchman theme
out of my mind, you know ? Remind me tomorrow to buy up all
the Wagner records in town and rent a chainsaw.

He switches the lights off on his bed table. The room is
completely dark, and we hear the next sentences on a black
screen.

CAROL
Helen Dubin's wrong for Ted.

LARRY
Yeah ?

CAROL
She's too mousey.

LARRY
Well, he's a little mousey, too. They could have their
little rodent time. They can eat cheese together.

Carol bursts out laughing. The phone starts ringing.
LARRY
Oh, Christ.

He switches the light back on, puts his glasses on his nose
and
picks up the phone.

LARRY
Hallo ? Yes. Yes, of.... Yes, of course you woke us. You
know, not everybody's up at one o'clock in the morning
watching the porn channel. I'll put her on.

He gives the phone receiver to Carol.

CAROL
Who is it ?

LARRY
Ted. For you.

CAROL
Ted, hi.

RESTAURANT - INTERIOR NIGHT

Medium shot of Ted, dressed in a night-gown, and standing
near the
counter of a restaurant. The room is very dark, only lit by
a lamp
on the counter.

TED
I figured out how he killed her and made it look like a
coronary. He gagged her and tied her to the treadmill, and
then he turned the exercise program up to the Olympic
levels.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - BEDROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT

Carols bursts out laughing.
CAROL
No, no. You know, I mean, I just think this guy is too
perky. You know, I mean he's not acting like a man whose
beloved of twenty-eight years died just a few days ago.

Larry is trying to get the telephone cord, stretched from
his
night-table to the handset hold by Carol, away from his
face.

LARRY
Jesus, are you onto that ? My God, I thought you were just
joking.

CAROL
Yeah, I know.
Genres: ["Comedy","Drama"]

Summary Larry and Carol observe their neighbors and discuss their personal lives. They return home to find that one of the couples they met earlier had encountered tragedy.
Strengths "The witty banter between characters keeps the audience engaged and interested. The mix of humor and sadness creates a complex emotional landscape for the scene."
Weaknesses "The plot feels somewhat aimless and doesn't have a clear objective or throughline."
Critique Overall, the scene seems to lack focus and purpose. The dialogue between the characters is fragmented and disconnected. The scene jumps from a group conversation to a private conversation between Larry and Carol without any clear transition. The conversation between Ted and Carol seems completely out of nowhere and doesn't add anything to the story. Additionally, the scene could benefit from more visual descriptions to give the audience a better sense of the characters' emotions and actions. The lack of details makes it difficult to visualize the scene in our minds. The scene needs to be restructured and rewritten with a clearer purpose and more cohesive dialogue.
Suggestions Overall, this scene seems to be lacking in direction and purpose. Here are some suggestions to improve it:

- Add more context or build-up to the conversation between Sy, Marilyn, Larry, and Ted at the start of the scene. Currently, it just feels like random small talk that doesn't really set up anything later in the scene.

- Tighten up the dialogue and make it more focused. The conversation between Larry and Carol jumps around a lot and doesn't seem to have a clear point. Consider cutting some of the back-and-forth or adding more meaningful exchanges.

- Clarify what the characters are feeling or thinking. There are a lot of vague statements about how Ted is acting "too perky" or Larry needs a physical check-up. It's not clear what these characters are really worried about or what they want to happen next.

- Consider adding more visual elements or actions to the scene. There's a lot of talking, but not a lot of movement or detail. Adding some physical gestures, facial expressions, or setting descriptions could make the scene more dynamic and interesting to watch.

- Make the phone call with Ted more significant. Right now, it comes out of nowhere and doesn't seem to have much impact on the characters. Adding some urgency or intrigue to the conversation could make it more compelling and tie the scene together better.



Scene 8 -  Tragedy at Every Turn
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 9
  • Plot: 7
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
LARRY
Let me speak to him, all right ?

CAROL
What? Oh. Here. Just a sec. Here's Larr...

She gives the handset to Larry.
LARRY
Hey, listen. She was not murdered. She... she had a heart
attack. It was a coronary. There was a doctor there. He
said to.... He was an old man.

RESTAURANT - INTERIOR NIGHT

Close shot on Ted, drinking from a mug.
TED
How do you know it was a real doctor ?

LARRY'S APARTMENT - BEDROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT

LARRY
I'm not gonna touch that. I'm tired. I want to go to sleep.
Look...

RESTAURANT - INTERIOR NIGHT

Medium shot of Ted.

TED
Wait-wait-wait a minute, wait a minute, put Carol back on,
I called about something else. Listen, I know a great
location for a restaurant.

NEW-YORK - A YARD - EXTERIOR DAY

A yard in the middle of old New-York buildings.

The camera is located at the inner end of the passage
leading from
the street to the yard. We gets a full shot of Carol and Ted
coming from the street and walking toward us and the yard.

TED
Hah, look at this. Isn't this great ?
CAROL
Well, it's dark.

TED
Aren't these walls great ? A cave, you know, like you have
to go through a little cave.

CAROL
Oh, I see.

TED
And then you come out, to this here.

They have reached the yard. The camera moves back to get a
medium
shot of them both.

CAROL
Oh, look at this though. It's really so beautiful.

TED
Yeah. Isn't it great ?
CAROL
But... it's kind out of the way for a restaurant, isn't
it ?

TED
No, no... that's the appeal. That's just the appeal,
because it's... it's, I mean it's so romantic... tucked
away back in here like this.

The camera leaves Carol and Ted in the middle of the yard
and
moves up and around to show us the old building around the
yard.

CAROL (voice over)
Yeah.

TED (voice over)
And, you don't want street traffic. You want...

CAROL (voice over)
No.

TED (voice over)
you want a little out of the way spot that people hear
about and lovers go to.

CAROL (voice over)
Yeah.

TED (voice over)
It takes months to take a reservation, you know ? Very few
tables.

The camera moves down to ground level to give us a better
view of
the yard. It does look a bit neglected, with weeds growing
in
between the stones covering the ground. There are some trees
and a
small out-of-order fountain with a statue on top of it.
CAROL (voice over)
You know, you've really thought this out.

TED (voice over)
Oh, well, I used to come here all the time with-with July,
when we were married.

CAROL (voice over)
Uh uh. Right.

The camera moves back to Carol and Ted.
TED
Used to walk around here. Really beautiful at night. It's
gorgeous at night.

CAROL
It's beautiful, I bet.

TED
I used to think, «What am I doing here with July ? We don't
love each other any more», you know ? It made the moment
doubly poignant.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - CORRIDOR - INTERIOR NIGHT

Medium shot of the corridor, showing the front door. Paul
opens
the front door. Larry and Carol are standing in the doorway.
Larry
is wearing a necktie and Carol is carrying a large tray.

PAUL
Hi. How are you ?

CAROL
Hi. How are you ?

PAUL
Oh, my...

CAROL
These are my floating islands. I hope you like meringue.

Paul takes the tray from Carol's hands.

PAUL
I love it. Come on in, come on in.

CAROL
Well, okay.

PAUL
This is unbelievable.

Carol enters the apartment, followed by Larry.

CAROL
I know, it's just...

PAUL
Did you do it ?
Larry closes the door behind him.
CAROL
I did do it. I told you. Anyway, this has got... this is
vanilla sauce here and I put little chocolate truffles.

PAUL
Well, come on in.

CAROL
Do you like chocolate truffles ?

PAUL
Would you share it with me ?

LARRY
Oh, no. She made these just for you. This is...

CAROL
Oh, well...
PAUL'S APARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT

They all enter the living room.

PAUL
No, no, no, it's too much for one. I'll I make some coffee.
Please.

LARRY
They're only half a dozen.

CAROL
No, no, no. Look, I'll make the coffee. That'd be better.
Let me make it.

PAUL
Oh, you've already done so much.

CAROL
No, no. I insist, I insist. Go on, sit down, relax.

She takes the tray from Paul's hands.

PAUL
Aren't you nice.

CAROL
Enjoy yourself, you've been through enough.

She walks to the kitchen, carrying the tray.

LARRY
She worked on those for... How're you holding up ?
PAUL
Oh, I don't know. I was thinking after a while. I'd get
away from here. From this place and all its memories.
LARRY
Uh uh, so you have someone to go with, or are you...

PAUL
I have a brother in Florida.

LARRY
Oh, really ?

PAUL
I'm hoping he can get away for a while.
Genres: ["drama"]

Summary Larry and Carol return home to find out Lilian, who they met earlier, had died of a heart attack. They go to a restaurant with their neighbors and talk about Ted's recent divorce. They then visit a yard and discuss opening a restaurant. Later, they bring a tray of food to Paul, who they also met earlier, to console him over his wife's death. Paul talks about wanting to leave the city to escape the memories.
Strengths "The scene sets a somber tone with the theme of tragedy and unexpected loss. It adds emotional depth to the characters and conveys their empathy for their neighbors. The dialogue feels natural and authentic."
Weaknesses "The scene could benefit from more conflict and higher stakes to make it more engaging. Some of the dialogue feels repetitive and meandering."
Critique The scene lacks clear objectives and doesn't advance the story. The dialogue feels forced and doesn't sound authentic. The transitions between locations are choppy and unclear, which could confuse the audience. The characters also lack depth and dimension, making it hard for the audience to relate to or care about them. Additionally, the descriptions of the settings are too vague and don't provide sufficient visual information. Overall, the scene needs more purpose, authenticity, and clarity to create compelling storytelling.
Suggestions First, there is a need to clarify the location of the Restaurant and Larry's apartment. It is unclear where these locations are in relation to each other and the yard in New York.

Next, the dialogue between Larry and Carol in the beginning could be more concise and to the point. They should avoid repeating themselves and instead focus on delivering the news about the heart attack in a more succinct manner.

As for the scene in the yard, it's important to establish the visual of the setting before jumping into the dialogue between Carol and Ted. Consider adding more description of the space and its atmosphere. Also, make sure the dialogue feels natural and not forced, particularly when they discuss the restaurant location.

Lastly, in the scene at Paul's apartment, there's a need for more description of the characters' actions and movements. It's unclear what Paul is doing when he opens the door and takes the tray from Carol's hands. More description of their body language would enhance the scene and make it more engaging for the audience.



Scene 9 -  Discovering Paul's Secret
  • Overall: 7.0
  • Concept: 6
  • Plot: 7
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
LARRY
Good. It's a good idea.

PAUL
Do you like snorkeling ?

LARRY
Snorkeling ? No, no. I get nervous when brightly colored
fish are staring at me face to face, you know.
PAUL
Hey, I've got some stamps I wanted to show you.

He turns to his desk to pick up a stamp album.

LARRY
Oh, stamps. Well, that's...

PAUL
Come on, look at these.

The camera pans to the kitchen.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - KITCHEN - INTERIOR NIGHT

The conversation between Paul and Larry keeps going in the
living-
room but we can't understand the words.

Carol puts water in the glass jar of the coffee machine. She
puts
the lid on the jar and turns around to put the jar in the
machine.
She looks in the coffee plastic container and notices there
is no
coffee inside. She bends down and opens the cupboard door.
Not
finding any coffee in the cupboard, she closes it, stands up
and
turns around to look inside the cupboard above the sink. She
closes it, and bends down to look inside the cupboard next
to the
dishwasher. She seems surprised by something and pauses.
Then she
takes a copper funeral urn from inside the cupboard. She
stands up
and takes the lid off the urn. She looks inside the urn and
closes
it. She seems a bit shocked and bends down to put the urn
back
inside the cupboard. Then she stands up and looks absently
around
her.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT

A little later.

Full shot of the room. Larry and Carol are sitting next to
each
other on the sofa. Carol is drinking coffee from a cup, and
Larry
is staring, with his arms crossed on his chest, looking a
little
bored. Paul is sitting on an armchair and eating the
floating
islands from a plate he is holding in his other hand.


PAUL
This is very delicious.

CAROL
Thank you.

PAUL
You are an artist.

CAROL
Well, thanks very much. Uh, was it a large... funeral ?

PAUL
Oh, no. We had... very few friends, no family.

The camera moves closer to Larry and Carol.
CAROL
Right. Just a simple affair, uh ? Well, they're the best,
aren't they ?
PAUL
Yeah.

CAROL
I guess. Anyway, then you're laid the rest, and, you know,
I was just... where, um, where are the twin cemetery
plots ? We... because, we were thinking that that was just
such a romantic idea. Weren't we, Larry ? You know ?
Larry ? You remember when we were talking about the twin
cemetery plots and, you know, how kind of romantic that
is ? Remember ?

Larry looks at his wife. He has a little difficulty to come
back
into a conversation he wasn't following.

LARRY
Uh-huh. Yes, yes. We were. We were spending the eternity
with the beloved. I sound like... I sound like one of those
guys, now.

The camera pans to Paul. He has put his plate on the low
table.

PAUL
Yes.

CAROL (voice over)
Yes but, I was just wondering where, um, where is the
cemetery ?

PAUL
Oh, it's... uh, in... uh, it's in Nyack. We used to summer
there occasionally.

He wipes his lips with his napkin.
LARRY'S APARTMENT - FRONT HALL - INTERIOR NIGHT

Medium shot. Larry enters the apartment, followed by Carol,
who
then walks in front of him.

LARRY
What was all that stuff about twin cemetery plots ?

CAROL
Listen, Larry.

LARRY
You know ? I mean, we-we never discussed it at all, but I
knew that you were trying to tell me something, so I picked
up on it quickly.
He closes the door behind him.

CAROL
Listen.
LARRY
But I... You know, we...

CAROL
Okay, just... I was in the kitchen okay ? And I was making
the coffee. There were no beans, so, I was looking in his
cupboards, just to see, you know, and I came across this
urn, okay ? And I opened it and there were ashes in it.

LARRY
Ashes ? Funeral ashes ? Did you wash your hands ?

CAROL
Larry, he had her cremated !

LARRY
How did you know it was her, for Christ's sake ? They were
ashes. What, did they resemble Mrs. House ?

He walks into the living-room.

CAROL
Oh, and who else would it be, okay ?

Larry picks up his jacket from the back of an armchair.

LARRY
Anybody. Could it be, an associate, an old relative, his
accountant, his cat. Who knows ?

CAROL (voice over)
Right, right. Hidden, uh ? Hidden away ?

LARRY
What do you mean? Th-th-the guy didn't do anything.

The camera pans across the hall toward the kitchen. She has
a box
(cereals ?) in her hand.
CAROL
Look, Larry. All I know is he lied, okay ? He lied.

She puts the box in a cupboard above the sink. Then she
picks up
the phone on the wall.

LARRY (voice over)
Look. Maybe-maybe-maybe he is embarrassed. Maybe he didn't
want to spend eternity next to the beloved, so he-he told
us that-uh... You know, what's the difference ? Who are you
calling ?

CAROL
Ted !
Genres: ["Drama"]

Summary Larry and Carol return home to find out Lilian, who they met earlier, had died of a heart attack. They go to a restaurant with their neighbors and talk about Ted's recent divorce. They then visit a yard and discuss opening a restaurant. Later, they bring a tray of food to Paul, who they also met earlier, to console him over his wife's death. Paul talks about wanting to leave the city to escape the memories.
Strengths "Strong emotional depth and character development"
Weaknesses "Lack of immediate plot progression"
Critique As a screenwriting expert, I have a few critiques for this scene:

1) The dialogue between Larry and Paul feels a bit aimless and lacks a clear conflict or purpose. It could benefit from some clearer character motivations or stakes.

2) The transition to Carol's actions in the kitchen feels abrupt and disconnected from the previous conversation. It could benefit from a clearer link between the two scenes.

3) The dialogue between Larry and Carol feels more engaging and focused than the previous conversation, but it still lacks clear stakes or tension. It could benefit from clearer character arcs and goals, which would help drive the conflict and increase the drama.

Overall, this scene could benefit from stronger conflict, clearer motivation, and more engaging dialogue that drives the story forward.
Suggestions As a screenwriting expert, my suggestions to improve this scene would be to focus on the emotional conflict and tension between Larry and Carol rather than the conversation between Paul and Larry about snorkeling and stamps. Also, the discovery of the funeral urn with ashes inside should be a more dramatic and impactful moment, with potential for suspense or even horror, rather than just being mentioned in passing. Finally, the dialogue should be more concise and natural, with fewer interruptions and repetitions.



Scene 10 -  Late Night Tension
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
The camera pans back to the living-room and Larry. Larry
walks
behind a partition, still holding his jacket. The camera
follows
his movement.

LARRY
Oh, Jesus. Leave the guy alone. You know, he-he... he's a
poor widower, he wants to go on a vacation or something.

CAROL (voice over)
Yeah. Where ? Oh, I know where, ah ah. Snorkeling, right ?
Ah ah.

Larry puts the jacket on something we don't see because it
is
hidden by the partition. Then he picks up a brochure on a
low
table and walks toward the kitchen. The camera follows him.

LARRY
So what ? Different strokes. You know, he has fun, uh,
sitting at the bottom of the water, face to face with
squid.

Carol is still standing in the kitchen, with the phone
handset on
her ear.

CAROL
Oh, I know. I know. What about this ? What if they had a
big insurance policy, or something like that, huh ?

LARRY
Too much «Double Indemnity», you know ?

CAROL
Hu-Huh.
(speaking on the phone)
Hi. Yeah. Hi, it's me. Listen, we were just in our
neighbor's apartment, right ?

Larry walks away from the kitchen.
CAROL
Yeah. And get this. I came across an urn with ashes in
it. Only he says he had his wife buried.

TED'S APARTMENT - SITTING-ROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT
Ted is lying on a large comfortable sofa, sipping beer from
a
bottle.

TED
That's what you do if you don't want an autopsy. You don't
want something discovered, you know ? Like-like poison.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - KITCHEN - INTERIOR NIGHT

Carol is still standing up, the telephone handset stuck
between
her ear and her shoulder.

CAROL
Mm. Right. They'd have detected poison, wouldn't they ?

TED'S APARTMENT - SITTING-ROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT

TED
Uh, I don't know. There's a lot of different kinds of
exotic poisons, you know ?
LARRY'S APARTMENT - FRONT HALL - INTERIOR NIGHT

Full shot of the kitchen, seen from the hall. Carol is still
standing up but now she holding the phone handset with her
hand.

CAROL
Yeah, but why would he... Why would he be lying ? I mean,
why-why would he lie at all ?

Larry walks back into the kitchen.

LARRY
Jesus, you're up to poisons already. You guys are slipping
into a mad obsession.

CAROL
Yeah. Oh, would you do that ? Because... That'd be great.
Because, you know, I'm not good at that kind of thing,
okay ? All right. Okay. Well, I'll talk to you later. Okay,
bye.

She puts the phone back on its hook on the wall

LARRY
Let's go to bed. Could we go to bed, now ?

CAROL
Hey, I'm not tired.

LARRY
What do you mean, «You're not tired» ?

CAROL
You know, Ted's gonna check with the funeral home,
tomorrow.

LARRY
Great.
CAROL
You know what I mean ? I mean, I don't understand why
you're not, not more fascinated with this. We could be
living next door to a murderer, Larry.

LARRY
Well, New York is a melting pot. You know, get used to it.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - BEDROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT

Later in the night.

Medium shot on the bed. Larry is asleep, but Carol is not.
She
moves in the bed, and then sits up. She turns around, pats
her
pillow, and tries to lie back on her side. But she sits up
again,
looking around the room. Eventually, she gets out of the
bed.

She walks around the bed in the dark, and switches on the
lights
in the corridor. The camera follows her in the corridor.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - FRONT HALL - INTERIOR NIGHT
Carol switches the lights on in the hall, then she looks
into the
peephole in the front door.

CAROL
Oh my God !

The camera turns around toward the corridor. Larry is
getting out
of the bedroom, putting his slippers on.

LARRY
Hey, are you okay ?

Carol walks in the corridor toward him.

CAROL
Larry. Larry, I heard a noise. I-I-I heard a noise in the
hallway, so I just... I... You know, I-I looked and I
think... I think Mr. House was getting on the elevator.

Larry hops toward her, still trying to put his slippers on.
She
backs up and they are now both in the front hall.

LARRY
Yeah ? You're sure ?

CAROL
Yeah, you know, I was... I'm-I'm... almost certain that it
was him.

LARRY
So-So-So what ?

CAROL
Just, you know... I mean, who else could it be ?

LARRY
So what ? It's not a crime. He can get on the elevator.
CAROL
I know. I know. But wh-who would it be at one-thirty in the
morning ?

LARRY
Oh, Jesus. I was in a deep sleep. What-What's the
difference ?

CAROL
But, you mean, you know how we're always complaining about
living on the geriatric floor. Do you know what I'm
saying ? A joke ?

While Larry is answering her, Carol opens the front door and
peeks
into the hallway.
Genres: ["Mystery","Drama"]

Summary After learning about their neighbor's suspicious behavior, Larry and Carol become paranoid and investigate further.
Strengths "The scene builds tension and sets up a mystery that leaves the audience wanting to know more. The dialogue is natural and believable."
Weaknesses "The scene lacks a clear direction and focus. Some of the conversations feel repetitive."
Critique Overall, the scene is well-written and most of the dialogue feels natural and realistic. However, there are a few areas that could benefit from some adjustments.

Firstly, the camera directions can be problematic in a script because they are typically the purview of the director. It may be best to leave out specific camera movements unless they are essential to the story.

Secondly, there may be room for more subtlety in the dialogue. Some of the characters' lines feel a bit on-the-nose. For example, when Carol says, "Hey, I'm not tired," it's clear she's implying she wants to keep talking about the situation with their neighbor, but the line feels a bit forced. It may be more effective for the characters to reveal their emotions indirectly, through their actions or facial expressions.

Finally, some of the exposition could be tightened up. For example, when Carol is on the phone, she says "listen, we were just in our neighbor's apartment, right?" which feels clumsy. It may be more effective to find a way to convey this information more organically, such as through dialogue between Larry and Carol earlier in the scene.

Overall, however, the scene is engaging and well-paced, and the characters are realistic and relatable.
Suggestions Overall, the scene could benefit from a clearer focus or purpose. It seems to be a mixture of dialogue that explores the neighbors and their potential suspicious behavior and a subplot about Larry and Carol's relationship. One suggestion could be to streamline the dialogue to focus more on the mystery of the neighbor and less on Larry and Carol's banter. Additionally, the camera work could be more intentional in highlighting key moments, such as the discovery of the urn of ashes or the moment when Carol sees Mr. House in the hallway. Overall, there could be more tension building throughout the scene to keep the audience engaged.



Scene 11 -  Paranoia and Suspicion
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 6
LARRY
All right, so it was Mr. House. So he got on the elevator.
It's not a felony. The guy pays rent. He's entitled. I
mean, what... Can you go back to bed ? This is crazy. You
woke me up out of a deep sleep. I gotta get up early
tomorrow morning.
Carol closes the door, and walks toward the kitchen. The
camera
follows her.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - KITCHEN - INTERIOR NIGHT

Carol looks through a notebook.

CAROL
I know what I'm gonna do. I'm gonna ring him up. I'm gonna
ring his apartment. I'm gonna see if he's home.

LARRY (voice over)
You're gonna ring Mr. House, now ?

CAROL
Yes, because this is really...

LARRY (voice over)
What are you talking about ?

CAROL
It's very sus...

Larry joins Carol when she already has the handset in her
hand.
But she succeeds in dialing Paul's number.

LARRY
Don't ring Mr... What are you doing ? No, don't ring...

CAROL
Let me just... Larry, don't. Wait.

LARRY
Don't ring Mr. house. This is a widower. Leave the poor guy
alone. You're crazy. Stop it.
Carol listens to the phone.

CAROL
That's one ring.

LARRY
So you saw him go out. It's not a-not a crime.

CAROL
Okay, two rings. He's not there, yet.

Larry takes the handset from Carol's hand.

LARRY
Give me this. Give me this.
CAROL
What are you doing ?

LARRY
Look, if you want to find out if somebody left, just call
downstairs. Call the-the-the person at the desk.
CAROL
All right, I'll call. Just keep ringing.

LARRY
Ask if someone went out.

CAROL
Keep ringing.

LARRY
Yeah, um. Sure, I'm gonna keep ringing. You got it.

While Carol walks out of the kitchen, Larry puts the phone
back on
its hook on the wall.

CAROL
Oh, man.

Carol walks into the hall. The camera follows her.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - FRONT HALL - INTERIOR NIGHT

LARRY (voice over)
This is insane. What's gotten into you ?

Carol picks up the building internal telephone handset from
the
wall.

CAROL
I don't know. What is he doing ? Where is this guy at one-
thirty in the morning ? You know what I'm saying ?

LARRY (voice over)
It's not your business. He can go any place he wants.

CAROL (in the phone)
Hallo ? Yes, hallo. This is Mrs. Lipton. Yes. Did anybody
just leave the building ? I'm just... hmm. You're sure ?
You're sure no one ? No, okay. All right. Yes. Thank you.

While she was talking on the phone, the camera has moved
toward
Larry, standing at the entrance of the kitchen.
LARRY
Okay. Are you happy ?

We hear the noise of the phone being put back on its hook.

CAROL
I don't believe this. Man, I don't get it.

Larry joins his wife in the hall.

LARRY
Now, can we back to bed ?

CAROL
No.
LARRY
For crying out loud, it's no big deal. You're making a
mystery where nothing exists.

CAROL
Just let me think about this a second. Okay, I got it.
Wait. I know, it... No, wait. Listen to me. Larry...
Listen. He got on the elevator, okay ?

LARRY
You know, I'm gonna...

CAROL
No, wait. No, no, listen to this. No.

LARRY
I wanna go to sleep. I don't want to be standing here in
the middle of the night.

CAROL
I know. Larry, he got on the elevator and he took it to the
basement.

LARRY
Oh, great ! Great ! So what ? Now, what've you got ?

CAROL
He has a car, right ? He's got the garage door key, he
opened... he could... he has the...

LARRY
So what ? So what ?

CAROL
What do you mean, «so what» ? He's...
LARRY
What's the big deal ? So, the next-door neighbor went out
in the middle of the night and took his car. So, he went
someplace.

CAROL
All right. So, I'm right, though.

She starts walking back to the bedroom. Larry follows her.
The
camera remains in the front hall, filming them.

LARRY
That's all.

CAROL
I mean, I'm right.

LARRY
I mean, so you're right. So big deal.

CAROL
Yes, he isn't in his apartment.

LARRY
But this kind of right is gonna put us in the toilet. So,
you're right. You're suspicious.

CAROL
Yeah, that's right.

LARRY
It says more about your mind that about him.

CAROL
What about your rigidity ? How about that ?

LARRY
Get into bed. Get into bed.

CAROL
How about that point ?

LARRY
You're so... What's wrong with you ? Jesus !

They disappear in the bedroom.

NEW-YORK - LARRY'S RESIDENCE STREET - EXTERIOR DAY

Long shot on the crossroad between the street where Larry's
residence is located and another street. Carol is crossing
the
street. She stops walking while on the crosswalk. The camera
zooms
on her and we see an expression of surprise on her face.

Reverse angle long shot on the entrance of Larry's building.
Paul
comes out of the building. The camera zooms on him : he
looks
around him as if afraid to be followed.

Reverse angle shot on Carol looking at him from a distance.
She
enters her building. She smiles to the attendant on duty.

CAROL
Hi !

LARRY'S BUILDING - BASEMENT - INTERIOR DAY
Genres: ["drama","mystery"]

Summary Larry and Carol become increasingly paranoid and suspicious of their neighbor's behavior, leading them to investigate further.
Strengths "The scene successfully builds tension and suspense, creating a sense of growing paranoia in the characters. The camera work and music effectively complement the tone of the scene."
Weaknesses "Some of the dialogue and actions of the characters may come across as unrealistic or exaggerated at times. The scene may also be too slow-paced for some viewers."
Critique Overall, the scene is well written in terms of dialogue and pacing. The characters have distinct voices and their actions drive the plot forward.

One critique would be that there are a lot of unnecessary stage directions. For example, "The camera follows her" and "The camera zooms on him". As a screenwriter, it's important to understand that the director and cinematographer will handle the camera movements and framing. So it's best to only include essential action and let the visuals be interpreted and executed by the production team.

Another critique is that there could be more visual description of the setting and the characters. There are a lot of interior shots, but not much detail is given about the physical space or the appearance of Larry and Carol. Adding more visual detail can help create a more immersive and vivid experience for the reader and ultimately the viewer.

Overall, the scene is well written but could benefit from some streamlining and more sensory detail.
Suggestions One suggestion to improve this scene is to add more stakes and tension. Perhaps there could be a reason why Carol is so obsessed with Mr. House's whereabouts - maybe she suspects he is involved in a crime or has information that is important to her. This would make her actions more justified and less like she is simply snooping.

Additionally, Larry's reactions could be more nuanced. Instead of just trying to go back to sleep, maybe he could express more frustration and concern about Carol's behavior. This would add more conflict to their relationship and make the scene more engaging for the audience.

The dialogue could also be tightened up for better pacing. There are many instances of characters repeating themselves or talking in circles, which slows down the scene and makes it drag. By editing the dialogue for clarity and brevity, the scene could flow better.



Scene 12 -  Investigating Paul
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
Full shot of Carol walking down the staircase leading to the
basement. We see her through the glass panel of a heavy
metal
safety door. She opens the door.

CAROL
Jack ?

The camera follows Carol to a reverse angle shot showing the
workshop of Jack, the factotum caretaker of the building.
With a
screwdriver and a plier in his hands, he is working on
something
we don't see.

CAROL
Jack, do you think you could come upstairs today, because I
got a leak in the kitchen ?

JACK
Well, yeah. Yeah.
CAROL
You can ?

JACK
Sure.

CAROL
Well, but, it will be this afternoon.

JACK
But I... I got...

CAROL
All right, you're not gonna go now ?

JACK
I'll be back in about a minute.

Jack walks out of his workshop and along one of the basement
corridors.

CAROL
In a minute.

JACK
Okay, just wait a second. I'll be right back.

The camera follows Jack walking away.

CAROL (voice over)
Yeah. Okay. All right. Oh, God.

The camera turns around to a reverse angle shot on Carol,
still in
the workshop. She looks around, apparently looking for
something.
She peeks through the door of the workshop, to make sure
Jack is
not coming back too early. Carol rushes to a key-box on the
wall,
into which there is a spare key for every apartment in the
building. She selects a key, takes it out of the box and
puts it
in her pocket. Then she leaves the workshop toward the
staircase.

LARRY'S LANDING - HALLWAY - INTERIOR DAY

Full shot of the hallway. Carol comes out of the elevator,
and
looks around her. She walks back and forth in the hallway,
before
coming back to Paul's apartment door, just in front of the
elevator. She opens the door with the key she has just
stolen in
Jack's workshop.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - CORRIDOR - INTERIOR DAY

Full shot of the front door, seen from the living room. The
front
corridor is completely dark. The door opens and Carol walks
in.
She closes the door behind her.

Carol walks toward the living room, and the light coming
from the
windows.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - KITCHEN - INTERIOR DAY
Carol crosses the kitchen. She kneels down to look into the
cupboard where she had found the funeral urn. Apparently the
urn
is not there anymore.

NEW YORK - A STREET - EXTERIOR DAY

Long shot on a crosswalk in New-York. Paul is crossing the
street.

The camera zooms on Paul. He has almost crossed the street,
but he
suddenly stops a few feet from the next sidewalk. He feels
his
jacket : apparently he has forgotten something in his
apartment.
He turns around and starts walking back on the crosswalk.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - KITCHEN - INTERIOR DAY

Carol is still looking in all the cupboards of the kitchen.
She
gets out of the kitchen into the living-room.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - LIVING-ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

The camera pans around the room, following Carol, who looks
inside
every piece of furniture in the room.

NEW YORK - A STREET - EXTERIOR DAY

Medium shot of Paul walking along the sidewalk, going back
toward
his apartment.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - LIVING-ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Carol has picked up a few papers from a low table, and is
looking
at them. She puts her hand into her trouser pocket to get
her
glasses out. She puts her glasses on to have a better look
at the
documents she has found.

LARRY'S BUILDING - LOBBY - INTERIOR DAY

Through the window of the lobby, we get a full shot of Paul
coming
toward the entrance of the building. An attendant rushes to
open
the door for him.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - LIVING-ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Carol is sitting at the desk. She has opened the drawer of
the
desk and is looking through its content. She takes an Air
France
ticket folder out of the drawer and looks inside it. Then
she
picks up another one.

LARRY'S BUILDING - LOBBY - INTERIOR DAY

Medium shot of Paul entering the elevator.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - LIVING-ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Carol closes the drawer of the desk. She stands up and picks
up
the phone from the desk and starts dialing a number.

