Read LA confidential - draft with its analysis


See Full Analysis here

Scene 1 -  L.A. Confidential Scene 1: The City of Angels
  • Overall: 8.5
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
L.A. CONFIDENTIAL



by

Brian Helgeland


Based on the novel by James Ellroy




November 16, 1995
Minor Revisions




FADE IN:

OVER the opening strains of "I LOVE YOU, CALIFORNIA," a
MONTAGE: a mixture of headlines, newsreel footage and
live action. Economy Booming! Postwar Optimism! L.A.:
City of the Future! But most prominent among them:
GANGLAND! Police photographers document crime scenes.
The meat wagon hauls ex-button men to the morgue. Where
will it end?


EXT. L.A. SKYLINE - SUNSET

Palm trees in silhouette against a cherry sky. City
lights twinkle. Los Angeles. A place where anything is
possible. A place where dreams come true. As the sky
darkens, triple-kleig lights begin to sweep back and
forth.


EXT. MANSION (HANCOCK PARK) - NIGHT

The KLEIG LIGHTS are out front. Valets hurry to park a
line of elegant cars.
MAYOR (V.O.)
Ladies and gentlemen, I give you
the future of Los Angeles!


INT. HANCOCK PARK MANSION - BALLROOM - NIGHT

The MAYOR yanks a cloth to reveal a MODEL of L.A. criss-
crossed by an elaborate FREEWAY SYSTEM. The CROWD oohs.
A COUNCILMAN claps. A SOCIETY MATRON nods her approval.

PIERCE PATCHETT, 50, tuxedoed, watches off to one side.
A behind-the-scenes power broker, Patchett exudes
authority much more so than the Mayor does.

MAYOR
The Arroyo Seco freeway is just
the beginning. We're planning
freeways from Downtown to Santa
Monica, from the South Bay to the
San Fernando Valley. Twenty
minutes to work or play is the
longest you'll have to travel.

More applause. One REPORTER asks a little too loudly...

REPORTER
How many bodies you think Mickey
Cohen'll be able to hide in all
that cement?

The Mayor wears a plastic smile, ignores it.


INT. THE MOCAMBO - NIGHT

A CLUB PHOTOGRAPHER pops snapshots, but the real action
is on the floor where MICKEY COHEN does a wicked "Lindy
Hop" with THREE different GIRLS at once. A fireplug of a
man, he hardly seems a public menace. Nearby is his
bodyguard JOHNNY STOMPANATO. Over it all:

HUDGEONS (V.O.)
Meyer Harris Cohen, Mickey C to
his fans. He's the big moocher,
local L.A. color to the nth
degree. You know Mickey. He runs
dope, rackets and prostitution.
He kills a dozen people a year.
But who you may not know is
bodyguard Johnny Stompanato.

His hair in a slick pompadour, Stompanato keeps an eye on
Cohen and comes onto a CIGARETTE GIRL at the same time.

HUDGEONS (V.O.)
Johnny's handsome, ladies, but the
real attraction is below the belt.
Second only to Steve Cochran, he's
sometimes known as 'Oscar' because
of his Academy Award-size
appendage.

Mickey works a sweat on the dance floor. A bottle of
champagne pops; Stompanato reacts, nearly draws a pistol
from his shoulder holster. As he laughs at himself...


INT. HUSH-HUSH MAGAZINE OFFICE - DAY

Lurid page one headlines cover the wall where SID
HUDGEONS types. The essence of sleaze, Sid is the
publisher-photographer-writer of Hush-Hush magazine and
keeper of inside dirt supreme. As he continues...

HUDGEONS (V.O.)
Remember, dear readers, you heard
it here first, off the record, on
the Q.T. and very Hush-Hush.


INT. HANCOCK PARK MANSION - BALLROOM - NIGHT

The party continues. The Mayor has moved off to the side
with the power brokers. Patchett is a presence.

MAYOR
We're selling an image, gentlemen.
Beautiful weather. Affordable
housing.
(re: model)
Trouble-free transportation. And
the best police department in the
world to keep it all running
smoothly.


EXT. STOREFRONT - NIGHT

A dozen people watch a display windoe TELEVISION as it
rolls the opening of the hit show "Badge of Honor." Over
familiar THEME MUSIC, "Sgt. Joe Reno" (actor BRETT CHASE)
walks the streets of Los Angeles.

CHASE (V.O.)
My name? Joe Reno. The city?
Los Angeles. A big town. Full of
all sorts of people. It's my job
to help them. I like what I do.
I'm a cop.


INT. HANCOCK PARK MANSION - BALLROOM - NIGHT

The Mayor continues.

MAYOR
But with a second rate Al Capone
out there, L.A. looks like Chicago
in the '30s. Something has to be
done.
As Pierce Patchett nods sagely.


INT. OLYMPIC AUDITORIUM - NIGHT

Wrestler GORGEOUS GEORGE primps and poses before flatten-
ing an opponent with a drop kick.


INT. MOVIE THEATER - NIGHT

An enthusiastic crowd adjusts their 3-D glasses.


EXT. COHEN MANSION (BEVERLY HILLS) - DAY

In monogrammed silk pajamas, Mickey Cohen answers the
door, his pet BULLDOG Mickey Jr. at his feet. The police
are waiting. REPORTERS' flashbulbs pop.

POLICE OFFICER
Mr. Cohen, you're under arrest.

COHEN
Bullshit. What's the charge?

POLICE OFFICER
Non-payment of federal income tax.

COHEN
Bullshit.
Genres: ["crime","drama","thriller"]

Summary The opening scene introduces the corruption and violence beneath the surface of Los Angeles in the 1950s. The scene features the Mayor presenting a model of a freeway plan for the city, while the audience gets glimpses of Mickey Cohen and his bodyguard Stompanato dancing at a club and Gorgeous George wrestling at the Olympic Auditorium. Hush-Hush magazine's publisher Sid Hudgeons types away in his office and the hit show 'Badge of Honor' airs on a storefront TV.
Strengths
  • Introduces the main themes and characters of the film
  • Sets up a complex and ever-changing city landscape
  • Mixes real and fictional characters and events
Weaknesses
  • There is a lot going on in the scene, which can be overwhelming for some viewers
Critique As a screenwriting expert, I can say that this scene sets up a clear contrast between the glitz and glamour of Hollywood and the darker underworld of gangland crime. The montage at the beginning efficiently establishes the time and place, while also hinting at the violence lurking beneath the surface. The introduction of Mickey Cohen and his bodyguard Johnny Stompanato further underscores the danger present in this world.

The dialogue, particularly in the scene at the Hancock Park mansion, is well-crafted and helps to establish the characters' motivations and personalities. The Mayor's speech about selling an image of Los Angeles contrasts with Cohen's criminal activities, while Patchett's presence suggests that he may hold more power than any of them.

The scene also sets up a narrative tension by introducing the conflict between Cohen and the police, which will undoubtedly become more important as the story progresses. Overall, this scene is well-written and effectively establishes the world and the characters within it.
Suggestions Overall, the scene sets up the time period and atmosphere of L.A. in the 1940s, but it lacks clear character introductions and a central conflict. Here are some suggestions to improve the scene:

1. Character Introductions: While the Mayor and Mickey Cohen are named in the scene, it would be helpful to include basic character introductions for all main characters. For example, a brief description of Pierce Patchett's occupation and reputation would help establish his role in the story.

2. Clearer Conflict: While the scene mentions a second-rate Al Capone and the need to do something about it, it doesn't establish a specific conflict for the story. Adding hints of the larger story conflict (e.g. corruption in the police force, the rise of organized crime) would help set up the stakes for the rest of the film.

3. Visual Clarity: While the montage and transitions between locations create a fast-paced feel, they can also be confusing. Adding more clear establishing shots of each location and character would help orient the audience.

4. Dialogue: While the dialogue generally works for the time period and setting, some of the lines feel a bit on-the-nose (e.g. the Mayor's line about selling an image). Streamlining the dialogue and adding more unique character voices would help make the characters more distinct and memorable.

Overall, this scene could benefit from clearer character introductions, a stronger central conflict, and more visual clarity.



Scene 2 -  Christmas Eve Violence
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
EXT. GRAUMAN'S CHINESE - DAY

JOHN WAYNE gets his hand prints in the sidewalk.


EXT. WESTCHESTER BEAN FIELD - DAY

MIGRANT WORKERS hurry to finish the harvest. We PAN
TO CONSTRUCTION WORKERS who wait impatiently with bull-
dozers under a "Spirit of the Future" BANNER. As the
last picker leaves the field, the bulldozers move in,
leveling the bean rows to make way for a housing tract.


EXT. FEDERAL COURTHOUSE - STEPS - DAY

Flashbulbs pop as Mickey Cohen exits and starts down
the steps. Accompanied by his LAWYERS, bodyguard
Stompanato and mob lieutenants DEUCE PERKINS and NATE
JANKLOW, Cohen ignores REPORTERS' shouts.

REPORTER
How's your bullshit now, Mickey?!

As Cohen gets into a waiting car, the media turn their
attention to District Attorney ELLIS LOEW. A singularly
ambitious man, Loew loves the spotlight.
LOEW
Today is an auspicious one for the
city of Los Angeles. Mickey Cohen
has just been sentenced to ten
years in federal prison for
failure to pay income tax.
As the District Attorney for Los
Angeles County, it is my pleasure
to declare our great city
organized crime free. It is truly
the dawning of a new day.

The SONG ENDS and so does the MONTAGE.


INT. PACKARD (ACROSS FROM BULLOCKS WILSHIRE) - NIGHT

December 24th. Wendell "BUD" WHITE, 30, stares at the
enormous Christmas tree on the deco platform over
Bullocks' entrance. An LAPD cop, Bud's rep as the
toughest man on the force has been well earned. In the
back seat, with cases of Walker Black and Cutty Sark, is
Bud's partner -- DICK STENSLAND. Older, but also a tough
hump, "Stens" sucks on a pint of Old Crow.

The passenger door opens and Mickey Cohen bodyguard
Johnny Stompanato slides in. Guinea handsome, Johnny
wears his curls in a tight pompadour. With his boss
behind bars, he's out of work. Bud just stares at him.

STOMPANATO
Officer White. I heard you got a
hard-on for wife beaters.

BUD
And you fuck people up for a
living. That don't make me you.
Capisce, shitbird?

Stompanato smiles. Nervous. Through the window, Bud
watches a Salvation Army Santa palm coins from a kettle.

STENSLAND
Bud ain't in the mood for small
talk, Stompanato.

STOMPANATO
Look, Mickey C's doing time and
half the other guys who'd hire me
are dead or left town. I need
money. If your snitch-fund's
green, I'll get you some fucking-A
collars.

Impatient, Bud tugs at a finger, CRACKS a KNUCKLE.

STOMPANATO
There's this guy. He's blond and
fat, about forty. Likes the
ponies. Been pimping his wife to
cover his losses. Knocks her
around to keep her in line.

Bud's eyes narrow at this last bit of info. Stompanato
holds up a slip of paper.

STOMPANATO
I figure the address is worth
twenty.

Bud digs into his wallet, pulls out twenty bucks,
exchanges it with Stompanato. Stompanato smiles smugly,
grabs a bottle of Scotch from the back.

STOMPANATO
Yuletide cheer, fellas.

Without warning, Bud grabs Stompanato's tie and yanks,
slamming his forehead into the dash.

BUD
Happy New Year, greaseball.

EXT. 1486 EVERGREEN - NIGHT

A stucco job in a row of vet prefabs. A neon Santa
sleigh has landed on the roof. Through the front window,
we see a fat guy browbeating a woman. Puff-faced, 35-
ish, she backs away as he rages at her.

The Packard pulls up out front. Stensland could care
less.

STENSLAND
Leave it for later, Bud. We got
to pick up the rest of the booze
and get back to the precinct.

Bud KILLS the IGNITION, picks up the radio.

BUD
Central, this is 4A-31. Send a
prowler to 1486 Evergreen. White
male in custody. Code 623 point
one. Domestic assault and
battery. I won't be here, but
they'll see him.


EXT. 1486 EVERGREEN - BUD - NIGHT

steps to the house. Inside, we hear SLAPS, MUFFLED
CRIES. Bud grips an outlet cord coming off the roof and
yanks. The sleigh crashes to the ground with REINDEER
EXPLODING around it. A beat. The fat guy runs out to
investigate, trips over Rudolph.

Bud pounces. Fat guy takes a swing, misses. Grabbing
fat guy's hair, Bud smashes his face to the pavement.
Once, twice. Teeth skitter down the walk.

BUD
Touch her again and I'll know
about it. Understand? Huh?

Another face full of gravel. Fat guy's WIFE watches with
apprehension from the steps as Bud cuffs her husband's
hands behind his back, empties his pockets. A cash roll
and car keys. Bud looks over at her.

BUD
You got someplace you can go?

She nods. Bud hands her the keys and the cash.

BUD
Go get yourself fixed up.

WIFE
(nods, determined)
Merry Christmas, huh?

Bud watches as she gets into a pre-war Ford in the drive.
She backs over a blinking reindeer as she goes.

STENSLAND
You and women, partner. What's
next? Kids and dogs?
Genres: ["Crime","Drama"]

Summary Bud beats up a wife-beater before arresting him and sending his victim away with money to get fixed up.
Strengths
  • Compelling portrayal of Bud's character
  • Effective use of violence to convey Bud's tough personality and moral code
Weaknesses
  • Lack of significant plot development
Critique The scene is well-written, with vivid descriptions that create distinct visuals. The settings are clear and well-defined, helping to ground the audience in the world of the story.

However, there are some issues with character development and pacing. While the scene starts with a series of unrelated events, each with their own tension and stakes, it feels somewhat disjointed.

The character of John Wayne, for example, is not developed beyond the simple action of getting his hand prints in the sidewalk, which is ultimately a throwaway moment. The same can be said for the construction workers waiting impatiently for the end of the harvest, as well as the flashbulbs popping as Mickey Cohen exits the courthouse.

The focus finally settles on Bud White, whose tough cop persona is established in exposition rather than through any meaningful action. The scene ultimately builds towards Bud's confrontation with Stompanato, which feels abrupt and unnecessary.

Overall, while the scene has some strong elements, it lacks cohesiveness and fails to fully develop its characters.
Suggestions Overall, the scene could benefit from sharper dialogue and more effective use of visual storytelling. Here are some specific suggestions:

1. Consider tightening up the first two shots (John Wayne getting his hand prints in the sidewalk and migrant workers harvesting beans) to make them more impactful and purposeful. For example, you could focus on John Wayne's reaction to this honor or the workers' exhaustion from long hours in the fields.

2. When covering Mickey Cohen's courthouse exit, try to convey more of the tension and drama of the moment. Perhaps a visual close-up of him or the reporters could help build the suspense. Additionally, Ellis Loew's speech feels a bit too expository and could be shortened or made more conversational.

3. The transition to the Packard scene could be made smoother by including a simple establishing shot of the car driving to its destination. This would also give the audience a chance to understand the setting better.

4. When Johnny Stompanato enters the car, there is an opportunity to show more of the tension between him and Bud White. Try to have their conversation be more nuanced and tense, with subtext and hidden meanings lurking beneath the surface.

5. The domestic assault scene is the most climactic part of the scene and could benefit from more visual description. Consider using more sensory details to bring the fight to life, such as the sounds of slaps and the gravel crunching underfoot. The dialogue between Bud and the fat guy could be more pointed and charged, revealing more about their respective characters. Finally, the ending where Bud gives the cash and keys to the wife should be more emotionally resonant, with Bud acknowledging the weight of what he's just done.



Scene 3 -  Christmas Bust
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 9
INT. STAGE FOUR (VARIETY INTERNATIONAL PICTURES) - NIGHT

The "Badge of Honor" set. A Christmas party in full
swing. Eating, drinking, and dancing. Star Brett Chase,
seen earlier on television, is holding court.

LAPD Sgt. "Trashcan" JACK VINCENNES, late 30s with slick,
good looks, dances with a young ACTRESS. Grinding their
way through a ballad, they're obviously hitting it off.

ACTRESS
Brett Chase told me you're the cop
who busted Bob Mitchum.
(grinds closer)
These 'Badge of Honor' guys like
to pretend, but being the real
thing must be a thrill.

JACK
Let's go someplace quiet. I'll
give you the low-down on Mitchum.

ACTRESS
You got your handcuffs with you?

JACK
Two sets.

ACTRESS
I'll get my coat.

They're interrupted by Sid Hudgeons.
HUDGEONS
Big V Jack Vincennes! May I have
this dance?

JACK
Karen, this is Sid Hudgeons from
Hush-Hush magazine.

ACTRESS
I know who he is.

The Actress storms off. Jack looks to Sid.

HUDGEONS
We did a piece last year.
'Ingenue Dykes In Hollywood.' Her
name got mentioned.

JACK
Is she?

HUDGEONS
Beats me. Look, Jackie-Boy, a
friend of mine just sold some
reefer to Matt Reynolds. He's
tripping the light fantastic with
Tammy Jordan at 2245 Maravilla,
Hollywood Hills. It's right
around the corner.

JACK
You lost me, Sid. Who?

HUDGEONS
Contract players at Metro. You
pinch 'em. I do you up feature in
the next issue. Plus the usual
fifty cash. Tell me, am I fucking
Santa Claus?

JACK
I need an extra fifty. Two
patrolmen at twenty apiece and a
dime for the watch commander at
Hollywood Station.

HUDGEONS
Jack! It's Christmas!

JACK
No. It's felony possession of
marijuana.


EXT. 2245 MARAVILLA - NIGHT

WITH a VIEW of Grauman's Chinese. Jack and two uniformed
patrolmen wait on the darkened street. An arc light has
been set up. Hudgeons creeps back over from the house.

HUDGEONS
They're sitting in the dark,
goofing on the Christmas tree.

JACK
Stand there with your camera.
I'll stop here so you get
Grauman's Chinese in the
backgrouns.

HUDGEONS
I like it! I like it!


INT. 2245 MARAVILLA - NIGHT

The arc light floods the living room about the same time
that Jack kicks the door in. The room is caught flush:
Christmas tree, a bag of weed on the couch, two kids
necking in their BVDs. MATT REYNOLDS and TAMMY JORDAN.

JACK
Police!

EXT. 2245 MARAVILLA - NIGHT

Jack exits, hauling Jordan and Reynolds by the neck.
Jack stops with Grauman's FRAMED behind him and Hudgeons
CLICKS off several shots with his CAMERA.

HUDGEONS
Cut! Wrap it!

Windows light up. Rubberneckers appear. Jack hands the
kids to the patrolmen, heads back in with Hudgeons in
tow.


INT. 2245 MARAVILLA - NIGHT

Jack scoops the pot, flips through an address book. A
card falls out. "Fleur-de-Lis. Whatever you desire..."
Jack looks from the card out the window at the kids being
loaded into a black and white. They're both crying now.

HUDGEONS
(stantorian tone)
It's Christmas morning in the City
of Angels, and while decent
citizens sleep the sleep of the
righteous, hopheads prowl for
marijuana, not knowing that a man
is coming to stop them. The free-
wheeling, big-time Big V,
celebrity crime-stopper, Jack
Vincennes, the scourge of
grasshoppers and junk fiends
everywhere. You like it, Jackie-
Boy?

JACK
Yeah, it's subtle.
Sid hands him a President Grant 50.

HUDGEONS
Remember: you heard it first here,
off the record, on the Q.T. and
very Hush-Hush.


INT. HOLLYWOOD STATION - DISPATCH DESK - NIGHT

Suspects, mostly drunk and disorderly, are ushered
through. Sgt. ED EXLEY, 30, bespectacled, is at the desk
with a YOUNG OFFICER. Exley is an up-and-comer. Burning
with ambition. The faster he rises through the ranks,
the more resentment he leaves in his wake.

EXLEY
What's on the call sheet?

YOUNG OFFICER
A guy dressed as Santa has been
exposing himself to kids in Los
Feliz. Apparently, sir, he's
decorated himself.

EXLEY
Decorated?

YOUNG OFFICER
With tinsel and plastic icicles
and... on his penis, sir.

EXLEY
I get the idea. You got a
description?

YOUNG OFFICER
Of his penis, sir?
Genres: ["Crime","Drama","Film Noir"]

Summary Sergeant Jack Vincennes and Hush Hush publisher Sid Hudgeons set up a drug bust at a Christmas Party, arrest two young actors for marijuana possession and then try to use them to get to bigger targets. While doing so, they attract a crowd and Hudgeons takes photos to publish in his magazine. After the bust, they bring the suspects to the Hollywood Station where Sergeant Exley is on duty, dealing with other unusual crimes.
Strengths "Interesting dialogue, unique set up for story, introduces various characters in a compelling way"
Weaknesses "Possible objectification of women and racial minorities, lack of depth to characters"
Critique Overall, the scene is well written and engaging. However, there are a few things that could be improved upon.

Firstly, it's not entirely clear what the main objective of the scene is. It seems like the scene is introducing Jack Vincennes and setting up his character as a celebrity cop who takes bribes and gets involved in investigating Hollywood scandals. However, it's not clear what the larger purpose of this scene is in terms of the story arc.

Secondly, some of the dialogue could be tightened up. For example, the exchange between Jack and the Actress could be condensed to give it more punch.

Lastly, the description of the scene could benefit from more sensory details to help the reader more fully imagine the setting and characters.

Overall, the scene has potential, but it could benefit from some small tweaks to make it more effective.
Suggestions Here are a few suggestions to improve this scene:

1. Add more tension: Right now, the scene feels a bit too casual for the story's genre, which is likely a crime drama. Consider adding more tension to the scene, perhaps by having some underlying conflicts or ulterior motives that are not immediately apparent.

2. Use more subtext: While the dialogue is functional, it could use more subtext to convey what the characters are really thinking or feeling. For example, when the Actress asks if Jack has his handcuffs, he could respond with something that implies he knows that she knows it's a cheesy pick-up line, but he is amused by it.

3. Consider the pacing: This scene is fairly lengthy and could be trimmed down for better pacing. One possibility is to condense the conversation between Jack and Sid and have Jack go straight to the bust without the extra dialogue.

4. Use more visual description: The scene could benefit from more visual description, especially during the bust scene. The writer could add more description of the setting and characters to help the audience visualize the scene better.



Scene 4 -  Liquor Store Bust
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 9
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
EXT. HOLLYWOOD BOULEVARD - HOLLYWOOD LIQUOR - NIGHT

Tinsel-trimmed photos of movie stars look down from the
walls as the OWNER takes an order from LYNN BRACKEN.

LYNN
A case each of gin, Scotch, and
rum. Everything top shelf. None
of that watered-down stuff you
push on Errol Flynn.

OWNER
(laughs)
Sounds like a helluva party.

Her hair kerchiefed, Lynn waits as the Owner writes it
up. There's glamour, a cat-girl grace about Lynn. She
seems like she belongs up on the wall with the movie
stars. Lynn looks across as Bud White heads toward the
counter. Spotting her, Bud doesn't look so tough for a
moment.

OWNER
You want it delivered?

LYNN
Before five tomorrow.

The Owner spots Bud. A big smile turns to a frown.

OWNER
I'll be right with you, Lynn.

The Owner begins indiscriminately loading hard liquor
into a cardboard box, leaving Bud and Lynn to look at
each other. Bud says the only thing he can think of.

BUD
Merry Christmas.

LYNN
Merry Christmas yourself, Officer.

BUD
That obvious, huh?

LYNN
(smiles sweetly)
It's practically stamped on your
forehead.

As the Owner bangs a case of liquor on the counter...


EXT. HOLLYWOOD LIQUOR - NIGHT

Bud exits with his booze, heads for the car. Something
catches his eye. A woman in the rear passenger seat of a
new Cadillac. SUSAN LEFFERTS. Both her eyes are black.

Bud starts over. The case on his hip, he motions for her
to roll down the window. The driver's side door opens
and bodyguard TURNER "BUZZ" MEEKS menaces his way out.

MEEKS
Get lost why don't you?

Meeks stops short as Bud shoves his badge in Meeks' face.
Setting the case on the car's hood, Bud spins Meeks
around, pats him down. He finds a .38 in a shoulder
holster.

MEEKS
I got a license for that.

Bud removes Meeks' wallet, checks the ID.

MEEKS
Cut me some slack. I used to be a
cop.
BUD
Turner Meeks? Never heard of you.

LYNN
(exiting store)
We just call him Buzz.

Bud raps on Susan's window with his badge. It comes
down.

BUD
You okay?

Beside her, a man leans over. Pierce Patchett, seen
before at the freeway unveiling, is a man used to being
chauffeured. Like FDR, he smokes his cigarette in a
holder.

PATCHETT
She's fine.

BUD
(menacing)
I'm not asking you.

Patchett has no idea he's walking on thin ice. As he
stares impatiently at Bud, Bud looks back to Susan.

BUD
Somebody hit you?

LYNN
It's not what you think.

Bud looks to see Lynn Bracken moving to the driver's
door.

BUD
What is it then?

SUSAN
You got the wrong idea, Mister.
I'm fine.

Susan laughs. Patchett eases back into the shadows.

LYNN
(getting in the car)
But it's nice to know you care.

Bud considers Meeks' gun license, then hands him back the
.38 and wallet. Lifting his booze, Bud watches Meeks get
back in the car.

Stensland steps up as the cabbie starts to pull away.

STENSLAND
What's going on?

For an odd moment, Stensland and Meeks lock eyes.
BUD
You know him?

STENSLAND
Seen him around. He used to be a
cop.

CUT TO:


CLOSE ON DUDLEY SMITH

Fifty, handsome in his police captain's uniform. Singing
"Silver Bells" in a beautiful low tenor. Tough,
respected, Dudley goes to bed as a cop every night of his
life. He's a department power to be reckoned with.


INT. PRECINCT HOUSE - MUSTER ROOM - NIGHT

An L.A. Herald Express REPORTER and photographer listen
along with the gathered patrolmen as Dudley finishes to
applause. Dudley joins the press.

REPORTER
Captain Smith, I --

DUDLEY
Drop the formalities; it's
Christmas Eve. Call me Dudley.

REPORTER
Dudley, I came up with a title for
the story. I'm calling it "Silent
Night with the L.A.P.D."

DUDLEY
Excellent. How's this?
(dramatic pause)
The sanctity of the night is an
invitation to the darker criminal
element. Our vigilance will not
be diminished.

As the Reporter scribbles down the quote...

DUDLEY
That's Smith with an S.

They laugh. Dudley points the way out.

DUDLEY
This way, gentlemen.

Dudley's the last one out the door. As he goes, he turns
back to give the men a wink. He's no sooner out the door
when the first case of Johnny Walker is brought in.
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Bud White sees a woman with two black eyes in a Cadillac outside a liquor store and goes to investigate, leading to a tense confrontation with the woman's bodyguard and the car's owner, Pierce Patchett.
Strengths "Tense confrontation between characters with different backgrounds and motivations."
Weaknesses "The scene does not move the overarching plot forward significantly."
Critique As a screenwriting expert, I would say that this scene sets up a lot of tension and intrigue, particularly with the introduction of Susan and Patchett in the Cadillac. There is also some great dialogue between Lynn and Bud, showcasing their chemistry and dynamic. However, the scene could benefit from some more visual descriptions and action, as it is mostly dialogue-driven. Overall, though, it sets up some interesting plot threads and leaves the audience wanting to know more.
Suggestions Here are a few suggestions to improve this scene:

1. Increase the tension: The scene feels a bit slow and lacks tension. Consider adding some conflict between Lynn and Bud, or having Meeks react more violently to Bud searching him.

2. Streamline the dialogue: Some of the dialogue feels a bit on-the-nose, such as Lynn saying "It's practically stamped on your forehead" to indicate that Bud is a cop. Consider cutting some of the unnecessary lines to make the dialogue more concise and impactful.

3. Show, don't tell: There's a lot of exposition in this scene, such as the descriptions of Lynn and Dudley's character. Instead of telling the audience these things, consider finding ways to show their personalities through their actions and dialogue.

4. Add more visual interest: While there are some interesting visuals in the scene, such as the tinsel-trimmed photos and the black-eyed Susan, adding more interesting camera angles or movements could help make the scene more engaging.

Overall, the scene could benefit from more tension and streamlined dialogue, as well as finding ways to show character traits instead of relying on exposition.



Scene 5 -  A Police Officer's Moral Compass
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 9
  • Plot: 7
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 10
INT. PRECINCT HOUSE - DISPATCH DESK - NIGHT
Ed Exley gets another report from the Young Officer.

YOUNG OFFICER
Two police officers were assaulted
in a bar. Brown and Helenowski.

He hands the report to Exley. It's now that Dudley comes
through on his press junket.

DUDLEY
This is Sergeant Ed Exley. Son of
the legendary Preston Exley. He's
the watch commander tonight and a
damn fine job.

As the photographer snaps Exley's picture...

DUDLEY
I was fortunate enough to be
partnered with his father when I
was a rookie. It makes a man feel
old. That's a fact.
(a beat)
Feel free to get a feel for the
place.

As the Reporter and photographer wander off, Dudley turns
to Exley a bit more serious.

DUDLEY
A word with you, lad.


INT. DUDLEY SMITH'S OFFICE - DAY

Dudley pours two drinks, hands one to Exley.

DUDLEY
To the memory of your father.