TED'S APARTMENT - SITTING-ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Full shot of the room, which is quite wide. Ted is seated at
his
desk, and the shot is taken from the other side of the room,
showing Ted's back. The phone rings. Ted picks it up.

TED
Hallo ?

PAUL'S APARTMENT - LIVING-ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Medium close shot of Carol speaking on the phone.

CAROL
Ted... I'm in his apartment.

LARRY'S BUILDING - ELEVATOR - INTERIOR DAY
Medium close shot of Paul inside the cabin of the elevator.
He
gives a quick look up to the floor numbers above the door.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - LIVING-ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Same shot of Carol on the phone.

CAROL
The urn is missing. It's gone. Yeah, I think it might have
been. He had this satchel last night. He was carrying this
bag, and I think that might have been what he had in his
satchel.

TED'S APARTMENT - SITTING-ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Close shot of Ted's back. He is still seated at his desk and
talking on the phone

TED
Listen, I'd get out of there right away, if I were you.
Genres: ["Drama","Mystery"]

Summary Carol steals a spare key from Jack's workshop and uses it to sneak into Paul's apartment. She searches through his belongings for information and discovers that the urn they found earlier is missing. She calls Ted to tell him and he warns her to leave immediately.
Strengths "The scene is fraught with tension as Carol searches through Paul's apartment. The suspense builds as Paul returns while she is still there. The stakes are high as they are investigating a possible crime."
Weaknesses "The dialogue is not particularly memorable or impactful. The scene may also be slow-paced for some viewers."
Critique Overall, this scene is well-written and effectively conveys tension and suspense. However, there are a few areas for improvement.

Firstly, the descriptions of the camera movements can be simplified. Instead of listing each shot and camera angle, the scene could be summarized in a more concise and direct way.

Secondly, some of the dialogue feels a bit clunky and could benefit from some editing to make it sound more natural. For example, the exchange between Carol and Jack about the leak in the kitchen feels a bit stilted and could be streamlined.

Lastly, there could be more visual cues to help the audience understand what is happening. For example, when Carol is searching Paul's apartment, it would be helpful to include some shots of what she is looking at to give us a better sense of what she is searching for.

Overall, this scene has potential and could be tweaked to make it even more effective at building tension and suspense.
Suggestions Here are some suggestions to improve the scene:

1. Consider adding more dialogue to establish characterization and backstory for Carol and Jack. This can help the audience connect with the characters and feel more invested in their actions.

2. Consider adding more visual elements to the scene to make it more engaging and visually interesting, such as close-ups or interesting camera angles. This can help keep the audience's attention and make the scene feel more dynamic.

3. Try to increase the tension and suspense in the scene. This can be achieved through the use of music, sound effects, or by increasing the stakes for the characters. This can help create a sense of urgency and keep the audience on the edge of their seats.

4. Consider tightening up the pacing of the scene to make it more efficient and streamlined. This can be done by cutting unnecessary dialogue or actions and focusing on the most essential elements of the scene.

5. Finally, consider how this scene fits into the overall story and how it advances the plot. Make sure that it serves a clear purpose and that it sets up future events in a clear and effective way.



Scene 13 -  Carol's Investigation
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 9
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 7
The camera moves around Ted, showing the typewriter he is
typing
on.
TED
No, no, no. Go, go, go. We'll do... We'll talk more from
your apartment.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - LIVING-ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Same shot of Carol on the phone.

CAROL
He's not going snorkeling with his brother. He's got two
tickets to Paris, and he's got reservations at the Georges
Cinq hotel with a woman named Helen Moss.

She turns around, because she feels she heard a noise in the
landing hallway.

LARRY'S LANDING - HALLWAY - INTERIOR DAY

One of Paul's neighbor is standing in the hallway, waiting
for the
elevator. He's got some documents in his hand. The elevator
dings
and the door opens. Paul comes out.
NEIGHBOR
Oh. Hi. How are you ?

PAUL
Good morning. How are you ?

Paul has his key in his hand and is ready to open his
apartment
door.

NEIGHBOR
Good. You got the notice on the... Uh, maintenance
increase ?

Paul turns around to look at the neighbor.

PAUL
No. When did that happen ?

PAUL'S APARTMENT - LIVING-ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Close shot on Carol, whispering in the phone and looking
toward
the front door.

CAROL
I'm gonna look around and see what else I can dig up here,
okay ? Yeah. I'm telling you, this is just... Ted, I-I'm
just dizzy with freedom. This is just... uh, this is just
the craziest thing I've ever done.

TED'S APARTMENT - SITTING-ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Close-up shot on the ashtray, where a cigarette is burning
slowly.
The camera pans to a close-up shot on Paul's face, still on
the
phone.

TED
Yes, it's crazy. But soon, we'll be too old to do anything
crazy. Go, leave, leave, leave.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - LIVING-ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Carol puts the phone down on the desk. She stands and turns
around
when she hears the front door opening.

Black screen shot on the front door in the dark of the
corridor,
then the camera quickly spins around to show Carol, standing
in
the living-room, with a frightened look on her face. She
walks
away from the room. The camera spins back to the front door,
which
opens. Paul enters and switches the lights on. He closes the
front
door, and walks along the corridor to the living-room.

Carol walks into the kitchen from the living-room.

The camera pans to Paul, looking for something on his desk.
He
looks through all the documents scattered on the desk.

The camera pans back to Carol, hiding in the kitchen, then
back to
Paul.
Paul opens both his hands in a gesture of despair :
apparently, he
hasn't found what he was looking for. He starts walking
across the
room, and the camera pans back to Carol in the kitchen. She
rushes
out of the kitchen.

The camera remains at the same spot, and we see Paul in the
living-room, still looking for whatever he is missing. He
walks
out of the living-room through the kitchen.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - BEDROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Paul enters the room, looking in the inner pocket of his
jacket.
He walks around the room, and opens a closet. He looks
through the
hanging clothes, and finds a few documents in one of the
jackets.
He closes the closet, and starts looking through the
documents he
has found. He puts them inside the inner pocket of his
jacket. He
starts walking out of the room, when the phone rings. He
stops and
picks up the phone receiver on one of the night-tables.

PAUL
Hallo.

Medium shot of Carol hiding under the bed. We notice she
doesn't
have her glasses anymore.

PAUL (voice over)
Oh, hi. Yeah. I know. I-I...Yes, I miss you, too. I did. I
made all the arrangements.

Back to Paul standing by the bed and talking in the
telephone.

PAUL
Yeah, look. I... Okay, I have to run. But I'll see you
later, okay ? Okay.

He puts the phone down on its hook, and starts walking out
of the
room. He stops, thinks for a couple of seconds, turns
around, sits
on the bed and picks up the phone.
Back to Carol under the bed. The bed frame hits her back
when Paul
sits on it. She looks up. We hear Paul dialing a number.

PAUL (voice over)
Extension five. Well, keep ringing, would you please ?
Because I just talked to her. What ? Okay. Uh, will you
tell her... yes, tell her that Tom called. Tom. Thank you.

Back to Paul sitting on the bed. He puts the phone down on
its
hook, stands up and starts walking out of the room.

Back to Carol under the bed, waiting for Paul to get out of
his
apartment.

NEW-YORK - A STREET - EXTERIOR DAY

Starting from street level, the camera tilts up along a very
modern office building, all glass and steel. A sign, above
the
main entrance, says «10 East 53». This is the building where
Larry's office is located.
LARRY'OFFICE - INTERIOR DAY

Full shot of a large office room. In the forefront, a
reception
desk, with a young female receptionist talking to someone we
still
don't see. Coming from the other end of the room, Larry is
walking
with Marcia, a tall dark-haired lady, wearing sunglasses.

LARRY
So, I thought your rewrites were great. I really think you
helped your book, you know ? It's... It's dense a little
bit, but, uh...

MARCIA
Well, I don't want it to be too transparent, I mean...
Genres: ["Drama","Mystery","Thriller"]

Summary Carol sneaks into Paul's apartment to look for evidence and discovers more about his suspicious behavior while Larry is at work.
Strengths "The scene is suspenseful and keeps the audience on the edge of their seat. It also reveals more about Paul's suspicious behavior."
Weaknesses "The scene is somewhat slow-paced and doesn't have much dialogue."
Critique The scene is well-described with clear actions and dialogue, but there are a few opportunities for improvement. Firstly, it is not clear what the overall goal or conflict of the scene is. While it is important for a scene to have some level of tension or conflict driving it forward, this scene seems to primarily serve as a means of conveying information to the audience.

Additionally, some of the camera movements and descriptions could be tightened up for a stronger effect. For example, the camera pans back and forth between Carol and Paul several times, which could become repetitive. Instead, focusing on one character at a time would allow for a more intimate look at their emotions and motivations.

Furthermore, the dialogue could benefit from some subtext or hidden meanings, as it currently feels straightforward and lacking in depth. By adding subtext, the scene could become more suspenseful and intriguing to the viewer.

Finally, it may be helpful to provide more context for the scene to give it greater significance within the overall story. Without context, the scene feels disconnected from the larger narrative. By providing more information about the characters' motivations and how the events in this scene impact the story, the overall impact of the scene could be heightened.
Suggestions The scene could benefit from more visual variety and dynamic shots. Currently, the majority of the scene is shot in medium and close-up shots, with little variation in camera angles. Adding in some wide shots or creative camera movements could give the scene more visual interest. Additionally, the dialogue could be trimmed in places to make it feel more concise and engaging. Consider adding more action or character movement to the scene, as much of it is dialogue-heavy and may bog down the pacing. Finally, the scene could benefit from more tension-building moments to increase the stakes for the characters and keep the audience engaged.



Scene 14 -  Poker Lessons and Paranoia
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 10
They are now at the reception desk level, and, since the
camera is
following them, we can see the young gentleman the
receptionist is
talking with.

LARRY
That's... That's something you're never gonna have to worry
about, you know ? This book makes «Finnegan's Wake» look
like airplane reading, you know ? But-But it's long. It's-
It's-It's...

They are now walking along a corridor.

MARCIA
You know, you're the only editor in the world I'll take
suggestions from, but even you shouldn't push it.

LARRY
No, I'm not pushing it. I think the book is great.
Absolutely great. You know, but, uh... how much, how much
of Dorothy is you? As I was reading it, I kept thinking how
much is... you know, how much did you base it on your own
life ?
They have now reached a smaller room, actually Larry's
private
room. Marcia takes her glasses off, and then her coat, and
sits on
a sofa.

MARCIA
Well, I was a waitress. I lived with a poet. I was a film
critic.

LARRY (voice over)
Right, but not-not a blackjack dealer, right ?

MARCIA
No, but I put myself through school playing poker.

The camera pans to Larry, who is standing up at the other
end of
the room, looking through some documents.

LARRY
Oh, really ? Do you still play ?
MARCIA (voice over)
No, but I still know how.
LARRY
Yes ? Are you good ?

MARCIA (voice over)
Yeah.

LARRY
Yeah, because maybe you could give me some pointers.

MARCIA (voice over)
I could turn your game around in two hours.

LARRY
Could you ? That's great. That's... you know, you-you have
all these skills, and you're beautiful, and you can write
so well... and now it turns out you play poker. This is,
uh, too good to be true.

Larry sits down with the pile of documents on his laps. The
camera
pans back to Marcia. She has a cigarette in her hand.

MARCIA
Well, I wouldn't say beautiful.

LARRY (voice over)
Oh, I would.

MARCIA
But I do have tremendous sex-appeal.

The camera pans back to Larry, who is looking through the
huge
pile of paper on his laps, perhaps a manuscript.

LARRY
Okay, you sold me. Are-are you seeing anybody ?

MARCIA (voice over)
No. Don't let my confidence fool you, it's a facade. Why do
you ask ?

LARRY
Because I have a friend who became single recently, and I-I
know he would get a big kick out of you.

MARCIA (voice over)
Oh. So, when do you want your poker lessons ?

LARRY
Uh, next week. I could take you to lunch. We could-we
could, um, I'll put you on my expense account, and you
could... teach me when to... bet and when to fold.

MARCIA (voice over)
How about a cheeseburger right now ?

The phone rings.

LARRY
Now ? That's a possibility.
Larry picks up the phone from a small table.

LARRY
You know, we could, we could do...
(talking into the telephone)
Hallo. Yes ? Where are you ?

The camera pans back to Marcia, who listens to Larry,
smoking her
cigarette.

LARRY (voice over)
Is everything okay ? Really ? No, I could, sure.

The camera pans back to Larry.

LARRY
I could. Yeah. I need-I need, you know, five minutes, or
so. Okay. Yes. Yes. I know where it is. Okay, hold on.

He puts the telephone down on its hook.

LARRY
I can't do it. I have to... My wife, I have a little thing
I have to do. I'll do the cheeseburger with you next week,
or something.

The camera pans back to Marcia, who is smiling.

MARCIA
Story of my life !

She crushes her cigarette in and ashtray and stands up.

NEW-YORK - A PARK - EXTERIOR DAY

Full shot of a round concrete pond, with a fountain in the
middle
pouring water. In the background, a meadow, with chairs
scattered
on it. Carol is standing by the pond. Larry is talking to
her,
looking very nervous.

LARRY
What do you mean, you snuck into his apartment ? Are you
nuts ?

CAROL
Oh, stop being such a fuddy-dud.

LARRY
A fuddy-dud ?

Carol starts walking around the pond. Larry follows her.

CAROL
Yeah.

LARRY
What are you talking about ? That's a crime. You can't do
that. You... That's-That's burglary and breaking and
entering. But... What has gotten into you lately ? For
crying out loud, save a little craziness for menopause.

CAROL
It was a cinch. I took the key and I just let myself in.

LARRY
Hey, look. Do... I don't want to... You-You'll wind up
rooming with John Gotti. You can't do that. You can't just
steal the key and then go into somebody's apartment.

CAROL
Listen. He's not going snorkeling with his brother, okay ?
Okay ?

LARRY
I don't wanna know. I don't wanna be an accessory.

CAROL
He's going to Paris, to a fancy hotel with a woman named
Helen Moss.

LARRY
Tell Ted. I don't want to know. Leave me alone.

They keep on walking around the pond, the camera following
them
from a fixed location. They are now hidden by the fountain.
Genres: ["Drama","Comedy"]

Summary Larry and Marcia discuss her writing and her skills at poker, while Carol sneaks into Paul's apartment and discovers more about his suspicious behavior.
Strengths "Engaging dialogue, tense atmosphere, character development"
Weaknesses "Some scenes may feel slow-paced or irrelevant to the main plot"
Critique The scene is well-written and has a good flow to it. The dialogue between Larry and Marcia feels genuine, and their chemistry is believable. However, there are a few things that could be improved upon.

Firstly, there could be more action or movement in the scene to make it visually more interesting. As it stands, the camera is mostly just following the characters as they walk and talk, which can be a bit static. Perhaps adding in some visual cues or actions could make the scene more engaging.

Secondly, the dialogue between Carol and Larry at the park feels a bit forced and unnatural. The way they talk to each other seems stilted and not as fluid as the previous conversation between Larry and Marcia. It might benefit from a bit of editing to make it more natural-sounding.

Overall, the scene is well-executed and has good character development and dialogue, but could benefit from some more visual interest and natural-sounding dialogue between Carol and Larry.
Suggestions - Consider tightening up some of the dialogue to make it more concise and natural. For example, instead of "that's something you're never gonna have to worry about, you know?", simply say "you don't have to worry about that."

- Add more visual description to help paint a clearer image of the scene and the characters. What are they wearing? How are they moving? What is their body language saying?

- Consider adding some conflict or tension to the scene. Right now it is just a casual conversation, but adding in some sort of disagreement or obstacle for the characters to overcome can make the scene more engaging for the audience.

- Be careful with using voice overs - they can be a useful storytelling tool, but overusing them can be confusing and take away from the impact of the scene. Consider using them more sparingly and only when necessary.

- Finally, make sure the scene is advancing the plot and developing the characters in some way. If it is just filler or doesn't serve a purpose, it may need to be cut or revised.



Scene 15 -  Undercover Investigation
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 7
CAROL (voice over from behind the fountain)
I told Ted.

LARRY (voice over from behind the fountain)
You told Ted before you told me ?

CAROL (voice over from behind the fountain)
Yeah. He's more open-minded about these things.

LARRY (voice over from behind the fountain)
Yes, I know. I'm-I'm-I'm a bore. I'm-Because I-Because I
don't break the law, you know ?

CAROL (voice over from behind the fountain)
Yeah.

LARRY (voice over from behind the fountain)
I live within the Constitution, so I'm dull.

CAROL (voice over from behind the fountain)
Listen. Perhaps he got rid of the urn, okay ?

They appear back from behind the fountain.

LARRY
I-I don't wanna hear. Leave me alone. Don't tell me.

CAROL
He talked on the phone with a woman.

LARRY
How do you know ?
CAROL
Because he... Well, he came back while I was there, you
know, so...

LARRY
He did ?

CAROL
Yeah, but I hid under the bed.

LARRY
You hid under his bed ?

CAROL
He didn't see me, Larry. He didn't see me at all.

LARRY
I cannot believe this. My stomach is curdling, here I...

CAROL
He was-He was very lovey-dovey with his kind of bimbo, you
know ? He kept saying stuff like, you know, «don't worry,
it's gonna be all right. We're gonna be together.» That
kind of thing.

They keep on walking around the pond, slowly coming back
toward
the camera, which moves a little to meet them.

LARRY
But what would you have done if he, if he found you out ?

CAROL
I know, listen, I-I couldn't think that far ahead.

LARRY
That far ahead ? You're talking two seconds.

CAROL
No, I c...

LARRY
He could have looked under the bed and there you are. What
do you...

CAROL
Yeah, but... Larry, listen. And then, listen to this. He-He
called this woman back. Probably this-this Helen Moss
woman, right ?

LARRY
I don't wanna know. Leave me alone.

CAROL
And when he calls her back, she's not there. And then he
leaves this message, and he says : «Tell her Tom called».
You know what I'm saying ? Tom. Tom, Larry.

They are back at the same place where we saw them first by
the
pond. They stop walking.
LARRY
Yeah, yeah. I... I know, I get it, his name is Paul, but I
don't care. I don't wanna hear.

CAROL
Well, okay. Well, I'll tell you. I thought I did...

LARRY
I just don't...

CAROL
I thought I did a great job, and so did Ted. I don't think
a private eye could have done any better than me. I put
everything back where I found it, I was very careful. I
made one mistake.

LARRY
What ?

CAROL
I left my reading glasses on his table.

Larry looks at her with a very puzzled eye.

LARRY'S LANDING - HALLWAY - INTERIOR NIGHT

Medium close shot on Paul's apartment front door. We get a
close
shot of the back of Carol's head. The door opens on Paul.

CAROL
Oh, hallo. Hi. I-I thought I'd bring you some chocolate
mousse. I know how much you enjoyed the last dessert.

Carol walks rapidly inside the apartment, followed by Larry.
Paul
looks a bit surprised by this intrusion. He follows them
along the
corridor. He doesn't even close his front door !

PAUL'S APARTMENT - CORRIDOR - INTERIOR NIGHT
The camera follows the three persons along the corridor.

PAUL
Well, thank you.

CAROL
I thought I'd-I'd give you, you know, another shot at
something really delicious. Do you want me to serve that
for you, because, you know, you should have it while it's
still fresh.

The shot becoming a bit wider, we notice that Paul is
carrying the
tray of chocolate mousse that Carol gave him when entering
his
apartment.

LARRY
And you can divide it up and we can all have some.

CAROL
That'd be great. That's a great idea.
LARRY
You'll really like this dessert.

PAUL
Okay, I'll get some plates for it. Wait a minute.

Paul walks out of the corridor toward his kitchen, and Carol
rushes into the living-room.

CAROL
Okay, that'd be really good.

LARRY
Yeah, that's great.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT

They both start searching the room frenetically. While Larry
looks
on the desk, Carol searches the rest of the room, even
kneeling on
the floor.

CAROL (WHISPERING)
Come over here. I put'em... um... right here. Right in here
somewhere. The first... Wait. I should...
(to Paul, with a much louder voice)
Uh, how-How are you doing in there ? You need...

Larry drops things on the floor. With a nervous gesture,
Carol
shushes him.

CAROL
You need any help ?

The camera pans to the kitchen, where Paul is preparing the
dessert.

PAUL
No, I'm fine. I'll be right in.
CAROL (voice over)
Um... Okay, great.

The camera pans back to the living room, where Larry is
still
nervously messing things on the desk. Then he starts moving
around
the room, looking for his wife's glasses. Carol puts things
back
in order on the desk. Larry walks to her, and whisper
something we
can't understand.
LARRY (to Paul, with a louder voice)
Are you okay ? Can-can-can-can we do anything for you ?
Genres: ["Thriller","Mystery","Suspense"]

Summary Carol sneaks into Paul's apartment to uncover evidence of his suspicious behaviour while Larry is at work. She discovers more but makes a mistake by leaving her reading glasses behind. Later, she and Larry return to Paul's apartment with an excuse to search his place for the missing item.
Strengths "The tense atmosphere and suspenseful situation are well-established, with the characters risking a lot to uncover the truth."
Weaknesses "Some of the dialogue is a bit on the nose and the plot feels a bit predictable at times."
Critique Overall, the scene is well-written and engaging. The tension builds between Carol and Larry as they discuss the information she has discovered about Paul, and the stakes are raised when they enter his apartment. The dialogue flows naturally and each character has a unique voice.

One possible critique is that there is a lot of exposition delivered through dialogue, especially in the beginning. This could be more effectively shown through action or visual cues. Additionally, the voiceovers from behind the fountain could be distracting and could potentially be shown through visuals or action.

Overall, though, the scene effectively builds tension and leaves the audience wanting to know what will happen next.
Suggestions Here are some suggestions to improve the scene:

1. Add more visual cues: As the scene mostly involves voice overs, it can be difficult for the audience to follow what is happening and who is speaking. To improve this, you can add more visual cues, like close-up shots of the characters' faces, or shots of the objects they are referring to.

2. Cut down on the dialogue: The dialogue in this scene can feel a bit repetitive and drag on for too long. To improve the pacing and keep the audience engaged, consider cutting down on some of the dialogue and condensing the information.

3. Use silence: Adding moments of silence can create tension and allow the audience to process what is happening. For example, when Larry discovers that Carol hid under the bed, there could be a moment of silence before he speaks again.

4. Show, don't tell: Instead of having Carol and Larry explain what happened in detail, try to show it through their actions and reactions. This can help the audience understand the situation better and make it more emotionally impactful.

5. Add more physical movement: The scene mostly involves the characters standing and talking, which can be visually dull. To make the scene more dynamic, consider adding more physical movement, like them walking around the park or interacting with the objects in Paul's apartment.



Scene 16 -  The Glasses
  • Overall: 7.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 7
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
PAUL (voice over from the kitchen)
Coffee or tea ?

CAROL
Tea. It's what... I'd like to have some tea.

Paul walks into the room, with a pair of glasses in his
hand.

PAUL
You know, I found your glasses.

CAROL
Mine ?

PAUL
These are yours, aren't they ?

CAROL
Yes.

LARRY
No.

CAROL
Uh, no. Yeah. Uh... No no no no no. They... They... Oh,
God.

Carol and Larry both look very nervous. Carol takes the
glasses
from Paul's hand.

LARRY
No, no, those aren't yours. These are the same, actually.
They are, aren't they ? These-These-These ones, are.

CAROL
They are actually... They're mine. Honey, they're mine.
I... You know what happened ? I think the other night, I
must have left them here. It's the strangest thing.

PAUL
Did you ? I didn't notice that.

CAROL
No, no. Yeah. I know. Because, remember, you were saying
that you thought that I left them at your mother's house ?
Carol and Larry both look very embarrassed. Paul looks at
them
with a slight surprised eye.

LARRY
At your mother's house.

CAROL
That's right. Of course, so...

She turns toward Paul, who has remained very calm.

PAUL
That mousse looks fabulous.

CAROL
Anyway, it's so good. I love mousse.

PAUL
Thank you very much.

CAROL
Hey, listen, are you looking forward to going snorkeling in
the Caribbean ?
PAUL
Very much. Very much.

CAROL
Uh uh.

PAUL
That's funny. I found those glasses under my bed.

CAROL
That's because I must have dropped them and they probably
got kicked under.

LARRY
Kicked under, right, because what she'll do, she'll drop...

CAROL
They were just...

LARRY
She'll always drop things and she'll kick them all around
the house.

CAROL
They f...

PAUL
The mousse ?
He walks away to the kitchen, with a strange smile on his
face.

LARRY
She's always-She's always kick...

Carol looks at Larry with a meaning look, to make him stop
rambling.
CAROL
Anyway, I'd love to have some mousse.

LARRY
Yes, really ? Remember there was the time you kicked the
mousse under the bed in the house. Remember that ? It
was...

Carol walks away toward the kitchen.

CAROL
I remember.

LARRY
It took-took six months to get the...

NEW-YORK - A STREET - EXTERIOR DAY

Medium full shot of Carol waiting under the awning of a
place
(hotel or club) called the «Five Hundred». She hears a car
stopping and she looks at the street.
TED (voice over)
Hi. I'm sorry I'm late. The traffic's murder.

Carol runs to the car.

CAROL
I know, but where... where are we going ?

TED (voice over from inside the car)
I looked up, looked up Helen Moss in the phone book.

Carol climbs into the car and closes the door.

CAROL (voice over from inside the car)
Yeah.

TED (voice over from inside the car)
It was just H. Moss.

CAROL (voice over from inside the car)
Right.
TED (voice over from inside the car)
So I-it's on Bank Street...

The car drives away, with Ted's voice fading as the car gets
away
from us.

TED (voice over from inside the car)
Bank Street... we're going to go down and do surveillance.
I got a lot whole of food. It's great. I called up this...
I called this number.

NEW-YORK - BANK STREET - EXTERIOR DAY

Full view of the corner of two very quiet streets. A brick
building covered with vines. The camera pans away from the
building to Ted's car parked on the other side of the street
corner. Medium shot of the inside of the car, through the
open
window on the passenger's side, Carol's side.

TED
There's her house.

CAROL
Right. So we should just sit here and wait, huh ?

TED
Yeah.

CAROL
Okay.

They look at each other and laugh.

Slightly later. Medium shot through the windshield. The view
is a
little blurred by the daylight reflection on the windshield.

TED
Maybe he thought that if he, if he, if he divorced her,
she'd-she'd hit him for a ton of alimony. Or maybe she,
maybe she controls the family fortune. What do you think of
that ?

CAROL
Oh, I don't know. Yeah, maybe we're wrong, Ted. Maybe we're
just, you know... I mean, maybe she died of natural causes,
like the doctor said and we're just two people with, you
know, hyperactive imaginations whose lives need a little
shot of adrenaline.
Ted looks through the paper food-bag he has brought with
him.

TED
Does yours ? I'll tell you, mine needs something.

CAROL
Yeah? What's that, there ?

TED
You want ? They're jelly doughnuts. You want a jelly
doughnut ?

CAROL (with a disgusted tone in her voice)
Ooh.

TED
Eh ? Come on. No, come on. Come on. You gotta get into it.

CAROL
Okay.

TED
Oh my God. Look, look, look, look, look !
Genres: ["Mystery","Suspense","Comedy"]

Summary Carol sneaks into Paul's apartment and almost gets caught when he finds her reading glasses left behind. She covers up her actions with nervous lies, and later meets with Ted to do surveillance on Helen Moss' house.
Strengths "The scene builds suspense with Carol almost getting caught, and has some humorous moments with Larry's rambling. The dialogue also reveals more about the characters' personalities."
Weaknesses "The scene doesn't have much action and doesn't move the plot forward significantly. It also doesn't have a strong emotional impact on the viewer."
Critique This scene is from the movie, "Manhattan," written and directed by Woody Allen. In the scene, Carol and Paul are having a conversation with Larry present. The conversation is about lost glasses, and they seem to be lying to each other and trying to cover something up. Later, Carol meets up with Ted, and they wait outside a woman's house.

Overall, the scene is well-written, with natural-sounding dialogue and subtle hints of tension and deception. It also effectively sets up the next part of the story with Ted and Carol's stakeout.

One suggestion for improvement would be to clarify the relationships between the characters earlier in the scene. It's not immediately clear who Larry is or what his relationship is to Carol and Paul. This could be done with a simple piece of dialogue or action to establish who he is, such as Paul introducing him to Carol.

Another suggestion would be to give more attention to the physical actions and movements of the characters. While the dialogue effectively conveys the tension and deception, adding in physical actions or facial expressions could enhance the scene's overall impact and make it more engaging for the audience.

Overall, the scene effectively sets up the story's tension and conflict while remaining natural and conversational in tone.
Suggestions The main issue with this scene is that it drags on for too long and it's not clear what its purpose is in advancing the plot or character development. One way to improve it would be to focus more on the characters' thoughts and emotions and make the dialogue more concise and purposeful. For example, cutting out Larry's rambling and focusing on Carol's guilt and nervousness about the glasses would make the scene more tense and revealing of her character. Additionally, adding in more visual elements and using the camera to create a sense of discomfort and unease could heighten the tension and add more depth to the scene. Finally, there needs to be a clearer transition or connection between this scene and the next one where Carol and Ted are conducting surveillance. Perhaps showing more of Carol's motivations for wanting to help with the investigation or adding in dialogue about her own personal reasons for wanting to solve the case would make the transition smoother and more meaningful.



Scene 17 -  Stakeout
  • Overall: 7.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 7
  • Characters: 6
  • Dialogue: 6
The camera pans to the other corner of the street. Two
people, a
male and a female, are coming out of the brick building.
CAROL (voice over)
What ? What ? What ? What ?

TED (yelling in voice over)
Helen ! Helen !
(Back to a normal low voice)
Duck, duck, duck !

Neither one of the couple has turned around at the sound of
Ted's
yelling, and they start walking down the street, away from
the
corner.

CAROL (voice over)
Ted! God, oh...Oh.

TED (yelling in voice over)
Helen !

The camera pans back to the car, looking through the open
window
on the passenger's side. Carol is hiding under the
dashboard. Ted
is hiding his face with his paper bag, holding a paper cup
in the
other hand.
TED
It's not her.

CAROL
It's not her ?

She sits back in her seat.

TED
No, it's not her.

Carol laughs.

TED
What...

CAROL
Oh, God, you really have this worked out, don't you ?

She keeps on laughing. Ted starts laughing too.

Slightly later. It is raining. It is still the same medium
shot
through the passenger's window, but the window is now
closed, with
the rain pouring on the window-pane.

TED
I figured she'd come out and go to work, you know ?

CAROL
Maybe she doesn't work. Maybe she's like... you and she has
writers hours.

TED
I'm writing a play about something that happened to you and
me.

CAROL
Oh, God. Oh, dear. What ?

TED
Remember-Remember that time... you and... you and I and
Larry and Julie were all on that-that eating tour of
France ?

CAROL
Oh, God. Yeah. Yeah.

TED
And they, and then they wandered off and they forgot to
pick us up ? You remember ? We had to share that bed-and-
breakfast place.

CAROL
Right. Do you remember those wonderful cottages ?

TED
Yeah.

CAROL
And I remember... that we shared a bedroom together,
right ?

TED
Yeah, but not a bed.

The camera pans away from the car to the other corner of the
street. Someone is coming out of the brick building. It is
apparently a male wearing white pants. He opens an umbrella.

CAROL (voice over)
No, not a... Well, God. You were too gentlemanly to suggest
that.

TED
Well, it's not... Not that I didn't think of it.

The camera follows the man with white pants, while he is
crossing
the street on the other side of the street from the car.

CAROL
No. Well, I knew what was going on in your mind... because
of the way you kept plying me with Chateau Margaux,
remember ?

The camera is back behind the passenger's window of the car.
Though the car-windows, we see the white-pants-man walking
on the
sidewalk on the other side of the street. Ted and Carol do
not
seem to notice him at all.

TED
It could have been our little secret, then you passed out.

CAROL
Well, you... Yeah, God. It seems like a long time ago,
doesn't it ?

TED
Not that long ago.

Slightly later. The rain has stopped. Same shot through the
passenger's window of the car, but the window is now open
again.

A long pause. Ted and Carol seem to be both lost them in
their own
thoughts. Then Ted gives a look outside and comes back to
attention.

TED
Look, look, look, look.

CAROL
Oh, what ?

The camera pans to the other side of the street. A woman is
coming
out of the brick building.

TED (yelling in voice over)
Helen !
(with a softer voice)
Duck, duck, duck, duck, duck !
On the other side of the street, the woman has stopped and
is
looking around her.

CAROL (voice over)
Oh, god, yeah. Right.

TED (voice over)
She didn't see us. She didn't see us.

CAROL (voice over)
No ? No. That's gotta be her.

TED (voice over)
I'll bet it's...

The woman starts walking again on the sidewalk.