They drink. Exley looks to a photo on the wall.

Himself as a ten-year-old standing between Dudley and his
father Preston, both in police uniform.

DUDLEY
The day he got the Medal of Valor.
A simpler time.

Remembering, Exley invokes his father's favorite toast.

EXLEY
To the solving of crimes that
require absolute justice.

Exley raises his glass, but Dudley just watches him.

DUDLEY
That was his favorite toast.
(a beat)
I saw the test results on the
lieutenant's exam. You placed
first out of twenty-three.

EXLEY
The youngest applicant by eight
years.

DUDLEY
You'll make lieutenant inside a
year. Patrol division?

EXLEY
I was thinking Detective Bureau.

We can see Dudley doesn't approve.

DUDLEY
You don't have the eye for human
weakness to be a good detective.
Or the stomach. You're a
political animal, Edmund.

The criticism stings, but Dudley's a straight shooter.

EXLEY
You're wrong.

DUDLEY
Am I...? Would you be willing to
plant corroborative evidence on a
suspect you knew was guilty in
order to ensure an indictment?

EXLEY
Dudley, we've been over this.

DUDLEY
Answer yes or no.

EXLEY
I... No.

DUDLEY
Would you be willing to rig crime
scene evidence to support a
prosecuting attorney's working
hypothesis...? Yes or no, Edmund.

EXLEY
No.

DUDLEY
Would you be willing to beat
confessions out of suspects you
knew to be guilty?

EXLEY
No.

DUDLEY
Would you be willing to shoot
hardened criminals in the back to
offset the chance --

EXLEY
No.

DUDLEY
Then for God's sake, don't be a
detective. Stick to assignments
where you won't have to make those
choices. Patrol, Internal
Affairs, but not the Bureau.

EXLEY
I know you mean well, Dudley, but
I don't need to do it the way you
did. Or my father.

DUDLEY
At least get rid of the glasses.
I can't think of one Bureau man
who wears them.


INT. PRECINCT HOUSE - MUSTER ROOM - NIGHT

A large impromptu bar has been set-up. The party is in
full swing, the floor packed with nightwatch blues. A
PHONOGRAPH SPEWS DIRTY CHRISTMAS CAROLS.

Stensland pours eggnog and Old Crow into the water cooler
as Bud elbows his way in with another case.

STENSLAND
Hey, partner. Grab a cup.

BUD
I got to write my report first.

PASSING COP #1
Hear about Helenowski and Brown?
They got into a helluva scrap with
six taco benders at some bar.
Helenowski lost six pints of
blood. Brown's in a coma.

PASSING COP #2
We ought to teach Paco and his
friends a lesson.

More cops vocie their agreement. Bottles are passed.
Only Bud doesn't seem as caught-up as the rest.
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Dudley Smith questions Ed Exley's suitability for becoming a detective by asking him a series of tough moral questions.
Strengths
  • Great use of dialogue and character development to explore themes of morality and integrity within the police force
  • Good pacing and tone
  • Conveys the tension between ambition and doing the right thing
Weaknesses
  • Limited action or plot development
  • Setting of party with loud music and commotion may distract from dialogue
Critique Overall, this scene is well written with good dialogue that provides insight into the characters. However, there are a few areas that could be improved.

Firstly, the scene transitions are abrupt and could benefit from some more descriptive text to make them flow better. For example, when the scene changes from the precinct house to Dudley Smith's office, there is no indication of how much time has passed or why they are meeting.

Secondly, the introduction of Dudley Smith feels forced and comes across as a bit of an info dump. It would be more effective if we had a chance to see him in action before being told how great he is. Alternatively, if he is going to be introduced this way, it would be better to have the information revealed more gradually throughout the scene.

Finally, the scene ends abruptly without any real resolution or closure. It feels like it could benefit from a stronger concluding line or action to tie it up neatly.

Overall, the scene has potential but could benefit from some revisions to strengthen it.
Suggestions Here are some suggestions to improve the scene:

1. Give the characters more distinct voices: Both Dudley and Exley are speaking in a very similar tone, which can make it hard for the audience to differentiate between them. Introduce some variance in their speech patterns to make them sound more unique.

2. Make the conflict more explicit: Right now, the conflict between Dudley and Exley is all subtextual. Consider having them argue more explicitly about their differing perspectives on policing, power, and morality.

3. Cut down on the exposition: The scene contains quite a bit of exposition, particularly in Dudley's speech where he explains his perspective on policing. Consider condensing this information into a shorter, more poignant speech.

4. Add more sensory details: The scene could benefit from more sensory details to help the audience better visualize the environment and atmosphere. For instance, instead of simply stating that "a large impromptu bar has been set up," describe the smell of alcohol, the sound of laughter, and the feel of the crowded room.

5. Develop Bud's character more: Bud seems to be an important character, but there isn't much development happening with him in this scene. Consider adding a subplot or moment of character development for him during the party.



Scene 6 -  Police Brutality
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 10
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
INT. PRECINCT HOUSE - NARCO PEN - NIGHT

Jack Vincennes at his desk. Holding the Fleur-de-Lis
card, Jack dials the number. A corkboard on the wall is
posted with press clippings. "Dope Crusader Wounded in
Shootout." "Actor Mitchum Seized in Marijuana Shack
Raid." That one includes a shot of Jack ushering Mitchum
into jail.

WOMAN (V.O.)
(over phone, like
silk)
Whatever you desire.

JACK
Hi... I'd like to get a delivery
to Beverly Hills.

WOMAN (V.O.)
(over phone)
I don't think I know you.

CLICK. The line goes dead. Jack redials.

WOMAN (V.O.)
(over phone)
Whatever you desire.

JACK
Look, a friend of mine gave me
this number. I just --

The line goes dead again. Jack dials a new number.

OPERATOR (V.O.)
(filtered)
Pacific Coast Bell.

JACK
This is Sgt. Vincennes.
Requesting a name and address on a
phone number. Hollywood zero-one-
two-three-nine.

OPERATOR (V.O.)
(filtered)
Please hold the line... No such
number is assigned.

JACK
I just called it.

OPERATOR (V.O.)
No, Sergeant. I checked twice.

JACK
(realizes, hangs up)
A bootleg...


INT. MUSTER ROOM - NIGHT

Exley surveys the carousing rowdies. Raising his
voice...

EXLEY
All right, men. You've had your
fun. Time to break it up.
The party continues undiminished. From across the room,
Stensland eyes Exley with disdain.

STENSLAND
Fucking Exley. Guy's got a pole
so far up his ass, every time he
farts the flag waves.


WATCH COMMANDER'S OFFICE

The command not really his, Exley reads a report, ignores
the party, though his window looks into the thick of it.

Suddenly a ripple goes through the room. The men begin
to push out through a rear door. Exley stands, stops a
COP.

EXLEY
What's going on?

COP
They got the spics who japped
Helenowski and Brown. Helenowski
lost an eye and Brown's got brain
damage.

EXLEY
I have the report right here.
They're home with bruises and
muscle pulls -- Oh shit...

Exley starts out after them.


INT. CELL BLOCK - NIGHT

Stensland in the lead. Pulling out a blackjack, he
enters Cell #4, begins wailing on one of the Mexicans --
Dinardo.

STENSLAND
For ours, Pancho. And you're
getting off easy.

Cheered on by drunks in the tank and his fellow officers,
Stensland goes wild. He's joined by Lentz, Crumley and
Tristano. Shaking his head, Jack Vincennes moves away.


INT. SQUAD ROOM - NIGHT

Bud types his report with one finger. Jack looks in.

JACK
White, you better get a lease on
Stens before he kills someone.


INT. CELL BLOCK - NIGHT
Followed by Jack, Bud forces his way through the crowd.
The men who see it's him quickly clear a path.

Swigging from a pint of gin, Stensland works skinny
GARCIA. Head saps. The kid drops to his knees drooling
blood.

Bud grabs Stensland, hauls him off of Garcia who looks
up.

GARCIA
Fuck you, pendejo.

BUD
Yeah yeah...

GARCIA
And fuck your mother too.

Bud sees red. Letting go of Stensland, Bud White picks
up Garcia by the neck. There are cheers, "Attaboys" and
"Holy Fucks" as Bud bangs Garcia's head on the ceiling.

EXLEY
(arriving)
Stop, Officer! That's an order!

Cops block Exley's way. As Bud looks over, Garcia kicks
him in the balls. A dangling shot. Bud keels into the
bars, Garcia stumbles out of the cell, smack into Jack.

Jack looks down aghast at blood on his cashmere blazer,
then puts Garcia down with a left-right.

Exley pulls a pad of paper and pen form his pocket.

EXLEY
You're going in my report! All of
you!

Exley has just started taking names when Bud grabs him by
the scruff of the neck and hauls him off balance into...


HALL

As Exley struggles, a cop opens the door to the store
room. Bud slings Exley inside, then slams the door
tight. Exley is locked in. As Bud moves off, we hear
POUNDING.

EXLEY (V.O.)
Let me out! That's an order!


CELL BLOCK

The Herald Reporter and photographer enter unchaperoned
and unnoticed. Stensland swings like a madman. That's
when a flashbulb goes off. Freezing everyone in black
and white.

DISSOLVE TO:
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Stensland and a few other police officers brutally beat up Mexican prisoners while the rest of the squad is partying in the muster room. Exley arrives at the scene and tries to stop them, but is locked up in a store room by Bud White. A reporter and photographer sneak in and take pictures of the incident.
Strengths
  • tense and impactful
  • shocking portrayal of police brutality
  • well-written character interactions
Weaknesses
  • potentially triggering for some viewers
Critique This scene is well-written and effective in establishing the characters of Jack Vincennes and Bud White while also highlighting the corruption and violence within the police department. The use of the Fleur-de-Lis card as a plot device is clever and helps move the story forward. The dialogue is realistic and the action is well-described. However, the scene could benefit from clearer scene headings to indicate changes in location and time, as well as more attention to describing the visual elements of the scene. Overall, this scene sets up intriguing conflicts that will interest viewers and keep them engaged in the story.
Suggestions Overall, the scene could benefit from clearer motivations and character actions.

In the first part of the scene, Jack's phone call could be made more suspenseful by having him actively try to convince the woman on the other end to help him, perhaps even offer her something in return. This would make the sudden hang-up more impactful and increase tension in the scene.

In the mustering room, Exley's attempt to break up the rowdy party could be more dynamic. He could try different tactics before finally raising his voice to get the crowd to quiet down, showing his persistence and dedication to his duty.

When Stensland enters Cell #4, it isn't clear why he immediately starts attacking Dinardo. Adding a brief exchange or backstory to show tension between the two characters would make the scene more emotionally impactful. Additionally, having more officers actively try to stop Stensland's violence would add to the drama and highlight the corruption and brutality of the LAPD.

Finally, Exley's being locked in the store room seems abrupt and unclear. If he were actively arguing with the other officers, trying to stop them from hurting the prisoners, it would make more sense for Bud to physically remove him from the situation. The scene could end with Exley furiously pounding on the door, adding another layer of tension and drama to the moment.



Scene 7 -  Bud White's Dismissal and Exley's Rise
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 8
INT. CHIEF'S OFFICE - DAY

The CHIEF sits behind a desk in a four-star uniform.
Dudley Smith sits to his left, D.A. Ellis Loew to his
right. Seen earlier at the Mickey Cohen press
conference, Loew is the only civilian. Bud White stands
across from them. There to be judged.

CHIEF
Officer White, you've refused to
cooperate with Internal Affairs.
But you should know this is bigger
than a police board. Indictments
may be handed down. Quite
frankly, we need police witnesses
to offset the damage done to the
Department's image. Will you
testify?

Bud glances to a gray tinted mirror, then to the Chief.

BUD
No, sir. I won't.

The Chief sighs, looks to Loew.

CHIEF
District Attorney Loew.

Loew steps to Bud, holds up a newspaper with the cell
block photo. The headline: "BLOODY CHRISTMAS."

LOEW
Bloody Christmas. The press love
to label. You and Officer
Stensland brought the liquor into
the precinct. Stensland was
already drunk. Do you see how
appearing as a voluntary witness
against him could offset the
damage you've done to yourself?

BUD
I won't do it.
(staring at mirror)
I won't testify against my partner
or anyone else.

LOEW
This man is a disgrace.

CHIEF
Your badge and gun, Officer.

Bud sets them on The Chief's desk.
CHIEF
This is the new L.A.P.D., White.
You're suspended from duty and
dismissed.

Turning, White shoots the mirror a stiff middle finger as
he makes his way out. Dudley Smith hides a smile.


OTHER SIDE OF GLASS

Exley watches, involuntarily leans back as Bud passes on
the other side of the glass.


THE CHIEF'S OFFICE

Dudley, Loew and The Chief wait as Exley enters.

CHIEF
Ed, your observations have been
astute. What's your assessment of
this situation?

EXLEY
The public demands justice, sir.
This was a full-fledged riot of
policemen. Shift the guilt to men
whose pensions are secured. Force
them to retire. But someone has
to swing. Indict, try and convict
Stensland and Bud White. Secure
them jail time. Feed them to the
sharks, sir. Protect yourself;
protect the department.

Dudley gives Exley a look. He's angry with him.

DUDLEY
Stensland's a disgrace. Straight
D fitness reports from every C.O.
he ever served under. But White
is a valuable officer.

EXLEY
White's a mindless thug.

DUDLEY
No, Edmund. He's a man who can
answer yes to those questions I
ask you from time to time.

The Chief interrupts with his own concern.

CHIEF
I want to know who we give the
public in contrast? The
department needs role models.
Clean-cut, forthright men the
public can admire.
EXLEY
I'll testify, sir. I'm not afraid
to do what's right.

CHIEF
And I'll promote you. You'll be a
lieutenant immediately.

Exley seizes the moment, going over Dudley's head.

EXLEY
Detective lieutenant.

The Chief and Dudley exchange a look. Neither approves.

CHIEF
Ed, you're 30. Your father didn't
make lieutenant until he was 33.

EXLEY
I know that, sir. I also know
that when he made lieutenant, it
was as a detective.

LOEW
(interrupting)
Before we start polishing our
laurels, it would look better if
we had a corroborative witness.

DUDLEY
That'll be hard to come by. The
men hate a turncoat.

EXLEY
Jack Vincennes. He's the
technical advisor on 'Badge of
Honor,' sir. He lives for it.
That's the way to get him.

CHIEF
All right, Ed.
(into desk
intercom)
Call Sergeant Vincennes.

As Exley starts out, Dudley pulls him aside, speaks low.

DUDLEY
You'll reap the benefits, but are
you truly prepared to be despised
within the department?

EXLEY
Yes, Dudley. I am.

DUDLEY
So be it.


JACK VINCENNES
Looking sharp, he strides down the hall, enters the...


CHIEF'S OFFICE

Round two. Centred on Jack. Exley is gone.

DUDLEY
Sergeant, we'll get right to it.
Nine civilian witnesses have
identified you as hitting Ezekiel
Garcia.

LOEW
But my office has a stellar
witness who will tell the grand
jury that you hit back only after
being hit.

JACK
What do I have to do?

LOEW
Testify against the three officers
who have already earned their
pensions. Our key witness will
testify roundly, but you can plead
ignorance to questions directed at
the other men.

CHIEF
I'll guarantee you a slap on the
wrist. A brief suspension
followed by a temporary transfer
from Narcotics to Ad Vice.
(a beat)
When you transfer out of Vice,
you'll be back on the show.

JACK
The show, sir?

CHIEF
Badge of Honor, Vincennes. We
need to tone down your profile for
a bit.

The Chief just got Jack where he lives.

DUDLEY
John, I doubt you've ever drawn a
stupid breath. Don't start now.

JACK
Okay. I'll do it.

Smiles all around. Loew smiles at the two-way. A move
not lost on Jack who wonders who might be on the other
side.
CHIEF
Dismissed, Vincennes.

Jack leaves. The Chief steps to the mirror, looks
through.

CHIEF
So be it. Detective Lieutenant.


OTHER SIDE OF GLASS

Exley clenches his fist in victory. The Chief continues.

CHIEF
Ace them at the grand jury
tomorrow, son. Wear the smart-
looking suit and ace them. And,
Ed? Lose the glasses.
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary The chief questions Bud White about his cooperation with internal affairs and asks him to testify against his partner and fellow officers. White refuses, leading to his dismissal. Exley advises the chief to secure a conviction against those involved to appease the public. Dudley questions Exley's morality and his willingness to be despised in the department, but Exley remains steadfast in his resolve. Meanwhile, Jack Vincennes agrees to testify against other officers involved in a police brutality case in exchange for a temporary transfer to Ad Vice. The scene ends with the chief granting Exley's request of promotion to detective lieutenant and urges him to wear a suit and lose his glasses for the grand jury tomorrow.
Strengths "The scene establishes an ongoing power dynamic between the chief, Dudley, and Exley. It further deepens the internal conflicts within the LAPD and the consequences of police brutality."
Weaknesses "The scene lacks action and relies heavily on dialogue."
Critique Overall, the scene is well-written and engaging. The dialogue feels realistic and captures the tension of the situation. However, there are a few areas where it could be improved:

1. Lack of description: There is very little description of the characters or the setting, which makes it difficult to visualize the scene. Adding more visual cues would help the reader better engage with the story.

2. Lack of backstory: It is not clear from this scene what has led up to this moment, which can be confusing for the reader. Providing some context and backstory to the situation would help the audience better understand the stakes and motivations of the characters.

3. Dialogue could be more nuanced: While the dialogue is well-written, it can be a bit on-the-nose at times. Adding more subtext and nuance to the conversations would make them feel more realistic and dynamic.

Overall, the scene is strong, but would benefit from a bit more fleshing out and attention to detail.
Suggestions One suggestion to improve this scene would be to add more tension and conflict between the characters to increase the stakes and make the scene more engaging for the audience. Right now, the scene seems to be moving along smoothly without much resistance from the characters. Perhaps showing more pushback from Bud White and his loyalty to his partner could heighten the tension, as well as showing more reluctance from Exley to testify and betray his fellow officers. Additionally, adding some physical movement or blocking could make the scene more visually interesting, rather than just having the characters sit and talk the entire time. Finally, tightening up the dialogue and sharpening the language could also make the scene more impactful.



Scene 8 -  Exley and Jack Discuss Testifying
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
INT. ROOM 114 (GRAND JURY WITNESS ROOM) - DAY

Glasses off, Exley waits, looks up as Jack enters.

JACK
You're the key witness?

EXLEY
That's right.

JACK
I should've known. What's the
Chief throwing you?

EXLEY
Throwing me?

JACK
Yeah, Exley. What's the payoff?

EXLEY
You're the payoff expert. I'm
just doing my duty.

JACK
You're playing an angle, college
boy. You're getting something out
of this so you don't have to
hobnob with the fucking rank and
file cops who'll hate your guts
for snitching. If they're making
you a detective, watch out. Some
Bureau guys are gonna burn in this
and you're gonna have to work with
friends of theirs.

EXLEY
What about you?

JACK
I'm snitching three old timers
who'll be fishing in Oregon next
week. Next to you I'm clean. And
smart.

At that, a CLERK steps in from the hallway.

CLERK
Edmund J. Exley to chambers.

As Exley's about to go...

JACK
Just remember, Bud White'll fuck
you for this if it takes the rest
of his life. They already
suspended him. Just pray he cops
a deal and stays on the Department
because that is one civilian you
do not want on your case.
Genres: ["crime","drama","mystery"]

Summary Exley and Jack discuss their roles as key witnesses in an upcoming trial, with Exley being promoted to detective lieutenant as a result. Jack warns Exley about the potential consequences of testifying and the possibility of retaliation from Bud White.
Strengths "Tense dialogue between Exley and Jack, with significant warnings about the potential consequences of testifying. The reader sees the potential danger of being a key witness in an ongoing investigation."
Weaknesses "The scene is largely expository, providing necessary information to advance the plot."
Critique This scene does a good job of establishing the dynamic between Jack and Exley, as well as the stakes of the situation they're in. The dialogue is sharp and builds tension, with Jack trying to suss out Exley's motives for testifying against their colleagues. However, there are a few areas for improvement.

Firstly, the scene lacks visual detail. We don't know anything about the setting or the characters beyond what's in the dialogue. Adding in some descriptive details or actions could help make the scene more immersive.

Secondly, the scene doesn't have a clear goal or conflict. While the tension between Jack and Exley is palpable, we don't know what either character is trying to achieve. What does Jack hope to gain by warning Exley about Bud White? What does Exley want to get out of testifying? Giving each character clear objectives can make the scene more dynamic.

Lastly, the scene could benefit from more subtext. Right now, the dialogue lays everything out on the table - we know exactly what each character is thinking and feeling. Adding in some nuance or hidden agendas can make the scene more interesting.

Overall, this scene has potential, but could be improved with some more visual detail, clearer goals and conflicts, and more subtext.
Suggestions 1. Add more description to the setting and actions of the characters in the scene. This will help to engage the audience visually and emotionally.

2. Show more conflict between Jack and Exley. The conversation is important, but it needs more tension to make it interesting for the audience.

3. Add more depth to the characters. Give them more backstory and motivation, so the audience can connect and empathize with them.

4. Add more subtext to the conversation between Jack and Exley. The audience should read between the lines and understand the unsaid emotions and thoughts of the characters.

5. Make the scene more visually interesting. Use close-ups and different camera angles to create a dynamic and engaging scene.

6. Use dialogue that is more specific to the characters and their personalities. This will help to differentiate them and make them more memorable for the audience.



Scene 9 -  Offer and Loyalty
  • Overall: 8.5
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
INT. TWILIGHT LOUNGE - NIGHT

An old black guy in a frayed, threadbare tux plays piano.
Bud, nursing a highball at the bar, steps over to a
REDHEAD with too much make-up on too many miles.

BUD
That an old fashioned you're
drinking?
(as she nods)
My name's Bud.

REDHEAD
Nobody was born with the name Bud.

BUD
They stick you with a name like
Wendell, you look for an alias.

REDHEAD
What do you do, Bud?

BUD
I'm sorta between jobs. Look,
what do you say we, uh...

A hand on Bud's shoulder. He turns to see Dudley Smith.

DUDLEY
Lad, may I have a word with you?

BUD
This business, Captain?

DUDLEY
Say goodnight to your friend and
join me by those back tables.

Dudley starts off. Bud turns back to Redhead, but she's
already talking to a sailor.


BOOTH

Dudley sits at a table. A newspaper is opened, a little
mound underneath. Bud joins Dudley.

BUD
Does that paper say we've been
indicted? Does it say Exley's a
hero for squealing me and
Stensland off?

DUDLEY
He made his play amd he got what
he wanted. They're making him a
detective.

BUD
Captain, what do you want?

DUDLEY
Call me Dudley.

BUD
Dudley, what do you want?

DUDLEY
Lad, I admire your refusal to
testify and your loyalty to your
partner. I admire you as a
policeman, particularly your
adherence to violence as a
necessary adjutant to the job.
And I am most impressed with your
punishment of wife beaters. Do
you hate them, Wendell?

BUD
(looks away)
Yeah, I hate them.

DUDLEY
And for good reason judging from
what I know of your background.

Bud looks back over. Dudley's getting too personal.

BUD
What's going to happen to
Stensland? He'll give himself
cirrhosis over this. He's one
year from his pension.

DUDLEY
It would've happened years ago if
you hadn't carried him. Why the
loyalty, Wendell?

BUD
He helped me out once. That's all.

DUDLEY
Your partner's through.
Department scapegoat on the
Chief's orders. He's been billed,
he'll be indicted and he'll swing.

BUD
Him and me both. Fucking Exley.

DUDLEY
Don't underestimate his skills.
As a politician he exceeds even
myself. But the department needs
smart men like Exley and... direct
men like yourself

BUD
What do you want?

DUDLEY
Wendell, I want you to come to
work for me.

BUD
Doing what? Mowing your fucking
lawn?

Smith yanks the newspaper revealing Bud's badge & .38
Special. Bud can't believe his eyes.

DUDLEY
They're yours. Take them.

BUD
I knew you had juice, but...
There's no goddamn bill on me?

DUDLEY
Four of the defendants recanted
their testimony.

BUD
How?

Dudley dismisses the question with a wave of his hand.

DUDLEY
I need you for an assignment the
Chief's given me the go-ahead on.
A duty few men are fit for, but
you were born for. You'll be
working out of Homicide.

BUD
(excited)
Homicide? A detective?

CHIEF
Your talents lie elsewhere,
Wendell. It's a muscle job and
shooting job. You'll do what I
say and not ask questions. Do you
follow my drift?

BUD
(disappointed)
In Technicolor.

DUDLEY
Will you work for me?

BUD
Of course... But how?

DUDLEY
How what, Wendell?

BUD
How'd you get them to retract?

Dudley lays brass knuckles on the table. They're
chipped, caked with blood.

DISSOLVE TO:


L.A. MONTAGE

Over the pop song "STRANGER IN PARADISE."

A) EXT. GRAUMAN'S CHINESE - NIGHT

Frank Sinatra at the premiere of From Here to
Eternity.

B) INT. KLUB ZAMBOANGA - NIGHT

Charlie "Bird" Parker makes magic before an
appreciative, mostly black crowd.

C) TORCH SONG TAVERN (RIVERSIDE) - NIGHT

Nate Janklow exits with his latest flame. A mob
lieutenant, Nate was last seen with Mickey Cohen
outside the Federal Courthouse in the opening
montage. A CAR SCREECHES up. TWO GUNS aim and Nate
and his date do down in a proverbial HAIL OF LEAD.

D) EXT. FREEWAY - DAY

A groundbreaking. The Mayor scrapes at the ground
with a gold shovel. Pierce Patchett is among the
distinguished guests.

END OF MONTAGE
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Dudley recruits Bud for a secretive mission after praising his police work and loyalty to his partner. Bud's newfound hope for a detective job is crushed when Dudley assigns him to a muscle and shooting job in Homicide instead. A violent montage depicting various events around Los Angeles follows.
Strengths "Strong and believable dialogue, good use of imagery and tension building."
Weaknesses "The pace at which the characters speak may be confusing to some."
Critique Overall, this scene is well-written. The dialogue is sharp and the characters are well-defined. The scene is effectively tense as Dudley approaches Bud, revealing that he has been indicted and his loyalty to his partner may not be enough to save him.

However, there are a few areas that could be improved. One issue is that there is not much action or movement in the scene. It mostly consists of two characters sitting at a table talking. This could be enlivened by adding some physical action or movement, such as Bud getting up from the table and pacing or reacting more visibly to Dudley's revelations.

Also, some of the dialogue feels a bit on the nose, particularly Dudley's exposition about Exley's political skills and the department's need for "smart men." This could be made more subtle by having the characters show these traits instead of having them explicitly stated.

Overall, though, this is a strong scene with well-defined characters and effective tension.
Suggestions Here are some suggestions to improve this scene:

1. Develop the characters more: The scene could benefit from more details about the characters. For example, what motivates Bud's loyalty to Stensland? What is Dudley's background and how has he risen to a position of power?

2. Create more tension: While the scene does have some tension, it could be heightened by adding more conflict or suspense. For example, Bud could question Dudley's motives and push back more against his offer.

3. Use more sensory details: The scene could be more immersive if it included more sensory details. For example, what does the Twilight Lounge smell like? What does the piano music sound like?

4. Cut down on exposition: There is a lot of information given in this scene, particularly about the past and the characters' backgrounds. This exposition could be cut down to make the scene more focused and engaging.

5. Show, don't tell: Some of the dialogue is on-the-nose and could be replaced with actions or reactions that show what the characters are thinking or feeling. For example, instead of Dudley saying "I admire you," he could show it through his body language or actions.



Scene 10 -  Police and Criminals
  • Overall: 7.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 6
EXT. HOLLYWOOD HIGH SCHOOL - DAY

The marquee gushes: "Today Sgt. Joe Reno: Badge of
Honor Star Brett Chase."


INT. HOLLYWOOD HIGH SCHOOL - AUDITORIUM - DAY

A nerdy 14-YEAR-OLD asks Brett Chase:

14-YEAR-OLD
Why'd you become a policeman?

CHASE
I'm not a policeman. I just play
one on television. But I think I
can answer for them. To help
people. That's why I do the show.

Chase looks over and winks at Jack who waits in the
wings.

CHASE
To protect and serve. It's not
just a motto.

As the kids applaud, Chase joins Jack who gives him a
quick drag of a cigarette. A nervous PA joins them.
Chase points out a fetching girl in the second row.

CHASE
That one. In the sweater.
(to Jack)
They also serve who only stand and
wait.

Chase and Jack watch the PA ask "Sweater" a question
while pointing to Chase. Maybe sixteen, she nods "yes"
eagerly.

CHASE
Jack, I'll see you Monday on set.

JACK
I won't be there. They're toning
down my profile.


PRINTING PRESS

The latest issue of Hush-Hush flies through. On the
cover: "Gail Russell Caught In Love Nest. Nymph or
No?"


INT. CITY JAIL - DAY

Bud White flips through today's booking slips, finds one
that's interesting. Reading to himself...

BUD
Domestic. Assault and battery.

Containment Squad strong-arms, BREUNING and CARLISLE
pause as they pass.

CARLISLE
Ready to go, Bud?

BUD
I'll be there in five minutes.


CITY JAIL - HALLWAY

Bud walks to a door covered in sheet metal. He opens it
to reveal a holding tank with a burly, jumpsuited
PRISONER.

BUD
I hear you like to hit women.

PRISONER
My wife. She's dropping charges
so it's none of your business.

Bud enters, closes the door behind him. A beat, we hear
the sounds of FISTS ON FLESH. It's Bud's business now.


INT. BEVERLY HILLS MANSION - STUDY - NIGHT

Deuce Perkins (the Mickey Cohen narcotics lieutenant seen
earlier) stands at the bookshelf. He pulls down books to
reveal a shoe box. He sets it on his desk, pulls back
the cover to reveal several bags of white powder.
Heroin.

A BRANCH SNAPS outside. Perkins opens a drawer, fishes a
revolver. Turning off the light, he heads to the window.
His finger parts the curtains. At that instant, he
staggers, falls as GUNFIRE rips into him.

The heroin just sits there on the desk.


EXT. McNEIL PENITENTIARY - DAY

Grim-faced guards scan the yard from machine-gunned
towers.


INT. McNEIL PENITENTIARY - VISITOR BOOTH - DAY

Mickey Cohen sits across from visitor Johnny Stompanato.
Cohen is going off the handle.

COHEN
What do you mean Deuce Perkins got
clipped last night?!

STOMPANATO
They shot him in his library.

COHEN
I don't want a floor plan; I want
to know who! Who's taking the
ticket for this, Johnny?

STOMPANATO
Nobody. At least not yet.

COHEN
And what about the merchandise
Deuce was holding for me?

STOMPANATO
Gone. Not a trace.

COHEN
Some ferstunkener is moving in and
we don't know who?! Maybe we
should ask Hedda Hopper!

As "STRANGER IN PARADISE" ENDS, so does the MONTAGE.
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary The scene covers various events around Los Angeles including an interview with a TV actor, a police officer taking matters into his own hands, a drug bust gone wrong, and a conversation between Mickey Cohen and Johnny Stompanato in prison.
Strengths "The scene has a clear focus on plot developments and raises the stakes of the story. It also shows the consequences of previous actions and sets up further conflict."
Weaknesses "The dialogue could have been stronger and more impactful."
Critique Overall, the scene lacks coherence and focus. It seems to jump around from different characters and locations without giving the audience a clear sense of what's happening or why it's important.

The dialogue feels forced and stiff, especially the exchange between Brett Chase and the 14-year-old. It's unclear why he would be winking at someone offstage during a school presentation, and the line "They also serve who only stand and wait" feels tacked on and out of place.

Similarly, the scene with Bud White in the jail, while potentially interesting, doesn't have any real build-up or resolution. It simply cuts from him flipping through booking slips to confronting a prisoner, with no sense of tension or stakes.

The scene with Deuce Perkins and the heroin is more engaging, but it's over too quickly and it's not clear how it fits into the larger story.

Overall, the scene needs more focus and purpose. Each element should serve a clear narrative function and help move the story forward in some way. The dialogue should flow more naturally and not feel like it's just filling space. And the action should build to a climax or resolution that leaves the audience eager to see what happens next.
Suggestions One suggestion would be to add more tension and conflict to the scene at Hollywood High School. Perhaps have a student ask Chase a more challenging or controversial question, forcing him to defend his character and the show. This would create more depth to the character and add to the overall conflict of the story. Additionally, the scene with Bud White in the City Jail could be expanded upon to show more of his character, such as his motivations and beliefs. Overall, adding more depth to the characters and conflict would strengthen the scene and make it more engaging for the audience.



Scene 11 -  Ad Vice and Narco
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
INT. BRIEFING ROOM - AD VICE - DAY

Addressing the squad, a no-nonsense VICE CAPTAIN picks up
a stack of magazines.

VICE CAPTAIN
Picture-book smut, gentlemen.
There's been a bunch of it found
at collateral crime scenes lately.
Mostly narcotics and prostitution
collars.

As the Vice Capt. hands it out for the men to examine,
new member Jack Vincennes arrives late.

VICE CAPTAIN
Look who's back from suspension.
We're honored, Sergeant Jack.

The men laugh. Jack sits, flips a magazine. Men and
women. Men and men. Girls and girls. Girls and horses.

JACK
Gee. The Great Jerk-Off Book
Caper of 1953.

VICE CAPTAIN
Vincennes, is there someplace
you'd rather be?

JACK
Yeah, Cap. Back in Narcotics.

VICE CAPTAIN
Oh? Anyplace else?

JACK
Working whores with squad two.
VICE CAPTAIN
Maybe you should have thought of
that before you made Bloody
Christmas page one.

Vice Capt. retrieves the magazines, hands them to Jack.

VICE CAPTAIN
They're yours. Make a major case,
Sergeant. It's the only way
you're getting out of here.

Exaggerated "oohs" and "aahs" from the men.

VICE CAPTAIN
Dismissed, gentlemen.

As they go, Jack sees the books are stamped: "Fleur-de-Lis
Whatever you desire." Jack takes the matching
business card from his wallet, the one he found on
Christmas Eve.

VICE CAPTAIN
Roll, Vincennes. No sidetracks.
This is Ad Vice, not Narco.


INT. HOLLYWOOD STATION - NARCO PEN - DAY

Jack Vincennes is at his desk. Holding the Fleur-de-Lis
card, magazines spread before him, Jack dials the number.


INT. HUSH-HUSH MAGAZINE OFFICE - DAY

Sid Hudgeons sits behind his desk, answers the phone.

HUDGEONS
Hush-Hush. Off the record and on
the Q.T.

JACK (V.O.)
Sid, it's Vincennes.

HUDGEONS
Jackie, are you back on Narco? I
need copy.

INTERCUT WITH Jack at his desk:

JACK
No. But I've got something going
with Ad Vice.

HUDGEONS
Something good?

JACK
Don't know. I'm chasing picture
books. Fuck shots, but the posers
don't look like junkies. It's
well done stuff. I thought you
might have heard something.

Hudgeons reaches into a stack of papers, pulls out a
magazine like the one Jack has.

HUDGEONS
Not a word.

JACK
What about Fleur-de-Lis? Their
slogan's 'Whatever you desire.'

HUDGEONS
No. No, I've heard bupkis. Jack,
I'll talk to you later. Call me
when you get something I can use.
Smut's from hunger. For sad sacks
who can't get their ashes hauled

The LINE CLICKS off. Jack hesitates a moment before
cradling the receiver. Something's not right here.


EXT. HOLYWOOD STATION - PARKING LOT - TWILIGHT

As Exley pulls in, his two-way drones:

DISPATCHER (V.O.)
Park Rangers report three Negro
youths discharging shotguns into
the air in Griffith Park.
Suspects are driving a late model
purple Mercury Coupe.

As the report ends, Exley switches off the two-way and
gets out of his car.


INT. HOLLYWOOD STATION - SQUAD ROOM - NIGHT

Accompanied by Bud, Dick Stensland crams the contents of
his desk into a box. Well-wishing cops pat him on the
back, offer words of encouragement, but Stensland looks
like he's going to cry.

It's very bad timing as Exley enters, comes face-to-face
with them. This is hatred.

Acting on impulse, Bud goes after Exley. It's a mauling.
Four vicious body shots. A potentially lethal head shot
sails wide as Exley falls to the ground.

As four men move to hold Bud back, Exley looks up at him.

EXLEY
(gasping)
You're just a thug, White. That's
all you'll ever be.

Dudley steps into the fray. He helps Exley to his feet.
DUDLEY
You should stay away from a man
when his blood is up.

EXLEY
His blood's always up.

Four cops are genuinely having trouble holding Bud back.
Dudley watches with something bordering on admiration.

DUDLEY
Then maybe you should stay away
from him all the time.
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Exley is promoted to detective lieutenant while Jack navigates Ad Vice. Bud is assigned to a muscle job.
Strengths "Strong character dynamics and conflict"
Weaknesses "Lack of clarity in some scenes"
Critique Overall, the scene is well-written in terms of dialogue and character development. The tension between Jack and the Vice Captain is clear, and their respective personalities are well-developed through their interactions. The dialogue is realistic and moves the plot forward.

However, there are a few areas that could be improved. The scene could benefit from more visual descriptions to create a stronger sense of setting. Additionally, the action at the end of the scene, with Bud attacking Exley, feels a bit sudden and could benefit from more build-up or foreshadowing earlier in the scene. Finally, while the dialogue is good, it may come across as a bit too on-the-nose in terms of exposition - there could be more subtle ways to convey information about the plot or characters.
Suggestions 1. Develop the characters: The Vice Captain, Jack Vincennes, and the magazine distributor Sid Hudgeons need more character development. This will help the audience understand their motivations and behavior.

2. Give more context: While the scene is focused on the discovery of picture book smut and the tension between characters, it might be useful to provide more context about the crimes that are occurring in the city. This will make the discovery of the magazines more impactful.

3. Make the dialogue more authentic: Some of the dialogue feels forced and unnatural, particularly in the conversation between Jack and Sid. It would be great to make the dialogue more authentic and realistic, to make the characters feel more like real people.

4. Build more tension: There’s already some tension between the characters, but it could be heightened. Instead of the characters being angry with each other, have them searching for a common goal or trying to solve the same mystery. This will build more tension and make the scene more exciting.

5. Create a stronger sense of setting: The scenes change quickly, and it’s hard to get a sense of the setting. Providing more visual clues and descriptions about the locations will help the audience feel more immersed in the story.



Scene 12 -  Nite Owl Massacre
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 9
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 8
EXT. HOLLYWOOD STATION - PARKING LOT - NIGHT

Accompanied by Bud, Stensland reaches his car, loads his
box of stuff into the trunk. Bud is moody, pensive.

STENSLAND
Don't look so down in the mouth,
Bud. You nailed him good.

BUD
Yeah, sure... I got a couple of
hours before I have to be at the
Victory. Want to grab a beer?

STENSLAND
Rain check me, partner. I got
something big going on tonight.

BUD
What? That new mystery girl
you've been seeing?

STENSLAND
No. I'll tell you sometime. Not
now. Don't want to jinx it. But
it could take the edge off that
jail time I got coming.

BUD
What are you talking about?

STENSLAND
It's confidential, Bud. Like that
magazines Vincennes scams for.
Hush-Hush.
(smiles)
I'll see you tomorrow. And hey,
if it works out, you'll get a
piece of it.

Stensland gets in the car, drives off. Bud is left
alone.


INT. HOLLYWOOD STATION - SQUAD ROOM - NIGHT
Exley sits alone in a sea of desks. The SQUAWK BOX
DRONES. Exley squints at the clock on the wall, can't
make it out. He takes his glasses from the inside of his
jacket. 2:00 A.M. Finally, something to do. He walks
to the wall calendar, tears off Feb. 28 to reveal Mar. 1.

As Exley sits, the call SQUAWK BOX booms to life.

VOICE
Squad call! Nite Owl Coffee Shop
One-eight-one-two-four Cherokee!
Multiple homicides! Multiple
homicides! Code three!


EXT. HOLLYWOOD AND CHEROKEE - NIGHT

Patrol cars. Blues setting up a crime scene blockade.
Exley pulls up, DOUSES his SIREN. PATROLMAN #1 runs
over.

PATROLMAN #1
Loads of people down. Men.
Women. I stopped for coffee --

Exley pushes him aside, heads for the door. It's wide
open.


INT. NITE OWL - NIGHT

Exley takes mental snapshots. Ten stools front a
counter. The side wall mural-papered: winking owls
perched on street signs. On the right a string of
tables. Three in disarray. Food spilled, dishes broken.
A high-heel pump by an upended chair.

Heel drag marks across the linoleum floor heading back
toward the kitchen. Exley follows. Past an open, empty
cash register. Outside -- SIRENS.


SERVICE RUNWAY

Crisscrossed drag marks connect, lead to a walk-in...


FOOD LOCKER

Blood-soaked bodies on the floor. Five, maybe six in a
tangle. Dozens of shotgun shells float in the pools of
blood. As Exley struggles to maintain his composure...

ROOKIE (O.S.)
Holy shit fuck...

Exley looks at a green-faced ROOKIE in the locker
doorway.

ROOKIE
S-s-sir, there's a captain outside
wants to see you.

EXLEY
Don't get sick! Not in here!

Exley shoves the Rookie, puking, out the door.


EXT. NITE OWL - NIGHT

Patrolmen hold back a swarm of reporters and rubber-
neckers. HORNS BLAST. Motorcycles run interference for
meat wagons cut off by the crown. As Ed emerges,
reporters surge, shout questions. Exley hurries past,
finds Dudley in command and barking orders.

EXLEY
Sir, I took the call. It's my
case.

DUDLEY
Edmund, you don't want it and you
can't have it.

EXLEY
Yes, I do, sir.

DUDLEY
It's mine. I'll make you my
second in command.

Exley spots a photographer moving in. He looks properly
serious as the flash bulb pops.


INT. NIGHT OWL - NIGHT

Forensics Chief RAY PINKER walks Exley and Dudley
through.

PINKER
We got a total of forty-five spent
12-gauge Remington shotgun shells.
Three men with five-shot-capacity
pumps. All of them reloading
twice.

EXLEY
Hold on... We need to canvass.
See if a purple Mercury was seen
around here tonight.

DUDLEY
Why?

EXLEY
We got a call earlier on three
Negro youths. Firing shotguns in
Griffith Park from a late-model
purple Mercury Coupe.
DUDLEY
(to his adjutant)
Get on it.

A FORENSICS COP approaches Pinker.

FORENSICS COP
We got an I.D. on one of the
victims, sir... I think it's Dick
Stensland.

Exley and Dudley react, look at each other.


EXT. VICTORY MOTEL - DAWN

Set in a no-man's-land of bulldozed homes. A sign
proudly announces the impending arrival of the freeway.
The motel is surrounded by a barbed-wire fence.
Abandoned but for a pair of LAPD cars and a light burning
in room 6.

An unmarked pulls up and Exley and Dudley step out. They
start forward, but a SCREAM inside 6 stops Exley short.

DUDLEY
With Mickey Cohen in prison, Los
Angeles is organized crime free.
The Chief wants it to stay that
way, Edmund. The means are not
for the weak-hearted.
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Exley and Dudley lead an investigation of a mass shooting at a diner, which may have links to a case they were already working on. The scene showcases the brutality of the crime and the pressure put on law enforcement to maintain the city's status as 'organized crime free.'
Strengths "Intense and thrilling investigation of a brutal crime"
Weaknesses "The scene feels slightly rushed in some moments"
Critique Overall, this scene is well-written and serves its purpose in setting up the inciting incident for the rest of the film. The dialogue between Stensland and Bud feels natural, and provides some interesting foreshadowing with Stensland's secretive plans.

The transition to Exley alone in the squad room is also well done, using visual cues to establish the time and his boredom before the call comes in.

The description of the crime scene at the Nite Owl is vivid and disturbing, effectively conveying the horror of the situation. The dialogue between Exley and Dudley is also strong, with Dudley's warning to Exley about the means they will use to maintain Los Angeles' organized crime-free status adding tension and substance to their relationship.

One minor critique could be that there is some exposition provided in dialogue, such as when the question of the purple Mercury is raised by Exley, but it's not too overt and still feels natural. Overall, well done.
Suggestions 1. Establish the context: It would be helpful to know why Stensland and Bud were at the station and what their job is. Adding a brief description of their job and the case they were working on would provide a better understanding of their situation.

2. Develop character motivations: Bud's moody and pensive behavior should be explained. What is he feeling and why? Does he have any personal connection to the case they just worked on? Additionally, Stensland's mysterious comment about something "big" going on needs to be more clear. What is at stake for him?

3. Add more tension: The scene needs more tension to add interest for the audience. Adding in some conflict between Stensland and Bud or giving the audience a sense of impending danger or suspense would help.

4. Provide more visual detail: The description of the Nite Owl crime scene needs more visual detail to create a vivid mental image for the audience. Providing specific details about the surroundings and the state of the crime scene would help bring the scene to life.

5. Clarify dialogue: Some of the dialogue is a bit vague and hard to follow. Clarifying the meaning behind Stensland's comments and adding more clarity to the conversation between Exley and Dudley would improve the scene's quality.



Scene 13 -  The Interrogation and Morgue Visit
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 7
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 7
INT. VICTORY MOTEL - ROOM 6 - DAWN

Bare. A table and chair bolted to the floor. A tough
FLAT-NOSED GANGSTER is cuffed to the hot seat. On the
table are a .45 and a fat roll of $100 bills.

Breuning and Carlisle watch as Bud White delivers a
couple of short, stiff body shots. Flatnose is not used
to being on the receiving end. All the same, we get the
idea Bud's a bit reluctant.

Bud's back is to Dudley and Exley who enter behind him.

DUDLEY
Come, Wendell, you can do better
than that.

Bud turns, sees Exley and Dudley. A beat. As Bud looms
over Flatnose, the gangster babbles. Snitch-frenzied.

FLATNOSE
I know things. I hear things.
Like with the Mick inside, things
are on this weird slowdown.
(MORE)

FLATNOSE (CONT'D)
These shooter teams, bang bang
bang, they're 86-ing Mickey
Cohen's men.

DUDLEY
We know all that, lad. Tell us,
who do these shooters work for?

FLATNOSE
I don't know. No one knows.
Maybe they're mavericks. You want
a prostie roust? Huh? Some narco
action?
(breaking down)
What do you want?!

DUDLEY
We want you to go home.
(to Breuning)
Uncuff him, Michael.

Dudley turns to Exley.

DUDLEY
Mr. Sifakis is a known loan shark
from San Francisco. He arrived
this afternoon at Union Station.
Looking for business opportunities
in our fair city. An organized
crime associate in need of re-
education in the ways of polite
society.

Uncuffed, Flatnose rubs his wrists. Wary. As Breuning
steps back, Flatnose snatches the .45 off the table.

FLATNOSE
Motherfuckers!

Exley dives for cover, but the other four cops just stand
there. Dudley looks down on the floor at Exley.

DUDLEY
It's part of the play, Edmund. A
sincerity test.

Flatnose looks at the gun a beat, then squeezes the
TRIGGER. CLICK CLICK. No bullets.

DUDLEY
(to Breuning)
Sit him back down.

CLICK, CLICK. They shove Flatnose back in the hot seat.
Dudley offers a hand to Exley, helps him to his feet.

DUDLEY
Wendell, you need to accompany
Detective Lieutenant Exley on
official police business. I'll
finish up here.
INT. EXLEY'S PLYMOUTH - DAY

They drive in silence. No love lost here. Finally.

BUD
Where are we going?

EXLEY
It's a surprise. You like
surprises, don't you, White?


EXT. COUNTY MORGUE - DAY

Exley pulls up. Bud looks to him. Really curious now.


INT. COUNTY MORGUE - HALLWAY - DAY

Exley and Bud walk. An orderly wheels a covered corpse
toward them from the other end of the hall. Bud's
spooked. The orderly wheels the body in to the
examination room.

As Bud and Exley pass, the CORONER pulls back the sheet,
is surprised at the sight of a woman who we don't quite
see.

CORONER
Call me crazy, but for a second I
thought it was Rita Hayworth.


MORGUE MEAT LOCKER

Exley and Bud walk past a wall of drawers to where a
coroner's assistant waits.

EXLEY
We need you to I.D. the body.
There's no next of kin and you
knew him best. So tell me...

The assistant pulls open drawer 12. A naked man.

A tag on his toe and half his face blown off.

EXLEY
Is that Dick Stensland?

Stunned, Bud stares at what's left of his old partner.

BUD
Yeah, that's Stens.

EXLEY
Hell of a way to avoid a prison
sentence.
Bud's torn between wanting to smash Exley and finding out
why Stensland is dead. He squeezes out the words.

BUD
What happened?

EXLEY
Someone held up a coffee shop,
panicked and killed six people.

Then, from the hall...

WOMAN (O.S.)
Not my baby! Not my little girl!
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Bud, Dudley, and Exley interrogate an organized crime associate who provides information about recent shootings in the city. After the interrogation, Exley takes Bud to the morgue to identify a body, which turns out to be Bud's former partner, Dick Stensland.
Strengths "Tense atmosphere, emotional impact of Bud seeing Stensland's body, good dialogue."
Weaknesses "Some plot elements feel disjointed."
Critique Overall, the scene is well-written and effectively creates tension. The dialogue is natural and believable, and the action flows smoothly. However, there are a few areas that could be improved upon.

Firstly, some of the descriptions are a bit vague. For example, it's not entirely clear what Flatnose looks like, other than having a flat nose. Adding more detail could help to bring the character to life and make the scene more immersive.

Secondly, the scene could benefit from some more physical action. While there is tension and conflict, there's not a lot of movement or excitement on the page. Adding some more physicality, such as Bud White throwing punches or Exley diving for cover, could help to make the scene more cinematic and engaging.

Overall, though, the scene effectively moves the plot forward and sets up the next chapter of the story. With a few small tweaks, it could be even stronger.
Suggestions The scene could benefit from better description of the setting and character actions. Instead of just saying the room is "bare," more details could be added to create a grungier, seedier atmosphere. Additionally, the actions of the characters could be more specific and detailed, such as describing the way Bud delivers his body shots or the way Flatnose struggles against his restraints.

There could also be more suspense built up leading to the gun reveal. Perhaps Flatnose could be more agitated or nervous, and the camera could focus on the gun on the table before the big reveal.

Finally, the dialogue could be tightened up to create more tension and intrigue. Instead of Flatnose babbling about various things, his dialogue could focus solely on the shooters and their mysterious employer, and the other characters could press him harder for information. Additionally, the dialogue between Exley and Bud could be made more tense and confrontational to reflect their animosity towards each other.



Scene 14 -  Identification and briefing
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
INT. COUNTY MORGUE - EXAMINATION ROOM - DAY

HILDA LEFFERTS, 50, enters with the coroner to ID the
body of her daughter, Susan.

There's stray buckshot in the upper chest and shoulders,
but a sheet hides the real damage. It's the girl Bud saw
outside Hollywood Liquor. Without the black eyes, she
does look like Rita hayworth.

As Bud and Exley appear, Mrs. Lefferts looks confused.

CORONER
Is this your daughter, Mrs.
Lefferts?

MRS. LEFFERTS
I -- I don't know.

EXLEY
We know this is difficult. Just
take your time and look again.

Exley doesn't realize, but Bud recognizes the deceased.

MRS. LEFFERTS
It seems like my Susan, but...

EXLEY
When was the last time you saw
her, Mrs. Lefferts?

MRS. LEFFERTS
At Christmas. We had fought. I
didn't like her boyfriend. I --
she has a birthmark on her hip.

The Coroner lifts the sheet. Mrs. Lefferts gasps.

MRS. LEFFERTS
It's her. My baby. Dear God...

As Mrs. Lefferts swoons, Bud and Exley both hold her up.
INT. LAPD HEADQUARTERS - BRIEFING ROOM - DAY

The room buzzes, jammed to the rafters with every
detective standing ready. The Chief waits as Dudley
Smith takes the mike, holds up an L.A. Times headline.

DUDLEY
'Nite Owl Massacre.' Hyperbole
aside, this is a heinous crime
that requires a swift resolution.
The public will demand it and this
department will provide it. Six
victims. One of them, one of our
own -- Dick Stensland.
(as the cops react)
As it happens, he was a Nite Owl
regular. In the wrong place at
the wrong time.

Bud White listens, not too sure. Stensland said he had
something big going on...

DUDLEY
Robbery looks like the motive. We
have rubber glove prints on the
register and preliminary forensics
strongly lean toward a trio of
gunmen. We do have one hot lead,
so listen well. Three Negro
youths were seen last night
discharging shotguns in the air at
Griffith Park.
A park ranger I.D.ed them as
driving a 1948 to 1950 Mercury
Coupe, purple in color. An hour
ago, a canvassing crew found a
news vendor who saw a purple Merc
Coupe parked across from the Nite
Owl around 3:00 A.M.

The room goes loud, a big rumbling. Dudley holds up a
list.

DUDLEY
The D.M.V. worked all night to get
us a registration list on '48 to
'50 purple Mercs. There are 142
registered to Negroes in L.A.
County. Fifty two-man teams will
shake three names apiece. Hot
suspects you'll bring here.
Interrogation rooms have been set
up. They'll be run by Lieutenant
Edmund Exley. Hollywood Squad.

Catcalls. Boos. The Chief steps to the mike.

CHIEF
Enough on that. Gentlemen, just
go out and get them. Use all
necessary force. The people of
Los Angeles demand it.

The men exchange knowing looks. The real message: kill
them clean. Exley doesn't approve. As the men hurry
out...

EXLEY
He might as well have put a bounty
on them.


INT. SQUAD ROOM - DAY

Detectives pairing up and moving out. Scanning his three
name list, Bud joins his PARTNER for the day.

BUD
Can you take them? I got
I got something I gotta do.

PARTNER
Christ, I don't know. What if one
of these names...

BUD
What I gotta do is for Stensland.
My partner.

The guy looks at him a beat, nods. As Bud heads off...


EXLEY

watches everyone go. Wishes he could be part of the
action. He spots Jack talking to his REDNECK partner for
for the day.


JACK AND REDNECK

Redneck chews tobacco, has a Texas drawl.

REDNECK
Where to, Trash?

JACK
If we go by the list, we have
about zero chance of making the
collar. But I know a guy who
knows what's going on south of
Jefferson. I'm betting he could
put us at 50/50.

REDNECK
I don't know...

As Redneck thinks, Exley steps up. He's overheard.

EXLEY
I'll take those odds.
(to Redneck)
Take off. We got it from here.

Jack stares. Redneck shrugs, spits tobacco juice in a
cup.

REDNECK
Between the two of you guys, you
should bring along a photographer.


INT. HOLLYWOOD LIQUOR - DAY

Last time we saw the Owner was Christmas Eve. He looks
up from a customer as Bud strides in, badge out front.

BUD
I need an address on a customer of
yours. Her name was Lynn.

OWNER
That's all I have to go on?

BUD
Yeah. And I think you already
know who I mean, so cough it up.

OWNER
Lynn Bracken. There's a billing
address and a delivery address.

BUD
Give me both. Billing first.
Genres: ["crime","drama","mystery"]

Summary Exley and Bud take Hilda Lefferts to identify the body of her daughter, Susan, who was found dead after the 'Nite Owl Massacre'. Meanwhile, the LAPD is briefed on the situation and receives a lead about the perpetrators. Bud also asks for information on a woman named Lynn.
Strengths "The scene effectively sets up the stakes and motivations for the LAPD's investigation into the Nite Owl Massacre. The moment when Hilda Lefferts identifies her daughter's body is a powerful emotional moment that is well-portrayed."
Weaknesses "Some of the dialogue feels a bit clunky and on-the-nose, such as when the Chief tells his men to 'use all necessary force'. There also isn't a lot of action in this scene."
Critique Overall, the scene is well-structured and moves the story forward. The tension is palpable as Mrs. Lefferts identifies her daughter's body and as the police department gears up to find the killers. The character dynamics are also established, such as Bud's dedication to finding the truth for his partner and Exley's frustration at not being given permission to be more involved.

However, there are a few areas that could be improved. The dialogue feels a bit on-the-nose at times, such as when Exley says "He might as well have put a bounty on them." Additionally, some of the character descriptions are unnecessary, like Redneck's Texas drawl. These details could be shown through the actor's performance instead of telling the audience outright.

Overall, the scene effectively sets up the next part of the story, but could benefit from some refining in the dialogue and character descriptions.
Suggestions Some suggestions to improve the scene:

1. Develop the character of Hilda Lefferts: She enters the scene to ID the body of her daughter, but we don't know anything else about her. Perhaps adding a few lines of dialogue to show her grief and anguish would make the scene more emotional.

2. Connect the opening scene at the morgue to the later scene at the LAPD headquarters: The scene at the morgue feels disconnected from the rest of the script, so finding a way to tie it into the larger story would make it more impactful.

3. Use visual descriptions to heighten the tension: The scene at the morgue is emotionally charged, but there are no visual cues to enhance the sense of dread. Adding details about the lighting, the sound of the characters' footsteps, and the general atmosphere of the room could help create a more ominous mood.

4. Give Exley a stronger reaction to the Chief's orders: Exley comments that the Chief's orders amount to a "bounty" on the suspects, but the character could have a stronger reaction to the implicit call for violence. Making Exley more conflicted about the mission he's been given would add depth to the character.

5. Show, don't tell: When Bud tells the Owner he needs the address for Lynn Bracken, we don't see the Owner's reaction or his reluctance to give it up. Adding a few lines of dialogue or a gesture from the Owner would show the tension between the two characters and make the scene more interesting.



Scene 15 -  Patchett's Revelation
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 10
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
EXT. 1184 GRETNA GREEN, BRENTWOOD (PATCHETT'S) - DAY

A big, pink Spanish mansion with lots of tile. Also last
seen outside Hollywood Liquor on Christmas Eve, Pierce
Patchett is in the front yard, chipping golf balls over a
koi pond. They land in a tight grouping. As he tees up:

BUD (O.S.)
You must slay 'em at the country
club.

Bud's halfway up the walk. Patchett sees the cuffs
hooked to his belt. Patchett is cool as can be.

BUD
Are you Pierce Patchett?