CAROL (voice over)
Are you sure ?

TED (voice over)
I mean, she answered to Helen.
CAROL (voice over)
She answers to... She's pretty.

TED (voice over)
Yeah, I'll say.

The woman has reached the corner of the street and she lifts
her
arm.
CAROL (voice over)
She's... What is she doing ? She's getting a...

TED (voice over)
She's getting a cab.
A yellow cab stops near the woman.

CAROL (voice over)
Okay, okay. Hold on.

TED (voice over)
Keep-Keep down.

CAROL (voice over)
Okay, don't worry. Don't worry.

TED (voice over)
I'm gonna follow her.

CAROL (voice over)
All right.

The woman opens the cab door and climbs into it.

NEW-YORK - A STREET - EXTERIOR DAY
Genres: ["drama"]

Summary Ted and Carol conduct surveillance of Helen Moss, a suspected target. They both await her to exit her apartment building, and when she does, they follow her.
Strengths "The scene has a suspenseful tone that keeps the audience engaged. The use of voiceover adds a layer of intrigue to the events unfolding in the scene."
Weaknesses "The dialogue between Ted and Carol is not very engaging and lacks depth. The scene could benefit from more character development."
Critique Overall, the scene lacks clear direction and purpose. While there are some intriguing moments between the characters, such as their banter and the suspenseful moment when they think they've found their target, there isn't a clear plot or conflict to drive the scene forward. Additionally, the use of voiceover feels excessive and distracting, as it removes the audience from the present action and relies heavily on telling rather than showing. A stronger sense of purpose and more dynamic action would greatly improve the scene.
Suggestions Firstly, it would be helpful to have some context as to why Ted and Carol are following this woman named Helen. It would also be helpful to have some dialogue or actions that foreshadow their intentions, instead of just having them randomly appear on screen.

In terms of the scene itself, the constant use of VO (voice over) can become tedious for the audience, and it may be more effective to show the characters' reactions and actions instead. Additionally, the dialogue between Ted and Carol feels repetitive and lacks depth. It would be more engaging to have them engage in a meaningful conversation about their intentions or feelings towards the situation, rather than just casually chatting.

Finally, the camera work in this scene feels stagnant. Adding some movement or different angles could help break up the monotony and make the scene more visually interesting.



Scene 18 -  Behind the Screen
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 7
Long shot of a street covered with a metal structure. We
could be
under a commuter train bridge. The yellow cab is driving
toward
us. The cab stops at the corner of the street with another
street.
The woman comes out of the cab, and walks away on the
sidewalk of
the other street. The camera pans back to the first street
and we
see Ted's car coming toward us. The camera stops at the
corner of
the street and Carol walks out of the car. She runs in the
direction of Helen, and waves Ted to join her. The camera
pans to
the end of the street, which actually is a dead end street
with
the back door of a movie house. The woman enters the movie
house.

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - INTERIOR DAY

Medium shot of a door leading to an emergency stair way.
Helen,
the woman we just saw coming out of the yellow cab, is
coming down
the steps and through the door. She is blonde, young and
pretty.

PAUL (voice over)
Watch your step. It's very steep. Be careful.

Behind Helen, Paul is coming out of the stairway. Helen has
stopped to look around her.

HELEN
Oh, this is beautiful.

PAUL
Isn't it ?

HELEN
Yeah.

The camera pans away from the couple toward the main hall of
the
movie house. It is an old-fashioned movie house, with red
velvet
seats, and a carved balcony.

PAUL (voice over)
Well, we only show revivals now. This week, we have Fred
Astaire. Next week, we have an Orson Welles festival.
HELEN (voice over)
Oh, yeah ?

PAUL (voice over)
Yeah, it'll be about the last thing we do before we start
renovating.

The camera keeps on panning around the room.

HELEN (voice over)
Mm. Oh, Paul, I...

PAUL (voice over)
Oh, come on, there's nobody around.

We hear moaning and kissing sounds.
HELEN (voice over)
I-I...

PAUL (voice over)
Come on.

HELEN (voice over)
Okay.

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - BACKSTAGE - INTERIOR DAY

Full shot of the backstage behind the screen. In a corner, a
stairway going to the top of the backstage. Half-hidden on
the
stairway, Carol and Ted.

HELEN (voice over)
I've never been behind a movie screen before like this.

PAUL (voice over)
Strange, isn't it ?

HELEN (voice over)
Yeah.

PAUL (voice over)
Used to be a first-run house when the neighborhood was
better.

The camera pans to the back of the screen, in front of which
Paul
and Helen are standing.

HELEN
Oh.

PAUL
Beautiful, huh ? Look around.

HELEN
All these mirrors.

The camera pans around the room, where a lot of huge mirrors
are
stacked.
PAUL
Huh ? Well, it used to be all mirrors, and it was quite
beautiful.

The camera tilts down to give us a closer shot on the
mirrors.
PAUL (voice over)
I'm having all this broken glass replaced as we go along
with this renovation. You know, they used to have stage
shows, here. Now, of course, we only show old movies.

The camera tilts back up on Paul and Helen.

HELEN
It has such a lonely feeling.

PAUL
That's because I'm the only one here. And my assistant,
Mrs. Dalton. I'm gonna have this place fixed up, then I'm
gonna sell it. The money's gonna come in handy.
HELEN
It sure will.

Paul looks around, a bit worried.

PAUL
What's that noise ?

HELEN
Where ?

The camera pans to the other side of the room, where a
middle-aged
woman with red curly hair has just entered. She is Gladys
Dalton,
Paul's assistant. She is walking with the help of a cane.

PAUL (voice over)
Oh, Mrs. Dalton. I didn't know you were here so early.

GLADYS
Oh, uh, I-I didn't know whether an-anyone was here. I-I'm
sorry. I-I-I heard the noise and I thought...

PAUL (voice over)
It's quite all right.

GLADYS
But, but, uh...

PAUL (voice over)
It's quite all right.

GLADYS
I apologize.

PAUL (voice over)
Quite all right.

GLADYS
All right.

Gladys Dalton starts going out of the room and the camera
tilts up
on the stairway, on which Ted and Carol are still hiding.

HELEN (voice over)
I'd love to really get an acting job. I had it with this
modeling.

PAUL (voice over)
Maybe you won't have to work at all.

Ted and Carol are moving away from the stairway, which
remains
empty.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - BEDROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT

Close shot on the clock on the wall : the time is just after
one
o'clock. The room is completely dark and the clock is the
only
source of light. The camera pans to the bed and on Carol,
sound
asleep. We hear a noise, like an object dropping down. Carol
instantly wakes up. She gets up and the camera pans to
Larry,
still asleep. He eventually wakes up, moves around in the
bed,
takes his glasses from the night-table and put them on his
nose.

CAROL (whispering in voice over)
Oh, my God.

Slowly Larry gets out of the bed.

LARRY
What's the matter ?

CAROL (voice over)
Larry, come with me, okay ?

Larry starts walking along the corridor.

LARRY
Oh, Geez, I was...
CAROL (voice over)
Come on.
Genres: ["Suspense","Drama"]

Summary Carol and Ted follow the suspected target, Helen Moss, to a movie house where she meets up with Paul. Paul shows Helen around the movie house and reveals his plans to sell it. Meanwhile, Carol and Ted hide behind the screen and overhear their conversation.
Strengths "Excellent use of tension and building suspense. The dialogue between Paul and Helen is intriguing and reveals important details about the plot. "
Weaknesses "Some of the dialogue feels a bit contrived and forced. The scene lacks significant action or plot development. "
Critique Overall, the scene is well written and visually descriptive. The use of voice over adds depth to the characters and their thoughts, and the camera movements help to clearly establish the setting and action. However, it could benefit from more dialogue and action, as well as clearer character motivations. It is unclear why Helen is going to the old movie house, and why Ted and Carol are hiding on the stairs. Adding more context and conflict would make the scene more engaging and propel the story forward.
Suggestions This scene could use some clearer character motivations and action. The audience isn't given much information on why the characters are in the movie theater or what they hope to achieve there. To improve this scene, consider adding some dialogue or actions that reveal what the characters want and why they're in the movie theater. Additionally, the use of voice over can be a bit jarring and could be avoided by having the characters speak their lines on camera. Another suggestion would be to add some visual interest or unique camera angles to make the scene more engaging for the audience.



Scene 19 -  Carol and Larry Break into Paul's Apartment
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 8
LARRY
I was fast asleep. I was dreaming of round card girls.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - FRONT HALL - INTERIOR NIGHT

Larry has reached the front hall. Carol is looking through
the
peephole of the front door.

CAROL
Okay. Uh, it looks like he's gone. Yeah. Yeah. He's gone.

LARRY
Oh, Christ. Not that again. Please, you know...

CAROL
Listen, Larry. I want to take another look around his
apartment. Yeah.

Carol walks along the corridor toward the bedroom. Larry
follows
her.

LARRY
What are you talking about ? Where're you going ?

CAROL
Listen.

LARRY
It's-It's one o'clock in the morn...

CAROL
He'll never be back, Larry.

LARRY
What ? What ?

LARRY'S APARTMENT - BEDROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT
CAROL
No, he's not coming back. Not for at least an hour, an hour
and a half.

LARRY
What-What're you doing ? You got his key ?

CAROL
Yeah.
LARRY
You're kidding. What are you talking about ? You can't
do... Why... because you-you followed him to the movie
house, you-you said there was nothing happening.

CAROL
No, wait a minute, look, he was with this young model type,
and they were talking about money.

Carol is putting her shoes on.

LARRY
Well, so what ? That's the...

CAROL
So, that's the motive.

LARRY
What... Hey, listen to me. Come here.

CAROL
What are you talking about ?

Carol walks back through the corridor toward the front hall.
Larry
follows her.

LARRY
Come here. Wait a minute. Come here. Look, look.
CAROL
Come here. What do you mean, Larry ?

LARRY
I've been thinking about you.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - FRONT HALL - INTERIOR NIGHT

CAROL
What do you mean ?

LARRY
I think you gotta see... I gotta... You gotta, you gotta go
back to your shrink.

CAROL
What do you m...

LARRY
I want you to see Doctor Ballard again.
CAROL
Huh ? Larry, I went for two years.
LARRY
I'm s... Yeah. I know. But you...

CAROL
Just come... come on.

LARRY
You know how General Motors will recall defective cars ?
Well, you gotta go in for a tune-up.

CAROL
Larry, we'll be in and out in five minutes.

LARRY
You got... No. No.

CAROL
Five. Only five.

LARRY
I... What... I'm telling you, I'm your husband. I command
you to sleep !

He points to the bedroom.

CAROL
Well, I didn't...

LARRY
Sleep ! I command it !

CAROL
No, I...

LARRY
I command it ! Sleep !

CAROL
Larry, all I can tell you is, if this had been a few years
ago, you would have been doing the same thing. Because if
you recall, we solved a mystery. Yep, we solved a mystery
once. Remember ? It was the-it was the noises in the attic
mystery.

LARRY
Uh, yes. The country house. The bluebird. I know.

CAROL
That's right. So...

LARRY
But that, though, was a sweet mystery. This is murder.
CAROL
This... Wh... You agree, right ? It's murder, Larry ? So,
I'm right.
She opens the front door and walks out of the apartment.

LARRY
No, I... Yeah, look, no, I-I forbid you ! I forbid you to
go! It's a-a... I'm forbidding ! Is that what you do when I
forbid you ? If-If that's what you... I'm not going to be
forbidding you a lot, if you do...


LARRY'S LANDING - HALLWAY - INTERIOR NIGHT

Full shot of the landing. Carol is walking rapidly toward us
and
Paul's apartment. Larry walks behind her. Carol takes Paul's
key
out of her pocket and tries to open the front door. But she
takes
the wrong key on the keyring.

CAROL
Oh, damn it.

Larry takes her by the shoulders.

LARRY
Don't do this. We should be asleep, now, in one of our many
cuddling positions.

CAROL
Please, stop it, will you ? Please, be quiet, Larry.

LARRY
This is wrong.

CAROL
Be quiet. You're gonna wake up the neighbors, okay ? Okay,
I got it. I got it.

She opens the door.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT
Full shot of the front door, seen from the living room. A
small
lamp is still lit on a low table. The door opens and Carol
walks
in, followed by Larry.

LARRY
This is no good. I promise you, this could only lead to
great unhappiness.

CAROL
Listen, Larry... Relax, okay ?

She closes the front door.

LARRY
Pl... I can't relax. How can I relax ? I'm in a strange
man's apartment in my, in my T-shirt and-and pajamas.

CAROL
Oh, don't worry about it. All right, now Ted told me to try
something here... Yeah.
She rests her hands on the telephone, which is next to the
lamp.

LARRY
What do you mean, Ted told you ? Who... Ted ? Ted ? What is
he, your mentor ?

The camera zooms to a close shot on the telephone. Carol
picks it
up.

CAROL
Um, «Last number dialed».

The camera zooms backward to Carol with the phone handset to
her
ear.
Genres: ["Mystery","Crime","Drama"]

Summary Carol and Larry break into Paul's apartment in search of evidence and argue about their actions while doing surveillance on a suspected target.
Strengths "The tension and conflict between Carol and Larry raise the stakes and keep the audience engaged. The scene moves the plot forward significantly."
Weaknesses "Some of the dialogue could be more concise, and there are moments where the tension feels forced rather than natural."
Critique As a screenwriting expert, my first impression of this scene is that it is part of a larger story, and without that context, it is difficult to fully critique. However, based solely on this scene, there are a few things that stand out.

Firstly, the dialogue between Larry and Carol feels a bit forced and unnatural at times. It is possible that this is intentional and meant to establish a tense relationship between them, but it could also be improved by adding more subtlety and nuance to their interactions.

Additionally, the scene could benefit from more visual cues and actions to convey the characters' emotions and motivations. As it stands, there is a lot of dialogue, but not much movement or physicality that could enhance the scene's dramatic impact.

Finally, there is a lack of clear stakes or conflict in this scene. While there are hints at a mystery or potential danger, it is not fully developed in this particular moment. To create more tension, the scene could benefit from a clearer sense of danger or suspense that the characters are actively trying to avoid or confront.

In summary, while the scene does contain some interesting elements, there is room for improvement in terms of dialogue, visual storytelling, and establishing clear stakes and conflict.
Suggestions One suggestion would be to tighten up the dialogue to eliminate unnecessary repetition and make it more concise. The pacing of the scene could also be improved with the use of more dynamic camera angles and blocking to create tension and suspense. Additionally, adding more sensory details and descriptions could enhance the atmosphere and mood of the scene. It might also be beneficial to delve deeper into the characters' motivations and emotional states to make the scene more impactful and engaging for the audience.



Scene 20 -  Larry and Carol Break into Paul's Apartment
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 7
LARRY
Ted is a sick schmuck. He's-He's home, and we're in...

CAROL
Just be quiet for a second, all right ?

She listens to the phone.

CAROL
Shhh !

LARRY
I mean, I'm... What if he comes back ? I'm... My heart
is....

CAROL
Larry.

MALE VOICE OVER FROM THE PHONE
Waldron.

CAROL
Uh, who ?
MALE VOICE OVER FROM THE PHONE
Who is this ? Who do you want ?

CAROL
Um, who's this ?

She puts her hand on the phone microphone and turns toward
Larry.

CAROL
Do you know anybody named Waldron ? Waldron ?

LARRY
Hang the phone up.

CAROL
Just be quiet. Okay, wait.

LARRY
Hang the phone up, now.

She puts the phone handset back to her ear.
CAROL
Oh, great. Now they-they hung up on us.

LARRY
Good, good.

He takes the handset from her hand and slams it down.

CAROL
Oh, great.

LARRY
Let's get out. I wanna go home. I want to go back to bed.

CAROL
No, just let me think for a second, now. Waldron, right ?
Helen Moss. Okay. He used the name Tom, right ? So, Tom
Waldron. We gotta run a check on that.

LARRY
Run a check on it ? What, do you want to beat it down to
the morgue ? You got all the jargon.

CAROL
Come on.
She walks away from the phone table.

LARRY
Where are you going ?

CAROL
Right.

PAUL'S APARTMENT - BEDROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT

Carol enters the bedroom, followed by Larry.
LARRY
I'm not a night person. I don't wanna be... What are you...
I don't know what I'm looking for.

CAROL
Oh, oh, wait. Look.

She starts looking through the mail scattered on a table.

LARRY
What ? What do you wanna do, go through the guy's mail ?
This is insane.

He starts looking through the mail.

CAROL
What do you mean ?

LARRY
Oh, my...
As he takes some more letters, Larry hits a small porcelain
statuette, and drops it on the floor, where it breaks. He
bends
down to pick up the debris.

LARRY
Jesus. Oh, Christ !

CAROL
What are you do... Well, just... Clean it up, Larry. Clean
it up.

Larry stands up.

LARRY
What do you mean, clean it up ? What am I gonna do,
vacuum ?

CAROL
Put it under the rug, or something like that, okay ?
LARRY
I can't. It's a wall-to-wall carpet. I broke his-his-his-
his... porcelain...

He looks at the porcelain pieces in his hands.

CAROL
Well then glue it. Glue it back to...

She moves around the room.

LARRY
What do you mean, glue it ? What are you talking about ?

CAROL
Oh, look. Look.

LARRY
What ?

CAROL
Look.

She shows him a pair of gloves she just picked up on a low
table.

LARRY
So what ? Gloves. I have gloves. They keep my fingers warm.

CAROL
So ? I know. I know, but you keep yours out on the bureau
in this kind of weather ? Uh ?

LARRY
Let's get out of here, because this is a...

CAROL
I think something's very strange, here. I mean, he left
these out and ready. I think the whole thing is really
sinister.
LARRY
It's eye of the beholder. What you have... you've got to go
to the eye doctor, get happy glasses.

He pushes her toward the exit of the room.

CAROL
What ?

LARRY
Look, I'm gonna take the pieces with us, and we'll-we'll
get rid of them.
NEW-YORK - CLUB TWENTY-ONE - EXTERIOR DAY

Medium shot of the famous entrance of the club 21, with the
line
of painted cast iron lawn jockey statues which adorns the
balcony
above the entrance. The camera zooms backward to give a full
shot
of the entrance of the club.

NEW-YORK - CLUB TWENTY-ONE - INTERIOR DAY

Full shot on the lobby of the club. On the right, a counter
with
an attendant behind the counter. Facing us the entrance of
the
main room. Carol, Larry, and their son Nick, are coming out
of the
room. Nick must be in his early twenties.

CAROL
So, how did you like your birthday cake, Nick ?

NICK
I loved it, I...

CAROL
I know.

NICK
I loved... But then again, I love chocolate anything, so...
The camera moves around the three people as they walk toward
the
cloakroom.

CAROL
I know.

LARRY
Right.

CAROL
I know. What-What-What are you laughing about ?

NICK
Well, I...

LARRY
If only he could stay in town-If only could stay in town
just a couple of more hours.
NICK
I know. I was going to, but I...
CAROL
Well, what about that ?

NICK
They're working us so hard at school. I can't.

CAROL
Oh.

They've stopped in front of the cloakroom.
Genres: ["Drama","Thriller"]

Summary Larry and Carol break into Paul's apartment in search of evidence and argue about their actions while doing surveillance on a suspected target.
Strengths "The tension is well-crafted and the stakes are high. The broken statue adds another level of complication to the situation."
Weaknesses "The dialogue could have been stronger and more impactful."
Critique As a screenwriting expert, I would critique this scene by saying that it lacks clear objectives and urgency. The dialogue feels aimless and doesn't do enough to drive the plot forward. Additionally, the scene could benefit from more action and visual cues to heighten the tension. The use of pronouns like "he" and "they" can also be confusing for the audience if they are unsure of who the speakers are referring to. Finally, the scene could benefit from clearer character motivations and development to make the audience care about what's happening.
Suggestions Firstly, I think the dialogue could be improved to make it more engaging and impactful. There is a lot of back-and-forth between Larry and Carol, but it doesn't necessarily add much to the scene. I would suggest focusing on the tension and urgency of the situation, and making sure the dialogue reflects that.

Secondly, I would suggest adding more visual elements to the scene to make it more dynamic. Right now, it's just the two characters talking in a room. Adding some movement, action or interesting camera angles would help to keep the audience engaged.

Thirdly, I think the stakes could be made clearer. What are the consequences if they don't find Waldron or if they get caught? Adding a sense of danger and consequences would heighten the tension in the scene.

Lastly, I would suggest looking at the pacing of the scene. It can be difficult to maintain tension and keep the audience engaged for a long scene like this, so it's important to keep the momentum going and cut any unnecessary moments.



Scene 21 -  Surveillance and Wine Tasting
  • Overall: 7.0
  • Concept: 6
  • Plot: 6
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 8
NICK
I gotta get right back.

CAROL
Really.

LARRY
I'm gonna take him to Brooks Brothers for his present. And-
And-And, uh...

NICK
Brooks Brothers. Yeah.

LARRY
Your mother's going to a wine-tasting.

CAROL
You're going to get something from Brooks Brothers ?

NICK
Yeah. A sweater.

LARRY
She's going to a wine-tasting. Can you believe that ?

CAROL
Well, if I'm going to be a restaurant owner, I should know
something about wines. Don't you... Larry ?

Larry walks across the lobby, because he has seen someone he
knows
in the sitting-room. He waves his hand and comes back to his
wife
and his son.

LARRY
Hi. Hey, I want you to meet somebody.

CAROL
What ?

The camera pans around, to show us Marcia crossing the
sitting-
room.

LARRY
I want you to meet somebody. This is, this is...

MARCIA
Hi, Larry.
LARRY
Hi. How are you ?

MARCIA
Good. How are you doing ?

LARRY
This is my wife.

Marcia has reached the lobby.

CAROL
Honey, I'm here. I'm right o...

LARRY
You snuck around.

CAROL
Carol. Remember me ?

LARRY
Yeah. This is Marcia Fox.

The two women shake hands.

CAROL
Oh, hi.

MARCIA
Hi.

LARRY
My son Nick. He's in town on, uh...

MARCIA
Good to see you.

LARRY
It's his birthday, so we took him to Twenty-One.

Marcia shakes hands with Nick.
NICK
Nick. How are you doing ?

LARRY
It's a tradition we have in the family.

MARCIA
That's great. Oh, your friend called me. He's taking me to
dinner in New Jersey next week. Some mafia joint.

LARRY
Oh, I fixed her up with Ted. He's going to take her...

CAROL
Oh, you did.

LARRY
Yeah. That place that we ate at.
CAROL
Well, very nice. That's lovely.

LARRY
He's a lot of fun. You'll have a very good time.

MARCIA
Great. Great.

LARRY
That's great. So.

MARCIA
Well, good to see you. Good to see you.

CAROL
Okay, you too.

MARCIA
Take care.

CAROL
Goodbye.

Marcia walks away.

LARRY
Oh, it's great. She'll have a great time.

CAROL
So, that's Marcia Fox, huh ?

LARRY
S-So, what are you making a face for ? She's great.

CAROL
Well, do you think she's Ted's type ? Is that...
LARRY
Ted's type ?

CAROL
Yeah.

Larry gives his ticket to the cloakroom attendant, whom we
don't
see.

LARRY
She's anybody's type. She's brilliant, she's talented.
Yeah. I gave you...

CAROL
Thank you.

Larry gives her purse to Carol.

LARRY
You get your bag.
CAROL
You know, your pupils are dilating.

LARRY
No, she's dangerously sexual.

They start walking toward the entrance of the club.

CAROL
I just wanted to tell you that.

LARRY
Let me tell you... Listen, when you go to the wine-tasting,
honey...

CAROL
I see.

LARRY
Getting back to real life, spit it out. Okay ? When you
drink...

NICK
Yeah. Don't drink too much, Mom.

LARRY
Yeah, spit... And spit it out.
CAROL
What do you mean ? Nick.

LARRY
They spit it out at a wine-tasting, you know what I mean ?
Because, yeah. I don't want you to be lying on the bathroom
floor with your head by the bowl tonight, you know ?

They walk out of the club.
NEW-YORK - A LOUNGE - INTERIOR DAY

This is very nice lounge in New-York, very tastefully
decorated.
It looks like one of those old English Club in London.
Beautiful
paintings on the walls, and even stained glasses on the
windows.

This is where the wine-tasting is taking place. The camera
pans
around the room. We see people talking while holding wine-
glasses.
We hear Ted and Carol's conversation without seeing them
yet.

TED (voice over)
That Mouton 45. That was...

CAROL (voice over)
Didn't you love it ?

TED (voice over)
Oh, that was-was like, sublime, you know ?

CAROL (voice over)
Yeah.
TED (voice over)
And the inexpensive Spanish one. Wasn't that... wasn't that
a nice surprise ?

CAROL (voice over)
It was very, very...

TED (voice over)
Wasn't that great ?

CAROL (voice over)
Yeah.

TED (voice over)
Look at these paintings. Look at this.
CAROL (voice over)
So, uh...

The camera has reached Ted and Carol and follows them
walking in
the room.

TED
I love the blue in that.

CAROL
So, Larry fixed you up with Marcia Fox, huh ? His, uh...

TED
Yeah, yeah, well, you know. He's...

CAROL
His favorite writer.

TED
He says she's wonderful, and I'm...

CAROL
Oh.
Genres: ["Thriller","Drama"]

Summary Carol and Larry attend a wine tasting while Ted and Carol discuss their assignment. Larry introduces them to Marcia Fox and makes a wisecrack about wine-tasting.
Strengths "The dialogue between characters is sharp and witty."
Weaknesses "The scene doesn't have a lot of action or plot development."
Critique As a screenwriting expert, it’s difficult to accurately critique this scene without the context of the rest of the script or film. However, based purely on this excerpt, there are some observations that can be made.

Firstly, the scene lacks a clear objective or conflict. There doesn’t appear to be a goal that any of these characters are trying to achieve, making it difficult for the audience to become invested in the scene.

Secondly, there are a lot of characters in this scene, and not all of them are necessary. It’s difficult to keep track of who’s speaking and why, which can lead to confusion for the audience. The writer could benefit from simplifying the scene and focusing on only the essential characters and dialogue.

Finally, there is a lack of action or movement in this scene. It’s predominantly a conversation, with characters standing or sitting in one place and talking. A good scene should have some visual interest, whether it’s characters doing something physically or moving between locations.

Overall, while this scene isn’t terrible, it could benefit from some clarity in terms of character objectives and a streamlined approach to dialogue and character interaction.
Suggestions This scene currently lacks a clear objective or conflict. To improve it, consider adding a clear goal for the characters or a problem they need to solve. For example, perhaps Nick desperately needs a present for his birthday and is struggling to find the right one, while Carol and Larry bicker over their differing opinions on wine-tasting. Additionally, consider cutting some of the unnecessary dialogue and focusing on only the most important information and interactions between the characters. Lastly, think about adding more visual and sensory details to create a more immersive experience for the audience.



Scene 22 -  Carol's Discovery
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
TED
I'm trying to do everything I can to get out and meet
people, you know.

CAROL
Sure.

We now get a medium shot of Carol and Ted walking toward us.

TED
I'm-I'm not looking forward to this.

CAROL
So, you're taking her to Vincent's out in Jersey ?

TED
Yeah.

CAROL
Is that what you're...
TED
I-I guess. She's not my first choice.

CAROL
No ? God, look at this! Oh, that park is so beautiful.
They have reach a large window, where they can get a view of
the
park on the other side of the street.

TED
Yeah, it's great. Of course, I can't have my first choice.

CAROL
No ?

TED
I'm getting drunk. I don't know what I'm saying.

He sits down. She sits down on the sofa besides him. Behind
them,
you see the park through the windows.

CAROL
You're getting... So am I. I don't know about this.

Ted looks at his watch.

TED
I'm gonna be late for my shrink. I've got a...

CAROL
You've got to go, huh ?

TED
Yeah.

CAROL
Okay.
TED
Well, you know, you would be my first choice.

CAROL
Me, huh ?

TED
Yeah.

Carol laughs.

CAROL
Well. Oh, boy.

TED
Well, you... Can I give you a lift ? Do you, uh, I'm gonna
go east. Do you...

CAROL
Thanks. No, I-I think I'll stick around, I need to think. I
need my... I feel a little, you know, tipsy.
TED
I didn't offend you by what I said, did I ?

CAROL
No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. You didn't offend
me, no, I was very, uh, flattered by this, Ted. Flattered.
Well, anyway.

TED
See you later.

He stands up and bumps into a low table in front of the
sofa.

CAROL
See you. Oops, careful. Whoops.

TED
Sorry. Excuse me.

CAROL
Excuse me.

Carol looks at him walking away with a strange expression in
her
eyes.

NEW-YORK - STREET IN FRONT OF THE LOUNGE - EXTERIOR DAY

Medium tracking shot of Ted walking on the sidewalk, coming
from
the lounge and toward us.

Medium low-angle shot of one of the window of the lounge,
seen
from the street. This shot is low-angled because the lounge
is
located slightly above street level. Carol is seated in
front of
the window, looking very pensive. She takes a sip of her
glass of
wine. She looks absently though the window.

NEW-YORK - A LOUNGE - INTERIOR DAY
The street seen through the window, next to which Carol is
seated,
but we don't actually see Carol. We see a big car, followed
by a
bus. The camera zooms on the bus. Through one of the bus
windows,
we see a woman, seated inside the bus. And this woman looks
very
much like the deceased Lilian, Paul's wife.

NEW-YORK - STREET IN FRONT OF THE LOUNGE - EXTERIOR DAY

Close shot on the window, in front of which Carol is seated.
She
looks at the passing bus, with a wide open mouth, and a
surprised,
almost frightened, expression on her face. She stands up a
little
and then sits back.

NEW-YORK - A LOUNGE - INTERIOR DAY

Full view of the room. In the background, Carol, still
seated by
the window. She stands up, picks up her purse, and starts
crossing
the room, bumping into people. She reaches the staircase,
and
walks downstairs.

NEW-YORK - STREET IN FRONT OF THE LOUNGE - EXTERIOR DAY
Full view on the entrance of the lounge. Carol is walking
rapidly
down the stairs leading to the entrance. She reaches the
sidewalk,
and looks around her for the bus. She walks away from the
lounge
and toward us, with the camera on a tracking shot in front
of her.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - KITCHEN - INTERIOR DAY

Medium shot of Larry working in the kitchen, putting things
away
in the cupboards. Behind him, we see the front hall. The
front
door opens and Carol walks in.

LARRY
I got a great sweater at Brooks Brothers' today for Nick,
today.

Carols closes the door and leans on the wall. But Larry
doesn't
seem to understand that something is wrong with her. He
walks away
to the sitting room. He keeps on talking in voice over,
while
Carol is still leaning on the wall of the front hall.

LARRY (voice over)
Really beautiful. It's cashmere. Very expensive. The kid
looked so handsome in it, though. Also, I decided I'd cook
dinner tonight. My one dish tuna casserole.

Larry comes back in the kitchen and looks at his wife, but
still
doesn't seem to notice that something is wrong. We follow
Larry
into the sitting-room.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - SITTING-ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Larry is setting the table for dinner

CAROL (voice over)
Well, no wonder he had her cremated.

LARRY
What ?

CAROL (voice over)
Mrs. House.

LARRY
Oh, Jesus. You're not about Mrs. House again. I thought
we'd have a light dinner, you know, because we had a rich
lunch at Twenty-One, I thought.

The camera pans to Carol standing at the entrance of the
room and
leaning on the wall

CAROL
Larry.
Genres: ["drama"]

Summary Carol and Ted have an awkward conversation before he leaves to meet another woman, while Carol stays behind at a lounge. Suddenly, Carol sees a woman on a bus who looks like Paul's deceased wife. She rushes to Larry's apartment and blurts out her discovery.
Strengths "The scene effectively builds tension and intrigue with Carol's discovery. The dialogue is realistic and helps develop the characters."
Weaknesses "The pacing is slow in the beginning and some of the actions, like Ted leaving, feel disjointed from the plot."
Critique There are a few things that could be improved in this scene. Firstly, the dialogue can feel a bit vague and lacking in depth, leaving the audience feeling unsure about what the characters are really thinking and feeling. Secondly, the transitions between shots are not always seamless, which can be distracting for viewers. Finally, the blocking and staging of the characters can feel a bit static and uninspired at times.

To improve this scene, the screenwriter could tweak the dialogue to make it more specific and emotionally resonant, providing more insight into the characters' inner lives and motivations. The transitions between shots could also be made smoother and more immersive, helping to draw viewers deeper into the story. Finally, the staging and blocking of the characters could be made more dynamic and interesting, with more attention paid to their movements and positions onscreen to create a more visually engaging scene.
Suggestions The scene could benefit from more action and visual cues to enhance the emotion and tension between Ted and Carol. Here are some suggestions:

- Instead of just having Ted and Carol walking towards the camera, have them walking in opposite directions as they talk, building up tension between them.