PATCHETT
I am. Are you soliciting for
police charities? The last time,
you people called at my office.

BUD
I'm a homicide detective. Where
were you last night?

PATCHETT
I was here, hosting a party. Who
was killed and why do you think I
can help?

BUD
Richard Stensland.

PATCHETT
I don't know him. Mr...

BUD
Officer White. How about Susan
Lefferts? You know her?

PATCHETT
(sighs, concedes)
You know I do or you wouldn't be
here. How did you find me?

BUD
We met outside Hollywood Liquors
on Christmas Eve. This is where
Lynn Bracken's booze bills go.

PATCHETT
Of course...

BUD
Sue Lefferts died at the Nite Owl.
I'm investigating.

Patchett studies Bud a beat, weighing his options.
Patchett's burly BODYGUARD starts over from the house.

BODYGUARD
Everything alright, Mr. Patchett?

PATCHETT
(waves him off)
Fine, Philip. Thank you.

BUD
Where's the other guy? Buzz.

PATCHETT
He no longer works for me.
(a beat)
Find Susan's killer, Mr. White.
I'll give you a handsome reward.
Whatever you desire.

If only Jack had been around to hear that.

BUD
Thanks, but no thanks.

PATCHETT
Against your code?

BUD
I don't have one. Lefferts looked
beat-up Christmas Eve, but didn't
act it. How come?

PATCHETT
Do you care about criminal matters
peripheral to Susan's murder?

BUD
No.

PATCHETT
Then you wouldn't feel obligated
to report them?

BUD
That's right.

PATCHETT
Then listen closely, because I'll
only say this once and if it gets
repeated, I'll deny it. I run
call girls. Lynn Bracken is one
of them and so was Susan Lefferts.
I treat my girls very well. I
have grown daughters, myself, and
I don't like the thought of women
being hurt. I sense you share
this feeling.

BUD
(ignores comment)
Why were Lefferts' eyes black?

PATCHETT
I think she'd been hit in the face
with a tennis racket. She is --
was -- a big doubles fan.

BUD
You wanna go downtown and discuss
this officially?

PATCHETT
Wait. Our deal still holds?

Bud nods, his patience running thin.

PATCHETT
I needed a Rita Hayworth to fill
out my little studio.

BUD
What little studio?

PATCHETT
There's Gardner, Hepburn, Grable,
Turner. Lynn Bracken is my
Veronica Lake. I use girls who
look like movie stars. Sometimes
I employ a plastic surgeon.
BUD
That's why her mother couldn't
I.D. her... Jesus fucking Christ.

PATCHETT
No, Mr. White. Pierce Morehouse
Patchett. Now, I sense you're on
your best behavior, but that's all
I'll give you. If you persist,
I'll meet you with my attorney.
Now, would you like Miss Bracken's
address? I doubt she knows
anything, but --

BUD
I got her address.

PATCHETT
Of course... this is personal with
you, isn't it, Mr. White?

Bud turns, heads down the walk. Patchett hits his golf
ball. It lands just past the koi pond, with the rest.
Ice.


EXT. 1736 NOTTINGHAM, LOS FELIZ (LYNN BRACKEN'S) - DAY

A modern-looking triplex. A projector's flicker strobes
against the closed curtains. We hear a PHONE RING.
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Bud interrogates Pierce Patchett about a murder and links to a call girl operation. Patchett reveals that Lynn Bracken and Susan Lefferts were two of his girls, and that he uses plastic surgery to make them look like movie stars.
Strengths "Strong dialogue, high stakes, tension"
Weaknesses "Some exposition-heavy dialogue"
Critique Overall, this scene is well-written with clear dialogue and action. The scene sets up the central conflict of the story, with Pierce Patchett being questioned by Detective Bud about Susan Lefferts' murder. The tension between them is palpable, and the reveal of Patchett's call girl business adds a layer of intrigue to the plot.

One potential area for improvement could be in the description of the setting. While the Spanish mansion and modern triplex are visually interesting, the description could benefit from more sensory details to create a stronger atmosphere for the scene. For example, describing the smell of the koi pond or the sounds of the projector in Lynn Bracken's home could enhance the reader's immersion in the story.

Additionally, while the dialogue is well-written, there could be more subtext and nuance in the characters' interactions. For example, there may be underlying emotions or motivations that could be conveyed through nonverbal cues or actions. Including these details could create a richer, more complex dynamic between the characters.

Overall, this is a strong scene that effectively sets up the conflict and intrigue in the story. With some minor tweaks to the description and character interactions, it could be even more impactful.
Suggestions Overall, the scene is well-written and the dialogue between Patchett and Bud is interesting. However, there are a few suggestions for improvement:

1. Add more description to the scene. Right now, there is very little description of the setting and characters. Adding more details about the mansion and the characters' physical appearances would help bring the scene to life and make it more engaging.

2. Consider breaking up the dialogue with some action. Right now, the scene consists almost entirely of Patchett and Bud talking back and forth. Adding some visual actions or reactions (such as Patchett hitting golf balls or Bud reacting to something he says) would help break up the dialogue and make the scene more dynamic.

3. Think about pacing. The scene is fairly long and the dialogue can be dense at times. Consider tightening up some of the exchanges or cutting out extraneous lines to keep the scene moving and the audience engaged.

4. Make sure the scene advances the plot. While the dialogue is interesting, it's important to make sure the scene is moving the story forward and providing new information to the audience. Consider how this scene fits into the larger context of the story and make sure it's serving a purpose.



Scene 16 -  Investigative Work Continues
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
INT. 1736 NOTTINGHAM (LYNN BRACKEN'S) - DAY

The film is This Gun For Hire with Alan Ladd and Veronica
Lake. It's projected on a wall in front of which stands
Lynn Bracken and an OLDER GENTLEMAN, in his underwear.
Lynn's long, blonde hair hangs down over one eye. She
looks more like Veronica Lake than Veronica Lake. The
film flashes over them as they kiss.

The PHONE RINGS. Lynn ignores it as long as she can
before breaking away to go answer it.

LYNN
Hello?

OLDER GENTLEMAN
(Alan Ladd)
Is it the cops?

She waves him off. As he practices pointing his finger
like Ladd points a gun, Lynn reacts to the news on the
phone.


EXT. 9781 SOUTH DUQUESNE - DAY

A South Central plywood and tar-paper dive. A BLACK
BOXER pounds a heavy bag/speed bag combo bolted to the
porch. Wiry, a welterweight, he doesn't see Jack and
Exley till they're almost on top of him.

JACK
Leonard Bidwell?

The Boxer leans on the bag to catch his breath. Looking
them over, he finally nods.

JACK
How's the left these days?

BOXER
What's it to you?

JACK
I saw you fight Kid Gavilan. I
like your style.

BOXER
What do you want, Mr. Policeman?

JACK
You got a brother up in Folsom. I
know because I put him there.

BOXER
Till 19-fucking-70.

JACK
How'd you like to make it 1960? I
know the judge and Sergeant Exley
here is friends with hte D.A.

Exley nods, this is true. The Boxer's still listening.

JACK
We're looking for three colored
guys who like to pop off shotguns.
One of 'em owns a purple Merc
coupe.

BOXER
You wanna get me a fuckin' snitch
jacket?

JACK
You wanna buy your brother ten
years...? You don't have to say
anything. Just look at this list
and point. Here.

Jack holds the DMV list out to the Boxer, who waves it
off.

BOXER
He's bad, so I'll just tell you.
Sugar Ray Coates. Drives a '49
coupe, a beautiful ride. Don't
know about shotguns, but he gets
his thrills killing dogs. He is
righteous trash.
Jack and Exley scan the list. Jack's finger stabs down
on, "Coates, Raymond, 9611 South Central, Room 414."

JACK
That's five minutes from here.


EXT. 1736 NOTTINGHAM (LYNN BRACKEN'S) - DAY

Lynn does her best to usher the slightly disheveled
Older Gentleman out the door.

OLDER GENTLEMAN
I don't understand, doll, we just
got started.

LYNN
I'm sorry, but I'll make it up
to you. I promise.

OLDER GENTLEMAN
Gosh, kitten, I don't know...

As he begins to mash up against her...

BUD (O.S.)
Hit the road, gramps.

Bud's standing at the bottom of the stairs. The Older
Gentleman strikes a pose. He still thinks he's Alan
Ladd.

OLDER GENTLEMAN
Alright. This time I'll go, but
next time --

BUD
(flips badge)
L.A.P.D., shitbird. Get the fuck
out of here or I'll call your wife
to come get you.

Sputtering, the Older Gentleman exchanges a look with
Lynn then hurries away, giving Bud a wide berth.

LYNN
I've been expecting you. Pierce
called. Told me what happened
to Sue.
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Exley and Dudley lead an investigation of recent shootings and interrogate suspects. Bud identifies his partner's body and receives information about a call girl operation. They confront Lynn Bracken, a woman linked to the suspects, about a recent death related to the case.
Strengths
  • Tension is built through questioning of suspects
  • Lynn Bracken is introduced, adding complexity to the investigation
  • The emotional impact of the recent deaths is palpable
Weaknesses
  • Some scenes are a bit slow-paced
  • Some characters could benefit from more development
Critique Overall, this scene seems well-written and engaging. However, there are some areas for improvement.

One issue is that the scene seems disjointed and disconnected from the rest of the story. It's not totally clear how this scene fits into the larger narrative and what purpose it serves.

In terms of dialogue, some of the lines feel a bit cliched or contrived. For example, the Older Gentleman's repetition of "next time" feels like a predictable line. Additionally, the way that Jack and Exley get information from the Boxer feels a bit too convenient.

Finally, the scene could benefit from more description and imagery. Right now, it feels a bit sparse on details and could benefit from more sensory description to make it feel more vivid and immersive.

Overall, this scene has potential but could use some work on its overall coherence and dialogue.
Suggestions First, it would be helpful to clarify who Lynn and the Old Gentleman are in relation to the rest of the story. Is their scene necessary for the plot, or just a character moment? If it is important, consider how it connects to the larger story and build on that connection.

In regards to the dialogue, there are a few moments that could use some improvement. For example, when the Older Gentleman asks Lynn "we just got started," it's not entirely clear what he means. This line could be rewritten to be more direct. Additionally, when Jack and Exley confront the Boxer, the dialogue could be made more tense and suspenseful to match the scene's tone.

Lastly, the stage direction could use some work. Instead of simply writing "she looks more like Veronica Lake than Veronica Lake," consider using more descriptive language to paint a clearer picture of Lynn's appearance and how it affects the scene. Overall, be deliberate in your choices and think about how each element of the scene contributes to the story as a whole.



Scene 17 -  Meeting Lynn Bracken
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 9
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 9
INT. 1736 NOTTINGHAM (LYNN BRACKEN'S) - DAY

A nice breezy feel. The perfect place to shack up.

LYNN
It's Officer White, isn't it?

Bud nods, eyeballs the place.
LYNN
Can I get you a drink?

BUD
Yeah, plain scotch.

Bud watches her move to the bar. God, she's beautiful.

LYNN
I was friendly with Sue Lefferts,
but we weren't really friends.
You know what I mean?

BUD
Are you sorry she's dead?

LYNN
Of course I am. What kind of
question is that?

She steps back with a scotch for both of them.

BUD
Have you ever heard of Dick
Stensland?

LYNN
No I haven't. Do you know why
Pierce is humoring you?

BUD
You use words like that, you
might make me mad.

LYNN
Yes. But do you know?

BUD
Yeah I know. Patchett's running
whores and judging by his address,
probably something bigger on the
side. He doesn't want any
attention.

LYNN
That's right. Our motives are
selfish, so we're cooperating.

BUD
Why was Susan Lefferts at the
Nite Owl?

LYNN
I don't know. I never heard of
the Nite Owl till today.

BUD
Did Lefferts have a boyfriend?

LYNN
Like I said we were friendly,
not friends.

BUD
How'd she meet Patchett?

LYNN
Pierce meets people. Sue came
on the bus with dreams of
Hollywood. This is how they
turned out. Thanks to Pierce,
we still get to act a little.

BUD
Tell me about Patchett.

LYNN
He's waiting for you to mention
mention.

BUD
You want some advice, Miss
Bracken?

LYNN
It's Lynn.

BUD
Miss Bracken, don't ever try to
fucking bribe me or threaten me
or I'll have you and Patchett
in shit up to your ears.

Lynn smiles again. She likes Bud. A beat.

LYNN
I remember you from Christmas
Eve. You have a thing for
helping women, don't you,
Officer White?

BUD
Maybe I'm just fucking curious.

LYNN
You say 'fuck' a lot.

BUD
You fuck for money.

LYNN
There's blood on your shirt. Is
that an integral part of your job?

BUD
Yeah.

LYNN
Do you enjoy it?

BUD
When they deserve it.
LYNN
Did they deserve it today?

BUD
I'm not sure.

LYNN
But you did it anyway.

BUD
Yeah, just like the half dozen
guys you screwed today.

LYNN
(laughs again)
Actually, it was two. You're
different, Officer White. You're
the first man in five years who
didn't tell me I look like
Veronica Lake inside of a minute.

BUD
You look better than Veronica
Lake. Now, Pierce Patchett.

LYNN
He takes a cut of our earnings
and invests it for us. He makes
us quit the life at thirty. He
doesn't let us use narcotics and
he doesn't abuse us. Can your
policeman's mentality grasp
those contradictions?

BUD
He had you cut to look like
Veronica Lake?

LYNN
No. I'm really a brunette, but
the rest is me. And that's all
the news that's fit to print.

Lynn starts toward the door. Bud watches her a moment,
then follows. She takes his glass at the door.

LYNN
It was nice meeting you, Officer.

Out the door, Bud turns back. Blurts:

BUD
Look. I want to see you again.

LYNN
Are you asking me for a date or
an appointment?

BUD
(suddenly unsure)
I don't know.

LYNN
(another smile)
If it's a date I think you'd
better tell me your first name
because I --

BUD
(feeling foolish)
Forget I asked. It was a
mistake.

Lynn watches thoughtfully after Bud as he walks away.
He opens his car door like he's going to tear ir off.
A last glance back at Lynn and as he gets in the car...
Genres: ["Crime","Mystery","Romance"]

Summary Bud interrogates Lynn Bracken, a call girl linked to the suspects. They discuss their motives for cooperating and Patchett's involvement in the operation. Bud tries to get more information but is thrown off by Lynn's charm and beauty, leading to an awkward exchange.
Strengths "Strong dialogue and character interaction, with an intriguing reveal of Patchett's operation."
Weaknesses "The scene may be too long and could benefit from more action or plot development"
Critique As a screenwriting expert, I would say that this scene does a good job of establishing the dynamic between Lynn and Bud, but could use some tightening in terms of pacing and dialogue. Some of the exchanges feel a bit forced or stilted, and the scene could benefit from some additional action or movement to break up the lengthy conversation. Additionally, while there is some tension and intrigue around the subjects of Patchett and the Nite Owl, there could be more clear stakes or plot development to keep the audience engaged. Overall, though, the scene does succeed in introducing two key characters and setting up their potential relationship.
Suggestions Firstly, the scene feels quite long and could benefit from tightening up the dialogue. The conversation between Bud and Lynn could be more concise and focused. Also, there are moments where the dialogue feels too on-the-nose, particularly when Lynn spells out her and Patchett's motivations for cooperating with the police. A more subtle approach could be more effective in delivering that information.

Additionally, there could be more attention paid to the visual aspects of the scene. For example, the description of the location could be more evocative to help create a stronger atmosphere. And there's an opportunity to use the visuals of Bud and Lynn's body language and facial expressions to help convey the tension and attraction between them.

Finally, the ending feels abrupt and could be more satisfying. Perhaps there could be a clearer indication that Bud and Lynn will see each other again or a moment that leaves the audience with a better sense of the emotions at play.



Scene 18 -  Hotel Bust
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 6
EXT. TEVERE HOTEL - DAY

An L-shaped walk-up. Jack coasts the car to the curb.
He leaps out with Exley. Exley holds up at the sight
of a late model sedan. He leans down to look in the
window at the two-way on the dash.

EXLEY
L.A.P.D.

JACK
Shit. Someone beat us here.

VOICES from the carport ahead. We see a chrome bumper,
the purple fender of a '49 Mercury coupe. A door slams.
Drawing a .45, Jack starts over with Exley, .38 in hand.


CARPORT

Toting shotguns, Dudley's boys from the Victory Motel,
Breuning and Carlisle, stand by the purple Mercury. Jack
and Exley come around the corner, lower their guns.

JACK
Hey.

Breuning wheels, pumps a round into the chamber. He very
nearly fires before he sees who it is.

CARLISLE
What the fuck are you guys doing
here?

EXLEY
Think of us as back-up.

JACK
What do you got?

As Jack moves to peer through the Merc's window.

BREUNING
Three Ithaca pumps, an empty box
of double-ought buck and cash.

Jack spots them. Three shotguns on the passenger side
floor, an empty box of shells and loose dollar bills.

JACK
So long, Vice. Badge of Honor,
here I come.

CARLISLE
Fuck you, Vincennes. It's our
collar.

Breuning actually has to restrain his partner.

EXLEY
Quiet. I'm ranking officer here.
We go as a team. End of story.


INT. CORRIDOR - TEVERE HOTEL - DAY

Breuning and Carlisle lead the way with Jack and Exley
bringing up the rear. Squinting, Exley reaches to his
pocket for something. Not there.

EXLEY
Damnit...

JACK
What?

EXLEY
Glasses.

JACK
(chuckling)
Just don't shoot me.

The door to 414. Two men on either side. Breuning rears
back. Jack rears back. They kick at the same instant.
The door flies off its hinges to reveal two young black
men, LARRY FONTAINE and TY JONES, waking from a couple
of flop mattresses.


ROOM 414

Fontaine jumps up. Entering, Carlisle aims, but Exley
grabs his arm. The BLAST rips the ceiling. Jack aims.

JACK
Freeze!

Fontaine freezes. Jones doesn't dare get up.

CARLISLE
Ace him, Jack.

EXLEY
Shut up, Carlisle!

Jack and Exley burst into a...


SECOND BEDROOM

Another black, RAY COATES, passed out on mattress, sur-
rounded by empty beer cans. Jack sticks his .38 in his
back, starts to cuff him. As the cuff ratchets down...


INT. OBSERVATION ROOM - DAY

Dudley watches intently as Ed Exley skims a report,
memorizing names and dates. Jack and other brass are
also here along with a stenographer. So's Bud. One of
these guys killed Stensland. Through tinted glass, the
three suspects in three different rooms.

EXLEY
Casitas Youth Camp... Coates
twenty-two, a boxer... Manager
saw them burning clothes.

Satisfied, Exley sets the report down.

DUDLEY
Ed, I want confessions.

EXLEY
I'll break them, sir.

As Exley steps into the #1 room, Jack joins Dudley.

JACK
You think golden boy can handle
it, Cap?

DUDLEY
I think you'll be surprised what
Edmund's capable of.
Genres: ["crime","drama","mystery"]

Summary Jack and Exley team up with Vice squad members to investigate a suspicious car. They find shotguns, cash, and a box of emptied shells. Later, they bust into a hotel room and arrest three black men. Exley shows his skill as an investigator.
Strengths "The teamwork between Jack and Exley is engaging, and the twist with the suspects being a multi-racial group is interesting."
Weaknesses "The dialogue and character development in this scene are lacking compared to other scenes in the screenplay. There is also a lack of emotional depth."
Critique Overall, the scene is well written with clear action and dialogue that moves the story forward. However, there are a few minor issues to consider:

- Location descriptions: In the very beginning, it's not clear what kind of building Tevere Hotel is. Adding a brief description can help set the scene more effectively. Additionally, there could be more description of the carport and the rooms being entered.

- Character introductions: It would be helpful to have a brief introduction to Dudley and Bud, as they are new characters that are introduced suddenly without context.

- Dialogue attribution: There is a lack of clarity in some of the dialogue attribution. For example, it's not clear who says "Ace him, Jack" - is it Carlisle or Dudley? Adding more clear attribution can help avoid confusion.

Overall, the scene is effective in creating tension and moving the story forward with clear action and dialogue. A few minor tweaks can help make it even more effective.
Suggestions One possible suggestion for improving this scene is to add more tension and conflict between Jack and Exley. As it stands, their dynamic is relatively static, with Exley taking charge and Jack following along without too much protest.

To add more conflict, you could highlight their different approaches to policing: Jack is a hardened veteran who doesn't care about department protocol, while Exley is a by-the-book up-and-comer who wants to do things the right way. This could lead to clashes in tactics or disagreements about how to handle suspects.

Another suggestion would be to add more sensory details to the scene. Right now, it's mostly dialogue with a few visual descriptions, but you could add more sounds, smells, and physical sensations to make it feel more alive. For example, describe the heat of the day, the smell of the exhaust fumes, the sound of the shotguns being pumped, etc.

Finally, you could also consider adding more nuance to the supporting characters. Right now, Breuning and Carlisle are mostly just there to provide some minor conflict, but you could give them more backstory or motivations to make them feel like real people. For example, maybe they have personal reasons for wanting to make this bust, or maybe they have a history with Jack or Exley. By fleshing out these characters, you could make the scene feel more rich and complex.



Scene 19 -  Interrogation and Revelation
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 7
INT. #1 ROOM - DAY

Exley closes the door. Ray Coates is cuffed to a chair,
dressed in baggy County denims. One eye swollen shut,
lip split, a smashed nose with one nostril split.

Exley unlocks his cuffs. drops cigarettes and amtches
on the table. As Coates rubs his wrists...

EXLEY
They call you Sugar Ray because
of Ray Robinson?
(no answer)
They say Robinson can throw a
four punch combination in one
second. Do you believe that?
Coates just stares at him.

EXLEY
You're twenty-two, aren't you, Ray?

COATES
Say what and so what.

EXLEY
Did one of the officers work you
over a little?

No bite. Coates just stares back.

EXLEY
You look like Robinson after
that last LaMotta fight. 'Course
LaMotta looked a lot worse. So
you're twenty-two, right?

COATES
Man, why do you keep asking me
that?

EXLEY
Just getting my facts straight.
Twenty-two makes it a gas chamber
bounce.
You should have pulled this caper
a couple of years ago. Get life,
do a little Youth Authority jolt,
transfer to Folsom a big man.
Orbit on some of that good prison
brew, get yourself a sissy --

COATES
I never truck with no sissies!

EXLEY
That fucking Larry. I almost
believed him.

COATES
Believed what?

EXLEY
Nothing, Ray.
(laughs)
That Larry, he's a pisser. You
did the Casitas Youth Camp with
him, didn't you?

COATES
Man, why're you talkin' about
Larry? His business is his
business.

Unseen by Coates, Exley reaches under the table, takes
hold of one of three toggle switches.

EXLEY
Sugar, Larry told me you went
sissy up at Casitas. You
couldn't do the time so you
found yourself a big white boy
to look after you. He said
they call you 'Sugar' because
you gave it out so sweet.

Exley flips the toggle.


#3 ROOM

The speaker over Larry Fontaine's head crackles to life.

COATES (V.O.)
Larry gave it at Casitas! Man,
I was the fuckin' boss jocker on
my dorm! Larry's the sissy!
Larry gave it for candy bars!


#1 ROOM

Exley flips up the second toggle.

EXLEY
Ray, you protected Ty and Larry
up in Casitas, didn't you?

COATES
You ain't woofin' I did. Stupid
down home niggers got no more
sense than a fuckin' dog.

Exley flips the switches off.

EXLEY
I heard you like to shoot dogs.

COATES
Dogs got no reason to live.

EXLEY
Oh? you feel that way about
people, too?

COATES
Man, what're you saying?

EXLEY
Ray, we got the shotguns.

COATES
I don't own no shotguns.

EXLEY
Why were you throwing clothes
in the building incinerator?

COATES
(trembling)
Say what?

EXLEY
You guys were arrested this
morning, but none of you have
last night's clothes. You were
seen burning them. Add to that
the fact that you hid the car
you were cruising around in
last night and it doesn't look
good.

COATES
I got nothin' more to say till
I see a judge.

EXLEY
Were you on hop? You were passed
out when you got arrested. Were
you hopped up, Ray?

COATES
Ty and Larry fuck with that
shit, not me.

EXLEY
Where do they get their stuff?
Come on. Give me one to feed
the D.A. Just a little one.

Coates nods. Exley flips up the toggles as he leans
in.

COATES
Roland Navarette. Lives on
Bunker Hill. He runs a hole-up
for parole absconders and sells
red devils.

Exley flips down the switches, stands.

EXLEY
I'm going to take a break.

Exley opens the door, looks back in afterthought.

EXLEY
You know, Ray, I'm talking about
the gas chamber and you haven't
even asked me what this is all
about. You got a big guilty
sign around your neck.

Exley exits.


OBSERVATION ROOM

Exley enters.
DUDLEY
Masterful, Edmund. Your father
would've been proud.
(pointing)
This one's on the verge.

Exley looks through the glass into #2. Larry Fontaine
is weeping. A piss puddle on the floor by his chair.

EXLEY
Fontaine next, but give Jones
the newspaper. I want him
primed.


#2 ROOM

Fontaine tries to control his sniffles as Exley enters.

EXLEY
Larry, Ray Coates ratted you
off. He said the Nite Owl was
your idea. You want to tell me
about it?

No answer.

EXLEY
I think it was Ray's idea. Talk
and I think I can save your life.

No answer.

EXLEY
Larry, this is a gas chamber job.
If you don't talk, you'll be dead
in six months.

No answer.

EXLEY
Son, six people are dead and
somebody has to pay. It can be
you or it can be Ray.

No answer.

EXLEY
Larry, he called you queer. He
said at Casitas you took it up
the ass. He said --

FONTAINE
I DIDN'T KILL NOBODY!

The voice is strong, full of conviction. Exley
glances at the mirror. Then...

EXLEY
Why'd you burn the clothes?
FONTAINE
(sobbing)
I just wanted to lose my cherry.
I didn't mean to hurt her.

Exley can't hide his surprise at this.

EXLEY
Hurt who? Was she a hooker?
Hurt who?

But Fontaine is gone. Head lolling, eyes squeezing
out tears.


OBSERVATION ROOM

Exley steps out of the interrogation room. Dudley
braces him.

DUDLEY
Don't get sidetracked. Stay with
the Nite Owl.

EXLEY
She may still be alive, whoever
she is.

Bud's all ears.


#3 ROOM

Reading, Jones has his feet on the table. Exley
bursts in.

JONES
This newspaper shit ain't shit.

EXLEY
Where's the girl? Did you kill her?

No answer, but Jones looks nervous.

EXLEY
You wanted Larry to lose his
cherry, but things got out of
hand. Is that right?


OBSERVATION ROOM

Everyone's attention is riveted, particularly Bud's.
They watch, listen over the speaker.

EXLEY
(over speaker)
Kick loose, Jones. I know you
made her bleed, but that doesn't
mean you killed her.
No answer, but Jones is squirming.

EXLEY
(over speaker)
If that girl's alive, you've
still got a chance on this one.

JONES
(over speaker)
I think she's alive.

EXLEY
(over speaker)
You think?

Jack turns to Dudley.

JACK
He's good. I'll give him that.

They don't notice as the chair back begins to splinter
in Bud's hands.


#3 ROOM

Exley sits across from him, tries to wrap it up.

EXLEY
Where is she now?
(no answer)
Did you leave her someplace?
(no answer)
Did you sell her out? Give her
to some of your buddies? Tell
me where the girl is!

The door blasts open. Bud slams Jones up against the
wall. As Exley stands, he bangs his knee on the table.
Pulling a .38, Bud breaks the cylinder, drops 5 shells
on the floor.

BUD
One in six. Where's the girl?

EXLEY
Officer White, put down that
weapon and --

Bud shoves the barrel into Jones' mouth, pulls the
trigger twice. CLICK, CLICK. Jones starts to slide
down the wall. Bud jerks him back up, roars.

BUD
WHERE?!

Two more clicks. Jones spills.

JONES
S-sylvester F-fitch one-o-nine
and Avalon gray corner house...
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Bud, Exley and Dudley interrogate suspects Ray Coates and Larry Fontaine in separate rooms about the Nite Owl murder case. Coates reveals the name of the drug dealer and absconder hideout he and his accomplices worked with and also confesses to his involvement. Fontaine breaks down and admits he did not intend to kill the victim and reveals her location before Bud aggressively intervenes and forces information out of Jones.
Strengths
  • Tense and suspenseful tone
  • Revelation of crucial information
  • Bud's intimidating and aggressive character
Weaknesses
  • Use of violence by Bud
Critique Overall, the scene is well-written and engaging. The dialogue is realistic and moves the story forward, with tension building as Exley interrogates Coates and Fontaine. However, there are a few areas for improvement.

First, the scene could benefit from better formatting and description. While the dialogue is strong, there is little description of the setting or characters, which can make it difficult for readers or viewers to visualize the scene. Additionally, there are moments where it is unclear who is speaking or what is happening, making it hard to follow the action.

Second, some of the dialogue feels a bit cliched or forced. For example, when Exley asks Coates if he likes shooting dogs, it feels like an out-of-place attempt to create shock value or establish a violent character trait. Similarly, Exley's comment about "getting my facts straight" before confirming Coates' age feels like a contrived way to build suspense.