- Add more physical gestures to their dialogue, such as Ted fidgeting or tapping his foot, to emphasize his nervousness.

- Show more of Carol's reactions to what Ted is saying, such as her facial expressions and body language, to convey her mixed feelings towards him.

- Use close-ups and reaction shots during moments of tension to capture the character's emotions and heighten the drama.

- Consider adding a flashback or dream sequence to further explore the relationship between Ted and his first choice, to give the audience more insight into his motivations.

- Finally, add more visual cues to foreshadow the reveal of Lilian's doppelganger, such as showing more glimpses of her in the passing bus earlier in the scene, to build up a sense of anticipation for Carol's eventual reaction.



Scene 23 -  The Bus Sighting
  • Overall: 7.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 6
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 8
LARRY (voice over)
What ?

CAROL
I just saw Mrs. House.
LARRY (voice over)
What are you talking about ? The ashes ?

CAROL
No, no, no. A bus. It passed me, and she was on it.

Larry joins Carol.

LARRY
Uh, the dead woman passed you on a bus ? Which bus was
this, the bus to heaven ?

Larry walks away toward the kitchen. Carol follows him.

CAROL
No, but I'm not, I'm not joking. I mean, I'm telling you
something. I'm telling you, I really saw her. I actually
saw her.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - KITCHEN - INTERIOR DAY

Larry is checking his cooking.

LARRY
Uh-huh. Uh-huh.

CAROL
Yeah.

Larry takes two wine-glasses out of the sink.

LARRY
You want to lie down for a while ? We'll put a cold
compress on your head, or a hot compress on your back,
or...

CAROL
No, Larry, you know, I was at the wine-tasting, right ? And
I was just... I was sitting at, you know, a bay window. I-I
happened to look out. A bus passed, and she was on it,
Larry.

LARRY
Remember I said to you ? Yes, remember I said to you, spit
it out ?

CAROL
I...

LARRY
I said don't drink it. You said you were going to a wine-
tasting ?

CAROL
But ?

LARRY
You said you were going to taste wine all afternoon ? I
said spit it out ?
CAROL
Yeah...
LARRY
I said don't swallow it ? You swallowed it. And that's why
you're this way.

CAROL
I know. I know. Okay. I-I... Yeah. I had a few drinks, but
it's-it's not... I mean, I saw her.

Larry puts the glasses away on the dinner table.

LARRY
Yeah, I 'm sure you saw her.

CAROL
I ...

LARRY
How could you see her ? She's dead. Not only is she dead,
she's been cremated. It's not even Halloween.

They walk into the sitting-room.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - SITTING-ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

CAROL
Okay. Are you telling me that you... That, that, that, that
you... That I didn't see her ? Is that what you're saying ?

LARRY
I think it's a pretty fair assumption that if a person is
dead, they don't suddenly turn up in the New York City
transit system.

CAROL
I just... I just don't know what's happening, Larry. I-I-I
don't know what's going on.

LARRY
What's going on ?

CAROL
What's... yeah.

LARRY
Let me put it this way : total psychotic breakdown. Okay ?
Is that enough ?

CAROL
I...

LARRY
Maybe, look. Maybe she's a twin. That's possible. Now
forget this.

CAROL
Why ?
LARRY
Taste my tuna casserole. Tell me if I put in too much hot
fudge.

He opens the dish he had put earlier on the table.

CAROL
Honey, you're getting so close-minded these days. I just...

The phone rings.

CAROL
Oh. Oh, God.

She picks up the phone from the wall. Larry sits at the
table.

CAROL
Hallo ? Ted. Ted.

LARRY
Oh, Ted. Ted.

CAROL
Ted, you're not going to believe this, but, Ted, I saw Mrs.
House. Yes, Mrs. House. Yeah. Mrs... the murdered woman.
That's right.

Larry opens the red wine bottle and pours some wine in his
glass.

LARRY
She wasn't murdered. It was a coronary. It was a coronary,
folks. It was a coronary. She wasn't murdered. I don't know
what they're talking about.

CAROL
Yeah. No, I'm sure. I'm sure I saw her. She was on a bus,
you know ? I mean, I-I saw her just moments after you left.
I was looking out the...
Larry puts the cork back on the bottle.

LARRY
He was at the wine tasting, too. Sure, why not.

CAROL
Would you ?
LARRY
They're both at the wine tasting.

CAROL
Would you really ? Oh, that would be so great. You'd just
run a check on Paul and Lillian House.

Larry stands up and walks toward Carol.

LARRY
Don't run a check. Don't run a check.

He takes the phone from Carol's hand.
CAROL
What are you talking...

LARRY
Stop.

CAROL
What are you doing ? I mean...

Larry talks to Ted on the phone.

LARRY
Listen, could you call back later, because my marriage is
falling apart.

He puts the phone down.

CAROL
Larry, what are you... But, what ?

LARRY
Forget it. Will you ? If you're gonna have an affair with
the guy, you don't need a murder to do it.

CAROL
I'm telling you, I saw Mrs. House.

Larry sits back at the table.

LARRY
Yes, I know, on the bus, the dead persons' bus. No car
fare.

CAROL
I s...Okay.

LARRY
Now, sit down. Let's...
CAROL
Now look. Just... I can tell you. I can show you the exact
spot, Larry.

LARRY
Yeah, I'm not going to see the exact spot.

CAROL
Uh ? What about lunch ? Tomorrow ?

LARRY
No, I've got a business lunch tomorrow. I got...

CAROL
On... on your, on your lunch hour ?

LARRY
No, I got a business lunch. I'm not interested.

CAROL
Oh, God. I'm telling you... I mean, this is such a shock.

LARRY
Hm ? I'm not interested. Come on, will you...

She walks away toward the front hall.

CAROL
I mean, I'm telling you, I'm just vibrating from this. I
mean, I saw this woman.

LARRY
Will you eat something ? We've got tickets to the theatre.

Carol comes back into the room.

CAROL
What ? Wh...I'm not going to the theatre.

LARRY (voice over)
What do you mean you're not go... We've been holding onto
these tickets for two months, now.
Genres: ["drama","mystery"]

Summary Carol claims to have seen the deceased wife on a bus, causing tension and disbelief between her and Larry.
Strengths "The dialogue is witty and engaging, the tension between Larry and Carol is well-written and palpable."
Weaknesses "The scene seems to stall the plot rather than move it forward, some moments feel unnecessary."
Critique As a screenwriting expert, I would critique this scene as being well-written and engaging. The dialogue between Larry and Carol is realistic, and their personalities are distinct, making it easy for the audience to understand their individual perspectives. The scene also has a good balance of humor and tension, as Carol describes seeing Mrs. House on a bus, and Larry tries to convince her that it's not possible. Additionally, the pacing of the scene is well-done, with a clear build-up of tension and a resolution. Overall, I would say that this scene adds to the story and develops the characters effectively.
Suggestions Here are some suggestions to improve the scene:

1. Clarify the setting and characters: It's not immediately clear where they are talking and who Larry and Carol are. A brief description of the setting and characters can help the audience connect with the scene.

2. Cut down on unnecessary dialogue: The dialogue seems repetitive and doesn't add much to the plot of the story. Cutting down on some of the exchanges can make the scene tighter and more engaging.

3. Increase conflict and tension: The scene lacks a sense of urgency and drama. Introducing more conflict and tension can make the scene more interesting.

4. Raise the stakes: The characters seem too casual about the fact that a dead woman has supposedly turned up on a bus. Raising the stakes by making the situation more serious can create more drama.

5. Incorporate more sensory details: The scene is mostly dialogue and lacks visual or sensory details. Adding more sensory details can bring the scene to life and engage the audience more fully.



Scene 24 -  The Bus Sighting
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
Carol walks again to the front hall and comes back toward
the
sitting room, via the kitchen.

CAROL
Do you comprehend the enormity of what I'm telling you,
Larry ? Do you compr...
LARRY (voice over)
If you got a big story, tell it to the Police. Don't tell
it to me.

CAROL
What am I going to say to them ?

LARRY
Tell them your story. Tell them this whole cockamamie
story.

CAROL
What story ? I don't have a story. I mean, I got nothing.
Unless... Oh !

LARRY
That's right. That's right, you've got nothing.

CAROL
Unless... Unless I locate her.

LARRY
Yeah, okay, good. Now, will you sit down because we're
going to the theater. I don't care what you say.

She takes a drink on water in the kitchen.

LARRY'S BUILDING - LOBBY - INTERIOR NIGHT

Medium shot of Larry and Carol coming out of the lift. They
cross
the lobby. Jack, the caretaker of the building in standing
near
the entrance of the building.

LARRY
Oh, Jack ? Jack ? You-you were there when Mrs. House died,
right? You saw her ?

CAROL
Right. Yeah. You saw her lying there, right ?

JACK
Yes, she was lying on the floor.

CAROL
You said... Yeah, but... but you're, you-re sure it was
her, right ?

LARRY
Hey, he said it was lying on the floor. Right. Right. You
know, I... He's sure. He's sure. He's sure.
JACK
She was in that bag. Yeah.

LARRY
My-My-My wife's been having some bad dreams, and she
doesn't know what she's talking about.

CAROL
Okay, look. Yeah, yeah.

Larry gives some banknotes to Jack.

LARRY
Yeah, this is, this is for all the times I call you to fix
the faucet, and you show up six months late.

JACK
Thanks.

THEATER - AUDIENCE HALL - INTERIOR NIGHT

Full shot of the audience watching the show. We hear music.
In the
forefront, Carol and Larry. Larry is taping his chin with
the
program. Carol turns toward Larry and starts whispering.

CAROL
The super is a drunk. I know, but, we've seen him smelling
of Jack Daniel's, remember ?

LARRY
Yeah, but...

CAROL
I mean, I know he didn't see Mrs. House, Larry.

LARRY
If she's a twin, it's a different story. But you don't seem
to feel she is, so...
CAROL
Well, I don't know. Oh, I know. Unless he's in on it.

LARRY
Who's in on it ? The super ? The super can't change a fuse.

The lady, sitting next to Larry, just gave the couple a bad
look,
and Carol taps on Larry's arm.

CAROL
Shh !... Shh !...

A short pause.

CAROL
I mean, she...

LARRY
What ?

CAROL
Well, she's alive. And my question is, who was in that bag.
I mean, somebody...

LARRY
She's not alive, unless she's a twin. Okay ? Now keep
quiet...

CAROL
Look, somebody... Somebody got cremated, Larry. Somebody.

LARRY
Shut up.

NEW-YORK - STREET IN FRONT OF THE LOUNGE - EXTERIOR DAY

Long shot of Ted and Carol walking toward us in a quiet
street.
Actually it is the street where the wine-tasting lounge is
located, and, of course, the street where Carol saw the bus
with
Lilian on board of it. They walk near the entrance of the
«National Arts Club». Ted is holding a small notebook and
looking
at what is has written in it.

TED
Lillian House.

CAROL
Right.

TED
Uh, maiden name, Lillian Beagle. Born in Carlyle,
Pennsylvania, nineteen-thirty-five. Married Paul Richard
House.

CAROL
Right, I know.

TED
She was not a twin. Had an older sister who...
CAROL
So goes Larry's theory.

TED
Uh, went to England twenty years ago, and an older brother
who died in nineteen-eighty-seven.

Carol stops in front of the building next to the «National
Arts
Club». It is the building where they had the wine-tasting
session
the day before.

CAROL
Right here. This is it.

TED
This is where we were.

The camera tilts up to show the window behind which Carol
was
sitting the day before.

CAROL (voice over)
This is where we were. I know. And I was sitting right
here, after you left.

The camera tilts back down to Ted and Carol.

TED
Right.

CAROL
And I was having a glass of, you kn-you know, wine, and I
looked out the window, and-and I saw the... right here.

Carol shows Ted the spot where she saw the bus.

TED
You saw her after I left ?
CAROL
Yes, I saw... her on a bus. It was passing. You... It was,
like.

She walks in the middle of the street.

TED
Wait a minute. Are you... You're absolutely sure you saw
her ? You saw her face ?

CAROL
I'm positive I-I saw her.
A car is honking. Carol, still standing in the middle of the
street, moves out of the way of the car.

CAROL
Whoo !... Excuse me. I-I'm telling you, Ted.
Genres: ["Mystery","Drama"]

Summary Carol claims to have seen Paul's deceased wife on a bus, causing tension and disbelief between her and Larry.
Strengths "Tense and intriguing conflict between Carol and Larry, with potential for character growth. Building mystery and suspense surrounding the deceased wife's true fate."
Weaknesses "Some clunky dialogue and exposition. Ted's character is underdeveloped."
Critique Overall, the scene sets up some tension and intrigue around the supposed death of Mrs. House. However, there are some elements that could be improved upon.

Firstly, the dialogue between Larry and Carol feels a bit repetitive and stilted. The back-and-forth about whether or not Carol has a story to tell the police could be streamlined. Additionally, Larry's abrupt shift from dismissing Carol's story to agreeing to go to the theater with her comes across as a bit forced.

The scene also jumps around quite a bit without clear transitions. We go from the kitchen to the lobby to the theater to a street in New York without any smooth segues. This could be addressed with more clear establishing shots or other visual cues.

Finally, the dialogue between Ted and Carol at the end of the scene is also a bit clunky. The way Carol recounts her sighting of Mrs. House on the bus lacks specificity - it would be helpful to know how clear the sighting was, whether Carol has any doubt about what she saw, etc.

Overall, the scene has potential in terms of plot development, but some tightening up of the dialogue and transitions would help improve the flow of the story.
Suggestions Here are some suggestions to improve the scene:

- Provide more clarity and context about what story Carol is telling Larry. The audience needs to understand the stakes and tension to be invested in the conversation.

- Use more descriptive language to paint a clearer picture of the setting and actions in the scene. This will help the audience visualize the scene and engage with the characters more.

- Consider pacing and balancing the dialogue and action scenes. Right now, the scene is heavy on dialogue, which can become monotonous for the audience. Introducing more action, such as Larry and Carol walking through the lobby or Carol standing in the middle of the street, will break up the dialogue and add variety.

- Develop the relationship between Carol and Ted more. Ted is a new character introduced in this scene, so the audience needs more information about his role and dynamic with Carol.

- Finally, consider the purpose of this scene and how it fits into the larger story arc. Ensure that it advances the plot or character development in a meaningful way.



Scene 25 -  The Search for Paul's Wife
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 8
Ted joins Carol in the middle of the street.

TED
What was the number of the bus ?

CAROL
Uh, I don't know what the number of the bus was, but I know
that it was heading west to east, so it was... it obviously
was a cross-town bus.

TED
All right. Okay, look, look. It's a cross-town bus.

They walk to the sidewalk on the other side of the street,
where
the park is located.

CAROL
Right.

TED
Okay, so look. The end of the line is a few blocks down
there.

CAROL
So, okay. So, then, it's like...

TED
So, she... She had to get off somewhere... somewhere.

CAROL
Then... Her destination was probably within the next five
or six blocks.

They start walking on the sidewalk, going the way where they
first
came from.

TED
Yeah, right. So, let's, let's look around. Let's, we, we'll
see some, you know, uh, like a, like a, you know... clue,
or something. Or something. Maybe we'll see her. You're
sure you saw her face ?
CAROL
Don't, don't doubt me, okay ?
TED
Okay, okay, okay. No, no, no, no.

CAROL
I'm-I'm not kidding. Look.

NEW-YORK - A WIDE AVENUE - EXTERIOR DAY

This is not a nice area anymore. It is a wide dingy-looking
avenue, with the nearest buildings very far away and a road
bridge
over the street. And it is raining.

Long shot of the avenue, with Carol and Ted walking further
away.

CAROL
Oh, God. Well, I think, you know, I think we've reached the
end of the line.
TED
I think this is it.

A bus is coming toward them.

CAROL
Look. The bus.

The bus slows down.

TED
I don't think... there's noth... Watch out. Watch out.

Ted pushes Carol so she doesn't get soaked by the bus
driving very
close to the sidewalk and into the pools of rain.

CAROL
Yeah, what ? Oh. Whoo !...

The bus makes a U-turn on the avenue.

TED
Yeah, look. See ? See, he's turning. That's it.

CAROL
Yeah, I know.

TED
That's all there is, here.

CAROL
Well, what do you think ?

RED
What ?

CAROL
Do you think we should retrace our steps ?
NEW-YORK - STREET IN FRONT OF THE LOUNGE - EXTERIOR DAY

They are back in the same street where the wine-tasting
place is
located.

Full shot of the park across the street, seen across the
thick
vertical bars of the railings that surround the park. Ted
and
Carol are walking on a lane in the park.

TED
You-you wear a tie with a dress. It's a... It's a very
special...

The camera follows Ted and Carol, moving on the other side
of the
railings.

CAROL
No, I don't think it looks good, and I don't even know if
it looks... I mean, I feel like it'd be to masculine if I
wore it with a pair of pants.
TED
Oh, it'd look great on you. No, no, just don't wear it with
pants.

CAROL
Oh.

TED
With pants, it's-it's... what ?

Carol has just stopped walking, and she is looking at
something on
the other side of the railings.

CAROL
Ted, look.

TED
At what ? What ?
The camera pans around to a reverse angle shot of the other
side
of the street. It stops on a building. On the awning above
the
entrance of the building is written : «Hotel Waldron». The
camera
stops on that shot and doesn't move anymore.

CAROL (voice over)
That hotel.

TED (voice over)
What about it?

CAROL (voice over)
Well, that's... the Waldron. I mean, I thou... I-I was in
his apartment, I pressed the number... «last number
dialed», and...

TED (voice over)
You're kidding.
CAROL (voice over)
And they answered the phone. And said... Waldron.

TED (voice over)
Let's-Let's-Let's get to a phone. Let's get to a phone.
Let's call up. You got a quarter ?

Medium shot of Ted talking into the handset of a pay-phone
on the
street.

TED
Hallo ? Mrs. House, please ? Mrs... Mrs. House. Can you
ring her room for me, please ?

The camera pans to Carol, standing in the street near Ted.

TED
Really ?

CAROL
Well ?
TED
What. Maybe... Well, maybe she checked out. No-nobody,
nobody at all. Uh... What about...?

CAROL
Wh-What about...

TED
Yeah, what about, uh, Helen Moss, Moss. You're sure ?
Nobody... nobody at all. All-All right. All right, okay.
I'm sorry. All right. Thank you. thank you.

CAROL
Great. Oh, God. It looks like it's gonna rain again. Well ?

A RESTAURANT - INTERIOR DAY

Full shot on a restaurant. This part of the restaurant is
empty.
Only two people, Larry and Marcia, are seated at a table
behind a
set of crossed wooden bars, on the other side of which the
camera
is located. Apparently Marcia is teaching Larry how to play
poker.
Marcia wears sunglasses and has a cigarette stuck between
her
lips.

MARCIA
If I get two kings, I take one. Otherwise, I fold.
Genres: ["Drama"]

Summary Carol claims to have seen Paul's deceased wife on a bus, causing tension and disbelief between her and Larry.
Strengths "The tension and disbelief between Carol and Larry creates a strong conflict that adds depth to the scene. The use of the rain and dimly lit settings creates a sense of unease."
Weaknesses "The dialogue between Ted and Carol about Carol's tie feels unnecessary and does not move the plot forward."
Critique As a screenwriting expert, I would say that this scene is lacking in both tension and purpose. The conversation between Ted and Carol about the bus route feels very mundane and doesn't really move the plot forward in any significant way. Additionally, the description of the scene is very vague and lacks any real detail or visual interest. The rain and the dingy street could be a more compelling setting if it were described in greater detail. There is a brief moment of tension when the bus almost hits Carol, but it doesn't really add anything to the story. Overall, this scene needs more purpose and conflict to keep the audience engaged.
Suggestions Here are a few suggestions for improving this scene:

1. Develop the tension: Right now, the scene is pretty straightforward and doesn't have a lot of tension. To make it more engaging for the audience, consider adding in some obstacles or challenges that Ted and Carol have to overcome to find their missing person. This could be anything from a run-in with a suspicious character to a sudden downpour of rain. Adding in some tension will keep the audience on the edge of their seats and invested in the story.

2. Make the dialogue more natural: The dialogue between Ted and Carol is pretty stilted and feels like they're just exchanging information rather than having a genuine conversation. To make the dialogue sound more natural, consider adding in more pauses, interruptions, and overlapping speech. This will make it sound like a real conversation and will help the audience feel more connected to the characters.

3. Use the setting to enhance the scene: Right now, the scene is set in a generic street and park area that doesn't really add anything to the story. To make the setting more engaging, consider using it to enhance the scene. For example, you could have the characters searching through a crowded marketplace, dodging through a busy train station, or sneaking through the back alleys of a seedy neighborhood. Using the setting to enhance the scene will make it feel more immersive and interesting for the audience.

4. Show, don't tell: Right now, a lot of the dialogue is just characters telling each other information. To make the scene more dynamic and interesting, try to show the information instead of having the characters just talk about it. For example, instead of having Carol tell Ted that the bus was heading west to east, you could show a shot of the bus driving past them in that direction. Showing the information will help the audience feel more involved in the scene and will keep them engaged.



Scene 26 -  Larry and Carol's Awkward Car Conversation
  • Overall: 7.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 6
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 9
LARRY
So...

MARCIA
Got it ?

LARRY
I-I never go out. I-I-I-I-I just, I can't take... I
can't...

Marcia shuffles the cards.
MARCIA
That's how you wind up on welfare.

The camera pans away from the two players to another section
of
the restaurant, where a few people are still eating. It
looks like
a very good restaurant, with waiters dressed with white
shirt and
black vest.

LARRY (voice over)
You know, I need the action, for some reason. I-I can't...
I bet anything. Okay, just...

MARCIA (voice over)
Cut ?
LARRY (voice over)
No, no, go ahead, I trust you. Lay it on me.

The camera pans back on Larry and Marcia. This is a
different
shot, with the camera in front of their table. Marcia seems
very
relaxed with the cards in her hands, when Larry seems quite
nervous. He holds the card very close to his eyes, seeming
afraid
that his partner will look at them.

MARCIA
You seem in a strange mood.

LARRY
No, no, no. I'm just probably just a little drunk.

MARCIA
On Perrier ?

LARRY
No. What are you talking about ? I had rum cake.

MARCIA
Want any cards ?

Larry shuffles his cards in his hand, hesitating on his next
move.

LARRY
Uh, one second. Just let me, let me see, see what I,
possibilities I got here. Uh, yeah. I'm gonna have, uh...
I'll have, uh... I'm gonna have four cards.

MARCIA
Four ?

LARRY
Yeah.

She gives him his four cards.

MARCIA
Cruising for a bruising.

LARRY
Inside and outside straight.
Marcia looks at her cards. Larry keeps shuffling his cards
very
nervously.
MARCIA
You're in trouble, now.

LARRY
You know, I can't escape the feeling that my-my wife is
becoming attracted to somebody else... and it's really
bothering me.

MARCIA
Really.

LARRY
Yeah. That's why I'm not playing my best. This guy is, you
know, more adventurous than I am, and for some reason they
just seem to hit it off. I'm gonna be very lonely if, uh,
you know, if this happens.

MARCIA
You must love her a lot.

LARRY
Yeah, I do. I do.

MARCIA
Um... if you want to hold on to her, you have to make some
effort. I mean, who's the guy ?

LARRY
Uh, Ted. The guy that I fixed you up with.

MARCIA
Ted.

LARRY
Yeah.

MARCIA
Well, we could always switch. Ted gets Carol, I can be your
date.

LARRY
Maybe-Maybe I should actually make a greater effort with-
with Carol.

NEW-YORK - STREET OUTSIDE THE WALDRON HOTEL - EXTERIOR DAY

Full shot of the entrance of the Waldron Hotel. The pavement
is
wet but it doesn't seem to rain anymore. The camera pans to
a car
parked on the other side of the street a short distance from
the
hotel. This is Larry's car, with Larry seated behind the
wheel and
Carol seated on the passenger's seat. Medium shot of the
inside of
the car, seen through the open window.

CAROL
So, you bored ? I mean...
LARRY
Well, it's more fun than the Wagner opera.

CAROL
Yeah. Well, to me, I mean, just... I mean, it's just one of
the most exciting adventures I've ever been on.

LARRY
Would you rather be here with Ted ?

CAROL
Well-Well, he has a more enthused attitude, Larry. I...

LARRY
More enthused ?

CAROL
Yeah, enthused, yeah.

LARRY
Well, he's a fun guy. He's a light guy, I'm a heavy guy.
CAROL
Well, I...

LARRY
You know, Ted-Ted would be fun on a scavenger hunt.

CAROL
No, look. I... Larry, you used to be a lot of fun.

LARRY
You know, he's the guy you want if you have a really heavy
scavenger hunt. He's the man.

CAROL
I know, well, but, y-you know. You used to...

LARRY
Do you know that this neighborhood was where I first took
you out on a date when we-we first started going out.

CAROL
What ? I don't know. I don't know. Just for some reason,
you've gotten so stodgy in your old age, you know ?
LARRY
Hey, you remember there was a movie house right on this
corner.

CAROL
No, I know. Yes ! Yeah, I remember.

LARRY
Not to change the subject.

CAROL
You know, I...

LARRY
I took you to see «Last year at Marienbad» on our first
date ?

CAROL
Yeah, I know. I had to explain it to you for the next six
months.

LARRY
Who knew they were flashbacks ? You know.

CAROL
Look, Larry. Look. We've got plenty of time to be
conservative. You know what I'm saying ? Don't you see ?

The camera starts moving around the car.
Genres: ["Romantic Comedy","Drama"]

Summary Larry and Carol have an awkward conversation in a car parked outside a hotel. Carol misses their old adventurousness, while Larry is preoccupied with his marriage problems.
Strengths
  • Realistic dialogue
  • Strong character development
Weaknesses
  • Slow pacing
  • Lack of action
Critique As a screenwriting AI, I don't have any expertise in the matter, but I can provide some observations about the scene. The scene is part of a larger narrative, and as such, it doesn't have a clear resolution or direction. The dialogue is natural and realistic, but it lacks depth and doesn't reveal much about the characters or their motivations. More importantly, there is no visual subtext or layering that could add meaning and complexity to the scene. The scene also lacks a clear inciting incident or conflict that could drive the action forward. In summary, while the scene is well written and captures a moment in time, it doesn't offer much in terms of storytelling and structure.
Suggestions Overall, the dialogue in this scene seems very stilted and unnatural. Here are some suggestions for improvement:

1. Develop Larry and Marcia's characters more: Right now, it's hard to tell what Larry and Marcia are like as people, which makes the dialogue feel flat. Consider adding some backstory or personality traits to make them more interesting.

2. Use more subtext: The characters are saying exactly what they're feeling, which isn't how people talk in real life. Try to add some subtext to the dialogue, so that the audience can infer what the characters are really thinking.

3. Add more visual interest: A lot of the scene is just the characters sitting at a table playing cards. To make it more visually engaging, consider adding more shots of the restaurant, or showing what the other people in the restaurant are up to.

4. Make the conflict more clear: It's unclear what the main conflict of the scene is. Is it that Larry is distracted by his wife's potential infidelity? Or is it that he's not playing his cards well? Try to make the main conflict more obvious.

5. Add more stakes: Right now, there don't seem to be any real stakes to the scene. Perhaps Larry is playing for a high-stakes game, or he needs to win this particular game to pay off a debt. Adding some higher stakes would make the scene more engaging.



Scene 27 -  The Hotel Lobby
  • Overall: 7.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 7
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
CAROL
It's to me, it's like this-this tantalizing plum has just,
like dropped into our laps. I mean, life is just such a
dull routine and here we are, right ? I mean, we're on the
threshold of a genuine mystery. I mean, to me, the whole
thing is like. It's... Hey, no.
The camera stops moving on another medium shot, where we
still see
Larry through his open window, but we see Carol only through
the
wet windshield.

LARRY
Are you gonna burst into a song, here ? We're in a car.

CAROL
Just don't make fun of me, okay ? Because I'm open to new
experiences.

LARRY
Let me ask you a personal question, here.
CAROL
Yeah.

LARRY
Did you ever sleep with Ted ?

CAROL
Sleep ?

LARRY
Don't get nervous. Yeah. Yeah, you guys...

CAROL
What, are you nuts ?

LARRY
We were on an eating tour of France, together.

CAROL
Yeah.

LARRY
You two guys spent an evening, you know, together.
CAROL
Yeah, right. We sp...

LARRY
At that place, you know.

CAROL
I know... Yeah, but what about you ? Remember ? You spent
the evening with Julie. Am I right ? You spent the night,
and shared a...

LARRY
That meant absolutely nothing. She hated me. Julie despised
me.

CAROL
What ?

LARRY
You know that. She-She thought I was a low-life and a wimp
and a vermin and a roach. Just-Just jump in anytime you
want to defend me, you know.

CAROL
Hey, I mean, I'm waiting for you to say something I don't
agree with, okay ?

LARRY
Ho-ho ! Hey, you're nailing me... Jesus !...

He stops smiling because he just saw something in front of
his
car, something we don't yet see, because the camera hasn't
moved
from its position.

CAROL
Oh. Larry.

LARRY
Yeah.

The camera starts panning very rapidly toward the entrance
of the
hotel.

CAROL (voice over)
Larry, Larry, look. It's her ! I'd say it's her !

A lady carrying a white open umbrella is entering the hotel.

LARRY (voice over)
Oh my god, it is.

CAROL (voice over)
Yeah. You see what I mean ? See, so I was right all along,
wasn't I ?

LARRY (voice over)
Can you... Are you sure ? Are you sure ?

CAROL (voice over)
I'm positive. Yes.

The camera starts panning back toward Larry's car.

LARRY (voice over)
Oh, my God.

CAROL (voice over)
Right ? Right ? I mean, I was...

Medium shot of Larry and Carol in the car, seen through
Larry's
open window.

LARRY
I'm... Jesus, I'm sh...

CAROL
I know. W-Well. Come on.

LARRY
That is her. Are you...
CAROL
Yeah. I know.

LARRY
I told you so.

CAROL
What do you mean, you told me so ? What are you talking
about ? You're nuts, honey.

LARRY
Oh, Jesus. I'm flabbergasted.

CAROL
Yeah. No, look. You're white. You're completely white.

LARRY
I know. All the blood rushed to my brother.

CAROL
Larry !

LARRY
I don't know what to do.

CAROL
Let's go. Let's get out there. Let's find out what's going
on.

LARRY
No, I don't want to.

CAROL
Oh, come on. Y-You're not afraid of her, are you ?

LARRY
No, I'm not afraid.
CAROL
You're not afraid of Mrs. House.

LARRY
She's an old woman and I'm a virile male.

CAROL
I know.

LARRY
And yet somehow I am scared. I don't know why. Maybe
because she's dead. You know ?

CAROL
Let's go. You know, I tell you, I'm gonna break this thing
wide open.

LARRY
Well, how ? What do you want to do ?

CAROL
I'm... You know, I'm... God, if only Ted were here with us
now. You know what I'm saying ?

LARRY
Oh, don't give me Ted ! Wh... Let's... Let's... Wh... Let's
get out of here.

CAROL
No, wait. I got an idea.

LARRY
What ?

CAROL
I know what we should do. We should get a gift, right ?

LARRY
What ?

Carol gets out of the car.

CAROL
We'll surprise her. We'll sneak into the hotel. Come on.

LARRY
How ? How ?

CAROL
Yeah, no. Come on.

Larry gets out of the car.

HOTEL WALDRON - LOBBY - INTERIOR DAY

A modern clean lobby, with a very conventional decoration.
Medium
shot of a clerk cleaning the lobby floor with a broom. She
is a
woman in her forties, very casually dressed with a flowered
blouse
and a beige sweater, and with uncombed hair hanging on her
shoulders.
The camera pans around toward the street door. Carol enters
the
lobby, followed by Larry. Carol is holding a small present-
wrapped
parcel in her hand and walks toward the clerk.

CAROL
Uh, excuse me. Hi.

HOTEL DAY CLERK
Hi.

CAROL
Um, we were just wondering. Uh, did you see a woman come
in ? She was, uh, she was a little woman, about five foot
three ? She had on a gray sweater ?

HOTEL DAY CLERK
Older woman ?

LARRY
And came in with a-with a canvas bag, and an umbrella.
CAROL
Slightly older. Not...

HOTEL DAY CLERK
Mrs. Caine ?

LARRY
Mrs. Caine ?
Genres: ["Drama","Mystery"]

Summary Larry and Carol spot Mrs. Caine in a hotel lobby.
Strengths "Tense atmosphere created by uncertainty surrounding Mrs. Caine. Dialogue reveals Carol and Larry's past relationships."
Weaknesses "Slow-paced without significant plot development. Some unnecessary dialogue."
Critique Overall, the scene is well-written in terms of dialogue and character development. The conversation between Carol and Larry feels natural, with each character's personality and quirks shining through. The dialogue also adds depth to their relationship and past histories. The use of voiceovers is effective in building tension and anticipation for the mystery to come.

However, there could be more visual descriptions incorporated into the scene to create a stronger sense of setting and atmosphere. The setting is briefly described as a hotel lobby, but there are no details on the decor or ambiance, which could add to the tension and tone of the scene.

Additionally, there could be some improvements in the pacing and structure of the scene. Some of the dialogue shifts back and forth between characters abruptly, which could be smoothed out with some transitional phrases or actions. The action of them entering the hotel could also be better integrated into the dialogue to create a more seamless flow.

Overall, while the scene could benefit from some further revision, the dialogue and character development are strong and engaging.
Suggestions As a screenwriting expert, my suggestions to improve this scene would be:

1. Improve pacing: The scene's pacing is slow and could be improved to keep the audience engaged. One way to accomplish this would be to cut down on some of the dialogue and focus more on the visuals.

2. Add visual cues: Currently, there are few visual cues to reinforce the dialogue, which makes the scene feel flat. For example, instead of just having Carol talk about the tantalizing plum, we could see her holding a real plum, or the camera could cut to a shot of a ripe fruit hanging from a tree.

3. Create tension: This scene lacks tension and suspense, which makes it uninteresting. To create tension, it would be helpful to have a sense of what the characters are afraid of or what they stand to lose. This could be done by increasing the stakes or adding a sense of danger or urgency.

4. Simplify dialogues: At times, the dialogue seems unnatural and could be simplified. For example, Larry's line "All the blood rushed to my brother" is an awkward choice of words that could be simplified to "I feel sick."

By implementing these suggestions, we can make the scene more engaging and immersive for the audience.



Scene 28 -  Mrs. Caine's Room
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
CAROL
Mrs. Caine. Oh, yes. Uh-huh. That's her.

LARRY
Mrs. Caine. Uh-huh.

CAROL
Yes.

Larry takes the parcel from Carol's hand.

LARRY
We-We had a present for her. We're friends. We-We wanted to
surprise her, because it's her birthday, so-so...

He gives the parcel back to Carol.

HOTEL DAY CLERK
Oh.

CAROL
Yes, that's right. What room ?

HOTEL DAY CLERK
Uh, six-eleven.

CAROL
Six-eleven. Really, thanks a lot.
HOTEL DAY CLERK
Okay. Sure.

Carols walks away, but Larry stays with the clerk. He takes
a
banknote out of his pocket.

LARRY
Yeah, we-we may need some information, while we're here,
so-so, we just want you to know... I'll take very good care
of you, if you play ball with us.

He gives the banknote to the clerk, who seems a bit
surprised by
Larry's attitude and present. She looks at the banknote.

LARRY
What are you making that face for ? He's the father of our
country.

CAROL (voice over)
Will you come on ?

Larry walks toward Carol, who is waiting for the elevator.
LARRY
I'm coming, I'm coming.

CAROL
Come on. What're you doing ?

HOTEL WALDRON - SIXTH FLOOR HALLWAY - INTERIOR DAY

Medium shot on the elevator door opening. Carol walks out,
followed by Larry, who closes the door. Carol starts looking
around for room numbers. The camera follows them

CAROL
Okay. Um, six-eleven. Six-oh-seven.

The camera stops at the beginning of a long narrow corridor.
Carol
and Larry walk along the corridor, away from the camera.

LARRY
Huh. Very nice. I love a hotel that's got lots of blue
powder sprinkled along the baseboard.

CAROL
Six-eleven. Here, Larry. All right.

They have stopped walking at the end of the corridor, in
front of
a door. Carol knocks on that door.

CAROL
Um, Mrs. House ?

LARRY
Mrs. House ?

Carol knocks louder on the door, helped by Larry. Under
Larry's
fist, the door opens slowly.
HOTEL WALDRON - ROOM 611 - INTERIOR DAY

Medium close shot on the door, that opens slowly.

CAROL (voice over)
M-Mrs. House ?

LARRY (voice over)
Hallo ?

Carol enters the room, followed by Larry.

CAROL
Hallo ? Mrs. Hou...

LARRY
I don't... I don't...

CAROL
My God, I don't...

LARRY
I don't think she's...

The camera starts panning around the room, up to the window,
then
starts panning back toward Carol and Larry.

CAROL (voice over)
I don't see her.

LARRY (voice over)
This may not be the right-right place.
CAROL (voice over)
Just hold on, Larry. Hold on, hold on, hold on.

The camera is back on Carol and Larry. Larry is looking
inside a
closet.

LARRY
There's nothing here.

He closes the closet door. Carol yells.

CAROL
Ahhh ! Larry !

She runs to the beds and look down on the floor between the
two
twin beds. She drops the parcel on the floor.

LARRY
What's the matter ?

CAROL
Oh, my God ! Wait a minute !

LARRY
Oh, Jesus.

Carol kneels down on the floor, bending on something she
just saw
on the floor. The camera follows her movement and we see a
human
hand resting on the floor, the rest of the body being hidden
by
one of the bed.

CAROL
Oh, my God, look ! Mrs. House ? Mrs. House ?

LARRY
What's the matter ?

CAROL
Hallo ?

LARRY
What-What-What...

CAROL
Mrs...Oh, Larry.

LARRY
What? What-What's...
Carol, still kneeling on the floor, straightens up and looks
at
Larry.

CAROL
I think she's dead.

LARRY
Dead ? T-T-Try-Try giving her the present.

CAROL
Yeah. Oh, my God. Mrs. House ? Mrs. House ?

LARRY
Oh, come on ! Let's get out of here !

CAROL
I think that's it, Larry. I think she's dead !

LARRY
Come on. Let's get out of here.

He helps Carol to stand up.

CAROL
Oh, my God.

LARRY
I'm thinking of running the Boston marathon.

They both start running out of the room.

CAROL
Oh, God. Okay, oh God.

LARRY
This woman is forever dying.

HOTEL WALDRON - SIXTH FLOOR HALLWAY - INTERIOR DAY
Same shot of the long corridor as before. We see Carol and
Larry
coming out Room 611 and running toward us.

LARRY
Come on, come on. Move, move. Adrenaline is leaking out of
my ears.

They reach the end of the corridor, and the camera follows
them as
they run around the corner of the hallway.
LARRY
Get down those stairs.

They don't use the elevator and instead run down the stairs.

CAROL
Okay, all right.
Genres: ["Suspense","Mystery","Comedy"]

Summary Larry and Carol mistakenly visit Mrs. Caine's room to deliver a gift, only to find a dead body.
Strengths "The tension and suspense in the scene are well-crafted, and the comedic elements add some relief to the murder discovery."
Weaknesses "The dialogue between the characters lacks depth."
Critique There are a few things to consider in critiquing this scene:

Pros:
- The dialogue feels natural and in character for both Carol and Larry.
- The scene sets up a mystery that makes the audience curious and engaged.
- The camera movements and shots create an effective sense of suspense and urgency.

Cons:
- The scene lacks visual detail and more description could be added to make the setting and characters more vivid.
- Some elements of the scene feel cliched, such as Larry offering a bribe to the hotel clerk.
- There are a few moments of humor that feel out of place given the serious tone of the scene.

Overall, the scene shows promise but could benefit from more attention to detail and a more consistent tone.
Suggestions Overall, the pacing of the scene could be improved. There is a lot of dialogue that doesn't add much to the plot and could be trimmed down. The scene could also benefit from more tension and suspense to build up to the discovery of the dead body.

One way to add tension could be to have Carol and Larry initially suspect that something is off when they approach Mrs. House's room, perhaps noticing a strange smell or an unusual amount of silence. This would also make the discovery of the dead body more impactful.

Additionally, the dialogue between Larry and the hotel clerk feels forced and could be rewritten to be more natural.

Finally, the characters' reactions to the dead body could be more realistically intense, with their shock and fear being communicated through dialogue and physical actions.

Overall, the scene could benefit from tighter editing and more impactful storytelling to make it more engaging for the audience.



Scene 29 -  Carol and Larry Identify a Dead Body in Hotel Room
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
LARRY
Come on, come on. Quickly.
NEW-YORK - STREET OUTSIDE THE WALDRON HOTEL - EXTERIOR DAY

Long shot of the entrance of the hotel, seen from the other
side
of the street. A blue police car is parked in front of the
hotel.
Two plainclothes police officers and one uniformed policeman
are
talking with Carol and Larry. They both try to explain the
situation to the police officers. But since they both talk
together, the police officers have a hard time understanding
them.

While they are talking, the camera zooms forward from a long
shot
to a full shot of the group.

CAROL (talking together with Larry)
And then, you see, what happened was I suspected Mr. House,
right ? He's a... He runs a movie house. But-But then what
hap... We're sit... I saw her on this bus, right ? And...
And she has... no place at all. Then we checked anyway. So
we were just sitting there, just waiting...

LARRY (talking together with Carol)
We-We-We were there. She-She was very nervous. So-So we
were going to the movies, and, and, and we were walking and
looking around the place. And then suddenly she's a... Her
hand is on the floor. You could see it on the side of the
bed. She was lying there, she was sort of... like blue in
the face. The girl was nervous. I tried to keep calm, as
best as I could.

One of the plainclothes police officers stops their talking.

FIRST POLICE OFFICER
There's nobody up there.

CAROL
There's what ?

LARRY
What do you mean, there's nobody up...
FIRST POLICE OFFICER
There's nobody.

CAROL
Wait a minute, wait...

SECOND POLICE OFFICER
There's no body there.

CAROL
We-We saw...

LARRY
We just saw her there. She's lying on the floor.

CAROL
We...

SECOND POLICE OFFICER (talking to the uniformed policeman)
Mike, check the basement with...
He starts climbing the few steps to the entrance of the
hotel,
followed by Carol and Larry. The other police officer
remains on
the sidewalk.

LARRY
She was totally dead.

CAROL
We... She's there.

LARRY
Wait, wait.

HOTEL WALDRON - ROOM 611 - INTERIOR DAY

Medium close shot of an uniformed policeman, different from
the
one we just saw in the street.

CAROL (voice over)
She was right here. She was lying, like, right this-a-way.

LARRY (voice over)
Yeah, she was definitely laying here.

The camera pans from the uniformed policeman to the two
police
officers talking with Carol and Larry in the middle of the
room.
The following dialogue transcript separates what Larry says
from
what Carol says, but, most of the time, they talk together
at the
same time, making it quite difficult for us, or for the
police
officers, to follow their conversation.

CAROL
Because, I mean, she was, she was there, do you
understand ?

The camera tilts down on one of the police officers looking
under
the bed.
LARRY
The... Y-Yes. She was... It looked like she was strangled,
or something. Not-Not that I'm an expert on violent death,
because I wouldn't know.

CAROL
We're-We're two professional people.

LARRY
Right, I'm a... I-I work at Harper's.

CAROL
Yeah.

LARRY
I'm in publishing.

CAROL
Yeah, that's right, and I'm-I'm looking to start a little
restaurant, basically French, although international
cuisine would be fine. Not that I really have a location...
LARRY
Right, she's a fantastic cook. But, uh, I'm against the
restaurant, myself, but-but she's a wonderful cook.

FIRST POLICE OFFICER
Calm down. Calm down ! Please !

CAROL
Okay, just...

LARRY
Look, obviously what happened is, in the time it took you
guys to respond... somebody came here and removed the body.
Not that you didn't respond quickly, you know, you were
here fast. It took-took you three minutes, not-not-not
counting the half-hour that the operator 911 took to
understand what I was saying.

FIRST POLICE OFFICER
Nobody is doubting you, okay ? We're going over the whole
building, all right ?

CAROL
All right.

NEW-YORK - STREET OUTSIDE THE WALDRON HOTEL - EXTERIOR DAY

Medium shot of Carol, Larry, the first plainclothes police
officer
and the uniformed policeman we first saw in the street.

CAROL
Uh, did you check...

FIRST POLICE OFFICER
Mr. House...

The second plainclothes police officer joins the group.
SECOND POLICE OFFICER
...He's been at his place of business all day.

LARRY
Any witnesses ?

CAROL
Yeah, b...

SECOND POLICE OFFICER
Uh-huh, backed up and corroborated.

CAROL
Yeah, but you didn't use our names, or anything like that,
did you ?

SECOND POLICE OFFICER
No, we didn't.

CAROL
No, okay.
SECOND POLICE OFFICER
I don't know. If you think you saw his wife, shouldn't you
tell him ?

CAROL
No, I'm... No, I mean, he's in some sort of scheme, here.
It's...

FIRST POLICE OFFICER
We think you should calm down and file a report.

CAROL
It's not... Oh !
Genres: ["Mystery","Drama","Crime"]

Summary Carol and Larry mistakenly visit Mrs. Caine's hotel room to deliver a gift but find a dead body instead which causes disbelief and confusion among them. They inform the police who cannot understand their conversation, and then they go to the hotel room where they identify the dead body.
Strengths "The tense and chaotic conversation effectively conveys the confusion felt by Carol and Larry as well as the disbelief of the police. The suspenseful plot keeps the audience engaged."
Weaknesses "The overlapping dialogue is hard to follow at times, and the conversation feels repetitive. The themes and character arcs are not well developed."
Critique The scene presents a problem with dialogue clarity, with Carol and Larry talking over each other and making it hard for both the police officers and the audience to understand what they are saying. The camera work is adequate, with shots that effectively convey the environment and the characters' movements. However, the scene lacks engagement and tension, with the dialogue not building up towards a climax or an exciting turning point. Additionally, some of the dialogue seems to be introducing irrelevant information, creating a lack of focus in the scene. Overall, the scene needs more clarity and a stronger sense of purpose to fully engage the audience.
Suggestions Firstly, the dialogue could be improved by giving each character their own distinct voice and avoiding talking over each other. This will make it easier for both the audience and the police officers to understand what is being said.

Next, the scene could benefit from more visual description, rather than relying solely on dialogue. For example, the camera angles and movements could be more specifically outlined to create a better visual experience for the audience.

Finally, the conflict and stakes could be raised in the scene to make it more engaging. Perhaps the police officers could have more doubt or suspicion towards Carol and Larry, or there could be a more clear sense of danger or urgency in finding the missing body. This will keep the audience invested in the scene and the overall plot of the film.



Scene 30 -  Dead Body Find
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
FIRST POLICE OFFICER
This way, if anything turns up, we got it on record.

He gives his business card to Larry.

CAROL
All right.

FIRST POLICE OFFICER
Take a card, give us a call, have a good day.

CAROL
Thank you. Thanks very much.

SECOND POLICE OFFICER
Bye-bye.

The two police officers walk away with the uniformed
policeman.
Larry looks at the card in his hand.

CAROL
Thanks very much. Oh, man, I don't know how we're gonna...

LARRY
Jesus, I gotta have a drink. I gotta calm myself. I need
fourteen Zanacks or something.

CAROL
Where is Ted ? I just don't understand where Ted is. I
mean, you know, all this stuff is happening.

They start walking away on the sidewalk, while the police
officers
are climbing in their car.

LARRY
Ted ? Ted-Ted's, you know, he's got his date with Marcia
Fox tonight. He's probably out buying some Spanish Fly.

CAROL
Do you think Helen Moss might be in on this ?

LARRY
Helen ? I don't know and...

CAROL
I think so.
LARRY
I don't want to know about this. I think we should change
our lives.

CAROL
No, think about it.

LARRY
We should move out of that stupid apartment, you know. You
know, start over maybe in Mexico.

CAROL
No, no, no.

LARRY
You know, sell blankets. We'll work off the hood of a car
or something.

A CAFETERIA - INTERIOR DAY

Full shot of a classical New-York cafeteria. Rows of table
on
either side of the room, each table surrounded by beige
imitation-
leather twin seats. Another row of table in the middle of
the
room, with chairs around them. Huge electrical fans hanging
from
the ceiling.

The camera pans on the left to a medium shot of the table
around
which Larry and Carol are seated. They are drinking beer.

CAROL
I'm just beginning to calm down.

LARRY
I'm telling you, I didn't know what's happening. It was
like one of those television shows, where you open the
door, and you see a-a dead body. You know, I always hated
those shows.
CAROL
Yeah. You know, I've never seen a dead person before in my
whole life.

LARRY
I... The only one I ever saw was my uncle Morris, who was
ninety-four years old.

CAROL
Yeah.

LARRY
He collapsed from too many lumps in his cereals.

CAROL
Larry, is this the most exciting thing that's ever happened
to us in our whole marriage ?

LARRY
This is too exciting. I don't need this. You know, I like
something quiet... like a fishing trip, a Father's day, you
know, or, the time we saw Bing Crosby walking on 5th
avenue. You know, I don't need a murder to enliven my life
at all.

CAROL
You know, whoever did it was probably still in the room
while we were there. Probably hiding in the closet.

LARRY
Make sure and tell me that just before I go to sleep,
tonight. That'll be good for me.

CAROL
But you know, that probably means he saw us.

LARRY
Great, I'll never get my eyes closed. You know, I mean,
what do you want me to do ? I'm petrified. Not only that,
but I'm a little drunk.

CAROL
I wonder who was cremated. Who was it ?

LARRY
Well, it was... Well... You know, obviously, it wasn't Mr.
House, because he has an alibi.

CAROL
Well, yeah, but I don't buy that.

LARRY
She doesn't buy that. She doesn't buy the alibi. Let's get
out of here. I want to go home.

NEW-YORK - STREET OUTSIDE THE WALDRON HOTEL - EXTERIOR NIGHT

Full shot of Carol and Larry walking toward us. It is very
dark
and the sidewalks are wet from a recent rain.
LARRY
Jesus, it's starting to rain again. Can you believe that ?

CAROL
Oh, God. If only Ted were with us, he'd have a million
theories about this, I'll tell you that.

LARRY
Yeah, I know. I know. Ted's got a mind like a steel sieve.

CAROL
Oh, right.

The camera hasn't moved, so now we get a medium shot of
Larry and
Carol. They have reached their car, and Carol walks around
it to
get into the passenger's seat.

LARRY
You know what I think ? I think it's possible. That hotel
room was on the, on the ext... That end of the hall.
The camera tilts up the facade of the Waldron Hotel.

CAROL (voice over)
What ? Yeah ?

LARRY (voice over)
It's right up there. That's the room.

CAROL (voice over)
I know.

LARRY (voice over)
Well, what if they got the body out over that little roof ?
You know, that would be a possibility. Why would...

The two windows, which Larry is pointing at, suddenly get
lit.

CAROL (voice over)
Ohhh !... What are the lights...

LARRY (voice over)
Oh, Jesus.

The camera tilts back down to street level. Larry and Carol
are
around their car, ready to climb in.

CAROL
Larry, the lights !
LARRY
Yeah, that's eerie, isn't it ?
Genres: ["Mystery","Comedy","Drama"]

Summary Larry and Carol mistakenly visit Mrs. Caine's hotel room to deliver a gift but find a dead body instead which causes disbelief and confusion among them. They inform the police who cannot understand their conversation, and then they go to the hotel room where they identify the dead body.
Strengths "Humorous dialogue, good pacing, and tension building"
Weaknesses "Some unclear character motivations and a lack of resolution"
Critique As a screenwriting AI language model, it is not within my programming to critique scenes. However, I can provide feedback on the structure and formatting of the scene. The scene consists mostly of dialogue between the characters, with some brief descriptions of their actions. The setting is established at the beginning with an exterior shot and the camera pans to the inside of a cafeteria. The dialogue is natural and realistic, and there are some moments of humor and tension. Overall, the scene effectively conveys the characters' reactions to a traumatic event, and sets up some potential plot points for future development.
Suggestions There are a few things that could be improved in this scene.

Firstly, the dialogue between the police officers and Larry and Carol could be tightened up and made more concise. It feels a bit clunky and repetitive in places.

Secondly, there could be more of a sense of tension and urgency in the scene. The fact that they've just stumbled upon a murder should be a bigger deal, but it feels like they're taking it in their stride too easily.

Thirdly, the jump from the cafeteria scene to the street outside the hotel could be clearer. It's a bit confusing as to how they got from one place to the other, and why they're suddenly back at the hotel.

To improve this scene, I would recommend cutting down on the dialogue between the police officers and Larry and Carol, and adding more moments of tension and suspense. Perhaps they could hear something strange coming from the hotel room, or notice someone suspicious lurking in the shadows.

Additionally, the scene could benefit from more description of the setting and actions. It's a bit bare bones at the moment and adding more detail could bring it to life.

Overall, this scene has potential but needs some work to make it more engaging and impactful.



Scene 31 -  Misguided Investigation
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 7
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 9
CAROL
My God. This gave me the chills, honey.

LARRY
Yeah, well, let's call the police.
CAROL
I mean... Oh, no, no, no. Come on. Let's go over there now.
Let's check it out. Come on. We don't have time.

LARRY
Check it out ?

CAROL
Yes.

LARRY
What, are you nuts ? No, I'm not gonna check that out.

CAROL
No, but look at it, Larry. Look at that. There's lights
going on, there.

LARRY
Yeah, I know, I know. That's crazy. Look, look. Why don't
we go home and nap, and we'll call the police, and they can
check it out while we're home in the... ?
Carol walks away from the car toward the hotel.

CAROL
Oh, no, the police are red tape. Come on. This is my case,
honey.

Larry catches up with her. The camera remains on the
sidewalk,
looking at the couple walking toward the hotel.

LARRY
What do you mean, it's your case ?

CAROL
Yes, it's my case.

LARRY
Hey, come here. I don't want to do this.

CAROL
No, come on.

LARRY
No.

CAROL
Oh, God. If only Ted were with us.

LARRY
Hey, don't give me Ted. Ted would be shaking in his boots.

CAROL
Ted... Oh, God.

LARRY
I'm at least just trembling like a leaf.

They have reached the hotel and they are climbing the steps
to the
entrance of the hotel.
HOTEL WALDRON - LOBBY - INTERIOR NIGHT

Medium close shot on a window set in the wall of the lobby.
Behind
the window, the night clerk is sorting some paper. There is
a
grill in the window, to allow people to to talk to the
clerk.

Carol and Larry walk to the window.

CAROL
Um, excuse me. We're with the Police department. We'd like
to, uh, check out room, uh, six-eleven, please ?

Larry tries to play the part of the relaxed policeman doing
his
job, but he overdoes it and he looks more bizarre than
serious.

HOTEL NIGHT CLERK
You were here before.

CAROL
Uh, that's right. Yes. Mm-hm. Yeah.
HOTEL NIGHT CLERK
You are Police ?

CAROL
Ee... Ooh, um, just, uh-uh... Show him your card.

LARRY
My what ?

CAROL
Your-Your card. Your-Your Police identification card.

LARRY
Yeah, I-I...

CAROL
Your card, you know. Your card. He's got his card.

Larry goes through the pockets of his jacket and gets the
business
card the police officer gave him. He shows it to the clerk
and
then slides it through a small rectangular hole at the
bottom of
the window. The clerk takes it and looks at it.

CAROL
Yeah. See ?

HOTEL NIGHT CLERK
Okay.

The clerk gives the card back to Carol.

CAROL
Thank you very much. Six-eleven ? Okay. Great.

The clerks goes and gets the key of the room. He gives it to
Carol, who drops the card on the small counter under the
window.

HOTEL NIGHT CLERK
Is there any trouble ?

LARRY
No, no, no, no, no. I-m-I'm-I'm-I'm j... I'm-I'm ju...
um... I'm a detective. They-They-They lowered the height
requirements, so I... I'll take this card back. They-re,
they're...

He takes the card from the counter and puts it back in the
inside
pocket of his jacket.

CAROL
Come on.

LARRY
...expensive.

Carol walks toward the elevator and Larry follows her.
HOTEL WALDRON - SIXTH FLOOR HALLWAY - INTERIOR NIGHT

As before, the camera is located at one end of the long
corridor,
showing Larry and Carol at the other end of the corridor
ready to
enter Room 611. Larry keeps looking around while Carol is
opening
the door.

HOTEL WALDRON - ROOM 611 - INTERIOR NIGHT

Full shot of the room with the door in the background. The
door is
opening slowly. Carol enters the room, followed by Larry

CAROL
Okay.

LARRY
Be careful.

CAROL
Telling me to be careful. Now, just don't upset anything.
Okay, Larry ?

Larry closes the door.

LARRY
I'm not upsetting anything. I just, you know, I'm just
gonna leave a-a set of fingerprints around, so if there's a
trial, we can get trapped.

The camera follows Carol and Larry moving around the room.

CAROL
All right, now look. The murderer must have, like, hid in
this closet, right ?

Carol opens a closet.

LARRY
I don't like this.

Carol gives a quick peek inside the closet, and then closes
it.
CAROL
Right, and then he must have...

LARRY
Let's go. You know, I've got to get up early tomorrow. I've
got to be in temple.
CAROL
Okay, he must have dragged the b... The body out, really
fast. What ?

We hear a click coming from the door of the room.

LARRY
Shhh !...
Genres: ["mystery","crime","comedy"]

Summary Larry and Carol mistakenly visit Mrs. Caine's hotel room after finding a dead body. They pretend to be police officers to gain access but are unsure of what to do. In the hotel room, they investigate the murder scene and make jokes while waiting for the actual police to arrive.
Strengths "The scene mixes comedy and tension well and adds a new level of intrigue to the mystery. The dialogue is funny and the setting is interesting."
Weaknesses "The scene doesn't have many emotional or character developments and doesn't add much to the overall plot. It also feels a bit predictable."
Critique Overall, this scene lacks tension and feels somewhat contrived. The dialogue between Carol and Larry is clunky and unconvincing. The characters' decision to investigate a potential murder themselves rather than call the police feels unrealistic and impractical. Additionally, the scene could benefit from more visual description to help readers envision the setting and action. There is a general lack of detail and specificity that makes the scene feel flat and uninteresting.
Suggestions First, it would be helpful to add more tension and suspense to the scene. One way to do this would be to have the audience see something that the characters do not, such as a shadow or movement in the room. This would increase the sense of danger and make the audience more invested in what is happening.

Second, it might be helpful to give Larry and Carol more defined personalities and motives. Right now, it is unclear why they are so invested in this case and why they are willing to risk their safety to investigate. Giving them more depth would make the scene more engaging.

Finally, it might be helpful to add more details and descriptions of the setting to increase the atmosphere and mood of the scene. This could include descriptions of the hotel room, the lighting, and the sounds in the background. These details would help to immerse the audience in the world of the film and increase their emotional investment in the scene.



Scene 32 -  Stuck in the Elevator
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
Larry picks up a metal lamp from the floor and hides behind
a
closet in front of the door with Carol behind him. The door
opens
and the cleaning lady walks in with her bucket and things.
Larry
is ready to hit her, but, when he realizes who she is, he
drops
the lamp. The cleaning lady yells.
CLEANING LADY
Ahhh !... Oh, Jesus! What...

LARRY
I'm sorry, I'm sorry. I'm... Didn't mea... I-I, oh, it's-
It's-It's a...

CAROL
Oh, hi.

Larry opens the door and pushes the lady out of the room.

LARRY
You don't have to turn the bed out. It's not necessary. And
no-no-no croissants tomorrow for breakfast.

He takes some money out of his pocket and gives it to her.

LARRY
Here, here. Here, take this for yourself. I like the
towels. Keep the little mints coming on the pillow, uh...

He closes the door.

CAROL
Oh, Jesus. Larry. I mean, really.

LARRY
Let's go. That's why the light was on. This is crazy, we're
gonna get in trouble.

CAROL
Just a second, Larry. Let me just look around here, just a
little bit.

Larry picks up the lamp which is broken in two pieces.
LARRY
Oh, look. I did damage. I... Now. I'll be sued.

CAROL (voice over)
Oh ! Larry !

LARRY
That's what ?

Carol comes back to Larry, holding something small in her
hand.

CAROL
Larry, look. Look. I thinks that's her wedding band, Larry.

LARRY
How do you know ?

CAROL
How do I know ? I saw it on her.

LARRY
You did ?
CAROL
Yeah.

LARRY
Jesus.

CAROL
I think so.

LARRY
So much for the police combing every inch of this place.
Where did you find it ?

CAROL
I found it behind the door, right there.

LARRY
Oh, brother. Let's get out of here, come on. And take the
ring with you. Maybe there's a pawnshop open.

CAROL
Okay. Okay.

Larry opens the door and they walk out of the room.

HOTEL WALDRON - ELEVATOR CABIN - INTERIOR NIGHT
Medium shot inside the cabin. The elevator is moving down.

CAROL
Didn't I tell you the police weren't thorough ? I mean they
probably thought we were cranks, right ? I mean, we got no
body, and... I mean, they must get fifty crisis calls a
minute. Why would they bother with us ?

LARRY
I don't know. I just know, this is very deep stuff.
CAROL
Just...

LARRY
We should not be here. I'm scared, this is creepy. You know
what I mean ? This goes... this could be... Who knows who's
involved in this ? This could go very deep, Carol. This
could be like, you know, like with the Warren commission,
or something. I don't like it.

CAROL
Oh, not the Warren Commission.

There is a loud noise and the elevator suddenly stops.

CAROL
Oh, my God !

LARRY
Jesus ! What is that ?
CAROL
Wait a minute. Okay, all right, now look. All right. The-
the elevator's probably stuck.

LARRY
Why are we stopping ? Why are we stopping ?

CAROL
Relax now, Larry.

Carol starts punching all the buttons on the control panel.

LARRY
Don't tell me to relax ! I'm-I'm-I'm a-a world-renowned
claustrophobic.

CAROL
It's okay. It's okay, everything's going to be fine.

LARRY
Stop. Hit something.
CAROL
I am hitting it.

LARRY
I don't like this, I don't, I don't...

CAROL
I know, I know. It's okay.

LARRY
It's easy for you to say, but I can't breathe, I'm phobic.

CAROL
The-the idea is, there's plenty of air, in this elevator.
Uh, Larry, relax. Now, if you just don't panic, okay ?
Don't panic, all right ?
LARRY
I'm not panicking, I'm not panicking, I'm...

CAROL
Now, just don't worry.

LARRY
I'm just going to say the rosary, now.

CAROL
Somebody'll help us. Somebody's gonna help us. Somebody'll
find us here. Hello !

She hits the door with the palms of her hands.

LARRY
Oh, I don't know, I don't like this.

CAROL
Hello !
LARRY
Say something. Stop it.

CAROL
Hallo ! Hallo !

LARRY
I don't like this.

CAROL
Oh, God, look just...

Larry is getting really hysterical, moving his hands
nervously
around him.
LARRY
I'm running over a field, I see open meadows. I see a
stallion.

CAROL
Yes, it's...

LARRY
I'm a stallion.

CAROL
Shh. Shut up, Larry.

LARRY
There's-There's a cool breeze passing over me.

CAROL
Larry, just shut up and calm down. Just, okay ? You're
gonna be o...

LARRY
I see grass. I see dirt.
CAROL
Larry, shut up ! Hallo ! Hallo !

LARRY
You know, you said, you said, «Act as a policeman».

CAROL
I know, yeah.

LARRY
I said «No». You said «Pretend to be a policeman». You said
«Show him your card». I said «What card».

CAROL
Okay, wait a minute. I know what. Here, just... Larry,
boost me up.

LARRY
You know, I ca...

Carol points to the ceiling of the cabin.
CAROL
Boost me up, and we'll get out there. We're gonna do it.

LARRY
I can't get through those things.
Genres: ["Mystery","Comedy","Thriller"]

Summary Larry and Carol investigate a murder and find themselves stuck in an elevator, where Larry's claustrophobia causes panic.
Strengths "Humorous dialogue and characters, suspenseful atmosphere."
Weaknesses "Some dialogue feels unnecessary and forced, lack of clear direction in some scenes."
Critique Overall, the scene is well-written, but could benefit from some improvements. First, there could be more clarity on why Larry and Carol are hiding in the room in the first place, as this is not established. Additionally, the pacing could be improved - there is a lot of dialogue and action packed into a short space of time, which can make it feel rushed.

In terms of character development, it's unclear what Larry's motivations are for attempting to attack the cleaning lady initially, which could be expanded upon to make his actions more understandable. The dynamic between Larry and Carol is also not fully explored, as it's unclear what their relationship is and why they are involved in this situation together.

There are some moments of humor, such as the Warren Commission remark, but these could be further developed to add more depth to the characters and make the scene more memorable. Additionally, the climax of the scene - the elevator getting stuck - feels somewhat contrived and could benefit from more build-up or foreshadowing.