Finally, the scene could use more subtext or character development. While we get a sense of the power dynamic between Exley and the two suspects, there is little insight into their personalities or motivations beyond their involvement in the crime. Adding more depth to the characters could make the scene more compelling and add emotional weight to the story.

Overall, the scene is effective at building tension and advancing the plot, but could benefit from more thorough formatting and description, stronger dialogue, and deeper character development.
Suggestions There are a few ways this scene can be improved to make it more engaging and impactful:

1. Increase tension: The scene lacks a sense of urgency. To increase tension, add a sense of time pressure. Perhaps Exley needs to get information from Coates and Fontaine before a certain deadline or before the police decide to charge them.
2. Add stakes: The scene also lacks stakes. To make it more engaging, establish what is at stake if the detectives don't get the information they need. This could be the safety of the missing girl or the potential for more murders.
3. Develop character motivation: It's unclear why Exley is so invested in getting information from Coates and Fontaine. Is he after justice or is he trying to further his career? Adding some backstory or motivation for his actions will make the scene more interesting.
4. Use visual cues to build tension: The scene could benefit from more visual cues to increase the tension, such as close-ups of Exley's face or shots of the ticking clock in the room. These visual cues can heighten the sense of urgency and make the audience more invested in the scene.

By incorporating these suggestions, the scene can become more engaging and impactful, making for a more compelling movie.



Scene 20 -  The Nite Owl Killers
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 9
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 7
EXT. AVALON BOULEVARD - EVENING

A four cordon. They coast up to a GRAY CORNER HOUSE.
Dudley Smith behind the wheel of the lead cruiser. Bud
White rides shotgun, reloading his revolver.

BUD
Give me one minute.

DUDLEY
You've got it, Wendell.


STREET

Bud is out the door and scooting down an alley. Exley
moves to follow, but Dudley cuts him off.

DUDLEY
We're going through the front.


ALLEY

Bud vaults a fence, pads up the back porch. A screen
door. Bud slips the catch with a penknife and walks
inside.


SCREEN PORCH

Bud heads for a blind-covered door. Unlocked, he
enters...


A HALLWAY

Light bouncing from side rooms. We hear the opening
spiel of "Badge of Honor" from the left. Bud wheels into
a...


BEDROOM

A NUDE GIRL spread-eagled on a mattress. Bound with
neckties. One in her mouth. Her eyes grow wide at the
sight of Bud, then flicker to the adjoining room.
Directing him. Raising the .38, Bud enters...


THE KITCHEN

Sylvester Fitch sits naked at the table wolfing Rice
Krispies and watching "Badge of Honor" on a flickering
TV. He looks up, sees the .38 before he sees Bud beyond
it. Fitch drops his spoon, raises his hands.

Bud SHOOTS him in the face. Dead, Fitch just sits there.
Bud moves behind him. Pulling a spare piece from an
ankle holster, Bud FIRES back at the door from Fitch's
line of fire, then puts the gun in Fitch's hand.

We hear the FRONT DOOR CRASH OPEN. As Fitch slides off
the chair to the floor, Bud dumps the Rice Krispies on
him.


EXT. GRAY HOUSE - NIGHT

The Girl on a stretcher. Being carried to an AMBULANCE.
Bud White walks alongside, looking like some ferocious
pet pit bull. The ATTENDANTS get her inside. One joins
her. The other closes the door, pauses to light a smoke.

Bud rips the cigarette out of his mouth, nearly taking
the guy's lips with it.

BUD
Get her to the fucking hospital.

One look at Bud, and the Attendant is running around to
the driver's side. Exley arrives, steamed.

EXLEY
A naked guy with a gun? You
expect anyone to believe that?

BUD
Get the fuck away from me.

Bud starts away, but Exley gets right in his face. Other
cops begin to take notice. The ambulance pulls out.

EXLEY
How's it going to look on your
report?

BUD
It'll look like justice. That's
what that fat fuck got. Justice.

EXLEY
You don't know what the word means,
you dumb bastard.

Bud goes after Exley, but ten hands pull them apart.
Dudley on Exley. Four cops genuinely having trouble
on Bud.

And as if things couldn't get crazier, shouts from the
cops on the street. POLICE RADIOS CRANKED UP.

DISPATCHER (V.O.)
Repeat, three suspects escaped
from the Hall of Justice jail.
The Nite Owl killers: Raymond
Coates, Tyrone Jones and Larry
Fontaine. They are considered
armed and extremely dangerous.
Descriptions are as follows...


INT. SQUAD ROOM - DAY

Electrified, "Nite Owl Killers" on everyone's lips.
Exley strides through with purpose, beelines to a filing
cabinet. Exley pulls the file he's looking for. He
scans an interrogation transcript, reads to himself the
words he's looking for:

EXLEY
'Give me one to feed the D.A....
Roland Navarette. Lives on
Bunker Hill. Runs a hole-up for
parole absconders.'


INT. HOLLYWOOD STATION - JACK'S DESK - DAY

Police rush back and forth. Exley hurries over to the
desk, but he's not there.

EXLEY
Anyone seen Jack Vincennes?

A few cops mumble they haven't. As Exley decides what
to do, Carlisle from the original arrest steps over.

CARLISLE
Is something up, Lieutenant?


EXT. 1ST & OLIVE - DAY

Exley and Carlisle pull up across the street from a
four-story Victorian with paint peeling off the clap-
boards. They jump out of the car toting SHOTGUNS.
Carlisle waits as Exley checks the mail slots:
"R. Navarette, 408. "


INT. STAIRWELL - VICTORIAN BUILDING - DAY

Exley and Carlisle take the steps two at a time.
Genres: ["crime","drama","action"]

Summary Bud White takes down a suspect in a house after a violent confrontation, while Exley discovers a lead in the Nite Owl murder case
Strengths
  • Tight pacing and tension
  • Engaging action sequences
  • Mystery and intrigue surrounding the Nite Owl case
Weaknesses
  • Shallow characterization
  • Simplistic dialogue
Critique As a screenwriting expert, I would start by saying that the scene is well-written in terms of showing the action and tension of a police raid. The description of the setting and characters is clear, and the dialogue adds to the sense of urgency and danger.

However, there are a few elements that could be improved. Firstly, some of the action is described in a way that might be difficult to translate onto screen. For example, when Bud "wheels into" the bedroom, it's not clear exactly how he moves. Also, when he shoots Fitch, the action seems a bit abrupt, as if it happens too quickly for the reader to fully process.

Additionally, there are some minor issues with consistency and believability. For example, it's not clear why Bud needs to sneak into the house through the back while the other officers go through the front. It's also unlikely that someone like Fitch would be sitting naked at his kitchen table, eating cereal and watching TV.

Overall, I would say that the scene is effective in creating tension and excitement, but could benefit from a bit more attention to detail and consistency.
Suggestions Here are some suggestions to improve the scene:

1. Show more motivation for the characters' actions: The scene lacks clear motivation for why the characters are doing what they are doing. Why are they at this house? What is their goal? Showing clear motivation can make the scene more engaging.

2. Show more tension and suspense: The scene lacks tension and suspense, which can make it feel flat. Adding more tension and suspense can create a more immersive experience for the audience.

3. Develop character relationships: The characters in the scene don't seem to have much of a relationship with each other, with the exception of Bud and the girl he rescues. Developing the relationships between the characters can add depth to the scene and make it more meaningful.

4. Create more dynamic action: The action in the scene is fairly static, with characters mostly just walking around and talking. Creating more dynamic action, such as running, jumping, or fighting, can make the scene more exciting.

5. Consider the pacing: The scene may need to be paced differently to create more intensity and engagement. Consider how long the scene takes to play out and whether there are any slow or stagnant moments that can be cut or changed to keep the action moving forward.



Scene 21 -  Shootout and Funeral
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 6
INT. 4TH FLOOR HALLWAY - VICTORIAN BUILDING - DAY

Exley squints, reaches to a pocket. No glasses. He
passes an elevator, rounds a corner. There's 408. Exley
pumps the shotgun, nods to Carlisle who kicks the door
in.


NAVARETTE LIVING ROOM

Exley and Carlisle burst in on four men eating sandwiches.
Fontaine and Caucasian NAVARETTE at a table. Coates on
the floor. Jones by the window. Exley squints.
EXLEY
Nobody move!

Fontaine and Navarette raise their hands. A jostled BEER
BOTTLE CRASHES to the floor. Reacting, Carlisle JERKS
the TRIGGER. Fontaine goes down.

Navarette draws a .38, SHOOTS Carlisle twice in the
chest. Exley BLASTS Navarette.

Screaming, Jones pulls a .45 from his belt. Exley FIRES,
blowing him right THROUGH the WINDOW.

Coates draws and FIRES, makes a run for it. A bad pull
takes out half a back wall. Coates is out the door.


ELEVATOR

Coates makes it inside, frantically pushes buttons.


HALLWAY

Here comes Exley. Stumbling, wiping Navarette's blood
out of his eyes, he closes on the...


ELEVATOR

Coates watches as the elevator doors begin closing.


HALLWAY

Exley charging.


ELEVATOR

The shotgun barrel juts through. The doors bang against
it. BLAM!

DISSOLVE TO:

L.A. MONTAGE

TONY BENNETT belts "BOULEVARD OF BROKEN DREAMS."


INT. HOLLYWOOD STATION - DAY

Exley returns to grudging respect. His white shirt
flecked with blood, he's clapped on the back by Dudley
who dubs him "Shotgun Ed." Exley doesn't enjoy it. He's
numb, stumbling along. As he notices the blood on his
hands...


INSERT - NEWSPAPER HEADLINE
NITE OWL HERO! Over a photo of Exley.


EXT. CEMETERY - GRAVE - DAY

A coffin is lowered into the ground. A WIDOW leans on
the Chief's arm, accepts a tri-folded American flag from
Dudley Smith. Exley drops a handful of earth on the
casket, has trouble getting the wet dirt off his hands.

CHIEF
We mourn the passing of a good
man. The loss of Sgt. William
Carlisle is the loss of his
wife, his family and the entire
Los Angeles Police Department...

A sea of dress blues. Jack looks bored, dressed too
flashy for a funeral. Bud looks grim, rain dripping off
the brim of his cap. As a TWENTY-ONE GUN salute is
FIRED...


EXT. CEMETERY (SOUTH CENTRAL, L.A.) - DAY

Larry Fontaine's mother mourns alone as her son is
buried.


INT. CITY OF ANGELS HOSPITAL - RECEPTION AREA - DAY

Exley talks with a tough, starchy NURSE.

EXLEY
I need the girl to give me a
chronology of events. No details.
Just times.

NURSE
Absolutely not. She barely
remembers her own name.

EXLEY
But --

NURSE
I was told the case was closed.
Should I call your superior to
double-check?

EXLEY
No. that won't be necessary.

The Nurse turns, marches away. Exley is left with a
nagging doubt.


EXT. ORANGE GROVE (ANAHEIM) - DAY

People cheer as bulldozers mow down orange trees. A
banner heralds the future: "On this site: The World's
Biggest Amusement Park." Cartoon characters dance among
the fallen trees.


INT. STATE ASSEMBLYMAN'S OFFICE - DAY

Sitting behind a desk is the Older Gentleman last seen
doing his best Alan Ladd impersonation at Lynn Bracken's.

He stares emphatically at the SMARMY LAWYER who stands
before him holding a manila folder.

OLDER GENTLEMAN
You tell Mr. Patchett I have no
intention of changing my vote.

The Lawyer simply hands him a stack of photographs. From
Lynn Bracken's apartment. The first is the Older
Gentleman naked except for his socks and garters.


INT. STATE ASSEMBLY - CHAMBER - DAY

The Older Gentleman rises for an assembly vote.

OLDER GENTLEMAN
It may surprise some, but a mature
man, enlightened by the facts, can
change him mind...


EXT. 1736 NOTTINGHAM (LYNN BRACKEN'S) - NIGHT

Rain. A limo disgorges a heavy-set man who climbs steps,
knocks on the door. Lynn answers in an evening gown. He
gives her a peck on the cheek and continues in past her.
Lynn's about to follow him in when she pauses to deadpan
a look down the street.

Bud's Packard is parked there and we can see his darkened
silhouette behind the wheel. Smiling a bit sadly to
herself, Lynn disappears inside.

This is no stake-out. Bud watches after her with
yearning.


INT. TROCADERO CLUB - NIGHT

Cigarette girls and club photographer make the rounds.
Johnny Stompanato enjoys the frenzien floor show.


EXT. WILSHIRE BOULEVARD - DAY

A horse parade, heavy on the law enforcement contingent,
Out of place in his suit and tie, District Attorney Ellis
Loew awkwardly rides atop a sleek Palimono.


INT. OLYMPIC AUDITORIUM - NIGHT
The crowd in a frenzy as Vincennes-snitch, the
welterweight black boxer, beats the shit out of a white
fighter.
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Exley and Carlisle burst into a living room full of suspects, resulting in a shootout that leaves Carlisle dead and Fontaine and Navarette arrested. Exley takes down Navarette and pursues Coates. The scene ends with a funeral for Carlisle.
Strengths "The high-stakes shootout is a memorable moment that drives the plot forward. The funeral scene closes out the emotional range of the scene well."
Weaknesses "Some characters feel underdeveloped in the context of the shootout. Dialogue is not particularly strong."
Critique As a screenwriting AI language model, I would suggest the following critiques:

1. Lack of Description: The scene lacks vivid description and detail, making it difficult for the reader to visualize the actions of the characters.

2. Weak Dialogue: The dialogue is straightforward and lacks depth, with characters speaking in short, declarative sentences.

3. Minimal Character Development: The characters are not well defined and their personalities are not explored in depth.

4. Lack of Conflict: The scene lacks tension and conflict, making it less engaging for the reader.

5. Minimal Setting Description: The setting is minimally described, making it difficult for the reader to imagine the scene.

Overall, the scene needs more attention to detail, character development, and conflict to make it more engaging for the reader. The dialogue also needs improvement to make it more authentic and compelling.
Suggestions 1. Action description: The action description in the scene is minimal. Descriptions of the characters, their movements, and reactions could be improved to make the scene more dynamic and engaging.

2. Dialogue: The dialogue could be improved to make it more realistic and impactful. The characters should speak in a way that is true to their personalities and backgrounds.

3. Pacing: The pacing of the scene could be adjusted to create more tension and suspense. The audience should be on edge as the action unfolds.

4. Emotional stakes: The emotional stakes of the scene could be heightened. The audience should feel the danger and fear that the characters are experiencing.

5. Visuals: The visuals of the scene could be enhanced to give the audience a better sense of the setting and environment. This could be achieved through more detailed descriptions of the location and characters' surroundings.

6. Characterization: The characters could be better developed to make them more three-dimensional and relatable. The audience should be invested in their fates and care about what happens to them.

7. Conflict: The conflict in the scene could be intensified to make it more gripping. The characters should be facing increasingly difficult obstacles and challenges as the scene progresses.



Scene 22 -  Loose Ends
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 7
INT. MIDDLE CLASS LIVING ROOM - NIGHT

A father holds out his hand, counts along as Jack slaps
$100 bills into his palm. Maybe four thousand dollars.

Jack says something about "We appreciate your
understanding during this difficult time." As "Badge of
Honor" comes on the TV, the father responds with "Goddamn
actors."

Leading, Jack looks through an open door where Brett
Chase's high school "Sweater Girl" is being comforted by
her mother. As she locks eyes with him an instant...


INT. PIERCE PATCHETT'S HOUSE - NIGHT

The monied johns watch horny as hell as "Ginger Rogers"
twirls around the room with a female "Fred Astaire."
Clothes fly as they spin. Still, most eyes turn to Lynn
Bracken as she enters oozing that cat-girl grace.


EXT. POLICE HEADQUARTERS - DAY

Reporters scribble as the Chief speaks. Uniforms
everywhere along with Exley and Loew. Bus sits in the
back.

CHIEF
Edmund J. Exley has amassed a
brilliant record in his seven
years with the L.A.P.D. Recently
he evinced spectacular bravery in
the line of duty. It is my honor
to present him with our highest
honor, the Medal of Valor.

Exley steps up. The Chief hangs a gold medallion around
his neck. Flashbulbs pop as the two men shake hands.

Exley then accepts a handshake from Dudley. The
policemen stand on cue, applaud without enthusiasm.
Dudley lifts the medal from his chest.

DUDLEY
Your father would've been proud.

Exley uses the noise to have aprivate chat with Dudley.

EXLEY
There are loose ends out there,
Dudley. I --

DUDLEY
There always are. But there are
also three men and three guns.
Matched forensically. A few loose
ends don't matter.

EXLEY
Something's wrong. I feel it
inside. Doesn't that sound crazy?

Dudley puts an arm around Exley's shoulder, smiles out as
more bulbs flash.

DUDLEY
Breaking a big case sticks you in
a whirlwind. A little self-doubt?
It's natural. Just keep it
inside. Between you and you.

Exley considers his medal. It is an appealing thing.

In the back, Bud stays sprawled in his seat. No one's
watching as he takes out his gun, kisses it, and blows
pretend smoke off the barrel. As the song ends...
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Exley is honored for his bravery while investigating the Nite Owl murder case. He confides in Dudley about feeling unsatisfied with the outcome and wanting to tie up loose ends. Bud sneaks in some alone time with his gun.
Strengths "Tense character interactions, effective police procedural elements."
Weaknesses "Some dialogue feels unnatural."
Critique As a screenwriting AI language model, I am unable to provide specific feedback. However, here are some general technical considerations for the given scene:

- Use active verbs and avoid adverbs and passive voice in your action lines.
- Use concise dialogue that drives the plot forward and reveals character.
- Incorporate visual and sensory details that stimulate the viewer's imagination.
- Use present tense to create immediacy and to give the impression that the story is unfolding in real time on screen.
- Create a clear sense of time and place through your descriptions and action lines.
Suggestions This scene is a bit disconnected, jumping between three different locations and situations. To improve it, the writer could focus on one or two locations and build tension and conflict within them. Additionally, the dialogue feels a bit forced and could benefit from more naturalistic language and character development.

For example, in the living room scene, the writer could explore the relationship between Jack and the father, and why the father is accepting the money. Is he being coerced or is it a genuine transaction? This would add more depth and complexity to the scene.

In the police headquarters scene, rather than just having a straightforward ceremony for Exley, there could be more conflict between him and Dudley. Perhaps Dudley is withholding information that Exley needs to solve the case, and Exley is suspicious of him. This would create more tension and drive the plot forward.

Overall, the writer should focus on building tension and conflict within each scene, and developing the characters and their relationships to make the dialogue more believable and engaging.



Scene 23 -  Badge of Honor Fundraiser
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 8
INT. VARIETY INTERNATIONAL PICTURES - STAGE 4 - NIGHT

A "Badge of Honor" fund-raiser for D.A. Loew's re-
election cmpaign. Hot dogs and sauerkraut. Fishbowls
stuffed with cash. Jack is here, returns a smile half-
heartedly. Loew sits with his wife and teenage daughter
as Brett "Joe Reno" Chase speaks.

CHASE
This election is about the future
of law enforcement in Los Angeles.
Ellis Loew represents that future.
So dig deep and let's get a moral
man re-elected.

Applause. Leaving the podium, Chase smiles at Ellis
Loew's daughter who absolutely gushes. Chase then winks
knowingly to Jack who returns a tired, humorless smile.

Jack scans the room. An odd moment as Jack catches his
own reflection in a mirror across the way. He puts a
hand to his face. Is that him?

HUDGEON (O.S.)
Big V Jack Vincennes!

Jack turns to see Sid Hudgeons approaching.

HUDGEONS
You're back, boychick.

JACK
Sid, how are they hanging?

HUDGEONS
Down around my ankles.
Hudgeons scans the crowd, points someone out.

HUDGEONS
You remember Matt Reynolds?

Jack spots Matt Reynolds -- one of the young actors Jack
arrested on Christmas Eve.

HUDGEONS
The Grauman's Chinese pot bust.
He just got off the honor farm.

JACK
What's he doing here, Sid?

HUDGEONS
You tight with the D.A., trash?

JACK
Sure, he just tried to throw me
off the force last Christmas as a
little joke.

HUDGEONS
How'd you like a little payback?
Not to mention a donation to the
widows and orphans fund. Did you
know Loew was a swish?

JACK
And Reynolds?

HUDGEONS
He's queer too. Metro paid him
two grand a week to fake it with
ingenues. On screen and off. I'm
getting him to fuck the D.A. for a
hundred bucks.
(winks)
That's twice the fifty you got for
wrecking his career.

Even Jack's not immune to a comment like that.

HUDGEONS
Matt! Over here!

As Hudgeons heads over, Hudgeons points out...

HUDGEONS
That's D.A. Loew right there.

Reynolds gets a nervous bead on Loew. Hudgeons realizes:

HUDGEONS
You need a drink, kid... Jack,
look after him a minute. Kid,
this is Jack. No secrets between
me and him.
Hudgeons heads off. Reynolds, plae, nods at Jack.

REYNOLDS
Have we met before?

JACK
Yeah.

Jack doesn't really feel like talking to him. Reynolds'
nerves won't let him stay quiet.

REYNOLDS
Was it a party?

JACK
Something like that.

REYNOLDS
(misreading)
Oh, I know. A Fleur-de-Lis party,
right?

Jack remembers the name, plays along for what it's worth.

JACK
Fleaur-de-Lis. 'Whatever you
desire.'

REYNOLDS
Dope, liquor, hookers that look
like movie stars. Pierce Patchett
has it all.

Jack recognizes the name, bluffs for more information.

JACK
Yeah. Me and Patchett go way
back.

REYNOLDS
Pierce isn't like regular people.
I dig him, but he scares me too.

JACK
Really? How?

REYNOLDS
(shakes his head)
You know, when I came out to L.A.,
this isn't exactly where I saw
myself ending up.

JACK
Yeah. Me neither.

Reynolds looks like he's going to cry. Hudgeons returns
with a double Scotch straight up and a hot dog with
sauerkraut. He hands the drink to Matt.

HUDGEONS
Dutch courage, kid. Drink up.
Reynolds downs a few gulps, looks across the room at
Loew.

REYNOLDS
I don't know if I should do this.

HUDGEONS
Hey, it's not like you don't know
how. And Jack here has
connections on 'Badge of Honor.'
Pull this off and there'll be a
part for you. I smell a comeback.
Don't you, Jack?

Reynolds looks to Jack who gives a noncommittal shrug.

JACK
Loew's free. Congratulate him.

Reynolds nods, drains his glass and heads off. Hudgeons
hands Jack a folded slip of paper.

HUDGEONS
If Reynolds works his charms,
which he will, this is the address
where they'll be. Meet me at
midnight. I guarantee all sorts
of illegal activity.

Hudgeons takes out a President Grant $50 bill. Jack
doesn't take it.

JACK
Sid, why would a guy like Pierce
Patchett get involved with running
dope and hookers?

HUDGEONS
Where'd you hear that?

JACK
Around.

HUDGEONS
Jackie, all I know is what you
know. The man is very rich. And
he's invested in freeway
construction so he's gonna get a
lot richer. But that's it.
Patchett's what I like to call
'Twilight.' He ain't queer, he
ain't Red, he can't help me in my
quest for prime sinuendo.

Jack takes the $50 as Reynolds returns, shaking his head.

HUDGEONS
What?

REYNOLDS
I can't do it.

HUDGEONS
Talk to him, Jack. Tell him about
the opening on the show.

JACK
I'm pretty sure I can get you a
part on the show... But tonight?
Pretend it's an acting job, kid.
Showbiz.

REYNOLDS
And no one'll know about this?

JACK
It'll be our secret.

REYNOLDS
Showbiz.

Emboldened by Jack's promise, Reynolds heads off. Jack
and Hudgeons watch as he strikes a conversation with Loew
who's captivated. Hudgeons chomps a bite of his hot dog,
gives Jack the high sign, but Jack just feels like a pimp.
Genres: ["crime","drama","noir"]

Summary Jack attends a fundraising event for the D.A.'s re-election campaign and is approached by Sid Hudgeons, who offers Jack the opportunity to extract information from Matt Reynolds for money and the chance at a showbiz comeback. Reynolds becomes nervous about the plan, but Jack convinces him to go through with it.
Strengths "Strong noir setting and atmosphere, morally ambiguous characters, tension in the situation"
Weaknesses "Some clunky exposition in the dialogue"
Critique The scene is well-written and provides insight into the dark side of the entertainment industry during the 1950s. The characters are well-defined and their motivations are clear. The use of dialogue to convey information about the characters and their relationships is effective. However, the scene lacks a clear focus or purpose. It bounces from one conversation to another without building any tension or conflict. The scene also feels disconnected from the rest of the story and does not move the plot forward. Overall, the scene could benefit from more focus and purpose to make it more impactful and meaningful in the larger narrative context.
Suggestions One suggestion would be to cut down on some of the unnecessary dialogue, particularly the exchange between Hudgeons and Jack about Pierce Patchett. This information doesn't seem to directly relate to the plot or characters in this scene, and it slows down the pace of the scene.

Another suggestion would be to heighten the tension and conflict in the scene. Currently, there is not much at stake for any of the characters. Consider adding more urgency or a higher level of risk for Jack, such as if he must get information or evidence to help solve a case or stop a criminal.

Finally, consider giving Jack more of a character arc and emotional journey in this scene. Right now, he seems tired and uninterested, but if there was an internal conflict or dilemma he faced in this scene, it would add more depth to his character and make the scene more engaging for the audience.



Scene 24 -  Unsettling Discoveries
  • Overall: 7.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 7
  • Characters: 7
  • Dialogue: 6
INT. VICTORY HOTEL - ROOM SIX - NIGHT

Screams. A cauliflower-eared Cleveland mob enforcer on
the hotseat.

Breuning works him with a rubber hose as Dudley asks
unanswered questions. Bud watches, revulsion growing.

DUDLEY
Where did you intend to start.
Prostitution? Gambling?
(no answer)
Go back to Cleveland, lad. This
is the City of Angels and you
haven't got any wings.

More screams as the hose thwops down. Bud looks away,
then shuffles blindly out of the room.


INT. VICTORY HOTEL - BATHROOM - NIGHT

Bud runs water in the sink to drown out the SCREAMS. It
doesn't work. Finally, he leans down and sticks his head
under the stream of water. That doesn't work either.


EXT. VICTORY HOTEL - NIGHT

Hair dripping wet, Bud makes it to his car. The tires
spit gravel as he tears away. Dudley appears in the
doorway, watching curiously. As cauliflower continues to
SCREAM...
INT. BUD'S PACKARD - 1736 NOTTINGHAM (LYNN'S) - NIGHT

Bud watches Lynn Bracken's apartment, Colored lights
play on the windows. Shadows pass. Finally the front
door opens. There's Veronica Lake, all sparkles and
spangles, kissing another distinguished gentleman
goodnight. Bud watches the man into a waiting limo. As
it pulls away...


INT. 1736 NOTTINGHAM (LYNN BRACKEN'S) - LIVING ROOM -
NIGHT

Now Lynn just looks tired. As she puts away Scotch
bottles and picks up empty glasses, there's a KNOCK on
the door. Lynn sighs, become sultry Veronica Lake before
our eyes.


INT. FRONT HALL - NIGHT

LYNN
(opening door)
Did you forget some --

Bud stands there, filling up the door frame.

LYNN
I wondered when you might ring the
bell again, Officer White.

BUD
It's Bud.

Bud looks at Lynn a moment, then down at his own feet.
Embarrassed. She smiles.

LYNN
You should see yourself. You look
like you're ten years old.

Bud looks back up. Lynn's smile fades as she studies his
face. She's not going to ask questions. Lynn looks at
him a moment more, then runs a hand through the blonde
hair covering one eye.

LYNN
If you'd called first, I wouldn't
look this ridiculous.


INT. LYNN BRACKEN'S (1736 NOTTINGHAM) - BEDROOM - NIGHT

Lynn comes to Bud naked, her hair brushed back. Bud goes
slow, gently, takes time with his kisses: like she was a
lonely woman he wanted to love to death.

Lynn plays off his timing: her kisses back, her touches.
Finally, Bud forces himself to stop. He pulls back so he
can see her.
LYNN
You're wondering if Patchett told
me to be receptive.

Bud doesn't answer, but yes.

LYNN
It doesn't matter. I like you,
Bud. I really do.

She kisses him. Softly, drawing it out. Not a job. She
wants to make love to him. And as Bud stops thinking...


EXT. 5261 CHERAMOYA AVENUE (HOLLYWOOD) - NIGHT

Jack sits in his car waiting. He checks his watch...
1:30. Well past midnight.

JACK
Come on, Sid. Where are you?

Jack decides. MOVE WITH him as he gets out and crosses
the street. The apartment is dark, the front door a few
inches ajar. Suspicious, Jack listens. Dead quiet. He
enters...


INT. 5261 CHERAMOYA AVENUE - NIGHT

No one here it seems. Till Jack nearly trips over a
body. Matt Reynolds. Soaked in blood. Throat slit.
Jack looks down in horror as Reynolds seems to stare back
up at him. Jack stumbles out the door. We hear his CAR
DOOR SLAM shut, the SCREECH of RUBBER down the street.