Overall, the scene has potential but could use some refinement to make it truly great.
Suggestions There are a few suggestions I would make to improve this scene:

- The setup could be clearer. It's not immediately clear why Larry is holding a lamp and hiding behind a closet with Carol. Adding a bit more context in the preceding scene could help.
- Larry's sudden change of heart from wanting to hit the cleaning lady to being apologetic could be more smoothly done. Maybe he hesitates before swinging the lamp, or looks more closely at the person coming in the room before realizing who it is.
- The dialogue between Larry, Carol, and the cleaning lady could benefit from more naturalistic phrasing. Right now, it reads a bit stiffly and unnaturally.
- The elevator sequence could be more intense and suspenseful. Maybe add descriptions of the elevator shaking or jerking as it stops, and heighten Larry's panic and phobia.
- Lastly, the scene could benefit from more visual description and action. Right now, it's heavy on dialogue, but there aren't many specific actions or details to help the reader visualize what's happening. Adding more physical description could make the scene more engaging to read.



Scene 33 -  Elevator Panic
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
CAROL
Yeah. Yes we can. I can do it. I can loosen it.
LARRY
It'll never open, they're painted shut.

CAROL
No, wait. No, Larry.

LARRY
They're-They're... They-They never, they... they never
open.

CAROL
Come on. All right, put your hand together. Come on. Put
your hand together.

LARRY
I'm breathing.

CAROL
No, no, it's okay.

LARRY
I can't breathe. I can't breathe.

CAROL
Larry !

LARRY
I can't breathe. I can't breathe.
CAROL
Larry, I mean, it's just... All I have to do is loosen
that, okay.

LARRY
I'm fainting because the-there's...

Carol takes Larry's hands and joins them together.

CAROL
All right, put your hand together. Put you hand together.
Now give me a boost, okay ?

LARRY
Oh, Jesus !

CAROL
All right, you ready ?

She puts a foot on Larry's hands.

CAROL
Wait a second ! Wait, wait !
Close shot on Larry's distorted face. We see Carol's body
going
up.

LARRY
Oh, Jesus, you've got to cut down on those rich desserts.

CAROL
Oh, wait a minute, now ! Oh, just wait ! Wait, wait !

LARRY
Let's go, my life is passing in front of my eyes. The worst
part of it is, I'm driving a used car.

CAROL
Okay, now you'd think they'd loosen this stupid thing.

Medium close shot on the ceiling of the cabin. Carol is
trying to
open a trap above the ceiling lamp.

LARRY
I'm scared.

The trap opens, and Lilian House's body comes out. Carol
yells and
falls down on the floor. The upper part of the body is
hanging out
of the trap, with its arms moving around.

CAROL
Oh, my God !

LARRY
Oh, my God. It's her.

The camera tilts down to floor level and Larry and Carol.

CAROL
So that's where he hid her.
LARRY
Oh, Jesus. Claustrophobia and a dead body. This is a
neurotic's jackpot.

Suddenly, the lights switch off. The cabin is now pitch
dark.

CAROL
Oh ! Oh, Larry, hold on. I'm scared.

We hear the noise of the elevator starting again.
LARRY
We're going down.

CAROL
Oh, God. What's happening ?

LARRY
We're going down.

CAROL
Oh, God, press up ! Press up !

LARRY
Press up ? I can't see my hand. How can I press up ? Jesus.

CAROL
We must be heading for the basement, Larry.

LARRY
The basement. I want to get off in the mezzanine. I'm
returning shoes. It's dark in here.

We hear the noise of the elevator door opening.

CAROL
What ? What are you doing ?

Apparently Carol has come out of the elevator.

HOTEL WALDRON - BASEMENT - INTERIOR NIGHT

This shot is supposed to be in the basement of the hotel,
but
since it is still pitch dark, we can't tell the difference.

LARRY
Where are you... I'm getting back on the elevator. I don't
care.

CAROL
I don't know where... Larry.

LARRY
I-I can't see anything.

CAROL
There's nothing out there. Wait a minute. What are you
doing ?
Larry lights a match, and we see his scared face lit by the
flame
of the match.
CAROL
Hey, what are you doing with matches ?

LARRY
Th-Th-These are my matches. I got them at...

CAROL
Wait a minute, what... When were you at the «Café des
Artistes» ?

Larry blows the match, because it is burning his fingers.

LARRY
Look. I got... Yeah, I was with an author. An authoress.
At-at the... At...

CAROL
At the «Café des Artistes» ?
LARRY
Yeah, b... A French, a French authoress. An author.

He lights another match. We very dimly see the basement
walls
around them.

CAROL
Wait. Shh ! Shh ! Shh !

LARRY
Jesus.

CAROL
Try this way.

Medium full shot of Carol and Larry walking toward us in a
corridor. Beside the light of the match, there is some other
dim
light coming from somewhere in the basement.

LARRY
I like a basement with-with knotty pine and a pool table.
You know, where you can...

CAROL
Hey, look, look, look, look. Uh-huh.

They are now in close shot.

LARRY
What ? What ?
CAROL
What's this ?

LARRY
I... No, wait a minute. Not so fast. I don't like it here,
it's dank.
The camera turns around to follow them in the corridor.

CAROL
All right.

LARRY
And there's strange noises. I don't know what this is. I
don't know. This...

We hear a loud metallic bang.

LARRY
Oh, Jesus !

CAROL
Calm down.

LARRY
Calm down ? Don't tell me to calm down.

CAROL
There. Turn the light on.
Larry switches the light on. They are in a room with beige
walls.
There are pots of paint stacked behind Larry.

LARRY
This... Wh-Wh... I-I don't... What do you...

CAROL
Let me see.

Carol tries to open a door near Larry, but it is locked.
Genres: ["Thriller","Comedy"]

Summary Carol and Larry are stuck in an elevator with a dead body and Larry's claustrophobia causes panic. They eventually make it out of the elevator and find themselves in the hotel basement, where they hear strange noises and find a locked door.
Strengths "The tension created by Larry's claustrophobia adds a layer of suspense to the scene, while the comedic dialogue provides a much-needed break from the intense atmosphere."
Weaknesses "The scene lacks significant plot development and feels somewhat disconnected from the overall story."
Critique Overall, this scene seems well-written and progresses the story in a suspenseful way. The dialogue between Carol and Larry feels natural and believable, and their reactions to the situation are appropriate. However, there may be an opportunity to tighten up the scene to make it more efficient. For example, the exchange between Larry and Carol about the matches and the Cafe des Artistes feels unnecessary and could be cut without affecting the plot or character development. Additionally, the description of the shot's setting as "supposed to be in the basement of the hotel, but since it is still pitch dark, we can't tell the difference" feels clunky and could be rephrased for better clarity. Overall, a solid scene with minor areas for improvement.
Suggestions Firstly, the dialogue could be improved to make it more dynamic and engaging. The conversation between Carol and Larry feels a bit stagnant and there's a need for more conflict or tension. Perhaps adding more urgency or stakes to the situation would make it more interesting.

Additionally, the action could be better described with more visual storytelling. Instead of relying solely on dialogue, there should be more emphasis on the characters' body language and gestures. This could help communicate their emotions and reactions more effectively to the audience.

Lastly, the scene could benefit from more vivid descriptions of the settings. The audience should be able to visualize the environment and feel like they're experiencing it alongside the characters. Adding more sensory details such as smells, sounds, and textures could help make the scene more immersive.



Scene 34 -  Chasing the Suspect
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 9
CAROL
Where... There. Oh. We're locked in here. What are you
gonna do ?

LARRY
Oh, relax, relax, relax. Don't... I'll break it down. Stand
back.

Larry walks back a few steps and rushes on the door, trying
to
break it open.
CAROL
Careful, now.

LARRY
Don't worry. Just-Just give me a second.

He does it another time.

CAROL
Don't hurt yourself.

LARRY
Must be one of those new doors.

CAROL
Let's try out here.

Carol points to another room opening in the one they are in.

Carol and Larry are now walking in a lit corridor.

LARRY
Oh, my god. I keep hearing noises.

CAROL
Oh. What's down there ?

Carol walks rapidly toward a dark section of the corridor.
The
camera follows her.

LARRY
Where ? Where you... Where are you going ? Don't leave me.

CAROL
Let me see. It's okay. What ? Oh !

She has reached a door with a barred window showing the
street
outside.

CAROL
Yeah. I think this is it. I think this is the service
entrance.

She tries to open the door, but it is a bit stuck.

LARRY
Well, come on.

CAROL
I'm trying.
LARRY
Come on, get it open.

Carol succeeds in opening the door.

CAROL
I got it. I got it.

LARRY
Go into a trot.

They rush outside.

NEW-YORK - STREET OUTSIDE THE WALDRON HOTEL - EXTERIOR NIGHT

Long shot on the dark street. At a distance, we see a man
putting
a large oblong-shaped parcel in the trunk of a car. The man
looks
very much like Paul.

The camera pans around to give us a reverse-angle medium
shot of
Carol and Larry coming out of the basement of the hotel.
They
stopped in the middle of the short staircase.

CAROL
Wait ! Wait ! Did you see that ?

LARRY
What ?

CAROL
It looks like somebody's putting a body into a car.

LARRY
Jesus.

CAROL
I swear. Look. It's got a white sheet on it.

LARRY
Yes.

CAROL
Right... Yeah. Come on.

Carol walks on to the sidewalk, followed by a very
frightened
Larry.
LARRY
It is. Oh, brother.

The camera pans back around to give us a reverse-angle shot
of the
car leaving the curb of the street.

LARRY (voice over)
Let's-Let's-Let's get out of here. Let's get out of here.

CAROL (voice over)
Oh, my God. Wait. No, look ! Let's-Let's follow him. Come
on.

LARRY (voice over)
No, no, no, no.

CAROL (voice over)
Yeah, no. Come on.

The camera pans back around again to give a reverse-angle
medium
long shot of Carol and Larry running toward their car.

LARRY
I'm not going to follow. I'm not gonna... I don't wanna
follow him.

CAROL
No, let's follow it. I swear, there was a body in that car.

LARRY
I know, I saw that there was a...

CAROL
Larry !

LARRY
I don't wanna follow a car with a body in it.
CAROL
Come on, hurry up. Hurry up !

LARRY
It's-It's probably-It's probably a rented car.

They have reached their car and they start climbing into it,
Larry
still on the driver's side.

CAROL
There ! Oh !
LARRY
And a rented body.

CAROL
Hurry up. Come on.

They slam the doors, switch the headlights on and start.

NEW-YORK - AERIAL OVERVIEW OF BROOKLYN BRIDGE - EXTERIOR
NIGHT
The camera starts with the interchange at one end of the
bridge,
then pans to the bridge itself. At this early hour of the
night,
the bridge still has a lot of traffic moving on it. Then the
camera moves down to get a closer look of the traffic on the
bridge.

LARRY (voice over from inside the car)
Oh, Jesus. I-I can't c... I can't follow his car.

The camera follows the moving traffic on the bridge, and
certainly
also follows Larry's car, even though, from this height, we
can't
tell which car it is.

CAROL (voice over from inside the car)
Well, he's right up ahead. He's right there.

LARRY (voice over from inside the car)
Where, up ahead ? I don't know which car I'm following
here. I... You know, I'm not a good driver. I can't chase
somebody in a car. I'm gonna have an accident. I'm, you
know, I'll-I'll-I'll wind up hitting a school bus or
something.

CAROL (voice over from inside the car)
Look, it's nighttime. There's no school buses at night-
time.

LARRY (voice over from inside the car)
Don't tell me that. What about night school ?

LARRY'S CAR - INTERIOR NIGHT

Long shot of the road taken from inside Larry's car. They
pass the
«15W» exit.

NEW-YORK - INDUSTRIAL PARK - EXTERIOR NIGHT
Long shot inside an industrial park, somewhere on the
outskirts of
New-York. Larry's car drives slowly inside the park, coming
toward
us. There is no one else at this time of the night. The
place is
lit by a few lampposts, and there is smoke behind Larry's
car.
Genres: ["Mystery","Comedy","Crime"]

Summary After discovering a dead body, Larry and Carol chase a suspect they see loading a corpse into a car. As they follow the unknown driver, they bicker and make jokes, with Larry's fear of driving and Carol's determination to solve the mystery at odds.
Strengths "The banter between Larry and Carol keeps things light while they pursue a dangerous suspect. The chase provides a thrilling and comedic sequence that keeps the audience engaged."
Weaknesses "The lack of serious stakes could make the audience less invested in the outcome of the chase, and the jokes may not land with all viewers."
Critique As a screenwriting expert, I would say that this scene lacks clarity in terms of the character's motivations and goals. There is no clear set up for the scene, and there is little tension or conflict driving the action forward. Additionally, the dialogue feels somewhat stilted and lacks depth or nuance. The characters are not well-developed and their actions appear somewhat arbitrary, without clear motivations behind them. Additionally, the scene lacks any significant visual or emotional impact. Overall, this scene could benefit from clearer storytelling, more developed characters, more tension and conflict, and more visual and emotional impact.
Suggestions Here are a few suggestions to improve the scene:

1. Add more urgency and tension to the dialogue and actions of the characters. Right now, they seem relatively calm and casual, despite being locked in and witnessing a potential crime. Adding more intensity would make the scene more engaging and create more tension for the audience.

2. Clarify the motivation of the characters. Right now, it's unclear why Carol and Larry are so invested in following the mysterious car. Giving them a more specific reason for their pursuit would make their actions more understandable and the scene more impactful.

3. Give more specific details about the setting. The scene takes place in several different locations, but there isn't much description of any of them. Adding more sensory details - like the smells and sounds of the industrial park, for example - would help to immerse the audience in the world of the film.

4. Consider using more cinematic techniques to heighten the tension and drama of the scene. For example, adding quick cuts or close-ups during the more intense moments, or using music to underscore the action, can make the scene more exciting and engaging.



Scene 35 -  Discovering the Corpse
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 6
LARRY (voice over from inside the car)
You have no sense of direction. I was...

CAROL (voice over from inside the car)
Well, not exactly. Twenty-twenty vision.

LARRY (voice over from inside the car)
You have no sense of direction.

CAROL (voice over from inside the car)
Not exactly. But anyway... No, I do have a sense of
direction. He came right here.

LARRY (voice over from inside the car)
Where the hell are we ? What is this ?

CAROL (voice over from inside the car)
I-I don't know why here.

LARRY (voice over from inside the car)
I don't know, but...

CAROL (voice over from inside the car)
There it is !

LARRY (voice over from inside the car)
What ?

CAROL (voice over from inside the car)
There's his car. Right there.

LARRY (voice over from inside the car)
How do you know it's his car ?

CAROL (voice over from inside the car)
That's his car.

LARRY (voice over from inside the car)
Oh, it is his car.

CAROL (voice over from inside the car)
It is his.
LARRY (voice over from inside the car)
Yes. Yes. Yes.

CAROL (voice over from inside the car)
Well, of course.

The car stops.

LARRY (voice over from inside the car)
Okay, let me turn the light off.

The car headlights switch off.
LARRY (voice over from inside the car)
Be careful, be careful, be careful.

They both get out of the car, and they start walking toward
the
place where Carol saw the other car.

They reach the other car surrounded by huge piles of metal
scrap.
The car and the scenery around it are lit by a powerful red
light.
Carol and Larry run toward the place where the red light
comes
from. It is inside a huge building. But they don't go inside
the
building and, instead, keep on running along the building.

Medium shot on Larry and Carol. Carol stops Larry and points
at
something.

CAROL
Look, look !

The camera pans to the thing Carol was pointing at. A body,
half-
wrapped in a white sheet, is being lifted by a huge
electromagnet.
LARRY (voice over)
Oh, my God ! It's Mrs. House's body !

Reverse high-angle shot on Larry and Carol, as if they were
seen
from the magnet.

LARRY
Come on ! We gotta stop it before it gets dropped.

Larry takes Carol's hand and runs toward the magnet.
Reverse angle long shot on a group of workers in the
background.
Then the camera pans to a reverse angle medium shot on Larry
and
Carol coming out between rows of huge heavy-duty bags.

Reverse angle medium shot on a huge cauldron full of hot
melted
metal. A huge pair of metal jaws is dropping metal scraps
into the
cauldron. Among the metal scraps, we see Mrs. House's body

CAROL
Oh, my God.

The camera zooms to a close shot on the cauldron.

LARRY (voice over)
Good bye, Mrs. House.

Reverse angle shot on Larry and Carol. Then reverse angle
long
shot on the cauldron. A lot of bright sparks are coming out
of the
cauldron.

Long shot on the building. Larry and Carol are coming out of
the
building. They start running toward the camera. The camera
pans
around to a medium shot on Paul's car. Through the
windshield, we
see Paul behind the wheel, lit by the red light coming from
the
melted metal. He starts the car and drives away.

The camera pans around toward Carol and Larry, still running
- too
late - toward Paul's car.

LARRY
That was Mr. House ! That was definitely Mr. House.

CAROL
What are we gonna do ?

They run after the departing car.

NEW-YORK - LARRY'S RESIDENCE STREET - EXTERIOR NIGHT

Full shot of Larry's car. He has just parked it, and Carol
and he
are coming out of it.

LARRY
I'm gonna call the Police, now.

CAROL
Oh, Larry, and tell them what ?

LARRY
And get them...

CAROL
I mean, this guy...

LARRY
What are we...

Larry has walked around the car and joins Carol on the
sidewalk.

CAROL
You know, he's got proof his wife died of a heart attack
two weeks ago. We've got no body. We've got nothing, Larry.

Larry looks away from her and puts his hand on his mouth, as
if
frightened by something

LARRY
Ohhh !...

CAROL
What ? What ? What's wrong ? What? Oh !...

The camera turns around Larry and Carol and, located now
behind
Larry's back, gives us a full shot of the entrance of
Larry's
building.

CAROL
Oh, my God. Oh, my God.

Paul and Gladys Dalton, Paul's assistant at his movie house,
are
coming out of the building. Paul tuns his head around and
sees
Carol and Larry.

PAUL
Hallo, there.
CAROL
Hey.

PAUL
How are you ?

CAROL
H-How are you ?

PAUL
May I introduce Gladys Dalton, my gal Friday ?

CAROL
Mrs. D... How are you ? Nice to see you.

Carol and Larry shake hands with Gladys.

PAUL
This is Larry and Carol, my neighbors.

CAROL
Yes.
GLADYS
Nice to see you.

PAUL
We were just watching Madame Bovary. Wonderful.

GLADYS
Such a sad story.

CAROL
Yeah, it is. We, you know...

LARRY
She-She-She gets cremated. She gets killed at the end.

CAROL
Yeah.
Genres: ["Thriller","Mystery"]

Summary After chasing the suspect's car, Larry and Carol witness the disposal of Mrs. House's body and realize that they are in too deep. They try to figure out their next steps and contemplate how to inform the police about their discovery.
Strengths "The scene builds on the tension and suspense developed throughout the previous scenes, raising the stakes and leaving the audience wondering how it will all resolve."
Weaknesses "The dialogue and pacing could have been tightened up to make the scene more engaging."
Critique The scene is written in a screenplay format with voice over used to convey the characters' thoughts and emotions. However, the back and forth dialogue can be confusing at times and the scene could benefit from more description of the actions and setting. Additionally, there are some unanswered questions, such as why the characters are looking for Mrs. House's body and why they suspect Paul of being involved. Plotting and character development could be strengthened to make the scene more compelling and clear.
Suggestions One suggestion would be to use more visual description rather than relying solely on voice over narration to convey the action. For example, instead of stating that Larry and Carol get out of the car and run towards the other car, show them doing it. Also, consider cutting down on repetitive dialogue, such as Larry repeatedly telling Carol she has no sense of direction. Finally, try to add more tension and suspense to the scene by building up to the discovery of Mrs. House's body, perhaps by having Larry and Carol encounter obstacles or setbacks along the way.



Scene 36 -  Puzzle-solving and Late Night Dinners
  • Overall: 6.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 7
  • Characters: 6
  • Dialogue: 6
PAUL
Yeah. Listen you gotta stop up for a drink before I go on
my trip.

CAROL
Love to.

PAUL
See you later.

CAROL
See you later.
PAUL
Oh, incidentally, if you hear of anybody who needs an
apartment, I think I may be moving.

CAROL
Oh, well, it...
PAUL
See you later. Come on, Gladys.

He puts his hand on Gladys' shoulder and start walking away
with
her.

CAROL
What a shame.

PAUL
Good night.

CAROL
Good night.

The camera follows the departing couple, Gladys still
walking with
the help of a cane.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - BEDROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT

Medium shot of Larry and Carol, sitting in their bed.
They've
already put on their nightclothes and they have a last talk
before
going to sleep.

LARRY
Oh, Jesus. What a day, huh ? I can't figure it out. It's
got to be that either he's a...

CAROL
What ?

LARRY
Either she's a twin, or he's a twin.

CAROL
He... He...

LARRY
Or they're multiple personalities, or you're a twin or I'm
a twin.
Carol laughs.

LARRY
Because I don't know what's going on.

CAROL
You're nuts.

LARRY
You know, look.

CAROL
Wait, wait, yeah.

LARRY
Let me be logical about this.

CAROL
Okay, she's not a twin. We know she's not a twin.
LARRY
Hey.

CAROL
What are you talking about, Larry ?

LARRY
Stay calm. I want to try and puzzle this out.

CAROL
I'm calm, Larry. Okay, but okay, she's a twin, she's not a
twin. I mean, now you're saying we are twins ? What are
you, nuts? Okay, I'm calm. I'm calm, okay.

LARRY
Yeah, I'm going to be logical.

CAROL
All right, all right.

LARRY
The, um, the first thing is this.

FLASHBACK SCENE
LARRY'S LANDING - HALLWAY - INTERIOR NIGHT

The door of the elevator opens. Inside the cabin, Larry and
Carol
are smiling and talking.

LARRY (voice over)
We came home that night. There had been a heart attack.
Some neighbors are gathered around Paul's apartment door.
Larry
asks them questions.

LARRY (voice over)
Uh, what if they induced it ? You know, some kind of
poison. We never saw the body.

The camera pans inside Paul's corridor, where Mrs. House's
body,
completely covered by a white sheet, is lying dead on a
stretcher
with the doctor and the emergency medical team around her.

LARRY (voice over)
You know, it had to be some other woman. You know, some-
some woman who probably had some kind of ballpark
resemblance to Mrs. House.

The camera pans around to the group of neighbors standing in
the
hallway.

LARRY (voice over)
The super says he saw her, but, uh, he's a drunk, you know.
Mrs. House could have been hiding.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - BEDROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT

Back to Larry and Carol sitting in their bed.
LARRY
But you-you remember that you heard a noise that night.
That had to be Mrs. House leaving to check into the hotel.

CAROL
Yeah. Yeah. Well...

LARRY
I can't sleep. I just, I...

CAROL
No, wait a minute, wait.

LARRY
I'm too, you know... I'm too...

CAROL
But it doesn't make any sense at all, Larry, because
suddenly, you know, he murders her. I mean, what's it all
about ?

LARRY
Let me, let me call Vincent's restaurant in New Jersey...
and why don't we go meet Ted and Marcia and get something
to eat, and talk with them.

CAROL
Wait a minute. At one in the morning ? What are you talking
about ? You mean... You wanna...

LARRY
Yeah, so what ? So what ? It's so, you know, Ted-Ted was
taking her to a show and to-to-to dinner... so they'll be
there.

CAROL
All the way out to New Jersey...

LARRY
So, hey, kid, this is the apple. This is the town that
never sleeps. That's why we don't live in Duluth. That,
plus I don't know where Duluth is.

He picks up the phone on his night table.

LARRY
Lucky me.

VINCENT'S RESTAURANT - INTERIOR NIGHT

Vincent's is a nice cosy place, with dim lights, tasteful
decorations, and light piano music.

Full shot of a table with the four customer seen in profile.
Larry
is seated next to Marcia, and across from his wife. Ted is
seated
next to Carol. During the following conversation, the camera
moves
around the table.

TED
Uh, you really saw his face ?
CAROL
Yes. Oh, yes, I'm here to tell you...

TED
You saw, you saw what he looked like ? No question. You
know exactly who it is.

LARRY
Oh, no question about it. It was-It was Mr. House. There
was no... Not a, not a question. I mean, you could see him
because, uh, you know, there was-there was just no way that
you could avoid it. He was right there.
Genres: ["mystery","comedy"]

Summary Larry and Carol discuss and try to solve the mystery of the dead body they found while stuck in an elevator. They flashback to the discovery and Larry puzzles over possible scenarios, while Carol questions the motives of the killer. Later, they meet with friends to discuss recent events.
Strengths "Good mixture of mystery and comedy, strong dialogue"
Weaknesses "Lack of action and high stakes"
Critique As a screenwriting expert, I would critique this scene by saying that the dialogue is very natural and realistic, which is a positive aspect of the scene. However, the scene feels a bit slow and lacks any sort of tension or conflict. Additionally, the scene doesn't add much to the story or character development. It mostly consists of small talk and a recap of previous events. Therefore, the scene could benefit from some more dramatic stakes or tension to add to the overall plot of the story.
Suggestions Here are a few suggestions for improving this scene:

1. Add more backstory: The scene jumps right into the conversation between Paul and Carol, without giving much background information on their relationship or how they know each other. Consider adding a brief scene earlier in the script that establishes their connection.

2. Increase tension: There isn't much conflict or tension in this scene, which can make it feel flat. Consider adding an obstacle or disagreement between Paul and Carol to give the viewers something to care about.

3. Use visual storytelling: A lot of the dialogue in this scene is exposition-heavy, which can slow down the pace of the film. Consider using visual storytelling techniques to convey information instead, such as showing Paul packing for his trip or Carol looking pensive while Paul talks.

4. Streamline the dialogue: Some of the dialogue in this scene feels stilted and unnatural. Consider trimming some of the extraneous lines and making the conversation feel more organic. Additionally, the section where Larry and Carol are trying to puzzle out the mystery feels repetitive and could be condensed.

Overall, these changes would help make the scene more engaging and keep the story moving forward.



Scene 37 -  The Perfect Murder Theory
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 9
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 9
The camera stops on Marcia and thus stops moving around the
table.

MARCIA
To me, it's obvious.

LARRY
Wh... How do you see it ?
TED
How obvious ? What do you mean ?

MARCIA
Obvious he's committed the perfect murder.

LARRY
What do you mean ?

TED
What ? How ? What do you mean ?

MARCIA
Okay, look. You have to start off with another woman who
bears some ballpark resemblance to Mrs. House.

TED
Yeah.

LARRY
That's what I said. That's exac... I used the term
«ballpark resemblance» myself.

CAROL
I know. You used the term, right.

LARRY
It was my idea. I said what she said.

MARCIA
They're with this woman.

TED
Yeah.

FLASHBACK SCENE
PAUL'S APARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT
Paul and another woman, that looks like his wife, are seated
around a table, having dinner. Lilian House gives a glass of
wine
to the woman, then another one to Paul, and kisses him on
the
forehead.

MARCIA (voice over)
Maybe having dinner. They don't induce a heart attack,
because that's fiction bullshit.

Later. The woman has a hard attack. Paul helps her to walk
to the
sofa.
MARCIA (voice over)
She has a heart attack. She drops dead spontaneously.
They had no thought of killing her. Maybe they wished she
was dead.

TED (voice over)
Why ?

MARCIA (voice over)
I don't know. Maybe they stood to gain if she died. They
see a golden opportunity.
Later. Lilian, wearing a pink night-robe, is dressing the
dead
woman, lying on the sofa, into her own clothes.

MARCIA (voice over)
Mrs. House dresses her up in her clothes. She hides.

LARRY (voice over)
This is my theory. Exactly my theory.

MARCIA (voice over)
That's right. She checks into a hotel.

VINCENT'S RESTAURANT - INTERIOR NIGHT

Back to the restaurant. Long shot on the table. All the
other
tables are empty. The camera zooms to a full shot of the
table,
Marcia and Larry facing us, and Carol and Ted with their
back to
us.

CAROL
Yeah, well, we got that far, with the exception of the
actual spontaneous heart attack.

MARCIA
Okay, you know the husband's planning to go to Paris with
this pretty young woman.

TED
Yeah.

LARRY
Yeah.

MARCIA
He's cheating on his wife.

TED
Yeah.

MARCIA
So, instead of finishing the scheme they planned, he
double-crosses her and kills her, taking her share of the
profits.

TED
Well, you think, you think Helen Moss is in on this, too,
huh ?

MARCIA
Yeah, a good chance she's aware.

CAROL
Okay, but what about Mrs. Dalton ? He claims he took her to
the movies.

MARCIA
She's his alibi. She covered for him when he strangled his
wife. She said he was at work all day.
LARRY
That's right, because he introduced her as a colleague.

Marcia lights a cigarette.

TED
Wait, why... Why would she...

MARCIA
She's a colleague who maybe loves him.

TED
Oh, wait, wait. He's cheating on her, too.

LARRY
Cheating on two women ?

TED
Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's perfect. Just, it all fits.

LARRY
The guy doesn't look the part.
MARCIA
The point is, he's gotten away with the perfect murder.
There are no bodies around to prove anything. And all the
paperwork is strictly above board. He's home free.

TED
Oh, my... Oh, where did you find this woman ? She's a
genius.

LARRY
She's brilliant. She's brilliant. But the guy... He knows
that we know, so if he knows we're on him.

MARCIA
Well, he doesn't care. Why should he ? Everything's been
neatly disposed of. He's home free. Only he, and maybe his
mistress, know the truth.

CAROL
Well, j...

LARRY
She's right, there's no body.

CAROL
Hold on, hold on, for a second. We don't know this is all
true. This is just a theory.

LARRY
Yeah, but it's a great theory. Have you been paying
attention ? This is a great theory.

TED
Oh, yeah. It sounds good, it holds water. Everything fits
together in this.

CAROL
I am paying attention.

LARRY
I think it's great.

MARCIA
When I come back from the ladies room, I'll tell you how to
trap him.

She stands up and starts walking away to the toilets. Larry
and
Ted stand up too. They wait for her to be gone to sit back.

LARRY
Oh, excuse me.

TED
Where-Where did you find her ? She's-She's-She's really
something.

LARRY
Her mind, it just goes.

TED
Yeah, she's got one idea after another. It's like one thing
leads to another.

LARRY
Fantastic.

Close shot on Carol.

CAROL
I'm surprised you two didn't drool yourself to death.

The camera zooms back to a medium shot on Carol and Ted.

TED
Oh, I thought we just had a nice first date. That's...
LARRY (voice over)
I knew that they would hit it off.

CAROL
Why? Uh-huh. Yeah. Him.

LARRY (voice over)
I-I-I knew this.

CAROL
Yeah, uh-huh. What about you ? You were gonna jump into her
lap. I saw you, Larry.
Genres: ["Mystery","Drama","Comedy"]

Summary Larry, Carol, Ted, and Marcia discuss and theorize about the murder they witnessed, leading to Marcia presenting her theory of the perfect murder. They contemplate how to trap the killer and discuss his motives and connections with the other women in his life.
Strengths "Engaging dialogue and character interactions, with Marcia's theory adding intrigue to the unfolding mystery."
Weaknesses "Lack of action or significant plot developments in the scene, with the focus being on discussion and theory instead of action."
Critique Overall, this scene is well-written and engaging. The dialogue is natural and realistic, and the characters have distinct and compelling personalities. The use of flashback to show the murder plot is effective in providing visual context for the discussion.

One possible critique is that the scene may be too exposition-heavy, with characters explaining their theories in a lengthy and detailed manner. This could potentially slow down the pace of the scene and make it feel overly talky. However, the dialogue is snappy and engaging enough to mostly overcome this issue.

Another critique may be that the scene could benefit from a clearer sense of purpose or stakes. While the characters are discussing a murder plot, it's not clear what their goal or objective is - are they trying to solve the crime, or simply speculating for entertainment? A clearer sense of what is at stake for the characters would raise the emotional tension and make the scene more compelling.

Overall, this is a strong and well-executed scene that effectively uses dialogue and flashback to explore a murder plot.
Suggestions As a screenwriting expert, I have a few suggestions to improve this scene:

1. Remove the voiceovers: The use of voiceovers to explain what is happening in the flashback scene and Marcia's theory makes the scene feel disjointed. Instead, try to find ways to show these ideas visually through action and dialogue.

2. Use more descriptive action lines: There are several moments where the action lines are straightforward and lack descriptive language, such as "Marcia lights a cigarette." Try to use more descriptive language to create a vivid picture of what is happening on the screen.

3. Show more character development: The scene features a lot of dialogue and exposition, but it doesn't do much to further develop the characters. Try to find ways to use the dialogue to reveal more about the characters' motivations, relationships, and personalities.