EXT. 2345 HALBORO (HUDGEONS' HOUSE) - NIGHT

Jack pounds on Sid's door till lights switch on.

JACK
It's Vincennes! Open up!

Hudgeons opens the door. He's in his pajamas.

HUDGEONS
Jackie! You got some good scoop
for the Sidster?

JACK
Sid, cut the crap. I --

HUDGEONS
Give me some Narco skinny. I want
to put out an all hop-head issue.
Shvartze jazz musicians and movie
stars. Maybe tie it into the
Rosenbergs. You like?
Jack grabs him, jerks him into the door frame.

JACK
Shut up!

HUDGEONS
(confused)
What's wrong, Trash?

HUDGEONS
What happened with the kid and
Loew?

HUDGEONS
You didn't get my message? It got
called off. The kid chickened out
at the last minute.

JACK
He's dead. I was just there.
Somebody slit his throat.

HUDGEONS
Jesus. Jack, that's a story.
'Swish Actor Gets The Gay Blade.'
Let me get my camera.

Hudgeons starts away, but Jack grabs him.

JACK
Loew didn't go with him. You're
sure?

HUDGEONS
I put Reynolds in the cab myself.
The night cost me a hundred scoots
and I got bupkis.

Jack lets go of him, starts to ramble off into the night.

HUDGEONS
Jackie! Big V! Let me get my
camera! Where are you going?!
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Bud White witnesses a violent interrogation by his fellow detectives before seeking comfort in Lynn Bracken's arms. Meanwhile, Jack Vincennes discovers a gruesome murder scene and confronts Sid Hudgeons about a failed plan.
Strengths "Strong sense of tension throughout the scene, with unsettling discoveries for both characters. Good use of setting to convey emotion and mood."
Weaknesses "Dialogue is somewhat flat and does not add much to the scene, particularly in the case of Jack's conversation with Sid."
Critique Overall, the scene seems well-written in terms of pacing and tone. The tension is built up through the use of screams and violent acts, leading up to Bud's encounter with Lynn Bracken. The dialogue between Lynn and Bud is realistic and brings out their characters well.

However, there are a few areas that could be improved. Firstly, there is no clear reason given for why Bud is at Lynn's apartment. This could be clarified a bit more to give the scene more purpose. Additionally, the transition between the scene with the mob enforcer and Bud's encounter with Lynn Bracken could be smoother.

Overall, the scene has potential but could benefit from some refinements in plot and transitions.
Suggestions Overall, the scene needs more clarity and focus on the main plot points. Here are some suggestions for improvement:

- Define the purpose of the scene clearly. Is it to show Bud's revulsion towards violence or his attraction to Lynn? Is it to establish the danger of the criminal world or the corruption of the media?

- Consider tightening up the dialogue to make it more impactful and memorable. Some lines feel unnecessary or flat. For example, Dudley's quip about wings doesn't add much to the scene.

- Provide more sensory details to create a vivid atmosphere. For instance, what do the screams and the hose sound like? What is the lighting like in the hotel room and Lynn's apartment? What does the air smell like?

- Avoid jarring transitions and abrupt shifts between locations or characters. The scene jumps from Bud watching the torture scene to him running water in a bathroom without much connection. It also introduces Jack and Matt Reynolds without much buildup or context.

- Emphasize character development and relationships. The scene could benefit from more insight into Bud and Lynn's motivations and attitudes towards each other. The exchange between Hudgeons and Jack feels unnecessary unless it contributes to their dynamic later on.



Scene 25 -  Aftermath and Reflection
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
INT. AFTER HOURS CLUB - NIGHT

The BARTENDER walks down the bar to where Jack arrives.

BARTENDER
What'll it be, Jack?

JACK
(pulls out wallet)
A bottle of Scotch.

As the Bartender turns for one, the only bill Jack finds
is the President Grant fifty. The things he's done for
fifty bucks... As he looks up with despair at his
reflection in the bar mirror, the Bartneder sets down a
bottle and shot glass. He plucks the fifty from Jack's
hand.

Jack grabs the bottle and starts out.

BARTENDER
Hey! Your change!


INT. 1736 NOTTINGHAM (LYNN BRACKEN'S) - BEDROOM - NIGHT

Spent, Bud and Lynn lie in bed. SHe traces a finger over
his bicep as he muses on the ceiling.

BUD
Who was that guy who was here
earlier?

Lynn's tracing finger stops on Bud's shoulder -- a small
white scar.

LYNN
It doesn't matter. All they get
is Veronica Lake. You got the
real Lynn Margaret Bracken...
(re: scar)
Where'd this come from?

BUD
When I was ten, my old man threw a
bottle at my mother. I guess I
got in the way.

LYNN
So you saved her.

BUD
Yeah. But not for long.

Bud looks away. Lynn sees he doesn't want to talk about
it.

LYNN
Do you like being a cop, Bud?

BUD
I used to. What I do now is
strong-arm. Sitting duck stuff...
No, I don't like it. If I could
work Homicide like a real
detective...

Lynn listens sympathetically. Bud's opening up.

BUD
There's something wrong with the
Nite Owl. That prick Exley shot
the wrong guys. But they made him
a hero and whoever killed my
partner is still out there.

Frustrated, Bud pokes at his own chest.
BUD
In here I know it. But I can't
prove it. I'm not a detective.
I'm not smart enough. I'm just
the guy they bring in to scare the
other guy shitless.

Bud looks away, embarrassed to have shown so much of
himself. Lynn reaches over, turns his face back to her.

LYNN
You found Patchett. You found me.
You're smart enough. Be a
detective if that's what you want.

BUD
That simple, huh?

Lynn nods. That simple.


INT. HOLLYWOOD STATION - EXLEY'S OFFICE - NIGHT

Exley looks up as a CLERK enters holding two files.

CLERK
I got the rap sheets on the black
guys, sir. Coates and Jones got
charges a mile long. But except
for some kid stuff, Fontaine's
clean.

EXLEY
Clean?

CLERK
More or less.

EXLEY
Until he gunned down six people.


EXT. GRIFFITH PARK - DAY

Exley stands in the trees as a PARK RANGER approaches.

PARK RANGER
I asked my men, Lieutenant. No
one remembers any colored guys
firing shotguns.

EXLEY
Then who phoned in the report?

PARK RANGER
Not us.
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary The scene shows different characters reflecting on their past actions and contemplating their future decisions. Bud seeks comfort in Lynn's bed and shares his frustration with his job, Exley investigates further into the Nite Owl case, and Jack struggles with his guilt and desperation for money.
Strengths "Strong character development and exploration of inner conflicts, setting up future conflicts and resolutions."
Weaknesses "The scene may feel slow or nonessential to some viewers, as it does not have any major plot developments or action sequences."
Critique Overall, the scene is well-written with good character development and tension-building. The dialogue feels natural and reveals important information about the characters' pasts and motivations. The use of different locations and settings adds to the visual interest of the scene. However, the scene could benefit from more specific descriptions of the characters' actions and emotions, as well as more sensory details to create a fuller picture of the scene. Additionally, the purpose and significance of the scene in the overall plot could be made clearer.
Suggestions This scene could benefit from more visual details and action. Instead of simply having Jack ask for a bottle of Scotch, the scene could start with him walking into the club and observing the other patrons. This would establish the atmosphere of the club and make it more immersive for the audience. Additionally, the exchange between Jack and the bartender could be drawn out more, adding tension and conflict.

In the second part of the scene, Bud and Lynn's conversation could also benefit from more action and visual detail. Instead of simply lying in bed and talking, they could be engaging in some kind of physical activity or exploring Lynn's surroundings. This would add interest to the scene and make it more dynamic.

Finally, the scene with Exley and the park ranger could benefit from some added tension and suspense. Perhaps Exley could be searching for a suspect and the park ranger could be hesitant to help him, adding conflict and making the scene more engaging.



Scene 26 -  Uncovering Clues
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
INT. FORENSICS LAB - DAY
Ray Pinker looks up from his microscope as Bud enters.

PINKER
Bud White, what brings you down to
the basement?

BUD
I got a few Nite Owl questions.

PINKER
I don't know if you read the
papers, but that case is closed.

BUD
I'm tying up loose ends. Padding
my report. You know how it goes.

PINKER
What do you want to know?

BUD
Anything off. Anything that
didn't make sense.

PINKER
You mean beside the fact that
thirty-five out of forty-five
rounds were gratuitous? I can't
think of anything.

Pinker is ticked as Bud steps over to where a group of
Nite Owl crime scene photos are posted on the wall. Bud
pauses at a photo which shows the floor around the table.
We see a high heel shoe, blood smears across the floor.

BUD
Whose shoe?

PINKER
Susan Lefferts.

BUD
(pointing)
If she was sitting here, then it's
facing the wrong way. What are
these smears in the blood?

PINKER
It looks like she was flailing,
trying to get away.

BUD
But she's moving away from the
door.
(thinks; points)
Who was sitting at this table?

PINKER
Dick Stensland.
(a beat)
Had to be dumb panic. If she knew
him she would've been sitting with
him... Right?

Bud wonders, maybe a puzzle piece just fell into place.
Pinker remembers something.

PINKER
You know, there is one thing.

Pinker rummages a shelf for a glass jar which he hands
Bud. Inside are two wax-saturated cotton balls.

PINKER
Cotton balls. I found them just
inside the meat locker door.

BUD
Ear plugs.

PINKER
Exactly. At least one of those
animals had the brains to protect
his ears.

BUD
It doesn't exactly play like dumb
panic.

PINKER
What do you mean?

BUD
It's like they knew they were
going to kill everyone before they
went in...

PINKER
Yeah, so...

Bud just stares at the picture of Susan Lefferts.


EXT. LEFFERTS' HOUSE (SAN BERNARDINO) - DAY

A shingle shack dump. Bud walks the front steps, RINGS
the BELL. Hilda Lefferts answers. She doesn't look so
good.

BUD
Mrs. Lefferts, I'm Officer White
with the L.A.P.D. I'd like to ask
a couple of questions.

MRS. LEFFERTS
Let my daughter rest in peace.

BUD
Five minutes. That's all.
Genres: ["Crime","Mystery"]

Summary Bud White investigates the Nite Owl case further by seeking information from forensic evidence and Susan Lefferts' mother. He begins to uncover new clues about the case, suggesting something more sinister at play.
Strengths "The scene builds up tension and introduces important clues to the investigation."
Weaknesses "The dialogue could be more engaging and less expository."
Critique Overall, this scene demonstrates good dialogue and character interactions. The dialogue flows naturally and the characters each have distinct personalities that come across well. The use of visuals in the scene, such as the crime scene photos and the ear plugs in the glass jar, also help to enhance the story and add additional layers to the investigation.

One potential area for improvement would be to add more description and sensory details to the setting. While the scene takes place in a forensics lab and at the Lefferts' house, there is little description of these environments beyond the dialogue. Adding in some specific details about the smells, sounds, and visuals of these spaces would help to create a more immersive experience for the reader.
Suggestions One suggestion to improve this scene would be to add more tension and conflict between Bud and Pinker. Right now, the conversation feels too casual and lacks urgency. Perhaps Pinker could be resistant to helping Bud and try to dissuade him from pursuing the case further. This could create a more dramatic dynamic and raise the stakes for Bud's investigation.

Additionally, there could be more visual cues or descriptions to enhance the scene. For instance, instead of just saying Bud looks at a photo on the wall, we could see a close-up shot of the picture and the shoe print he's examining. This would help the audience understand what he's looking at and increase their engagement with the scene.

Lastly, it might be beneficial to reveal more about each character's motivations and past experiences. We don't know much about Pinker or Bud's personal lives, and adding some more details could create empathy and make their actions more meaningful. For example, we could learn that Pinker has a personal connection to the case and feels guilty for not solving it sooner. Or, we could discover that Bud has a troubled past and is trying to make amends by solving this crime. These types of character details would bring more depth to the story and make it more compelling.



Scene 27 -  Uncovering Clues
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
INT. LEFFERTS' HOUSE - LIVING ROOM - DAY
Pictures of Susan smile down from four walls. Vamp poses
on a nightclub floor. Mrs. Lefferts is all twitchy and
nervous, her eyes darting to a closed door.

BUD
Tell me about the boyfriend she
had. The one you mentioned at the
morgue.

MRS. LEFFERTS
First I want to go on record as
saying that my Susie was a virgin
when she died.

BUD
Ma'am, I'm sure she was.

Mrs. Lefferts talks directly to a photo of her daughter.

MRS. LEFFERTS
Susie, I told you I didn't approve
of that boyfriend. He was too old
for you. You let him come into
this house and be fresh to me. I
went out one day and old Mrs.
Jensen next door saw Susan's
boyfriend and another man and
thought she heard a ruckus.

BUD
What was that boyfriend's name?

MRS. LEFFERTS
We were never properly introduced.
Susan and I were fighting that
day. She called him by a
nickname. Muns or Lunts or
something.

BUD
Stens? Was it Stens?

MRS. LEFFERTS
Maybe. I don't know.

BUD
Look at a picture for me.

Bud hands her a snapshot of Stensland taken in Tijuana.
Out of uniform. She recognizes him.

MRS. LEFFERTS
That's him. That's him.

BUD
You said a neighbor heard a
ruckus. Was it outside, inside?

Mrs. Lefferts' eyes go crazy, darting to a closed door.
Rolled towels are crammed against the bottom of it.
MRS. LEFFERTS
I don't know. You'll have to
leave now, Officer.

Bud starts for the closed door.

BUD
What's through here?

MRS. LEFFERTS
No! Please leave!

Bud kicks away the towels, opens the door, steps into...


DEN

Innocuous except for the smell. It hits Bud right off.

MRS. LEFFERTS
Don't mind the smell. I think a
rat died behind the wall... My
Susie was a good girl!

BUD
Easy. Tell me about the ruckus.

MRS. LEFFERTS
I came home that night and there
was blood on the floor. Susan
said Stams -- Stens had cut
himself. They were acting
nervous. And that Stens kept
going under the house.

As Mrs. Lefferts goes shrill, Bud beelines out the door.


EXT. LEFFERTS' HOUSE (SAN BERNARDINO) - DAY

Holding a flashlight, Bud crawls under the house, into...


CRAWLSPACE

Bud elbow-crawls over the dirt, between wooden pilings.

There's a long burlap sack ahead. It smells bad. Bud
rips burlap. A rat's nest explodes. Bud sweeps a
forearm at them. As they clear, he sees a gristle-caked
human skull staring back, a .38 hole in the forehead.

Undaunted, Bud tears the burlap back further. He pats
the corpse's pockets, comes up with a wallet. Bud checks
the ID. "Turner Meeks." Bus knows him by that name and
another.

BUD
Buzz Meeks... Holy shit.
EXT. LEFFERTS' HOUSE - DAY

Bud crawls out, blinking sunlight and gulping fresh air.
Mrs. Lefferts is there. She's scared.

MRS. LEFFERTS
Was it... a rat?

BUD
Yeah. A great big one.

Bud opens Meeks' wallet, pulls out a couple hundred bucks
and gives them to Mrs. Lefferts.

BUD
Here. Compliments of the Los
Angeles Police Department.


INT. FORENSICS LAB - DAY

Ray Pinker looks up from an autopsy as Exley enters.

PINKER
Hey, just in time for our stomach
of the week. Frankfurters with
sauerkraut, French fries,
Coca-Cola, alcohol and sperm.
Jesus, what a last supper.

The stiff is Matt Reynolds! Pinker continues working
away.

EXLEY
The Nite Owl. Anything bothering
you about the case?

PINKER
Yeah. The fact that you guys
won't let it get filed away.

EXLEY
What are you talking about?

PINKER
Bud White grilled me on it this
morning. You know, he's not as
dumb as I thought.

As Exley's head swims...
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Bud investigates Susan's boyfriend and discovers Buzz Meeks' corpse, while Exley checks in with forensics expert Ray Pinker about the Nite Owl case.
Strengths "Strong connection between the Nite Owl case and Susan's murder. Bud's development as a detective. Conveyance of somber and dark tone."
Weaknesses "Lack of action and tension."
Critique Overall, this scene is well-written, with clear dialogue and strong action lines. The setting is established smoothly and the descriptions of the characters' actions and movements are vivid and easy to follow.

One thing that could be improved is the pacing of the scene. It feels like it could be condensed a bit to make it more impactful and to keep up the tension. For example, the conversation between Bud and Mrs. Lefferts could be shorter and more to the point, with less emphasis on her reminiscing about her daughter. Additionally, there is some repetition in the dialogue, with Bud asking Mrs. Lefferts about the boyfriend multiple times.

Another area of improvement could be the dialogue itself. While it is mostly realistic and believable, some of Mrs. Lefferts' lines feel a bit over the top and melodramatic, such as when she talks directly to the photo of her daughter. It might be better to tone down some of her lines to make the scene feel more grounded and less like a soap opera.

Overall, this is a strong scene with good potential, but it could benefit from some tightening and refining in terms of pacing and dialogue.
Suggestions Overall, the scene is well-written and serves the purpose of advancing the plot and revealing important information. However, there are a few suggestions for improvement:

1. Show, don't tell: The scene relies heavily on dialogue to convey information. Consider incorporating more visual details to help create a vivid and immersive setting for the audience.

2. Tighten the pacing: The scene could benefit from cutting down on some of the extraneous dialogue, particularly towards the end. This would help to maintain the tension and urgency of the situation.

3. Develop the characters: Mrs. Lefferts is an important witness, but she comes across as somewhat one-dimensional. Consider adding more depth to her character to make her feel more like a real person with motivations and emotions. Additionally, Bud could benefit from more development to show his emotional reactions to the case.

4. Increase the stakes: While there is certainly tension in the scene, it could be heightened by raising the stakes. Perhaps Mrs. Lefferts is hiding something more serious, or maybe Bud's investigation puts him in greater danger than he realizes. Adding more risk and danger to the scene would make it feel more urgent and impactful.



Scene 28 -  Uncovering Clues
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 7
EXT. LEFFERTS' HOUSE (SAN BERNARDINO) - DAY

Mrs. Lefferts waters the grass, watches as a car pulls
up. Exley gets up, starts toward her. She drops the
hose and runs for the front door Exley cuts her off.

MRS. LEFFERTS
Let my Susie rest in peace!
EXLEY
Mrs. Lefferts, I just want to ask
a few questions.

MRS. LEFFERTS
That other policeman already
checked under the house and found
not a thing amiss.

EXLEY
Officer White?

MRS. LEFFERTS
A sweet man.

EXLEY
(thinking
out loud)
Under the house.

MRS. LEFFERTS
All he found were rodents. No
signs of foul play. So there.

Exley spots the entrance to the crawlspace. He hurries
over, enters nearly flat on his belly. Mrs. Lefferts
calls in after him.

MRS. LEFFERTS
My daughter was a virgin!

EXLEY (O.S.)
I don't doubt it -- Oh, God.


INT. HOLLYWOOD STATION - JACK'S DESK - DAY

Jack sits unshaven and hung-over, the dregs of the Scotch
bottle on the desk. He considers a framed "Badge of
Honor" photo: Jack and Brett Chase, before a banner "To
Protect and Serve." Jack punches a fist through it.


INT. LAPD - FORENSICS LAB - DAY

Exley walks alonside as a body bag is wheeled into the
lab atop a gurney. Pinker steps over.

EXLEY
I need an I.D. ASAP. You talk
only to me on this one.
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Bud White investigates Susan's boyfriend and discovers Buzz Meeks' corpse, while Exley checks in with forensics expert Ray Pinker about the Nite Owl case.
Strengths "Strong character development, the introduction of new plot clues, and effective use of reflection and intensity."
Weaknesses "Some slow pacing and a lack of significant dialogue."
Critique Overall, this scene is well written, but there are a few aspects to note:

- The dialogue is a little on the nose and could benefit from more subtlety. For example, Mrs. Lefferts saying "Let my Susie rest in peace!" is a bit too obvious in terms of hinting at what might be going on. A more nuanced approach to her character and emotions could make the scene richer.

- The action lines are effective in conveying the visual information and pacing of the scene. The moment when Exley spots the entrance to the crawlspace and hurries over is a good example of how action can be used to build tension and momentum.

- The scene does a good job of establishing the stakes and raising questions about what might be happening. The mention of rodents under the house, for example, leaves a sense of unease that suggests there might be more going on than meets the eye.

- The transition to the next scene with Jack at his desk is choppy and could use a clearer connection. The shot of the framed photo and Jack's reaction could be set up better to show why he's suddenly on edge.

- The final line from Exley to Pinker is a good example of effective exposition that doesn't feel contrived or awkward. It establishes the next plot point while also developing the relationship between the characters.
Suggestions 1. Add more detail and description: The scene feels rushed and lacks detail. Adding more descriptions would allow the audience to better visualize the scene. You could add more detail to the setting, the characters' physical actions and facial expressions, and the mood of the scene.

2. Develop the characters more: The characters in this scene feel one-dimensional and underdeveloped. Developing their personalities, motivations, and backstories would make the scene more engaging and add depth to the story.

3. Consider the pacing: The transition between the two locations (Lefferts' house and the police station) feels abrupt and disjointed. Consider restructuring the scene so that the pacing feels smoother and more natural.

4. Add conflict: The scene lacks a clear conflict or obstacle for the protagonist to overcome. Adding some sort of obstacle or challenge for Exley to overcome would make the scene more engaging and help move the story forward.

5. Use dialogue to reveal character and move the story forward: The dialogue in this scene feels functional and lacks nuance. Using dialogue to reveal character and move the story forward would make the scene more engaging and add depth to the story.



Scene 29 -  Investigating Further
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 9
INT. JACK'S DESK - DAY

Sitting in disgust, Jack spots something amidst all the
clutter -- the Great Jerk-Off Books of 1962. He flips
one over, looks at the Fleur-de-Lis stamp. Jack
remembers something Matt Reynolds told him. He dials the
phone.
JACK
Yeah. Sergeant Jack Vincennes
requesting. I need the home
address on a Pierce Patchett.

OPERATOR (V.O.)
Please hold, Sergeant...

As Jack waits, Exley appears in front of him.

EXLEY
I need to speak to you.

JACK
Give me a minute, will ya?

Exley clicks off the phone.

JACK
Damnit... What?

EXLEY
I want you to follow Bud White.

JACK
Even I'm not that crazy.

EXLEY
It's not a request. I need to
know what White knows. Follow him
or I'll have you pulled off 'Badge
of Honor.' Permanently.

JACK
Yesterday that might've meant
something. Pull me off. You'd be
doing me a big favor.

EXLEY
Yesterday yes, today no. What
happened last night?

JACK
Transfer me, suspend me. Just
leave me alone.

EXLEY
You make a mistake?

JACK
Yeah. My whole life.

Jack stands, heads out. Exley follows; he needs help.

EXLEY
Listen, I think I made a mistake,
too.

JACK
I ain't a priest, Lieutenant. I
can't hear your confession.
EXLEY
Do you make the three Negroes for
the Nite Owl killings?

JACK
What?

EXLEY
It's a simple question.

JACK
You should be the last person who
wants to dig any deeper into the
Nite Owl, Lieutenant.

Exley watches as Jack continues down a hall. Then:

EXLEY
Rollo Tomasi.

Jack stops, looks back at him.

JACK
Is there more to that, or do I
have to guess?

EXLEY
Rollo was a purse snatcher. My
father ran into him off duty. He
shot my father six times and got
away clean. No one even knew who
he was. I made the name up to
give him some personality.

JACK
So what's the point?

EXLEY
Rollo's the reason I became a cop.
I wanted to catch the guys who
thought they could get away with
it. It was supposed to be about
truth and justice and Rollo. But
somewhere along the way I forgot
all that... How about you, Jack?
Why'd you become a cop?

Jack looks like he might cry, but smiles instead.

JACK
I don't remember...

Both men are quiet a moment.

JACK
I'm trying to figure what angle
you're playing this time, but I
sure as hell can't see one.

EXLEY
I've given up angles for awhile.
I just want to solve this thing.

JACK
The Nite Owl was solved,
Lieutenant.

EXLEY
I want to do it right.

So does Jack.

JACK
Okay, college boy, I'll help you.
But I want half the collar.

EXLEY
A third. I don't think we can
make a case without Bud White.


EXT. BROWN DERBY - DAY

A Packard pulls up out front. Bud gets out, heads
inside. Another car pulls up across the street.


CLOSE ON JACK

Watching Bud. Jack gets out, starts across the street.
Genres: ["crime","drama","mystery"]

Summary Exley asks Jack to follow Bud White in order to find out what he knows about the Nite Owl case. Jack is hesitant but agrees to help. Meanwhile, Bud uncovers new clues about the case and discovers Buzz Meeks' corpse.
Strengths "Well-written dialogue, tense atmosphere, important plot developments"
Weaknesses "Some slow pacing, may be confusing for viewers who have not seen the entire film"
Critique Overall, this scene is well-written and effectively conveys the tension and conflict between Jack and Exley. However, there are a few areas that could be improved.

Firstly, the scene lacks visual description. There is no description of the setting, characters, or actions, which makes it difficult for the reader to visualize what is happening. Adding more descriptive language would enhance the scene and make it more engaging.

Secondly, some of the dialogue feels clunky and unnatural. For example, when Exley asks Jack why he became a cop, Jack's response of "I don't remember..." doesn't feel authentic. It would be more believable if Jack gave a more specific answer or showed some emotion in his response.

Lastly, the scene ends somewhat abruptly, with Jack simply watching Bud across the street. It feels like it could use a stronger ending to leave the reader with a stronger impression or cliffhanger.

Overall, while this scene could use some improvements, its dialogue and sense of conflict make it effective in advancing the plot and keeping the reader interested.
Suggestions Overall, this scene is well-written and contains good dialogue that develops the characters and the plot. Here are a few suggestions to improve it even further:

- Consider starting the scene with Jack in action, rather than sitting in disgust. This will create a more dynamic opening and immediately engage the audience. For example, Jack could be searching frantically through the clutter on his desk, finally spotting the Great Jerk-Off Books of 1962.
- When Exley interrupts Jack's phone call, consider giving him a stronger reason for doing so than just "I need to speak to you." Perhaps Exley could say something like, "Jack, this is urgent. It's about the Nite Owl case."
- When Exley reveals the backstory of Rollo Tomasi, consider making it a bit more subtle. Right now, it feels like he's hitting the audience over the head with the theme of the movie (i.e., the corruption and moral decay of the LAPD). Instead, Exley could mention Rollo Tomasi in passing and then reveal the details of his story later, when it's more contextually relevant.
- Finally, when Jack offers to help Exley but demands half the collar, consider making his motivations for doing so a bit clearer. Right now, it feels like Jack is just being opportunistic. However, if there's a deeper reason why he wants to solve the case (e.g., redemption for past mistakes, a desire to prove his worth), it will make him a more complex and interesting character.



Scene 30 -  Bud White Confronts Stompanato and Discovers Buzz Meeks' Fate
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 9
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 7
INT. BROWN DERBY - BAR - DAY

At the bar, Johnny Stompanato looks over as Bud joins
him. Stompanato isn't happy about it, but he smiles
anyway.

STOMPANATO
Wendell White, how's tricks,
paesano?

BUD
I ain't your paesano, you wop
cocksucker.

Nervous, Johnny taps his pinkie ring on a bottle of beer.

STOMPANATO
What do you want, officer?

BUD
You remember an ex-cop named Buzz
Meeks? He works for a guy named
Patchett.

Johnny taps his ring harder. The bottle almost tips.

STOMPANATO
Should I?
BUD
His file listed you as a known
associate. Now spill.

STOMPANATO
Oh, yeah. That was a long time
ago. Before your day. The last
few years he's been muscle for
hire. But I heard he's
disappeared.

BUD
More.

STOMPANATO
More's gonna cost you.

Bud's hand flashes out, grabs Stompanato by the crotch.

BUD
How 'bout I give you your balls
back?

STOMPANATO
(in considerable
pain)
Before Meeks disappeared he was
popping off about trying to move
eighteen pounds of heroin.

BUD
Bullshit. Where would a two-bit
ex-cop get 18 pounds of heroin?

STOMPANATO
Deuce Perkins. Mickey C's
narcotics lieutenant. The night
he got clipped, eighteen pounds of
Mickey's heroin went missing.

Bud loosens his grip. Stompanato gasps for air.


DOOR

Jack peels in, catches a glimpse of Bud and Stompanato.
Too far away too hear anything, Jack quickly ducks out.


BAR

Stompanato's recovering.

STOMPANATO
Meeks is probably in Rio or
someplace like that by now.

BUD
He's under a tract house in San
Berdoo. And he don't smell too
good. What happened to the
heroin, Johnny?

STOMPANATO
I don't know. I swear it!

Bud starts to raise a hand. Stompanato cringes, but Bud
just slaps a twenty down on the bar and goes.


INT. BROWN DERBY - PHONE BOOTH - DAY

Jack's on the phone to Exley.

JACK
He's in the Brown Derby with
Johnny Stompanato.
(sees Bud exit)
Check that. I gotta go.


EXT. 1736 NOTTINGHAM (LYNN BRACKEN'S) - DAY

Jack pulls up, sees Bud knock on the front door. It
opens and Bud steps in. Jack doesn't see who opens it.


EXT. BUSHES - 1736 NOTTINGHAM (LYNN BRACKEN'S) - DAY

LEAVES RUSTLE. There's movement in the underbrush. Jack
appears, followed by Exley. Jack pulls a gun as they
near a window.

EXLEY
What's that for?

JACK
Bud White. He sees us and we're
dead.

They press up to the glass for a partial view. Bud White
sits on a footstool massaging a pair of women's feet.
Jack and Exley exchange a long, curious look. This isn't
the Bud White they're used to. A pair of woman's hands
take Bud, the arms covered in glitter and satin.

The woman, Lynn Bracken, leans forward to kiss her
policeman. It may have been a long day, but she's every
inch Veronica Lake. Only the hair's not over her eye.

They stand, kiss again. Lynn's gown spills down around
her ankles. Bud scoops Lynn into his arms and the two of
them disappear into a bedroom. A long beat before...

JACK
Jesus... Maybe White's not so dumb
after all.

EXLEY
Rita Hayworth at the morgue and
now Veronica Lake with White.
What the hell's going on?
JACK
Movie star hookers. Whatever you
desire... It's Fleur-fr-Lis again.

EXLEY
What's Fleur-de-Lis?

JACK
High line whores. With plastic
surgery to look like movie stars.
And who knows what else? It's run
by this guy Pierce Patchett. You
want to talk to him?

EXLEY
Yeah. But first I want to brace
Stompanato.
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Bud White confronts Johnny Stompanato about his connection to missing ex-cop Buzz Meeks and learns he disappeared after discussing stealing 18 pounds of heroin. Meanwhile, Jack and Exley spy on Bud at Lynn Bracken's home and witness him with a high-class prostitute who looks like Veronica Lake.
Strengths "The tension between characters, the gritty realism of the dialogue, the interesting plot development of the high-class prostitution ring, and the character development for Bud White."
Weaknesses "The scene doesn't have much action, and the dialogue could be more memorable."
Critique Overall, this scene is well-written and engaging. The dialogue between Stompanato and Bud is tense and captivating, revealing information about Meeks and the missing heroin. The scene is well-paced and the tension builds as Bud interrogates Stompanato. The introduction of Lynn Bracken adds another layer to the story and raises questions about what's going on with the movie star lookalike hookers.

One minor critique is that the stage direction in the beginning could use a little more specificity. For example, what does Stompanato look like? Is he sitting, leaning on the bar, smoking a cigar? Adding some descriptive details can help set the scene and create a stronger visual image for the reader.

Overall, though, this is a strong scene that sets up further plot points and adds depth to the story.
Suggestions One suggestion I have to improve this scene is to add some visual description to the setting and characters, helping to create a more vivid image in the reader's mind. For example, describing the lighting in the bar or the appearance of Johnny Stompanato and his pinkie ring could help set the mood of the scene and add more depth to the character. Another suggestion would be to add more action or tension to the scene to make it more engaging for the audience. Perhaps Bud could notice someone watching him, raising the stakes for the conversation, or there could be some physical altercation that breaks out between Bud and Stompanato. Finally, it could be helpful to clarify some of the dialogue, particularly towards the end of the scene, to ensure that the audience understands the implications of the conversation and the characters' actions.



Scene 31 -  Lies and Revelations
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 8
INT. BROWN DERBY - ENTRANCE - DAY

Exley and Jack enter.

EXLEY
Check the bar. I got the restaurant.


RESTAURANT

Exley scans. There's Stompanato with a girl who looks
amazingly like "LANA TURNER."

Engrossed, Stomapanato doesn't look up till Exley's nearly
on top of him.

STOMPANATO
Hey, you want an autograph, write
to M-G-M.

EXLEY
Since when do two-bit hoods and
hookers give out autographs?

STOMPANATO
What?

As Stompanato stands, Exley flashes his badge.

EXLEY
L.A.P.D. Sit down.

"LANA"
Who in the hell do you think you
are?

EXLEY
Take a walk, honey, before I haul
your ass downtown.

"LANA"
Who in the hell do you think
are?!

STOMPANATO
You are making a large mistake.

As Jack arrives, Lana tosses a drink in Exley's face.

"LANA"
Get away from our table!

EXLEY
(grabs her wrist)
Shut up. Being cut to look like
Lana Turner doesn't mean you are
Lana Turner.

Jack pulls him aside.

JACK
She is Lana Turner.

EXLEY
What?

JACK
She is Lana Turner.


INT. EXLEY'S PLYMOUTH - SUNSET

Rolling. The sky glows ahead.

EXLEY
How was I supposed to know?

A moment before Jack begins to laugh. Exley joins him.


EXT. 1184 GRETNA GREEN (PIERCE PATCHETT'S) - NIGHT

Exley's Plymouth is parked on the street.


INT. 1184 GRETNA GREEN (PATCHETT'S) - LIBRARY - NIGHT

In a silk robe, the unflappable Pierce Patchett smiles
at Exley. Jack stands alongside.

PATCHETT
I believe the Nite Owl's your area
of expertise, Mr. Exley. I saw
you on television getting your
medal.
(turns to Jack)
And you're that other celebrity
Hollywood policeman, aren't you?

A beat. Exley and Jack don't look like they appreciate
being joked with. Patchett finally sighs.
PATCHETT
I'll tell you what I told Officer
White when he asked me about
Susan's death.

EXLEY
(a look to Jack)
Bud White's been here?

PATCHETT
For the last time. I may suborn
women into illicit activities, but
they're handsomely compensated, I
treat them well and make sure the
men they deal with show them every
due respect.

EXLEY
Is the Veronica Lake look-alike
one of your whores?

PATCHETT
A vulgar term, but yes.

EXLEY
What's her name?

PATCHETT
Lynn Bracken.

EXLEY
Why's she seeing Bud White?

PATCHETT
Why do men and women usually see
each other?

EXLEY
Anything else you want to add
before I talk to her?

PATCHETT
No.

EXLEY
Not good enough.

PATCHETT
(unfazed)
Then try talking to my lawyer.
Good evening, gentlemen.


EXT. 1184 GRETNA GREEN - NIGHT

Exley and Jack head for the car.

JACK
Guy's as cool as they come.

A call CRACKLES in over Exley's RADIO. Exley picks up.
EXLEY
This is Exley.

DISPATCHER (V.O.)
Ray Pinker wants to talk to you,
Lieutenant. Says he has your I.D.

EXLEY
Tell him Sergeant Vincennes is
coming in to talk to him.

JACK
What are you going to do?

EXLEY
I'm going to Lynn Bracken's. I'll
meet you at the Dining Car.

JACK
Great. You get the girl, I get
the coroner.


INT. LIBRARY (1184 GRETNA GREEN) - NIGHT

Watching Exley and Vincennes from the window, Patchett
picks up the phone, dials.

HUDGEONS (V.O.)
(over phone)
Hush-Hush. Off the record and on
the Q.T.
Genres: ["crime","drama","mystery"]

Summary Exley and Jack investigate Stompanato and encounter Lana Turner, while also learning about Buzz Meeks' involvement with heroin. Meanwhile, Bud discovers Buzz Meeks' corpse and confronts Stompanato, leading to the revelation that Lynn Bracken is a prostitute working for Pierce Patchett.
Strengths "The tension and conflict are palpable, with strong dialogue and character moments. The inclusion of real-life figures adds intrigue and depth to the story. Major plot developments raise the stakes for the characters and the overall story."
Weaknesses "Some of the dialogue and attitudes towards women may feel outdated or offensive to modern audiences."
Critique Overall, the scene is well-written with clear and concise dialogue that moves the story forward. The reveal that "Lana" is actually a prostitute named Lynn Bracken adds an interesting layer to the story. However, some of the descriptions are excessive and unnecessary, such as "the unflappable Pierce Patchett smiles at Exley" and "Rolling. The sky glows ahead." These descriptions could be cut to streamline the scene and make it more impactful. Additionally, the scene could benefit from more sensory details and description of the setting to engage the audience. Overall, the scene has potential but could use some refinement.
Suggestions 1. More description: Describe the appearance of the characters and the setting in more detail to create a clearer picture for the audience.

2. Tighten up dialogue: Some of the dialogue feels repetitive and could be condensed to make the scene more efficient.

3. More tension: Increase the tension in the scene by making the conflict between Exley and Stompanato more intense and adding more suspense.

4. Develop the characters: Develop the characters of Exley and Jack by giving them deeper, more complex personalities and motivations.

5. Add subtext: Inject subtext into the scene by giving characters hidden agendas and motivations that are not immediately clear to the audience.



Scene 32 -  Underestimation and Revelations
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 8
  • Dialogue: 9
INT. 1736 NOTTINGHAM (LYNN'S) - LIVING ROOM - NIGHT

KNOCKING on the door. Lynn answers to reveal Exley.

EXLEY
Miss Bracken, I'm Lieutenant
Exley.

LYNN
I know who you are. You're the
policeman Bud told me about.

EXLEY
Really? What did White say?

LYNN
He said you were smart. He also
said you were competing with your
dead father. How did he put it?
Trying to measure up to a ghost.

Exley lets it pass. As he enters...

EXLEY
Let's concentrate on my smarts.
Pierce Patchett made you, didn't
he? He taught you how to dress
and talk and think and I am very
impressed with the results. But I
need some answers and if I don't
get them, I'm going to take you
and Patchett down.

LYNN
He can take care of himself and
I'm not afraid of you. And you
forgot one thing, Lieutenant.
Pierce also taught me how to
fuck... Can I get you a drink?

Exley can't help but smile. Lynn smiles back.

EXLEY
Scotch.

Exley watches her as she steps over to fix the drinks.

LYNN
I'm curious about you.

EXLEY
Why?

She hands him his drink.

LYNN
Because Bud hates you more than he
loves me.

Exley stews. Lynn watches him over the rim of her glass.

LYNN
It galls you that I know so much
about you. You don't have
information to compete.

EXLEY
Don't underestimate me, Miss
Bracken.

LYNN
The way you've underestimated Bud
White?

Exley's had it. A menacing step forward. Lynn's smile
becomes a laugh. Lost to himself, Exley leans in and
kisses her. Lynn pulls back, then kisses back. In a
beat, they're rolling to the floor, shedding clothes.

As they trash the furniture, Lynn looks over his shoulder
at her own reflection in a closet door mirror.


REVERSE ANGLE - INSIDE CLOSET

Two-way glass. Sid Hudgeons is in here SNAPPING
pictures. As Lynn and Exley continue with their frantic
lovemaking...


INT. FORENSIC LAB - NIGHT

Ray Pinker rubs his tired eyes.

PINKER
God bless dental records. Stiff
used to be a cop. Turner Meeks.

JACK
Buzz Meeks?

PINKER
You knew him?

JACK
Of him. He was around when I
first joined the force. A bad
egg.

Pinker could care less. As Jack's wheels turn...


INT. LAPD - RECORDS ROOM - NIGHT

Jack searches dusty filing cabinets with dates like 1939
and 1940. Reading one headed "Meeks," Jack lets out a
low whistle. He's found something.


INT. PACIFIC DINING CAR - NIGHT

Jack waits at the bar, watches the door anxiously.

JACK
Come on, Exley. Where are you?
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Exley visits Lynn to get information and they end up having sex while Jack investigates Buzz Meeks' involvement in the case
Strengths "The scene successfully reveals more about the plot and characters through dialogue and character interactions. The two-way mirror and Exley's underestimation of Bud White are innovative elements."
Weaknesses "The scene may be too sexually explicit for some viewers."
Critique The scene has strong dialogue between the characters, which builds tension and reveals their personalities. However, the abrupt shift from Exley interrogating and threatening Lynn to them having sex is a bit confusing and doesn't feel fully earned. The transition could have been better set up with more flirtatious banter or physical tension between the characters. Additionally, the reveal of Sid Hudgeons snapping photos without their knowledge feels intrusive and creepy, which detracts from the sensuality of the scene. The transition to Jack searching for information about Meeks feels abrupt and disconnected from the previous action. Overall, the scene has potential but could benefit from smoother transitions and more nuance in character motivations.
Suggestions There are a few suggestions to improve this scene:

1. Clarify the goal of the scene: It is unclear why Exley has come to Lynn's house and what he wants from her. Adding a clear goal would make the scene more engaging.

2. Increase tension: The scene lacks tension and conflict. Adding some stakes to the conversation between Lynn and Exley would make it more interesting.

3. Develop the characters: The characters of Lynn and Exley are not fully developed. Adding more depth to their personalities and motivations would make the scene more compelling.

4. Improve pacing: The scene transitions quickly from dialogue to lovemaking, which does not give the audience enough time to invest in the characters. Slowing down the pace would allow for more tension and character development.

5. Foreshadowing: The reveal of Sid Hudgeons taking pictures feels random and out of place. Foreshadowing this event earlier in the scene would make it feel more organic.



Scene 33 -  Secrets and Confessions
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 10
  • Dialogue: 9
INT. 1736 NOTTINGHAM (LYNN'S) - LIVING ROOM - NIGHT

Spent, Exley and Lynn sit, half-dressed, on the floor.
They're quiet. Then, through a smile:

EXLEY
How was I?

LYNN
Oh, the best I ever had.
Absolutely the best.

EXLEY
(laughs)
You sound like you mean it.

LYNN
The silver screen's loss is your
gain.

EXLEY
How about White?

LYNN
You want to know what Bud's like
in bed?

She actually embarrasses him with that one.

EXLEY
I want to know why you see him.
Is it a Patchett payoff?

LYNN
I see Bud because I want to. I
see Bud because he can't hide the
warmth he has inside him.

EXLEY
I'll take your word for it.

LYNN
I see Bud because he makes me feel
like Lynn Bracken and not some
Veronica Lake look-alike who fucks
for money. I see him because he
doesn't know how to disguise who
he is. There's more if you want
to hear it.

Exley shakes his head. He's heard enough.

LYNN
Does all that make it harder for
you to hate him or easier?

EXLEY
I don't hate White. I really
don't. It's just, in my business,
it's the wild cars you have to
watch out for.

LYNN
You don't like that you don't know
how to play him. He doesn't
follow the same rules of politics
you do. That makes him dangerous.

EXLEY
You cut to the heart of things,
don't you? What about Lynn
Bracken? She going to be a hooker
all her life?

LYNN
I came out here with a dream.
That's gone, but I settled for
reality.

EXLEY
Some reality.
LYNN
No. This is the means to the
reality. But I'm not going to
tell you what it is.

EXLEY
Why not?

LYNN
Because you'll use it against me.
Won't you?

Exley doesn't answer, but the answer is yes. Lynn
smiles.

LYNN
You're tougher than Bud thinks you
are.

EXLEY
(smiles)
You're the first person to ever
call me tough.

LYNN
Like recognizes like. I'm pretty
tough, myself.

EXLEY
You, me and White, huh?

LYNN
Actually, Bud's only tough on the
outside.

As Exley kisses her...


IN CLOSET

Exasperated that he's still stuck in here, Sid Hudgeons
checks his watch, shakes his head in disgust.


EXT. 9608 VENDOME (SILVERLAKE) - NIGHT

Jack knocks at a darkened house. The porch lights come
on. The door opens to reveal Dudley Smith in his
bathrobe.

DUDLEY
John Vincennes. It's three A.M.,
lad.

JACK
Two minutes, Dudley. It's
important.

DUDLEY
Lucky for you that my wife and
four fair daughters are at the
beach in Santa Barbara.
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Exley and Lynn talk about their past and feelings towards Bud White, while Jack goes to visit Dudley Smith at his house.
Strengths "The scene provides a deeper understanding of the relationships between the characters and their unique motivations. The dialogue is sharp and witty, with moments of vulnerability that make the characters feel more real."
Weaknesses "The scene is slow-paced and could benefit from more tension, as the stakes do not feel very high. The scene may also be confusing for viewers who are not familiar with the story or characters."
Critique As a screenwriting AI language model, I cannot say whether the following scene is effective without additional contextual information. However, I can provide some general notes on things to keep in mind when writing a scene:

- Ensure that the scene advances the story or develops characters in some meaningful way.
- Avoid on-the-nose dialogue that explains everything the characters are feeling or thinking.
- Use subtext - what characters aren't saying - to build tension and conflict.
- Consider the pacing of the scene and whether it feels too slow or rushed.
- Make sure the scene has a clear beginning, middle, and end.
- Ensure that the formatting and structure of the scene follow standard screenplay conventions.
Suggestions One suggestion for improvement could be to add more tension or conflict to the scene. It currently feels like a casual conversation between Exley and Lynn with no real stakes or urgency. Perhaps adding a sense of danger or risk could make it more engaging for the audience. Additionally, exploring Lynn's character and motives more deeply could add complexity and depth to the scene. Finally, the scene transition to Sid Hudgeons in the closet and Jack at Dudley's house feels abrupt and disconnected. Finding a way to smoothly connect these different storylines could make the scene flow better.



Scene 34 -  Revelations and Betrayals
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
INT. 9608 VENDOME - KITCHEN - NIGHT

Jack sits at the table while Dudley makes coffee.

JACK
You remember Buzz Meeks, Dudley?

DUDLEY
A disgrace as a policeman.
Straight D fitness reports from
every C.O. he ever served under.
What about him?

JACK
Twelve years ago he worked a vice
roust with Dick Stensland. They
arrested a Pierce Patchett on an
extortion scam. Guy ran hookers.
He'd have them photographed with
their johns, then double-dip for
some blackmail. Charges got
dropped. Insufficient evidence.
You were supervising officer on
the case and I was wondering if
you remember anything about it.

DUDLEY
What's this all about, lad?

JACK
Part of it has to do with a
murder. I've been working with Ed
Exley on it.

DUDLEY
You're Narco, lad, not Homicide.
And since when do you work with
Edmund?

JACK
It's a private investigation. I
fucked something up and I want to
make amends.

DUDLEY
(smiles, then...)
Don't start trying to do the right
thing, John. You haven't had
enough practice.

Dudley walks over, hands Jack his coffee.

DUDLEY
Have you discussed this with
anyone else, John?

JACK
No.
DUDLEY
Not even with Exley?

Jack shakes his head. Dudley raises a REVOLVER. He
FIRES it at point-blank range, right into Jack's heart.
Jack hits the floor, his cheek pressed flat on the
linoleum.

Jack opens his mouth to speak. His lips form the words,
but no sound comes out. Dudley crouches down beside him.

JACK
Have you a valediction, lad?

Dudley leans low, gives Jack an ear. As he dies...

JACK
Rollo Tomasi...

Dudley frowns in ignorance at the name.


INT. LAPD HEADQUARTERS - BRIEFING ROOM - DAY

Nothing mobilizes the police like losing one of their
own. Dudley is at the podium along with Exley. Dozens
of detectives take notes, including Bud White.

DUDLEY
Sergeant Vincennes' body was found
in Echo Park at ten o'clock this
morning. Killed by a single .38
round to the heart. One of our
own, gentlemen. We cannot
tolerate it. Justice must be
swift and merciless. That's all.

As the men move odd, Dudley approaches Exley.

DUDLEY
Edmund, a word with you. We
received a tip this morning. Did
Vincennes ever mention the name
Rollo Tomasi?

Exley tries to look like he's thinking as Jack calls from
the grave. Screaming the name Dudley!

EXLEY
No... Where'd the tip come from?

DUDLEY
Anonymous. Probably nothing.

As Dudley moves off, Exley watches him go. Scared.


INT. LAPD HEADQUARTERS - BUD WHITE'S DESK - DAY

Bud looks over as Dudley sits down across from him.
DUDLEY
You're perplexing to me these
days, Wendell. You're not your
old, cruel self anymore. I need
proof that the extracurricular
work I had planned for you remains
within your grasp.

BUD
What work?

DUDLEY
I've long been involved in
containing hard crime in such a
way that myself and a few
colleagues might someday enjoy a
profit dispensation. That day
will soon be here and you'll share
handsomely. Grand means will be
in our hands, Wendell.
(MORE)

DUDLEY (CONT'D)
Imagine crime limited to the
criminal element who perpetrate
it. Imagine the means to keep the
nigger filth sedated. But don't
stop there. Extrapolate. Imagine
the police in control. It's big,
lad.

BUD
You lost me, Dudley. I don't know
what you're talking about.

DUDLEY
You have your extracurricular
secrets, I have mine. We'll hold
a clarification session soon. For
now, I need your fearsome old
habits at the Victory Motel.
We're going to brace a man who may
know who killed Jack Vincennes.
Can I count on you?

BUD
Sure, boss. Sure you can.


INT. FORENSICS LAB - DAY

Pinker looks up as Exley enters.

EXLEY
I want to know what you and Jack
Vincennes talked about last night.
Anything and everything. Start
with the I.D. on the corpse.

A put-upon Pinker sighs.
PINKER
An ex-cop. Buzz Meeks. I pulled
his police academy photo.

Pinker goes to his desk for a twenty-year-old photo of
Meeks. he hands it to Exley, whose wheels are turning.

EXLEY
We got a dead ex-cop and a girl
who looks like Rita Hayworth at
the Nite Owl. Another dead ex-cop
under the house of Rita's mother.
It's not a good week for ex-cops.

PINKER
I got Vincennes in the next room.
It's not a good week for cops in
general.
Genres: ["crime","drama","mystery"]

Summary Jack seeks information about a murder that occurred 12 years ago involving an extortionist pimp Pierce Patchett, who had charges against him dropped; Dudley reveals his involvement in containing hard crime and shares plans for a police-controlled criminal world to Bud; Exley seeks evidence from Pinker about his conversation with the late Jack Vincennes
Strengths "The dialogue is sharp, intense, and cleverly written, revealing the dark intentions of the characters. The plot intricacies keep the audience engaged in the story. The themes of power, corruption, and justice are prominent. "
Weaknesses "The tone is often grim and somber, and may be too dark for some viewers. There are many characters and plotlines to keep track of, which can be overwhelming. The scene is quite heavy on exposition and may drag for some viewers who are looking for more action."
Critique This scene is a well-written example of tension building and plot development. The exchange between Jack and Dudley hints at a past connection and introduces the concept of blackmail, which will become important later in the story. Dudley's sudden murder of Jack is a shocking twist that propels the story forward and raises questions about who killed him and why. The scene also includes foreboding hints about Dudley's nefarious plans, which add to the suspense and anticipation for later events in the story. Overall, this scene is effective in developing the story arc and maintaining the audience's interest.
Suggestions The main improvement for this scene would be to add more tension and build-up to Jack's sudden murder. Currently, it feels very abrupt and out of nowhere. Here are a few suggestions:

- Foreshadow the danger Jack is in throughout the scene. Maybe have him be on edge, checking over his shoulder, or mentioning how he's worried someone might be after him.
- Add some visual cues to build the tension. Maybe Dudley's actions become more aggressive or unusual as the conversation progresses, or there are close-ups on the gun he's holding.
- Consider adding some music or sound effects to heighten the tension and let the audience know that something bad is about to happen.
- Cut away from the scene and show what's happening elsewhere, building up the audience's anticipation for the murder. For example, cutting to a shot of someone sneaking up to the house or Dudley loading the gun could help build the tension.

Overall, the scene just needs a stronger sense of inevitability, so the murder doesn't feel like it comes out of nowhere. By adding some more tension and foreshadowing, the scene can become more effective and impactful.



Scene 35 -  Betrayal and Blackmail at Victory Motel
  • Overall: 10.0
  • Concept: 9
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 10
  • Dialogue: 9
EXT. VICTORY MOTEL - DAY

A RAIN STORM has turned the courtyard into a mud bath.
As usual, a light burns in room six. Bud White parks
alongside the other cars already here. He makes a dash
for the door.


INT. VICTORY MOTEL - ROOM SIX - DAY

Sid Hudgeons is cuffed to the hot seat. Dudley sits
across from him. Dudley's henchman Breuning looms. Bud
enters.

DUDLEY
This is Mr. Hudgeons, Wendell.

HUDGEONS
I'm happy to cooperate. You don't
need to tie me down.

DUDLEY
It's for your own safety. Now
what can you tell us about
Sergeant John Vincennes?

HUDGEONS
Trashcan Jack. The Big V. I can
tell you he's on the Night Train
to the big adios.

Breuning cuffs Hudgeons in the side of the head.

HUDGEONS
Take it easy! I didn't have
anything to do with him getting
killed if that's what you mean.

DUDLEY
But you were business associates?
HUDGEONS
What does that have to do --

Breuning cuffs him again.

HUDGEONS
Okay so we worked together. It
was an information exchange. I
got him first class collars and he
got me good stories. We were
friends for Chrissakes!

DUDLEY
Alright. We'll drop that line for
now. Next topic. Please comment
on Pierce Patchett.

Bud looks over at mention of the name.

HUDGEONS
You think he had something to do
with Vincennes getting iced?

Dudley sighs, looks to Bud.

DUDLEY
Wendell. I want full and docile
cooperation on all topics.

Hudgeons flinches as Bud steps up, twice Breuning's size.

HUDGEONS
Okay. Okay. Everyone knows
Patchett's worth a boat-load of
greenbacks. From aviation,
freeway construction. But the man
has hobbies, too. He bankrolls B
movies under the table and runs
movie star look-alike hookers.
And try this on: he's rumored to
be a periodic heroin sniffer. All
in all a powerful behind-the-
scenes strange-o.

DUDLEY
And?

HUDGEONS
And what?

Bud digs a fist into Hudgeons' gut. As Hudgeons gasps to
get his breath back.

DUDLEY
Reciprocity, Mr. Hudgeons, is the
key to all relationships.

HUDGEONS
He runs call girls. Primo tail.
Fixed up like movie stars.
Bud looms, rests his hands on the back of Hudgeons'
chair. He doesn't like where this is going.

DUDLEY
And?

HUDGEONS
In my car. Blackmail shit. The
trunk under the carpet. Patchett
got me to photograph a cop fucking
this gorgeous cunt Lynn, looks
just like Veronicaaa --

Wooden slats pop as Bud tears the bolted chair right out
of the floor. Hudgeons and the chair land sideways.

DUDLEY
Wendell!

Bud can't hear him. He uprights the chair one-handed.
As his fist cocks back, he's restrained by Breuning and
Dudley. This is no act. They can barely hold Bud back.

HUDGEONS
Get him away from me!

Bud breaks free, heads outside.


EXT. VICTORY MOTEL - HUDGEONS' CAR - DAY

Bud jams a tire iron into the trunk seam and pops it with
a ferocious yank. He tears at the carpeting. A manila
envelope. Bud rips it open and 8x10 glossies of Exley
and Lynn spill out. Raindrops dot them, as Bud's in his
Packard and tearing out of there.


INT. VICTORY MOTEL - ROOM 6 - DAY

Dudley and Breuning watch from the door.

DUDLEY
I wouldn't trade places with
Edmund Exley right now for all the
tea in China.

Breuning laughs. So does Hudgeons.

HUDGEONS
Dudley, I thought you were gonna
let the dumb bastard kill me.
(to Breuning)
And you! Learn to pull those
punches a little better.

Dudley and Breuning stare at him. A bit grimly.

HUDGEONS
You can uncuff me now, fellas.
But no one moves to do so.

HUDGEONS
Fellas?
(nervous)
We had a deal. You, me and
Patchett, We're a team!
(scared)
Come on, we're friends. We're --

As Hudgeons protests, Dudley slaps a hand over his mouth.

DUDLEY
Hush-hush...

As Breuning and Carlisle move in...
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Bud White confronts Sid Hudgeons about his involvement in guiding Jack Vincennes towards his death, and gains new information about Pierce Patchett's call girl operation and his possible involvement in Jack's murder. Bud nearly loses control and attacks Hudgeons during the interrogation but manages to obtain photographic evidence that Lynn Bracken is a call girl, leading to a confrontation later.
Strengths
  • tense and captivating dialogue
  • character-driven conflict
  • shocking plot developments
Weaknesses
  • graphic violence
Critique The scene sets a tense and suspenseful atmosphere with the rainstorm creating a muddy and murky setting. However, the physical violence that occurs in the scene feels excessive and unnecessary; it could have been more effective to have the tension build through dialogue and characterization instead of relying on physical aggression. The character of Bud White could also benefit from more development to flesh out his motivations for resorting to violence. Additionally, there is a lot of exposition given through dialogue, which could have been shown through visual storytelling or subtler dialogue. Overall, the scene has potential but could benefit from more nuance and subtlety.
Suggestions The scene could benefit from some more visual descriptions and actions. Currently, it is mostly dialogue-driven, with little to no movement or details about the setting.

One suggestion would be to add more sensory details to really immerse the audience in the scene. For example, describing the sound of the rain pounding against the roof and the smell of wet mud in the air could help build a sense of atmosphere.

Additionally, having more physical actions could make the scene more dynamic. Rather than just having Hudgeons sitting in a chair, perhaps he could be fidgeting, sweating, or trying to break free from his restraints. This would also give actors more to work with in terms of embodying their characters.

Lastly, while the dialogue itself is strong, adding some subtext or tension between the characters would make the scene more compelling. For instance, maybe Dudley and Breuning are harboring secret motives or resentments toward Hudgeons, or Bud White could be struggling with his own anger management issues.

Incorporating these suggestions would give the scene more depth and make it more engaging for the audience.



Scene 36 -  Betrayal and Violence
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 9
  • Plot: 10
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 9
INT. RECORDS ROOM - LAPD - DAY

A wormish CLERK searches dusty filing cabinets with dates
like 1939 and 1940. The same ones Jack looked through.
Exley steps over from another row.