4. Vary the shot types: The scene mostly consists of medium shots of characters sitting around a table. To make it more visually interesting, try to vary the shot types and angles, incorporating close-ups and wider shots to create more visual interest.

5. Cut down on repetition: There are several moments where the characters repeat themselves, saying the same thing in slightly different ways. Try to cut down on this repetition and use the dialogue to move the story forward more efficiently.



Scene 38 -  Bluffing About a Dead Body
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 9
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 9
The camera moves around the table to a medium shot on Larry,
with
Ted and Carol's backs in the foreground.

LARRY
What are you talking about ?

CAROL
Huh ?
LARRY
I'm, I'm, huh, what's wrong with you ? I'm her editor. I'm-
I'm a father figure to her, how...

CAROL
Yeah, the only thing you didn't do is rub your hands
together. That was it.

LARRY
You gotta be joking. What... are you telling me that you're
jealous of Marcia ?

CAROL
I... Well. It's not that I'm jealous.

TED
Kids, kids. People, what are we doing, here?

The camera pans to a medium close shot on Carol.

CAROL
Yeah, look who's talking. My God, I mean, you kept staring
into her eyes like she was the Dragon Lady, or something.

The camera slightly zooms back to show us Larry and Carol

LARRY
What'd wrong with you ? You're jealous because he's-he's
interested in her.

TED
I'm interested in her theory. What... I don't... What are
you...

CAROL
Well, I'd just like to know if you take all your-your
authors to lunch at the Café des...
Marcia walks back to the table.

MARCIA
Okay, I've got it.

She sits down, while Larry half-stands up and then sits
back.
Close shot on Marcia

MARCIA
Here's the story. Since he's gotten away with it, all we
can do is bluff. As long as we have no body, we have no
case.

The camera pans to Ted.

TED
What... What do you mean ? What do we... We pretend that he
slipped up, and the molten steel didn't do the job ? What-
What do you mean ?
The camera pans back to Marcia.
MARCIA
Yeah, it's possible. He saw you there, he knows you're onto
him. After he ran away, why couldn't you have retrieved the
body ?

LARRY
You're kidding. I... We couldn't have gotten her out of
that. We... I would have wound up with a few toes and a
shoulder, maybe, at most.

MARCIA
Well, that's... Okay, okay, you have the body. What does he
know ? He was probably too scared to be very lucid.

The camera pans to Ted, who looks at Marcia with worshipping
eyes.

MARCIA (voice over)
He's an amateur. He dumped the body and ran off, and then
somehow - who knows the details, you two dug her out. Now,
you can send him to the chair.

CAROL
Okay, okay, just...

TED
I like this woman, she's lurid.

CAROL
Let me tell you why he's not going to believe us, okay ?

The camera pans on Larry.

LARRY
Yeah, first of all, because I can't, I can't bluff or lie
without giggling, so-so...

The camera pans to Carol.
CAROL
Yeah. No, because if we really had the body, why tell him ?
Why not go straight to the Police ?

The camera pans to Marcia.

MARCIA
If you tell the cops, you can't shake him down.

Medium shot on another table, around which two middle-aged
men are
seated, listening very eagerly to the conversation.
TED (voice over)
Oh, she's wicked. Oh, I-look... look how, look how this
works out. You go to the law, what do you gain ?

Medium close shot on Ted and Carol.

TED
I mean, so-so maybe they, you know, they put him in jail.
What have you got ? You haven't got anything.
LARRY (voice over)
Right.

TED
But if he wants the evidence, and he's got to pay for it,
now... Okay, now he's nervous, right ?

CAROL
Yeah, you know, wait. There's just so many fallacies in
this, I can't even count them.

The camera pans to Marcia and Larry.

TED (voice over)
What ? Name one.

CAROL (voice over)
Name one? Okay, the guy looks us straight in the eyes and
says, «What body? What the hell are you talking about ?
Prove it».

MARCIA
Well, that's when we keep bluffing.

TED (voice over)
What ? How ? What do we do ?

MARCIA
We produce the body.

LARRY
Yeah, but where are you gonna get it. Madame Tussaud's ?

MARCIA
Yeah. Say-Say we found someone to corroborate this story.

CAROL (voice over)
Oh, really. J-Just...

MARCIA
Someone he trusted.
The camera pans to Ted and Carol.

CAROL
Like who ?

MARCIA (voice over)
Like his lover. Say she called and said, «Paul, I've just
seen Lillian's body. They want a hundred thousand dollars
for it».

TED
Why-Why would she do that ?

The camera pans to Marcia and Larry.

MARCIA (to Larry)
Remember that book you recommended to me ? «Murder in
Manhattan» ?

LARRY
Oh, yes. Max Schindler's book. That's right, the phone
call.

CAROL (voice over)
I don't remember that book.

LARRY
This is perfect.

CAROL (voice over)
You never mentioned that book to me.

LARRY
No, no. Because you don't like light reading, so I never...

The camera pans to Ted and Carol.

CAROL
Since when did I not like light reading, Larry ?

TED
I don't know... I don't know this book. What is this book ?

The camera pans to Larry and Marcia.

LARRY
This book. That's fantastic ! It would be so perfect
because s-she's a, she's a-an, actress, or would-be
actress, anyhow, and you're-you-re... Jeez, we could use
his theatre. He's a playwright. This is so perfect. Your
theatre is empty all the time, anyhow.
The camera pans to Carol and Ted.

CAROL
Oh, God.

TED
Oh, yeah, thank you. That's great. What-What are we talking
about here ? What-What do you mean ? What-What is this ?

The camera pans to Larry and Marcia.
Genres: ["Mystery","Comedy","Thriller"]

Summary Larry, Carol, Ted, and Marcia discuss how to bluff the murderer by producing a body that they claim to have found, leading to Marcia presenting her plan for the perfect murder.
Strengths "The scene showcases the characters' intellect as they plot their next moves. It builds tension while bringing humor into the situation."
Weaknesses "The scene's dialogue can be a bit difficult to follow at times, as it throws many different ideas and plans into the mix."
Critique Overall, the scene seems to have a lot of dialogue and movement, which could potentially become confusing for viewers. At times, the conversation feels like it's going in circles, and it's not always clear what the characters are trying to achieve. Additionally, there are some moments where the dialogue could use some trimming or tightening to make it more effective. However, the scene does have some interesting dynamics between the characters, particularly in terms of their different motivations and levels of trust. With some edits, this scene could be more engaging and effective in moving the story forward.
Suggestions There are a few things that could improve this scene:

1. The camera movements could be more intentional and purposeful. Instead of just panning and zooming around the table aimlessly, the camera should have a clear objective and focus on the characters who are speaking at any given moment.

2. The dialogue could be tightened and made more concise. There is a lot of back-and-forth between the characters, and some of it feels repetitive or unnecessary. Streamlining the conversation would make it more engaging for the audience.

3. The stakes could be raised. Right now, there doesn't seem to be a lot at stake for the characters. Adding in some consequences or increasing the tension or urgency of the situation would make the scene more compelling.

4. The characters' motivations could be made clearer. While we understand that Larry is Marcia's editor and feels a fatherly protectiveness over her, it's not entirely clear why Carol and Ted are so invested in this situation. Giving them clearer motivations and backstories would make them more interesting and add depth to the scene.

5. The scene could benefit from more visual and sensory details. Right now, it's mostly just a conversation happening around a table. Adding in some visuals or sensory details would make the scene more immersive and engaging for the audience.



Scene 39 -  The Perfect Murder Plan
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 9
LARRY
Listen to this. What you do is, we get her in for a fake
audition, and you write some lines that don't mean
anything.

TED (voice over)
Yeah.

LARRY
And she does them, and she doesn't know what she's doing
and we tape-record it.

CAROL (voice over)
Uh...
LARRY
Listen to this.

CAROL (voice over)
I'm listening.

LARRY
And we edit it up. We edit the tape recording up, and we
make one end of a phone call...

The camera pans to Ted and Carol.

LARRY (voice over)
...and we play it into the phone to Mr. House.

TED
This is in the book ?

The camera pans to Larry and Marcia.

LARRY
This is perfect, list...

CAROL (voice over)
Oh, come on. No, that could never, ever work, in a million
years. You don't know what he's going to say.
The camera pans to Ted and Carol.

CAROL
What's he gonna say ?

The camera pans to Marcia and Larry.

MARCIA
In the book, they use several tape recorders.
CAROL (voice over)
In the book ?

MARCIA
We coordinate it.

LARRY
It's coordinated.

The camera pans to Ted and Carol.

CAROL
In the book. You mean, you're basing your plan on some dumb
paperback ?

LARRY (voice over)
This is great. This is great.

CAROL
I s... No, really.

LARRY (voice over)
I like... No, it's great.

CAROL
Oh.

The camera pans to Marcia and Larry.

MARCIA
He's gotten away with murder. Our only chance is to nab him
as he tries to kill again, cover his tracks.

Medium shot on the two waiters, standing on either side of
the
counter, and listening to the conversation.

LARRY (voice over)
It's great. What happens, is... it provokes him to kill
again. They catch him the second time.

MARCIA (voice over)
Exactly. He's gotten away with the first murder.
Medium close shot on Carol and Ted.

LARRY (voice over)
You know what I'm thinking, though ?

The camera pans to Marcia and Larry.

MARCIA
What ?

LARRY
Actually, in the book what happens is, now that I think of
it, he... he kills the... the two people that are working
the scheme on him.

TED (voice over)
Yeah, that's all right.
CAROL (voice over)
But...

TED (voice over)
But you're not worried about that.

LARRY
Um, well, I don't know.

MARCIA
It's perfect.

LARRY
Either that, or I've... I've just developed Parkinson's.

The camera zooms back, to show us the four people around the
table.

TED
No, we can handle him. We can handle him. Listen, this is
incredible. This is an incredible idea.
MARCIA
It's perfect. It's perfect. He knows you're onto him. You
shake him down.

CAROL
No, no.

MARCIA
He comes after you, we nab him.

The camera stops zooming back and gives us a full shot on
the
table.
TED
That's great. It's great. You're wonderful. I just... I'm
amazed.

MARCIA
Yeah.

CAROL
I... I just...

MARCIA
It's either that, or he walks.

CAROL
Yeah. Yeah, wait. I... So, what you're saying is...

TED
This is great.

CAROL
Wait, no, okay... What you're saying... Oh boy. You're
saying, you want to provoke Mr. House into trying to murder
Larry and me.
MARCIA
Yeah. It's perfect. You're not scared, are you ?

LARRY
No, no, no, no, no, I'm not scared. I'm not scared. I'm
just turning it over in my mind. I just want to check with
my clergyman before we commit.

NEW-YORK - A STREET - EXTERIOR DAY

Medium shot on Helen Moss, making a phone call from an open
booth
in the street. While she is talking, the camera comes closer
to
her, to a medium close shot on her face.

HELEN
Hi, uh, B-twenty-four messages ? Oh, really ? Audition for
what ? Did he say ? Okay, okay. Wait, hold on.

She looks into her purse and gets her agenda out of it.

HELEN
Let me get a pencil. Okay.
TED'S THEATRE - STAGE - INTERIOR DAY

Full slightly high-angled shot on the stage. In the middle
of the
stage floor, a white circle, on which there is a chair and a
small
table with a telephone. Suzanne Raphael, a young woman, is
auditioning. She is seated on the chair, holding the
telephone.
Behind Suzanne, which is the left side of the stage seen
from the
audience, a white wall, with a doorless opening. On either
side of
the wall, two red columns. And on either side of the girl,
which
are the front and the back of the stage, two red metallic
frames.
In front of the girl, a video camera on a tripod, with an
operator
standing behind the camera. Actually, the operator is Sy,
Larry
and Carol's friend, whom we have seen much earlier in the
film, in
the antique market and at Elaine's restaurant. The stage is
well
lit, when the audience hall is in the dark.

SUZANNE
Yeah, well, Dad, you know, I've heard just about enough of
this.

She slams the phone down. The camera pans around to show us
the
right side of the stage, where there is several rows of
theatre
seats and a table in front of the seats. Ted, Marcia and
Marilyn
are seated in the front row. Marilyn is Sy's wife, whom we
have
also seen earlier in the film. Carol is seated in the second
row,
behind Marcia.

TED
Good, that's great. Thank you, Suzanne. Thank you.
Genres: ["Mystery","Thriller"]

Summary Larry, Carol, Ted, and Marcia plan a fake audition to trap the murderer, but Carol questions the validity of the plan and the group discusses other options, leading to Marcia presenting her theory of the perfect murder.
Strengths "The scene is suspenseful and builds tension as the group discusses their plan. The dialogue is engaging and helps to reveal the personalities of the characters."
Weaknesses "The plan seems improbable and the group dismisses Carol's concerns too quickly."
Critique Overall, the scene is well-written with clear dialogue and a solid plot. The characters' motivations and personalities are established effectively through their dialogue and actions. However, some areas for improvement could include developing the tension and being more concise in the dialogue. Additionally, the scene could benefit from more visual storytelling to enhance the dynamic between the characters and the situation. Overall, the scene has potential with a few tweaks to enhance its impact.
Suggestions First, the scene could benefit from more visual variety. The majority of the scene takes place around a table, with only brief cutaways to other locations. Adding more variety in camera angles and locations would help keep the scene visually interesting.

Second, the dialogue could be tightened up. There is a lot of discussion about the plan to trap Mr. House, which could be condensed to make the scene more concise.

Third, the scene could benefit from more character development. We don't know much about Larry, Ted, Carol, or Marcia beyond their involvement in the plan. Adding more depth to their personalities and motivations would help make them more compelling to watch.

Finally, the scene would benefit from more tension. The audience should feel the stakes of the plan, and the risk involved in attempting to trap a murderer. Adding more suspenseful moments or high stakes would help increase the tension in the scene and keep viewers engaged.



Scene 40 -  Auditioning the Suspects
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 9
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 8
MARCIA
We'll let you know. That's Suzanne Raphael, right ?

TED
Yeah. Good, thank you.

Carol taps on Marilyn's shoulder, and whispers something to
her.
Ted joins them in their whispered conversation. The camera
pans
back on the stage. Larry, with a clipboard in his hand, has
entered the stage, pushing Helen in front of him.

LARRY
This is Helen Moss.

HELEN
Hi, there.

CAROL (voice over)
Hi, there.

MARCIA (voice over)
Hi.

HELEN
Hi.

Medium close shot on Ted, who stands up, and walks toward
the
stage. The camera follows him.
TED
Uh, have you, uh... I know, I know you just got the
material, uh, you know, just in the... last little while,
but... uh, h-have you had a chance to-to study it ? To go
over it, a little bit ?

The camera pans to a medium close shot of Helen.

HELEN
Yes, yes. Uh, I have, but, um, I have just a few questions.

TED
Sure , yeah.

The camera moves slightly, and is now located behind Ted's
back,
still with Helen in medium close shot.

HELEN
Is she divorced, in this ?

TED
Uh, yes. Yes.

HELEN
Uh, recently ?

TED
Yes. Yeah. But she's, uh, very, highly emotional.

HELEN
Yeah.

TED
You know really... uh, lot of... Lot of feeling. Very
strong.

HELEN
Oh.
TED
Hm ?

HELEN
Should I just begin ?

TED
Yeah, just... Whenever, you know, whenever you feel it.
Whenever you feel into it.

Ted walks away. Helen takes a very deep breathing, sits
down, puts
her hands trough her hair, takes another breathing, and
picks up
the phone handset from the telephone on the table. She
overdoes it
a lot, trying to act as the prima dona she is not.

HELEN
Yeah, okay.

She dials a fake number on the phone keyboard.

HELEN
Hello, Joe ? I-I was just... I...

TED (voice over)
Uh, let me stop you right there.

Helen looks in Ted's direction.

TED (voice over)
I'm sorry, I... uh, if you'll be... if you'll start out
more frightened... then that'll take you where you're gonna
go.

HELEN
Right, right.

She breathes deeply before starting again.

HELEN
Hello, Joe ? I can't talk much, now, and if I sound
strange, don't get alarmed.
Later. Helen is auditioning another scene. She doesn't have
the
phone in her hand any more. She is holding a script and
looking at
it. Larry is seated in front of her, and read his own script
on
his clipboard.

HELEN
Give me your hand. Hold on. Try not to fall. Hold on.

LARRY
I'm trying, I'm trying.

HELEN
Quickly ! Hurry !

Later. Close shot of Helen's face auditioning another scene.

HELEN
They're asking two hundred thousand dollars for it. Yeah.
They say it's Monet, but I say it's a fake.

Medium shot of Helen, seen from behind. We see Sy standing
behind
his camera on her right, and Larry standing with his
clipboard in
his hand on her left. In the background, Ted, Marcia,
Marilyn and
Carol listening to her. While Helen is talking, the camera
moves
backward through the opening in the scenery.

HELEN
Ever since Joe came home from Vietnam, he's cast a pall on
everything. A dark cloud, a pall.

A BUILDING - EXTERIOR NIGHT.

Full shot on the upper level of a building, that could be
either
Ted's theatre of Sy's workshop. The camera tilts down to
street
level.

SY'S WORKSHOP - INTERIOR NIGHT

We are inside Sy's workshop. It is full of very high-tech
video
and audio equipment.
Medium shot of Marilyn standing behind a computer. Close to
her,
Carol is seated on a table, and Ted is standing next to her.
They
are both looking at a large video monitor. On the monitor
screen
and on the computer screen, we see the same picture of Helen
auditioning with the telephone in her hand.

HELEN'S VOICE
Hello, Joe ? I can't talk much, right now...

The camera pans to Marcia, seated behind Carol and also
looking at
the monitor. Behind her, Sy is looking at another monitor,
and
manipulating some switches on an editing machine underneath
the
monitor. Larry is standing next to him.

HELEN'S VOICE
... and if I sound strange, don't get alarmed.

Sy rewinds the video tape.

HELEN'S VOICE
Hello, Joe ? I can't talk much right now.

Sy fast winds the tape.

HELEN'S VOICE
Hello, Joe ? Ever since Joe came back from Vietnam...

Close shot on Ted's face, then the camera pans to Carol and
Marcia, seated one behind the other, and behind them, Sy
working
on the editing machine, with Larry standing next to him. The
camera zooms on Sy.

HELEN'S VOICE
... he's cast a pall on everything. A dark cloud, a pall.

Sy rewinds the tape.
HELEN'S VOICE
A pall.

Sy rewinds the tape.

HELEN'S VOICE
Pall.

Sy rewinds the tape.
HELEN'S VOICE
Pall.

Slightly later. Medium close shot of Ted looking at
something we
don't see, with Marcia standing next to him.
Genres: ["Mystery","Suspense"]

Summary Larry, Carol, Ted, and Marcia audition their prime suspect, Helen, and discuss their plan to trap the killer.
Strengths "Tension builds as the group discusses their plan to catch the killer. The dialogue is natural and adds depth to the characters."
Weaknesses "The scene may drag on too long with little action. Some of the dialogue may be repetitive."
Critique As a screenwriting expert, my critique of this scene is that it lacks clear direction and purpose. The dialogue between the characters is disjointed and doesn't lead to a clear objective or goal. Additionally, the scene jumps between several different locations without a clear transition or purpose, which can be confusing for viewers.

In terms of character development, there is very little revealed about the characters themselves in this scene. We learn that Helen is auditioning for a role, but we don't gain any insight into her personality or motivations. Other characters are present but don't contribute much to the scene outside of the roles they play in assisting with the audition process.

Overall, this scene feels like it lacks a clear focus and direction. To improve it, the writer could consider giving the characters more depth and purpose in their interactions, clarifying the scene's context, and establishing a clear objective or goal for the characters to work towards. Additionally, more attention could be given to smoothing out transitions between different locations and ensuring that the dialogue flows logically.
Suggestions Here are some suggestions to improve the scene:

1. Develop the characters: The audience needs to care about the characters and be invested in their story. Try to build up their personalities and give them distinct traits and behaviors.

2. Make the dialogue more interesting: The dialogue should reveal character, advance the story, and be engaging. Try to make the language more natural and avoid using generic phrases and cliches.

3. Show, don't tell: Instead of having characters explain things to each other, try to show the audience what's happening through actions and behaviors. This will make the scene more dynamic and engaging.

4. Add tension: A good scene should have tension and conflict. Try to create tension by having characters face obstacles and challenges.

5. Tighten up the pacing: Cut out any unnecessary dialogue or actions that do not add to the scene. Try to make the scene as concise and focused as possible, while still maintaining its impact.



Scene 41 -  Helen's Voice
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 9
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
HELEN'S VOICE
Hello, Joe ?

The camera pans to Carol standing up and looking at the same
thing
as Ted. We hear Helen's voice distorted by Sy's editing
machine.
HELEN'S VOICE (distorted)
Hello, Joe.

The camera pans back on Ted and Marcia, then it pans to a
close
shot of a big high-tech tape recorder, on which Sy is
working. We
see his hands cutting off a short section of the audio tape,
and
gluing back the two severed ends of the tape together.

Full shot of the room. In the foreground, Sy is working on
his
tape recorder. On his right, Larry is standing and looking
at him.
On his left, Marilyn also looking at him. Behind him, Carol,
Ted
and Marcia, all looking at him.

TED
It's so...

The camera zooms on Ted and Marcia.

Close up shot on the tape recorder. Sy starts it.

HELEN'S VOICE
Hello, Paul ? I can't talk much, right now...

The camera tilts up from the tape recorder to a medium shot
on Ted
and Marcia. Ted smiles when he hears the work Sy has done
with the
tape.
HELEN'S VOICE
... and if I sound strange, don't get alarmed.
MARCIA (SMILING)
Perfect.

She shakes hands with Larry.

TED
That's great.
He also shake hands with Larry, moving slightly Carol out of
the
way.

MARCIA
You did great. Great.

Larry suddenly notices that Carol has been excluded from the
hand-
shaking party, and he turns around toward her.

CAROL
Well, yeah, it's, excuse me, hey, don't worry, yeah, okay.

MARCIA
Fantastic.

MARCIA'S CAR - INTERIOR DAY

The camera is behind Marcia, who is driving in a street in
New-
York. We see Helen walking on the sidewalk.

MARCIA
There she is.
The camera pans around, from inside the car, to get a better
shot
of Helen.

TED
Where ?

MARCIA
You have to keep her busy for all afternoon.

Through the back window of the car, we see Helen entering a
restaurant called «Time».

TED
Yeah, yeah, okay. Okay, yeah. Yeah, I'll-I'll just keep
improvising, you know ?

MARCIA
Okay, well, it shouldn't be too hard. She's a hungry
actress, you're a playwright with a role.
NEW-YORK - A STREET - EXTERIOR DAY

Close shot on Marcia's car, inside which Marcia and Ted are
talking together.

TED
You know what ? I'll g... I'll talk about the play, or, get
her, get her talking about the part, you know, her life.
I'll get her talking about her life, and her whole
background. Stop the car, I'm gonna get out here.

MARCIA
Good. We'll hook up later, okay ?

TED
All right. Good - Good luck with your assignment. Ok ?
MARCIA
All right, you too.

Marcia has stopped the car, and Ted is getting out of it.

SY AND MARILYN'S APARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Full shot of a large room, furnished with good taste. In the
background a large bay window, overlooking some green trees.
On
the right, there is a large modern mantlepiece. On the left,
a
bicycle is leaning on the wall. Under the window, a large
and cosy
sofa.

Carol and Sy are standing in front of the window and talking
together. Next to them and Marcia is also standing and
reading a
large album. In the foreground, Larry, who is the only one
not to
be casually dressed, and is wearing jacket and necktie, is
playing
with a small cassette-player in his hands. Marilyn is
walking into
the room.

MARILYN
Listen, does anybody want some guacamole or anything ?
Sy walks toward her, holding another cassette player. Carol
is
also holding one.

SY
Would you stop with the guacamole ? We have to get started
with this.

He looks at his watch.

LARRY
He should be back for lunch, right ?

SY
Come on, let's go.

MARILYN
Yeah. All right, let's go.

LARRY
So, everybody's got the right tape recorder and the right
tape in ?

SY
Yes, we do.

They all sit down around a low table.

MARCIA
Yeah.

LARRY
All right, one second. And then we ca... I mea... so, uh,
we're on speaker.

CAROL
This is so insane.
LARRY
Now wait, wait, wait. There's, um... I'm not nervous.

CAROL
Oh, w...

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - BACKSTAGE - INTERIOR DAY

The backstage is in the same disorder as before, with all
the
mirrors scattered around. Full shot of Paul and Gladys
standing in
the middle of the room

PAUL
I have the contractor come in and nobody's here ? Now you
see if you can find...

The phone rings.

PAUL
I'll get that. Uh, you go and call him.

Paul walks out of the room.
GLADYS
Oh. Yes, yes, all right.

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - OLD DRESSING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Paul walks into a small room in a corner of the backstage.
It must
have been a dressing room, but now it is full of various
junk,
with a big poster, that looks like a enlarged newspaper, on
the
wall. Paul picks up the phone from a small counter fixed on
the
wall.
Genres: ["thriller","crime"]

Summary Larry, Carol, Ted, Marcia, Sy, Marilyn, and Gladys work together on a plan to trap the murderer by faking a phone call from the victim, Helen. They test the validity of the plan by distorting Helen's voice with Sy's editing machine, and later go through with it.
Strengths "Tense and well-executed plan that showcases the characters' trust in each other."
Weaknesses "Dialogue can sometimes be unclear due to overlapping conversations."
Critique Overall, the scene seems well-written and moves the plot forward. However, there are a few areas that could be improved upon.

Firstly, there is a lack of clear scene direction. It's not always clear who is speaking and what they are doing in the scene. Adding some clear stage directions would help the reader follow along with the action.

Secondly, the dialogue could use some work. Some of the lines seem unnatural or stilted, and could benefit from some editing to make them sound more natural.

Finally, some of the descriptions feel unnecessary and could be cut down to keep the pacing of the scene moving smoothly. Overall, a solid scene but with room for improvement in technicalities.
Suggestions One suggestion for improving this scene would be to clarify the objectives of each character and their roles within the scene. It's currently unclear what Sy's editing and tape recording is for, and why everyone is gathered together. By providing clearer motivations and objectives, the scene can become more engaging for the audience and allow for a more coherent plotline. Additionally, the dialogue could benefit from a more natural, flowing conversation style that allows for more character development and interaction.



Scene 42 -  The Phone Call
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 8
PAUL
Hallo ?

SY AND MARILYN'S APARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Full shot of the little group around the low table. Marcia
and
Larry are seated next to each other in front of the camera,
Sy is
seated on Larry's left and his wife on Marcia's right. Carol
is
seated on the other side of the table, with her back to the
camera.

Marcia, who is seated next to the telephone, presses the
«play»
button on her cassette player. Helen's voice comes out of
it.

HELEN'S VOICE
Hello, Paul. I can't talk much right now. And if I sound
strange, don't get alarmed.

Marcia presses the «stop» button.

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - OLD DRESSING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Medium close shot of Paul on the phone.

PAUL
What's the problem ?
He sits down.

SY AND MARILYN'S APARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY
Marcia presses the «play» button.

HELEN'S VOICE
They have your wife's body. They showed it to me.

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - OLD DRESSING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

PAUL
Say that again.

SY AND MARILYN'S APARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Carol is shaking her head, not paying much attention to what
is
going on. Marilyn and Marcia both silently point to Carol's
cassette player, to tell her it is her turn to play it.
Carol
picks up her player to put it in front of the telephone and
presses the «play» button.
HELEN'S VOICE
They have your wife's body. They showed it to me.

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - OLD DRESSING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

PAUL
Exactly who has it ? How many are there ?

SY AND MARILYN'S APARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

It is Sy's turn to switch his player on.

HELEN'S VOICE
Your neighbors. That's right. They want two hundred
thousand dollars for it.

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - OLD DRESSING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

PAUL
Where are you calling from ? There's an echo. Are you on a
speaker phone ?

SY AND MARILYN'S APARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

The group seems surprised by a question they did not
expected.
Marcia silently points to Marilyn's player. Marilyn presses
the
«play» button.

HELEN'S VOICE
Hold on.
Marcia presses on the «mute» button on the telephone set.

LARRY
We don't have an answer for that. What are we gonna do ?

MARCIA
Go to a different thought.

CAROL
Mm...mmm... What thought ? Wait.

Marcia presses the «mute» button on the telephone. Sy turns
to
Carol.

SY
Shhh !...

Carol puts her hand in front of her mouth. Larry gets his
player
close to the telephone and presses the «play» button

HELEN'S VOICE
You've either got to pay them off, or get rid of them.

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - OLD DRESSING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

PAUL
Look, we can't talk about this on the phone. Can you meet
me ?
SY AND MARILYN'S APARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

It is still Larry's turn to use his player.

HELEN'S VOICE (louder)
Yes! They're keeping it refrigerated.

Marcia hits Larry's elbow, to tell him it was the wrong cue.

PAUL (voice over in the speaker of the telephone)
What ? What did you say ?

Larry is very nervous all of a sudden, and puts another
player in
front of the telephone.

HELEN'S VOICE
About two hours ago.

Larry drops the player.
PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - OLD DRESSING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

PAUL
Two... what ? Two hours what ?

SY AND MARILYN'S APARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Marcia points to Marilyn's player. Marilyn presses the
«play»
button.

HELEN'S VOICE
Hold on.

Marcia presses the «mute» button on the telephone set. Larry
just
got the cassette out of his player and can't put it back in.
He is
more and more nervous.
LARRY
Jesus... we're all screwed up. I got this all screwed up.

MARCIA
Okay, let's get off as quick as possible. We've done it.

SY
All right, well, do something. Do something.

MARCIA (to Larry)
Shhh !... Um, okay. Sh !...

She presses the «mute» button on the telephone, then presses
the
«play» button on her player.

HELEN'S VOICE
Hello, Paul. I can't talk much right now. And if I sound
strange, don't get alarmed.

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - OLD DRESSING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

PAUL
Look, Helen, you're not making any sense. I know you're
upset, but you have to pull yourself together. Now, could
we meet ? The usual spot.

SY AND MARILYN'S APARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

HELEN'S VOICE
Hold on.
Marilyn, who has just been playing her player, presses the
«stop»
button on it. Then Marcia presses the «mute» button on the
telephone. Meanwhile, Larry has succeeded in getting a good
length
of tape out of his cassette, and tries to put it back in !

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - OLD DRESSING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

PAUL
Helen ? Helen, you still there ? Helen ?

SY AND MARILYN'S APARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Larry is still trying to put the tape back into the
cassette.
Genres: ["Mystery","Thriller"]

Summary The group tries to trap the killer by faking a phone call from the victim, but their plan goes awry when they struggle to cue the correct audio. Despite their nervousness, they eventually succeed in getting the message across to the killer.
Strengths "Building suspense and tension"
Weaknesses "Unclear audio cues, somewhat confusing plot"
Critique Overall, the scene is well-written in terms of dialogue and action. It effectively conveys the tension and urgency of the situation as the characters try to figure out what to do about the missing wife. However, there are a few areas that could be improved upon.

Firstly, more description of the characters and their surroundings would be helpful in creating a clearer picture of the scene. The brief physical descriptions of the characters at the beginning are not enough to fully visualize them.

Secondly, the use of multiple cassette players feels a bit contrived and confusing. It might be more effective to have the characters simply pass the phone around or use speakerphone, rather than constantly switching cassette players.

Lastly, the scene could benefit from more varied camera angles to create visual interest and avoid monotony. The majority of the scene is described as either a full shot or medium close shot, which can make it feel repetitive. Incorporating close-ups or wide shots could help break up the visual monotony and add dimension to the scene.

Overall, with some minor adjustments, this scene has the potential to be a strong moment in the overall screenplay.
Suggestions One suggestion to improve this scene would be to focus on the emotional impact of the phone call, particularly on Paul, instead of intercutting between different characters playing the cassette. This would allow for more dramatic tension and a clearer sense of what is at stake. Additionally, the dialogue could be tightened up to make it more concise and impactful. For example, instead of Marcia saying "Go to a different thought," she could say something more urgent like "We need to act now, what's our plan?" This would heighten the sense of urgency and keep the scene moving forward. Finally, the scene could benefit from more visual elements, such as close-ups on the characters' faces or shots of their reactions, to add depth and enhance the emotional intensity of the scene.



Scene 43 -  The Failed Phone Call Trap
  • Overall: 8.5
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 8
MARCIA
Okay, hurry up, hurry up. Okay.

LARRY
Somebody press something, come on.

Now, Larry is surrounded by a hundred feet of tape, which is
flying all around him ! Marcia points to Carol's player.

CAROL
What ?

LARRY
You can't press some... Come on.
Marcia presses the «mute» button on the telephone, and Carol
presses the «play» button on her player.

HELEN'S VOICE
You have no choice, they've got the goods. You just pay
them off, or get rid of them. I have to hang up.

Marcia presses the «off» button on the telephone.

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - OLD DRESSING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Paul slowly puts the telephone down on its hook. He stands
up and
walks back to the backstage.

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - BACKSTAGE - INTERIOR DAY

GLADYS
What's the matter, Paul ? You look all shaken up.

PAUL
No, no. It's nothing.
GLADYS
I worry about you these days, Paul.

PAUL
I'm fine, I'm fine.

GLADYS
You're different.

PAUL
I said I was fine. Will you stop interfering ?

GLADYS
You never used to pull away from me.

PAUL (getting mad)
I told you to leave me alone ! I don't want to have this
conversation all the time !

He walks out and Gladys put her hands on her eyes. She
slowly
walks away with the help of her cane.

NEW-YORK - STREET OUTSIDE SY AND MARILYN'S HOUSE - EXTERIOR
DAY

Full shot of a nice building with short trees and wrought
iron
gates in front of it. We hear voices but we don't see anyone
yet.

LARRY (voice over)
Great. All right. Now, my job is to wait exactly one hour
and call Mr. House from a phone booth. Where are you...
Where are you running so fast ?

Carol runs out of the building.

CAROL
I have to go home and change.

Larry comes out of the building and closes the door. Carol
turns
toward him.

CAROL
I've got an appointment with a friend of Ted's about a
location for... What ?

LARRY
What's the matter ? What are you so angry about ? What are
you so... What are you so steamed up about ?

CAROL
What do you mean ? Well, I meant... I just don't understand
how you could give a book to Marcia, and not to me.

They start walking down the street. The camera follows them.

LARRY
What are you talking about ?

CAROL
I just don't need...
LARRY
We had just a big success in there.

CAROL
What...

LARRY
Marcia likes to read what I like to read.

CAROL
Oh, right, God. Yeah, well it's true. I guess it's true. I
mean, we've got nothing in common, that's for sure. Now
that, now that Nick's grown up, I mean, you know, we're
just left facing each other.

LARRY
You got stuff in common with Ted, right ? You can cook
together with Ted, or you can take your clothes off and
baste a chicken with him.

CAROL
Oh, right. Oh, oh, well, what about you and Marcia, huh ?
What does she teach you besides poker ? That's what I'd
like to know, okay ?

LARRY
Mud wrestling. Is that what you want to hear ? Nothing, I'm
her editor.

CAROL
Look, I think the time has come for us to reevaluate our
lives.

LARRY
I reevaluated our lives.

CAROL
Yeah.
LARRY
I... I... I got a ten. You got a six.

The camera stops moving and just shows just the departing
couple
walking down the street.

CAROL
Well, listen, I think maybe I will go back to seeing my
shrink.

LARRY
Oh. You don't have to see your shrink. There's nothing
wrong with you that can't be cured with a little Prozac and
a polo mallet.

CAROL
Just... I just would like to be alone for a while, okay,
Larry ?

LARRY
What are you talk...
CAROL
Just... just, I... I... Uh, okay ?

Long shot of Carol running away, while Larry, standing in
the
middle of the sidewalk, looks at her going away.

A CAFETERIA - INTERIOR DAY

A classical New-York cafeteria, with tables and chairs
scattered
all around the room. In the background the long counter,
where the
food is displayed, and along which the customer are lining
up at
lunchtime. Around a slightly isolated table on the left, Ted
and
Helen are talking.

HELEN
So, I have this, like, really crazy father and everything.

TED
Oh, yeah ?

The camera zooms to a medium shot on Ted and Helen.

HELEN
And, yeah. He's wanted, like, in three states. He has a
terrible driving record. So we had to move from Virginia
then to New Jersey, and...
TED
So, your father is wanted in three states for driving ?
Really ?

HELEN
Yeah, for driving. Yeah. So I moved to Hackensack, and
then... Well, anyway, I was in all these different contests
and I was even, uh, Miss, uh, Teenage Passaic.

TED
Oh, how wonderful.

LARRY'S APARTMENT - FRONT HALL - INTERIOR DAY
Genres: ["mystery","drama","comedy"]

Summary Larry, Carol, Ted, Marcia, Sy, Marilyn, and Gladys work to trap the murderer via a fake phone call from the victim. The plan goes awry, but they eventually succeed.
Strengths "The tension-inducing scene is well-paced, while the mixture of humor and drama keeps it from becoming too heavy. The character interactions and relationships add an extra layer of complexity to the plot."
Weaknesses "The audio distress feels somewhat contrived and takes away from the main plot. Additionally, some of the character developments feel unresolved."
Critique As a screenwriting expert, the following scene seems to be part of a larger context, so it is difficult to accurately critique the scene without understanding the full story arc. However, a few notes can be given:

- The scene feels disjointed and abrupt, jumping from several different locations and characters. This makes it challenging for the viewer to follow and comprehend the story.
- The dialogue between characters feels disconnected and lacks depth. While some characters have more defined personalities, such as Larry's sarcastic wit, others like Carol and Ted seem one-dimensional and typical.
- There is a lack of clear motivation for the characters and their actions. What is driving them to behave the way they do? Without clear motivations, the audience may struggle to relate to or care about the characters.
- The scene could benefit from a stronger visual component, such as more detailed descriptions of the locations, actions, and characters' emotions. A more focused and descriptive approach could help the audience understand the story better.
Suggestions One suggestion to improve this scene could be to add more visual elements to it. The dialogue is clear and the characters are established, but there is not much happening visually that engages the audience. Perhaps adding more action and movement to the scene, even in small ways, could make it more dynamic.

For example, when Larry is surrounded by tape, there could be more visuals of the tape flailing around him in chaotic fashion. When Paul puts down the phone and walks away, there could be a shot of him staring in disbelief at the receiver, giving more impact to the phone call he just received.

Additionally, the dialogue between Carol and Larry could use more specificity and detail. Rather than just mentioning that they have nothing in common, they could bring up specific interests or events that highlight their differences. This would add more complexity to their relationship, and make the scene more interesting to watch.

Finally, the scene could benefit from a more defined location. Rather than jumping between different settings with no clear connection, there could be more context and visuals that establish each location. This would add more texture and depth to the scene, making it feel more cohesive and immersive.



Scene 44 -  Trapping the Killer
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
Medium shot of the room. The front door opens and Carol
walks in.
She slams the door shut and puts her purse on a table. She
takes
her coat off, walks into the corridor and opens a closet to
put
the coat away in it. She then chooses a new set of clothes
and
shoes to go to her appointment. She closes the closet and
walks
into the bathroom to change. She closes the bathroom door.
The
camera remains outside the bathroom and starts moving along
the
corridor back to the front door. The front door opens and
Paul
walks in. He walks silently along the corridor toward the
bathroom.

A CAFETERIA - INTERIOR DAY

Same medium shot as before on Ted and Helen.

TED
Was that before or after the fourth abortion ?
HELEN
Well, after the fourth, but before the drama prize.

TED
The drama prize ?

HELEN
And... Mm... hm.

TED
I don't remember the...
HELEN
Remember ? Remember ?

TED
What ?

HELEN
«Out, out, damn spot ?» The topless «Macbeth» ?

TED
Oh, yeah. Oh, for the fraternity party, yeah, yeah.

HELEN
Yeah, yeah.

TED
Topless «Macbeth». I don't... How could I forget that ?
It's just...

NEW-YORK - A STREET - EXTERIOR DAY

Larry is in an open phone booth in a quiet street. He picks
up the
handset, put a coin in the slot, and starts dialing the
number he
has written on a piece of paper.

LARRY
Hallo, Mr. House ? This is Larry Lipton. I... I got a... a
package I think you're gonna want. Of course it's gonna
cost you, uh, $200,000 in... in small, unmarked bills.
Or... or... or large marked ones, if... if... if you want
to go that route.

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - OLD DRESSING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

The small disused dressing-room in the corner of the
backstage.
Paul is talking into the telephone. In front of him, Carol
is tied
on a chair, with a white cloth gag taped on her mouth. While
Paul
is talking, the camera zooms on Carol's frightened face.

PAUL
And I have a package you might want, Mr. Lipton. If you
ever wanna see your wife alive again, you'll do as I say.

NEW-YORK - A STREET - EXTERIOR DAY

Larry is still in the phone booth.
LARRY
Oh, really ? Well, I think you're bluffing. Yeah, don't...
don't ever try and bluff a bluffer. Yeah, if... if you got
Carol, put her on the phone.

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - OLD DRESSING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Paul takes the gag off Carol's mouth and put the phone
mouthpiece
in front of her lips.

CAROL (CRYING)
Larry, Larry, help me ! I'm here, Larry !

Paul puts the gag back on Carol's mouth

NEW-YORK - A STREET - EXTERIOR DAY

Larry looks very frightened.

LARRY
Oh, my... Oh, my God. D... Don't hurt her !

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - OLD DRESSING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Paul is holding the gag in front of Carol's mouth with one
hand
and the telephone with the other hand.

PAUL
I'll tell you exactly where to meet me, and you bring that
package I want. Now, once I have it and I'm safely gone,
you'll get your wife back. Otherwise, I'll kill her.

NEW-YORK - A STREET - EXTERIOR DAY

Larry is now very very frightened.

LARRY
Yes, yes. Yeah, no, no, no, no. I... I... I understand. I,
uh, yes, no. I'll be there. I'll be there. I... I... Yes,
I'll b... I... I'll bring your wife's body, she... In...
in... in the trunk of my car. Yes, I'll... I... I promise.
I'll be there. I...

Larry hangs up and hold the side of the phone booth.

LARRY
I don't have his wife's body. Bluff, bluff.

NEW-YORK - A STREET - EXTERIOR DAY
Long shot of a street covered with iron works. Actually,
this is
the same street and the same shot as the one we saw earlier
in the
film, when Ted and Carol were following Helen going to
Paul's
movie house in a yellow cab.

Larry's car is coming toward us, and then turns into the
dead-end
street where the back entrance of Paul's movie house is
located.

DEAD END STREET BEHIND PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - EXTERIOR DAY

Larry stops the car near the entrance of the movie house.
Paul is
waiting for him.

Medium close shot on Larry's car. Larry opens his door, and
comes
out of the car.

LARRY
Where's Carol ?

Paul walks toward the car. He's got a gun in his hand.

PAUL
First show me Lillian's body.

LARRY
I... I got it.

PAUL
There's no way she could have survived that vat of molten
steel.

LARRY
No, no, I... I... I got...

PAUL
If you're not bluffing, where is she ?

LARRY
Why are you so nervous ? What are you so nervous about ?

PAUL
Where ?

LARRY
If I don't have her, what are you so nervous ?
PAUL
Where is she ?
LARRY
I got her in the trunk of my car.

PAUL
Open it. Come on, now.

LARRY
I... I got her.

PAUL
If she's not there, I'll put a bullet through your head.
Now, open it !
Genres: ["crime","drama","thriller"]

Summary Larry and the gang attempt to trap the murderer by faking a phone call from the victim, but their plan goes awry. Paul, the killer, has Carol held hostage and demands a package from Larry in exchange for her release. Larry is forced to pretend he has the package, but when Paul demands to see Lillian's body, Larry realizes he has been caught in a lie.
Strengths "The tension is expertly built throughout the scene, with the stakes getting higher and higher as the characters realize they are in over their heads. The dialogue is sharp and propels the plot forward at a rapid pace. The character motivations are clear and well-established."
Weaknesses "Some of the scene transitions are abrupt and could benefit from smoother editing. Additionally, while the tension is high, some of the character actions feel contrived or forced in service of plot."
Critique This excerpt is a script for a suspense thriller movie. The scene is well written, and the action progresses in a clear and concise manner. However, there are a few areas that could be improved:

1. The opening scene where Carol is changing her clothes is unnecessary and adds nothing to the story. It could be edited out to make the scene more concise.

2. The dialogue between Ted and Helen in the cafeteria does not fit in with the overall tone of the script. The two characters are discussing mundane things like abortions and drama prizes while the audience is waiting for the suspense to pick up. This section could be cut.

3. The dialogue between Larry and Paul feels somewhat cliché and could use some reworking. The lines "I got a package you think you're gonna want" and "If you ever want to see your wife alive again, you'll do as I say" are a bit too predictable.

4. The ending of the scene is abrupt and leaves the audience hanging. It would benefit from a little more closure or an explanation of what happens next.

Overall, the scene is well written and effective at building suspense. With a few minor adjustments, it could be even stronger.
Suggestions One suggestion would be to add more tension and suspense to the scene in the bathroom. Instead of just having Paul silently walk towards the bathroom, have some ominous music playing in the background, or show close-up shots of his footsteps getting closer and closer. Another improvement could be to add more depth to Carol's character. Instead of just showing her changing clothes and going to an appointment, maybe include some dialogue or actions that give insight into her personality or her motivations. Additionally, it might be helpful to add more context and build up the stakes of the phone call scene with Larry. Show more of Larry's desperation and fear, and perhaps include more details on what led him to this point. Overall, adding more layers to the characters and increasing tension will make for a more engaging and suspenseful scene.



Scene 45 -  Backstage Showdown
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
LARRY
I... I...

Larry walks around his car toward the trunk.

PAUL
Come on! Come on!

Larry opens the trunk.
PAUL
Step back!

Larry takes something in the trunk, then closes it back, but
the
door of the trunk doesn't close well and opens again. Larry
walks
back to Paul and shows him what he's got in his hand.

LARRY
No, no, I got her. See, if I don't have her, how come I got
her ring ? I got her ring, there. This is... This is her
ring.

PAUL
I think you're lying !

He walks to the open trunk.

LARRY
It's a... No, no, no, no. Uh.

Paul takes a bad-looking dummy out of the trunk. Apparently,
it is
an amateur dummy that Larry has made himself.

PAUL
What is this ? What is this ?

He throws the dummy back in the trunk.

LARRY
I could never bluff.

PAUL
What ?

LARRY
I... I... I've lost a fortune in cards over the years.
PAUL
Listen to me.

LARRY
I'm not a bluffer.

PAUL
I'm going to put a... Get a...

They start fighting.

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - OLD DRESSING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Carol is still tied and gagged on the chair. She tries
desperately
to get free.

DEAD END STREET BEHIND PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - EXTERIOR DAY

Medium shot on Larry and Paul, still fighting. Larry
succeeds in
getting away from Paul, who fires his gun. But, apparently,
Larry
is not hit by the gunshot, because he runs toward the back
entrance of the movie house. The camera follows him.
PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - BACKSTAGE - INTERIOR DAY

Medium shot on the staircase on the side of the backstage.
Larry
runs down the stairs, while we hear the sound of the «Lady
from
Shangai». «The Lady from Shangai» is a 1947 film written,
directed
and played by Orson Welles.



MICHAEL (Orson Welles - voice over from the film)
That's what Grisby thought. But, of course, she meant to
kill Grisby, too. After he'd served his purpose. Poor
howling idiot.

Larry has now reached the backstage. He is behind the
screen, a
small part of which is seen on the side of the shot.

MICHAEL (Orson Welles - voice over from the film)
He never even did that. He went and shot Broome. And that
was not part of the plan. Broome might have got to the
police before he died.

Larry walks around the backstage, trying to find his way. We
see
the black and white film on the screen, but also reflections
of
the screen on the multiple mirrors scattered around the
backstage.

MICHAEL (Orson Welles - voice over from the film)
And if the cops traced it to Grisby... and the cops made
Grisby talk, he'd spill everything.

Medium shot on the staircase. Paul is walking very slowly
downstairs.

MICHAEL (Orson Welles - voice over from the film)
And she'd be finished, so she had to shut up Grisby but
quick.
Back on Larry, still trying to find his way around the
backstage.

MICHAEL (Orson Welles - voice over from the film)
And I was the fall guy.

Full shot on the screen, where a man is falling down a long
slide,
like the one used by kids on playgrounds. We hear the film
music.

Medium close shot on two mirrors, one behind the other. On
the
mirrors, we see the reflection of the screen. Paul is slowly
walking from behind the first mirror, his gun in hand.

Full shot on the mirrors, with Larry walking cautiously
among
them.

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - OLD DRESSING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Medium shot on Carol in the small room. She is still trying
to get
free from her bonds and gag.

ELSA (Rita Hayworth - voice over from the film)
Why don't you try to understand ?
PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - BACKSTAGE - INTERIOR DAY

Back to the mirrors showing numerous reflections of the
screen.

ELSA (Rita Hayworth - voice over from the film)
He was mad. He had to be shot.

MICHAEL (Orson Welles - voice over from the film)
And what about me ?

Paul walks in, his gun in his hand.

ELSA (Rita Hayworth - voice over from the film)
We could have gone off together.

Close shot of Larry half-hidden behind a large mirror.

MICHAEL (Orson Welles - voice over from the film)
One who follows his nature, keeps his original nature in
the end.

Larry inadvertently drops the large mirror on the floor. The
mirror breaks with a crashing sound.

CAROL (voice over)
Help ! Help !

The camera pans to Paul, walking slowly with his gun pointed
toward Larry.

PAUL
They can't see us behind the screen, and they can't hear us
with the sound on. Not even a gunshot.

Behind Paul, we see the film on the screen. We have now
reached
the famous last scene of the film, shot in the hall of
mirrors.
Rita Hayworth's face is reflected on the many mirrors in the
film,
just like, in the actual scene in the backstage, Paul and
Larry
are reflected on the many mirrors scattered around.

ARTHUR (Everett Sloane - voice over from the film)
I knew I'd find you two together.
Arthur's figure, walking with a cane, is reflected in the
many
mirrors in the film. Just the same, Gladys, who has just
entered
the backstage, walking with a cane, is also reflected on the
mirrors scattered around her. She has a gun in the hand
which is
not holding the cane.
Genres: ["Thriller","Film Noir"]

Summary Paul captures Carol and demands Larry hand over a package, only to discover he's been lied to. Larry and Paul engage in a physical fight and Larry manages to escape, running into the movie house's backstage area. Paul follows him, gun in hand, and they traverse the backstage area, all while scenes from the film 'The Lady from Shanghai' play in the background. Gladys enters with a gun, pointing it at Paul and the scene ends on a tense standoff.
Strengths "The intensity of the scene is its greatest strength, with a high-stakes standoff that keeps the audience on the edge of their seat. The use of the film 'The Lady from Shanghai' in the background adds an extra layer of tension."
Weaknesses "The dialogue could have been more impactful, particularly during the physical fight scene."
Critique Overall, the scene is well-written and provides clear visuals for the reader. However, there are a few areas that could be improved.

First, the dialogue between Larry and Paul is a bit repetitive and could be condensed. The back-and-forth of "I... I..." and "Come on! Come on!" doesn't add much to the scene and could be streamlined.

Second, the action in the scene could be more engaging. While there is some tension with the revelation of the dummy in the trunk and the ensuing fight, the pacing could be improved to heighten the suspense.

Finally, the use of voiceover from the film "The Lady from Shanghai" is interesting but potentially distracting for the audience. It may be better to find a way to convey the necessary information through the visuals and dialogue in the scene itself.

Overall, the scene has potential but could benefit from some editing and increased tension.
Suggestions 1. Clarify the stakes: What is at stake for Larry and Paul in this scene? Is it just about proving that Larry has the missing ring, or is there something bigger on the line? By clarifying the stakes, the tension of the scene can be heightened.

2. Condense dialogue: In some places, the dialogue could be tightened up to make it more dynamic and engaging. For instance, there's a lot of repetition in Larry's attempts to demonstrate that he has the ring.

3. Increase the urgency: The fighting scene between Larry and Paul could be made more urgent by intercutting it with shots of Carol struggling to free herself. This would create a parallel sense of urgency and heighten the stakes for the overall scene.

4. Make use of visual metaphors: The scene's use of mirrors could be heightened to create a visual metaphor for the characters' duplicitous and reflective natures. This could also be tied into the themes of the overall story.

5. Tighten up description: The scene's description could be tightened up in places to create more visual variety. For instance, the descriptions of the camera following Larry don't offer a lot of visual interest. By introducing different visual motifs, the scene could be made more dynamic and engaging.



Scene 46 -  Confrontation on the Backstage
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
While Gladys and Paul are talking, the film keeps on showing
on
the screen behind them, but we do not understand the words
from
the film, because Paul and Gladys' voices are louder.

GLADYS
Hallo, Paul. Didn't you expect me ?

Medium shot on the mirrors, showing several reflections of
Paul.

PAUL
Mrs. Dalton.

Close shot on Gladys' face. While she is talking, the camera
pans
away from her, showing her reflection on a mirror.

GLADYS
You made a lot of promises to me, over the years. And then,
you decided to dump me for that young model.

The camera keeps on panning, showing another reflection of
Gladys.

PAUL (voice over)
I never led you on.

GLADYS (with a very harsh voice)
It's late for excuses.

Medium shot on the mirrors showing several reflections of
Paul.

PAUL
None of you can prove anything.

Full shot of the screen, showing Arthur and his numerous
reflections on the mirrors in the film.

ARTHUR (Everett Sloane - voice over from the film)
So you'd be foolish to fire that gun.
Low angle shot on the staircase, showing Larry going down
the
stairs.

ARTHUR (Everett Sloane - voice over from the film)
With these mirrors, it's difficult to tell. You are aiming
at me, aren't you ?

LARRY
Carol ? Carol ? Carol ?
Medium shot of Gladys and one of her reflections.

GLADYS
I'm aiming at you, lover.

ARTHUR (Everett Sloane - voice over from the film)
Of course, killing you is killing myself.

GLADYS
Of course, killing you is killing myself.

ARTHUR (Everett Sloane - voice over from the film)
It's the same thing.

GLADYS
But you know, I'm pretty tired of both of us.

She fired her gun twice

Medium shot on the many reflections of Paul. He fires his
gun
twice. We hear noises of mirrors being broken by the
gunshots,
both in the film, and on the backstage itself.
Medium shot of Gladys and one of her reflections. She turns
around, not being sure, because of the mirrors, of Paul's
exact
location.

Medium shot of Paul walking on the backstage. We still hears
noises of mirrors being broken, but we don't know if the
noises
come from the film or the backstage.

Medium shot of Gladys and several of the reflections.

Medium shot of the floor of the backstage. We see the bottom
of
the screen and, of course, the film projected on it, and in
which
the mirrors are being broken. Paul enters from behind a
mirror
frame, and falls on the floor. Gladys' reflection appears in
several mirrors. She stops and looks at Paul's body lying on
the
floor.

PAUL'S MOVIE HOUSE - OLD DRESSING ROOM - INTERIOR DAY

Medium close shot of Larry entering the room. He rushes to
Carol,
and takes her gag off.

LARRY
God ! Are you okay ? Are you okay ?

He hugs and kisses her.

CAROL
Oh, God, Larry ! Oh, Larry, I'm so happy to see you !

LARRY
Jesus, I was, I was never so glad to see somebody in my
life. Are you all right ?

He starts untying her hands.

CAROL
Yes, I'm all right.

LARRY
You don't know what's going on out there. I'll never say
that life doesn't imitate art again. I'm... I'm... Oh,
gee...

CAROL
We... we gotta call the police, Larry.

LARRY
Yes, and... and... and... a glazier.

CAROL
I know. Oh, God.

LARRY
Quick, quick. Dial, dial, dial.

He picks up the telephone, and Carol, whose hands are now
completely free, starts dialing.
CAROL
Larry. Oh, God, Larry. Oh, God. Oh, honey. Oh, God. Ow !
Ow ! Oh, God ! Jesus !
Larry hugs and kisses her again.

LARRY
I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Oh, wife mine.

He takes the rope away, but he does it so nervously that he
almost
takes Carol's head off !

CAROL
Aow ! Aow !
(talking in the phone)
Hello ?

LARRY
Wife mine.

CAROL
Oh, God.

NEW-YORK - STREET IN FRONT OF THE POLICE STATION - EXTERIOR
DAY

Medium close shot on the top part of the door of the police
station. A sign says : «4th precinct 621».

The camera tilts down. Three uniformed policemen are
standing on
the sidewalk near the door. Marcia and Ted come out of the
station, and stop at the entrance.

TED
God, it's... it's so complicated. I can't... Can't keep
track of it all.

MARCIA
Oh, listen. I'll give it to you one more time.
Marcia takes a cigarette, and Ted lights it with his
lighter.

FLASHBACK SCENE
PAUL'S APARTMENT - LIVING ROOM - INTERIOR NIGHT

Medium shot. It's dinner time in Paul's apartment. Paul and
Lilian's sister are seated around the table. Lilian comes in
from
THE KITCHEN

MARCIA (voice over)
Mrs. House had a sister who moved to England many years
ago.
Lilian gives a glass of wine to her sister.

MARCIA (voice over)
She changed her name when she married.

Lilian gives a glass of wine to Paul.

MARCIA (voice over)
Her husband died. She moved back to New York recently, a
very, very rich widow... but a recluse.
Genres: ["Thriller","Drama"]

Summary Gladys confronts Paul while scenes from the movie play in the background. A shootout ensues and Paul is killed. Larry rescues Carol and they call the police.
Strengths "The tension is high throughout the scene, with action and suspense playing out at the same time. The use of mirrors to show reflections adds complexity to the scene and heightens the tension. The dialogue is crisp and adds to the overall tone of the scene."
Weaknesses "The use of the film 'The Lady from Shanghai' sometimes feels forced and unnecessary. The motivations of some characters could have been fleshed out more."
Critique Overall, the scene seems to have strong technical elements, including the use of mirrors to create multiple reflections and the combination of live action and a film shown on a screen. However, the dialogue and action can be confusing and hard to follow. The dialogue could benefit from clearer indications of who is speaking and when the voices are coming from the film or the live action. Additionally, the action of the scene, particularly the gunshots and breaking mirrors, could also benefit from clearer framing and sound design to help create a more coherent and impactful narrative. Overall, the scene shows potential, but could benefit from greater clarity in both dialogue and visual storytelling.
Suggestions Overall, the scene seems well-written and engaging. However, there are a few suggestions that could improve the scene:

1. Provide more context for the film being shown on the screen behind Gladys and Paul. What is the genre of the film? Is it a pivotal scene? This information can help the audience understand the importance of the film and why it is being shown.

2. Consider adding more visual cues to help the audience distinguish between the film being shown and the events happening in the backstage. For instance, the camera could zoom in on the film to emphasize its importance.

3. Consider adding more dialogue from Paul. His character seems to be lacking in this scene, and it would be helpful to hear his perspective on the situation.

4. Incorporate more active language and sensory descriptions to create a sense of urgency and excitement. For instance, describing the sound of the gunshots, the smell of the gunpowder, or the sight of the broken mirrors can help immerse the audience in the scene.

5. Provide more information on the character's motivations and emotions. Why is Gladys so angry with Paul? How does Carol feel after being rescued? These details can help create a deeper emotional connection with the audience and make the scene more impactful.



Scene 47 -  The Final Showdown
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 9
Lilian's sister has a heart attack. Paul helps her walk away
from
the table to the sofa.

MARCIA (voice over)
Mr. and Mrs. House knew they weren't in her will. They have
her over to dinner, she accidentally keels over. I guessed
right there.

Lilian's sister is lying dead on the sofa, and Lilian,
wearing a
pink night-robe, is dressing her sister in her own clothes.

MARCIA (voice over)
She has a reasonable resemblance to her sister, so they
fake it... Pretend Lillian House died. They cremate the
sister.

The camera pans to Paul talking on the telephone.

MARCIA (voice over)
Lillian checks into a fleabag joint... and for several
weeks she pretends to be her sister... closing her
accounts, liquidating her assets, accumulating big money.

The camera pans back to the sofa, where Lilian is still
dressing
her sister.

MARCIA (voice over)
What she didn't realize was that her husband was two-timing
her with Helen Moss, this pretty model.

NEW-YORK - STREET IN FRONT OF THE POLICE STATION - EXTERIOR
DAY

Back to the entrance of the police station, where Ted and
Marcia
are still talking. They start walking along the street.
MARCIA
So, he decides not to cut her in and go off to... I don't
know... With his mistress and, uh, keep all the dough. So,
he kills Lillian. He cremates her, or pours molten steel
all over her or something... and, uh, that's when we came
along and tripped him up.

Medium shot of Ted and Marcia slowly walking behind the
police
cars parked near the station.

TED
He had some great alibis.

MARCIA
Yeah, that woman that worked for him ?

TED
Yeah.

MARCIA
Mrs. Dalton ? She covered for him. She loved him. Not that
she dreamed he was a murderer.
TED
What do you... What do you... I want, I want to celebrate,
or something. What do you wanna do ? You wanna... Wanna go
see what, uh, what Larry and Carol are up to ?

MARCIA
I think they wanna be alone.

TED
Oh, yeah. Uh, okay. All right. Uh, well, you have any
plans ?

MARCIA
You're taking me to dinner, right ?

TED
Yeah, right. Absolutely. Only we can't sleep together.

MARCIA
Why not ?

TED
Not... not tonight.

MARCIA
Why not ?

TED
Well, I already slept with Helen Moss once today, and I'm
not young and active like I used to be.
MARCIA
You'll do anything to catch a murderer, won't you ?

NEW-YORK - LARRY'S RESIDENCE STREET - EXTERIOR DAY

Full shot of the corner of the street where Larry's building
is
located. The pavement is wet from a recent rain. Carol and
Larry
are coming around the corner of the street.

LARRY
What an experience.

CAROL
Oh, really one.

LARRY
I'm... I'm still vibrating.

CAROL
I know.

LARRY
Incredible.

Carol, who was walking quite rapidly, suddenly slows down.
Track
shot of Larry and Carol, with the camera in front of them

CAROL
Oh, you know, Larry, you were surprisingly brave.

LARRY
What do you mean surprisingly ?

CAROL
Yeah.

LARRY
You seem shocked.

CAROL
Well...

LARRY
You know, I'm a pretty good guy, you know.

CAROL
Well, you know... Yeah, I know, uh...
LARRY
Where do you wanna go for dinner tonight ? Let's not go to
any restaurant where they serve cowards.

Carol laughs.

CAROL
I don't know.

LARRY
I... What are you laughing at ?

CAROL
You know, Larry, I love you. I love you.

LARRY
How could you have ever been jealous of Marcia ? Isn't that
ridiculous ? Don't you know that I could only love you ?

CAROL
You were jealous of Ted.

LARRY
Ted ?

CAROL
Yeah.

LARRY
You've got to be kidding. Take away his-his-his elevator
shoes and his fake suntan and his capped teeth... and what
do you have ?

CAROL
You.

Larry laughs. They have reached their building and they
enter it.

LARRY
Right. I love that.

CAROL
I...

An attendant opens the door for them. Through the glass
doors, we
see them cross the lobby toward the elevator.

CREDITS

The credits are «Woody Allen style» : in white Windsor Light
Condensed typeface letters on a black background.

THE END
Genres: ["crime","mystery","romance","drama","comedy"]

Summary Paul demands a package from Larry in exchange for Carol's release, but Larry's lie is uncovered. A physical fight ensues and Paul is killed. Larry and Carol call the police.
Strengths "The scene is well-paced and exciting. The dialogue is witty and adds moments of humor to the otherwise intense scene. The standoff between Gladys and Paul adds tension to the scene."
Weaknesses "The scene may be too predictable for some viewers, and the physical fight between Larry and Paul may feel cliche."
Critique As a screenwriting expert, I would suggest that the scene lacks character development and plot progression. The dialogue feels forced and unnatural, with characters giving exposition through voiceovers instead of showing it through action and behavior. Additionally, the pacing seems slow and the scene feels unfocused, jumping between different locations and characters without a clear purpose. A stronger focus on character motivations and clearer storytelling would greatly improve this scene.
Suggestions As a screenwriting expert, my suggestions to improve this scene would be:

1. Show instead of tell: The exposition in the beginning of the scene can be more engaging if shown instead of told through a voiceover. For example, instead of the voiceover saying they "fake it" and "pretend Lillian House died", we could see Lilian faking her sister's death and cremating her. It would create a more engaging and suspenseful scene.

2. Use more visual description: The scene could benefit from more visual description that would help the audience follow the action. For instance, we could see Lilian's sister's heart attack happening at the dinner table, which would create more tension and drama. Also, when Ted and Marcia are walking behind the police cars, the camera could show them from a wider angle, so we can see the police cars more clearly.

3. Develop character relationships: The scene lacks strong character relationships, which could be developed further to make it more engaging. For example, there could be more tension between Larry and Carol as they discuss jealousy. Additionally, there could be more tension between Ted and Marcia as they discuss their plans to celebrate.

4. Tighten the dialogue: The dialogue could be tighter to make the scene more engaging. For instance, the conversation between Larry and Carol about jealousy could be shortened to make it more impactful.

By implementing these suggestions, the scene could become more engaging, suspenseful, and impactful.