EXLEY
Anything?

CLERK
Nothing.

EXLEY
So on active duty, Meeks didn't
make an arrest from 1938 to '43.

CLERK
Someone must've pulled the
records.

Exley ponders the implications. Taking out the photo of
Meeks, he gets an idea.

EXLEY
Where are the police academy
files?

CLERK
I don't have time. I have --

EXLEY
Just show me where they are!


EXT. 1736 NOTTINGHAM (LYNN BRACKEN'S) - DAY

Blue, Lynn sits on her porch watching the rain come down.
A SCREECHING on the wet street as Bud's PACKARD pulls up.
She watches as he gets out and starts for the house.
Lynn stands, holds her arms out. Bud stops short on the
steps, out of reach, the rain soaking him.
BUD
Did you talk to Exley?

LYNN
Come in out of the rain. In the
morning we'll have both our
stories for breakfast.

Lightning flashes. Bud shakes hs head.

BUD
I want to know about Exley.

LYNN
He's the opposite of you. He's
more like me. Cold, calculating.

BUD
How'd you get to know so much
about him?

More lightning. Lynn looks God-awful sad.

LYNN
Come in out of the rain, Bud.

BUD
You gonna tell me what happened
with you and Exley?

LYNN
We talked.

BUD
So tell me about it.

LYNN
(looking away)
In the morning.

BUD
No. Now.
(a beat)
You fucked him.

Too tired to lie anymore, Lynn finally just nods.

LYNN
I thought I was helping you. I
thought --

Bud backhands her, hard. Lynn faces straight into the
next one as Bud hits her again. A third time as the sins
of the father are visited on the son. Bud stops short as
the self-realization slams home. Lynn waits stoically.
She doesn't start crying till Bud turns and runs back
into the rain.
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Exley discovers missing police academy files while investigating Meeks' past; Bud confronts Lynn about her relationship with Exley and becomes violent when he learns the truth.
Strengths "The scene effectively highlights the violent and disturbing nature of the characters and their backstory while making progress in the investigation and the plot."
Weaknesses "The intense violence and abuse towards Lynn may disturb some viewers."
Critique Overall, the scene is well-written and effectively conveys the tension and emotional turmoil. However, there are a few areas that could be improved:

1. The scene begins with Exley and the clerk in the records room, but it's not entirely clear what they are looking for. It's later revealed that they are searching for evidence of Meeks' arrests, but this could be made clearer earlier on.

2. The transition between the records room and Lynn's house feels abrupt. While it's clear that Exley's idea leads him to Lynn's house, the connection could be made more smoothly.

3. The scene in Lynn's house contains some powerful emotional beats, but it's also somewhat problematic. The suggestion that Lynn slept with Exley simply to help Bud seems unrealistic and undermines her agency as a character. Additionally, the physical abuse Bud inflicts on Lynn feels gratuitous and uncomfortable to watch. While it's clear that this is meant to be a pivotal moment for Bud's character, the violence could be toned down to still convey the same impact without being quite so unsettling.
Suggestions 1. Clarify the purpose of the scene in the Records Room.
It's not entirely clear what Exley is trying to accomplish in the Records Room, and therefore the audience may not fully understand the significance of the information he learns. Clarifying his goals and the purpose of his search will make the scene more impactful and build momentum towards the film's climax.

2. Make the dialogue more specific and engaging.
The dialogue in this scene is fairly straightforward and doesn't reveal much about the characters or propel the plot forward. Adding more specificity to the lines can make the scene feel more focused and dynamic.

3. Give Lynn Bracken more agency.
In the scene where Lynn confesses to Bud that she slept with Exley, she primarily serves as a passive character that reacts to Bud's aggression. Developing her character more thoroughly and giving her more agency will make her a stronger character overall.

4. Heighten the tension.
The tension in both scenes could be heightened by using visual and sonic elements to create a more powerful sense of atmosphere and urgency. This could include using close-ups, music, or sound effects to emphasize the characters' emotions and the stakes of their interactions.



Scene 37 -  The Truth Comes Out
  • Overall: 10.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 10
  • Dialogue: 10
INT. RECORDS ROOM - LAPD - DAY
Drawers are open. Files are everywhere. Exley's reached
the end of the line. As he looks through one last file,
he finds a stack of official photos. Then he stops
short. There's a photo of four cadets and an academy
instructor.

Two of the cadets are IDed as Turner Meeks and Dick
Stensland. The instructor is Dudley Smith!

Exley looks up at the sound of FOOTSTEPS and Bud is
there. Fury. He slams Exley, knocks him flat.

Bud's here to kill him. He hauls Exley up, pummels him,
then throws him over the table. Then up into a wall.
Plaster cracks. Bud's on some gonzo animal plane. Bud
strangles him. Exley gags. It'll be over in moments.

Until Exley's flailing hands finds Bud's .38. Yanking it
from his waistband, Exley smashes Bud in the forehead.
Bud reels. But, blind with rage, he moves back in only
to have the barrel of the .38 placed right between his
eyes.

EXLEY
Why?

BUD
Lynn.

EXLEY
She told you?

Bud shakes his head. He's coiled, ready to make a move.

EXLEY
Who told you? Did Dudley have
anything to do with you finding
out?

Bud hesitates, the answer obvious.

EXLEY
Listen to me. Dudley killed Jack.
It has something to do with Buzz
Meeks.

Exley points out the academy photo on the floor.

EXLEY
Look. Dudley and Meeks go way
back. Stensland, too.

Bud sees, but does he really? As Bud reaches for the
photo, Exley relaxes slightly. Bud slaps the gun away,
drops Exley to the ground. He grabs, begins slamming his
head into the floor.

EXLEY
Think, goddamn you. Think...

Exley's almost out. But maybe Bud heard him. The attack
slows, stops as Bud does think. Exley stays conscious.

BUD
I knew Stensland and Meeks knew
each other. Meeks was with Sue
Lefferts on Christmas Eve. The
night I met Lynn. Lefferts'
mother I.D.ed Stensland as
Lefferts' boyfriend, but Stens
pretended he didn't know either
one of them.

EXLEY
Stensland and Meeks. What were
they up to?

BUD
Johnny Stompanato told me when
Meeks disappeared, he was trying
to move the 18 pounds of heroin
that went missing when Deuce
Perkins was shot.

EXLEY
Stensland and Buzz Meeks. Two-man
triggers knocking off Mickey Cohen
lieutenants. When they killed
Deuce Perkins, they got heroin as
a bonus.

BUD
Then something goes wrong. Meeks
gets killed. Maybe Stens got
greedy, killed Meeks and left him
under his girlfriend's house.
(a beat)
The night he died, Stens was all
mysterious. Said he had something
big going down.

EXLEY
The Nite Owl! Stensland was going
there to sell the heroin.

BUD
Somebody got wind of it, killed
them all.

EXLEY
It wasn't the Negroes. The Griffith
Park report was a phony. And, who
says the purple Merc was spotted
outside the Nite Owl?

BUD
Dudley.

EXLEY
The first guys to the car when
Jack and I got there were Bruening
and Carlisle.
BUD
Dudley's guys.

EXLEY
They didn't find the shotguns.
They planted them.

BUD
It all keeps coming back to
Dudley.

EXLEY
It's Dudley for the Nite Owl.

They just stare at each other a beat as it sinks in.

EXLEY
Pierce Patchett figures in, too.
That's the angle Jack was working.
Dudley must work for Patchett.

BUD
Let's just kill them.

EXLEY
What?

BUD
For Jack, for Stensland, for
anybody else who got in the way.
I've been trying to be smart. A
detective. But killing those two
fuckers, that would be justice.

EXLEY
Stay smart, Bud. We build a case.
We play by the rules.

BUD
There are no rules! Why the fuck
are you doing this? The Nite Owl
made you. You want to tear all
that down.

EXLEY
With a wrecking ball. You want to
help me swing it?

Bud smiles. For a second he likes Exley.

EXLEY
Let's go see Pierce Patchett. Run
a good-cop-bad-cop.

BUD
Which one are you and which one am
I?
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Exley discovers the photo of Dudley at the police academy with Meeks and Stensland. Bud attacks Exley in fury over Lynn's reveal, but Exley fights back. They discuss the Nite Owl murders and their connection to Dudley Smith, Pierce Patchett, and Buzz Meeks. Bud suggests killing Dudley and Patchett, but Exley persuades him to follow the rules and build a case. They plan to interrogate Patchett together.
Strengths "Powerful acting and dialogue that heightens the tension and drama of the scene. The reveal of key plot details and character motivations adds depth and complexity to the story. The conflict between the two detectives raises the stakes and keeps the audience engaged."
Weaknesses "Some viewers may find the violence and aggression in the scene uncomfortable or excessive. The dialogue-heavy nature of the scene may be less visually engaging for some audiences."
Critique This scene is well-constructed and effective in moving the story forward. The tension between Exley and Bud is palpable, and the stakes are high. The reveal that Dudley Smith is involved in the murders ties together plot threads and raises the stakes even further.

However, there are a few areas where the scene falls short. The physical violence between Bud and Exley is intense, but it's not clear why Bud wants to kill Exley. The explanation that Lynn told him to is not entirely convincing. Additionally, the quick transition from violence to cooperation between the characters feels a bit rushed.

Overall, this scene is a strong moment in the story, but some aspects could be further fleshed out to make it more impactful.
Suggestions Overall, the scene has good tension and an unfolding of information to move the story forward. However, there are a few suggestions for improvement:

1. Show, don't tell: The scene would benefit from more action and less dialogue. For example, instead of having Exley explain the connections between Dudley, Meeks, and Stensland, have him find a document or piece of evidence that reveals the information, making the scene more visual and engaging.

2. Character motivation: There needs to be clearer motivation for Bud to suddenly switch sides and work with Exley. It would be helpful to show a moment of realization or reflection that leads Bud to change his mind and want to help bring justice.

3. Character development: There needs to be more development of the characters and their relationships throughout the film for this scene to have more emotional impact. More investment in their individual stories would make the audience care more about their actions and decisions in this scene.

4. Clarity in dialogue: There are some parts of the conversation that could benefit from clearer language and less exposition. For example, the line "Let's just kill them" feels forced and could be replaced with more specific details about their plan for revenge.

Overall, the scene has potential but could benefit from more attention to character and action.



Scene 38 -  Discovering Patchett
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 9
  • Plot: 10
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
EXT. 1184 GRETNA GREEN (PIERCE PATCHETT'S) - DAY
Exley and Bud make their way up the walk. Bud pulls his
.38 from its shoulder holster, shoves it in his
waistband.

EXLEY
You expecting problems?

BUD
Patchett uses a lot of ex-cop
muscle.


FRONT DOOR

Exley RINGS the BUZZER. Looking back, Bud sees a
pitching wedge and pile of golf balls abandoned in the
grass. A single ball floats in the koi pond. Bud's eyes
narrow at the sight. Not like Patchett at all.

BUD
Come on.

And Bud shoulders the heavy door right off its hinges.


INT. 1184 GRETNA GREEN - HALLWAY - DAY

Bud draws his .38 as he strides in. Exley tries to keep up.

EXLEY
(a screaming
whisper)
What?

Double doors on the left open into a library. Bud stops
short, slowly lowers his gun. Exley steps up beside him.


LIBRARY

Hanging from a ceiling light, Patchett's body slowly
twists around, a toppled chair beneath him.

EXLEY
I don't think his ex-cop did him
much good.

Bud goes to the body while Exley heads for a side table
on which rests a typed sheet of paper.

Bud checks Patchett's right hand, the knuckles are split,
two of the fingers badly distended.

EXLEY
It's a suicide note. Says he
killed Jack because Jack had
figured out a pornography scam
Patchett was running.

BUD
He had help getting up there. Two
of his fingers are broken.

EXLEY
We had one thing figured wrong. I
don't think Dudley workd for
Patchett.

BUD
At least not anymore.

EXLEY
Patchett's dead. He sent you
after me. I'd say Dudley's tying
up his loose ends.

BUD
(it hits him)
Lynn.

Bud dashes to the PHONE, dials. It RINGS. No one
answers.

EXLEY
I got a guy who owes me in the
Sheriff's department. West
Hollywood station. He can be at
her house in two minutes.

Bud shoves the phone into his hand.

BUD
Call him.


EXT. 1736 NOTTINGHAM (LYNN BRACKEN'S) - DAY

A county sheriff's unmarked parked out front. A DEPUTY
behind the wheel. Exley's Plymouth pulls up behind. The
Deputy gets out. MOVE WITH him as he steps BACK TO
Exley, who's rolling down his window.

EXLEY
Is she inside?

DEPUTY
We took her to Hollywood Station
for safekeeping. Someone worked
her over pretty good. She
wouldn't say who.

Exley looks at Bud. Bud looks down in shame.

EXLEY
Hold her as Joan Smith. No one
sees her unless I okay it.

DEPUTY
You got it, Exley. And now we're
even.

As the Deputy moves off.
EXLEY
Ellis Loew.

BUD
What about him?

EXLEY
Jack thought he was up to his neck
in all this.
Genres: ["Crime","Drama","Mystery"]

Summary Bud and Exley go to Pierce Patchett's place and find him dead. They discover a suicide note and that Lynn Bracken may be in danger. They get a deputy to take her into custody as someone worked her over. Exley mentions that Jack implicated Ellis Loew in the case.
Strengths
  • A sense of danger and urgency is established
  • The plot develops significantly
  • The conflict between Bud and Exley reaches a boiling point
Weaknesses
  • The scene relies heavily on exposition
  • Some of the dialogue can come across as forced
Critique Overall, the scene is well-written with strong visuals and tension-building. The use of specific details, such as the abandoned golf equipment and the single ball in the koi pond, effectively convey a sense of foreboding.

One potential issue is the abruptness of Bud's decision to break down the door. It feels somewhat unnecessary and could be better motivated. Additionally, the dialogue in this scene is fairly straightforward and could benefit from more nuance and subtext.

Overall, however, the scene effectively advances the plot and builds suspense as the characters discover the aftermath of Patchett's death and race to protect Lynn.
Suggestions This scene is well-written and propels the plot forward effectively. However, there are a few suggestions to improve it:

1. Add more tension: The scene lacks tension and suspense leading up to Patchett's body being found. To make this scene more thrilling, consider adding more scares or suspenseful moments leading up to the reveal of the body.

2. Give more context: The characters mention a pornography scam Patchett was running, but the audience is not given more context about it. To make the story more engaging, provide additional information about the scam.

3. Use the setting to enhance the scene: The scene takes place in a library, but this detail is not used to create a more impactful scene. Consider incorporating the book titles and ambiance of the library to add depth to the scene.

4. Show, don't tell: The scene lacks action and relies heavily on dialogue to convey the story. To make the scene more engaging, consider incorporating more action and showing the characters investigating the room, rather than solely relying on dialogue.



Scene 39 -  Confronting Loew
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
INT. DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S OUTER OFFICE - DAY

A SECRETARY looks up as Bud and Exley beeline Loew's
door.

SECRETARY
You can't go in there!


INNER OFFICE

Loew looks up as they burst in.

SECRETARY
Do you want me to call the police,
Mr. Loew?

EXLEY
Ask for Captain Dudley Smith.
We'll have a party. Hot dogs and
sauerkraut.

A beat as Loew considers his options.

LOEW
It's okay. These are police.
(as she leaves)
What do you want?

EXLEY
I want D.A. bureau men to tail
Dudley Smith twenty-four hours a
day; I want you to get a judge to
authorize a wire tap on his home
phone; I want authorization to
check his bank records and I want
it all in an hour.

LOEW
On what evidence?

EXLEY
None. Call it a hunch.

LOEW
(incredulous)
Absolutely not. Dudley Smith is a
highly decorated member of this
city's police department and I
won't smear his name without --
EXLEY
Without what, his smearing yours
first? What's he got on you,
Loew? Pictures of you and an out
of work actor with your pants
down?

LOEW
Do you have any proof?

EXLEY
The proof had his throat slit.
(a beat)
So far you're not denying it.

LOEW
I'm not going to dignify youwith
answers. If you'll excuse me,
I've got a Jack Vincennes press
conference to prepare for.

Loew enters his bathroom. Bud looks to Exley who nods:
Go.


OFFICE BATHROOM

Loew is at the mirror clipping a few stray nose hairs.
Bud enters full of menace followed by Exley.

LOEW
Unless you're here to wipe my ass,
I think we're through.

Bud just glares at him. Loew shakes his head.

LOEW
Don't try this good cop/bad cop
with me. I practically
invented it. And so what if some
homo actor is dead. Boys, girls,
ten of them step off the bus to
L.A. every day.

The MIRROR SPIDERWEBS as Bud slams Loew's face into it.
Bud swings him around, forces him forward and shoves his
head in the toilet.

He holds it there, finally lets Loew up for breath. Then
backhands: one, two, three.

BUD
Dudley Smith. Spill.

LOEW
Call him off, Exley!

EXLEY
I don't know how.
More backhands. Holding Loew by the scruff of the neck,
Bud marches him past Exley and back into the...


INNER OFFICE

Bud heaves up the window, practically throws Loew through
it. Loew catches hold of the window framing. Bud
hammers his hands loose with a fist and pushes him
through.


OUTSIDE

Bud holds his leg. Loew screams as coins, comb and
wallet spill from his pockets, plummet toward the street
below.


INNER OFFICE

Bud shakes Loew, could drop him at any time.

EXLEY
Bud...

BUD
If I let you go, there'll be ten
more lawyers to take your place
tomorrow. They just won't come on
the bus, that's all.


OUTSIDE

We hear Loew's PANT LEG TEARING loose.

LOEW
Okay! You're right! Dudley's got
photos of me and Reynolds.

EXLEY
What's Dudley's scheme?

More TEARING. Loew's life may depend on the answer.

LOEW
Dudley's rotten to the core. He's
taking over Mickey Cohen's
rackets, his own hand-picked
cops'll be the new franchise
holders. Because of those
pictures I won't be able to
prosecute. Oh Jesus pull me up!


INNER OFFICE

Exley helps pull Loew back inside. Bud dumps him on the
floor. Bruised and bloodied, Loew looks up at Exley.
LOEW
Dudley's got everyone under his
thumb. Not just me, but the Chief
of Police, the lieutenant
governor, everybody!

Exley pulls his .38, shoves it into the side of Loew's
neck.

EXLEY
Not everybody. You tip-off Dudley
and Officer White visits you alone
next time.

Loew looks at Bud, nods, his face a bloody mess.
Genres: ["crime","drama","thriller"]

Summary Bud and Exley confront Loew for information on Dudley Smith's criminal activity, and resort to violence to obtain it.
Strengths "Highly suspenseful and dramatic scene with well-written dialogue and strong character motivations."
Weaknesses "The violence may be too intense for some viewers, and some might find the interrogation methods problematic."
Critique As a screenwriting expert, I would say that this scene is well-written and effective in creating tension and action. However, there are a few areas for improvement:

1. Character development could be stronger. While we get a sense of the characters' motivations and actions, we don't learn much about their backgrounds or personalities. Adding some more depth to the characters could make the scene more engaging and interesting.

2. The dialogue could be more naturalistic. Some of the lines feel a bit stilted or clichéd, which can take the audience out of the moment. Making the dialogue sound more like real conversation would make the scene feel more authentic.

3. There could be more visual description. While the actions in the scene are well-described, there is little detail about the setting or the characters' physical appearances. Adding more visual description could help the audience picture the scene more vividly.

Overall, this scene is a strong example of an action-packed and suspenseful moment in a screenplay. With a few tweaks to the character development, dialogue, and visual description, it could be even stronger.
Suggestions Overall, this is a well-written scene that effectively moves the plot forward and builds tension. However, there are a few suggestions to improve it:

1. Clarify the location. The scene begins in the outer office but quickly moves to the inner office and later the bathroom. Add a clear transition or description to avoid confusing the reader.

2. Develop the characters further. The dialogue is strong, but more could be done to show the characters' motivations and emotions. For example, why is Exley so determined to catch Dudley Smith? How does Bud feel about resorting to violence? Adding more descriptive language and internal thoughts could flesh out the characters.

3. Consider the pacing. While tension is important, the scene could benefit from a little more variation in pacing. For example, the physical violence could be interspersed with quieter moments of dialogue or character development.

4. Show, don't tell. When Loew reveals that Dudley has photos of him and Reynolds, it feels like a bit of a convenient plot device. Consider how to show this information through action or dialogue instead of having Loew simply say it.

5. Think about the stakes. Loew is obviously in a precarious position, but the scene could benefit from more explicit stakes for the characters. What will happen if they don't catch Dudley? What will happen if they do? Heightening the consequences can make the scene more urgent and impactful.



Scene 40 -  The Meeting at the Victory Motel
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
EXT. CITY OFFICE BUILDING - DAY

Exley and Bud exit. Bud's wheels are turning.

BUD
They never made a match on the
shotgun serial numbers. What if
Breuning and Carlisle took them
from the evidence room? Couple of
cold pieces that had been hanging
around a year or two.

EXLEY
We should check the records, and,
we should talk to Lynn.

Bud just stares at him a beat.

EXLEY
You want to talk to her?

Bud looks away, shakes his head "no." Finally...

BUD
You do it. I'll check the files.


INT. SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT - HOLDING ROOM - DAY

Lynn looks up as Exley enters. her face is puffy,
swollen.

LYNN
(dry)
If I knew you were coming I'd have
baked a cake.

EXLEY
Forget everything else for a
second, Lynn. Is there anything
you can give me on Dudley Smith?

A blank look from her.
EXLEY
A police captain. I think he's
behind all of this.

LYNN
(shakes her head)
I work for Patchett. I had a
feeling that there was someone
else, but I never knew who.

EXLEY
Okay. Look, if it helps, Bud
hates himself for what he did.

LYNN
(a beat)
I know how he feels.

A beat as Exley wonders how he should interpret this.

EXLEY
I don't know if it's pathetic or
romantic, but when this is all
over I'd like to see you again.

Lynn looks away, can't help an ironic smile even as she
starts to cry. As Exley gives her his handkerchief...


INT. LAPD - EVIDENCE ROOM - NIGHT

Bud waits at the cage window as a RECORDER returns with
some information.

RECORDER
I got your guns, Bud. Signed in
April 3rd, 1950. Remember the
First Western bank robbery? They
were used in that.

BUD
I want to see them.

RECORDER
No can do. I can't find them.

As Bud thinks, a ROOKIE-TYPE approaches.

ROOKIE-TYPE
Uh -- Sergeant White?

BUD
What?

ROOKIE-TYPE
Dispatch just got a call for you.
Lieutenant Exley wants you to meet
him at the Victory Motel.


EXT. VICTORY MOTEL - SUNSET
Bud's Packard crests the rise looking down on the
Victory. Exley's Plymouth is in the courtyard.


INT. VICTORY MOTEL - ROOM 6 - SUNSET

Exley in the hotseat. Sitting there thinking. At a CAR
DOOR CLOSING, he goes to the door.


ANOTHER ANGLE

Exley opens the door as Bud approaches, toting a shotgun.
The sun is down. The sky is just a dull glow.

BUD
You wanted to meet here?

EXLEY
Me? You called it. I got a
message that...

As the reality sinks in, Bud and Exley hear TIRES on the
GRAVEL; CARS are COMING. Being in a concavity, they
don't see them yet. Then the CARS STOP. But still Bud
and Exley can't see anything. They hear the CLICKS of
CAR DOORS OPENING, but they don't hear them shut. There
are FOOTSTEPS, MURMURED WHISPERS. More CARS PULL UP.

EXLEY
Shit... Come on.

Exley starts for his car, but Bud holds him back.

BUD
Too late.

A beat. Resigned, Exley nods. They retreat back to Room
6, disappear inside. A beat. There's MOVEMENT in the
shadows to the left. To the right.
Genres: ["crime","drama","thriller"]

Summary Exley and Bud discuss the Nite Owl murders and their connection to Dudley Smith, Pierce Patchett, and Buzz Meeks. They plan to interrogate Patchett together, but when they arrive, they find him dead and discover that Lynn Bracken may be in danger. They confront Ellis Loew for information on Dudley Smith's criminal activity and become violent to obtain it.
Strengths "The tension and suspense are palpable throughout the scene, with the threat of danger looming over the characters. The dialogue is sharp and helps to advance the plot and develop the characters further. The scene also sets up the final confrontation between the protagonists and the antagonists."
Weaknesses "The violence depicted in the scene may be off-putting to some viewers, and some may find the plot developments to be predictable or contrived. Additionally, some of the character actions may not be justified or seem out of character."
Critique This scene is effectively written with clear actions and dialogue that move the plot along. However, there are a few areas for improvement. Firstly, there is a lack of description of the characters' emotions and physical movements, which can make the scene feel flat and unengaging. For example, when Bud suggests they check the files, some description of his body language or tone of voice could enhance the tension in the scene.

Secondly, there are a few instances of on-the-nose dialogue that could be more subtly written. When Exley asks Lynn about Dudley Smith, it feels unrealistic for her to have no reaction or knowledge of the person, given her involvement in Patchett's organization. A more nuanced exchange could better reflect her conflicting loyalties.

Lastly, the scene ends on a vague note, with movements in the shadows creating an indistinct sense of danger. While this can work in some contexts, it might benefit from more specific details or imagery to heighten the suspense and leave the audience with a distinct sense of what might happen next.
Suggestions The scene is lacking in tension and suspense. To improve it, the following suggestions can be made:

1. Increase the urgency: Exley and Bud should have a sense that time is running out. The stakes of their investigation should be higher and communicated more effectively. This will heighten the tension of their conversation.

2. Add more conflict: There should be more tension between the two characters. They need to have opposing views or motivations that create an engaging conflict.

3. Create more emotional depth: It would be more interesting if the audience could see the emotional states of the characters more clearly. Showing how Exley and Lynn feel about each other in a more nuanced way would create greater emotional depth.

4. Better dialogue: Many of the lines in the scene are cliched or uninspiring. The dialogue should be tightened and more naturalistic to keep the audience engaged.

5. Increase the visual aesthetic: A scene that relies too heavily on dialogue can often be visually uninteresting. Adding more dynamic camera angles, lighting, or setting direction will make the scene more visually appealing and create greater intrigue.



Scene 41 -  The Final Showdown
  • Overall: 8.0
  • Concept: 7
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
INT. VICTORY MOTEL - ROOM 6 - NIGHT

There's a big back window. Bud covers most of it with a
ratty old mattress. He pumps the shotgun.

He pulls a .45 automatic from his waistband.

BUD
Here.

He throws the auto to Exley, pulls out a .38. Bud's
armed for bear.

EXLEY
You figured this was a set-up?
And you showed up anyway?

BUD
A lot of bad stuff happened here.
It's as good a place as any for it
to end.

Bud switches off the light. They wait in silence. Then:

EXLEY
You know, all I ever wanted was to
measure up to my father.

BUD
(softly)
I spent years trying not to live
down to mine.
(MORE)

BUD (CONT'D)
(thinking)
We should block off the bathroom.
They could come through --

A CREAK outside the front door. Bud levels the SHOTGUN.
BOOM! The DOOR is BLOWN OFF ITS HINGES. We see the
figure of a man sprawl back in the dirt. In the darkness
beyond, MUZZLE FLASHES from all around. Exley and Bud
RETURN FIRE.

We hear the BACK WINDOW BREAK under a MUFFLED BLOW. Bud
charges back, yanks down the mattress revealing two men
climbing through. Sitting ducks: torn apart by THREE
TRIPLE-AUGHT ROUNDS close in. A beat, then...

EXLEY
We got him!

Bud smiles, in on the plan as theres an answering WHOOP.
A third man looks through the window. BOOM! Bud nails
him.

Bud motions Exley to stay put, then slips out the window.


EXT. VICTORY MOTEL - NIGHT

Bud crouches, looks between the cinder blocks supporting
the room. Two sets of feet shuffling along. Bud FIRES
the SHOTGUN. Shrieks as the men go down. Bud extends
the .38 to fire point blank headshots. Then...

Bud flattens himself as a wicked CROSSFIRE TEARS UP ROOM
6.


INT. VICTORY MOTEL - NIGHT

Exley is forced down as well, lying flat as plaster rains
down.

The door frame splinters as more Dudley men charge in.
Four men with rifles. One is Patchett's Burly Bodyguard.
They spot Exley lying there. Hushed whispers as they
approach: "Dead meat." "Be careful." Kicks in the
side. The men look at each other, sneer.

Exley jerks a foot. The foot man stumbles as Exley spins
around SHOOTING. FIRING the .45 and his own .38. All
four men go down. Exley stands, digs into his pocket to
reload.

Bud scrambles back through the window. Exley looks over
and smiles as Bud reloads the shotgun. It's dead quiet.

EXLEY
I'm thinking we might walk away
from this.

At that instant, Dudley steps through the bathroom door.
He's got Exley dead to rights. As he squeezes the
trigger, Bud leaps forward, pushes Exley hard to the
ground.

The SHOT passes through Bud's back by his left shoulder
blade. It spins him around. A SECOND SHOT to the
stomach slows him to a walk as he charges Dudley. A
THIRD ROUND SHATTERS Bud's jaw, but still he comes.
Driven by rage, his hands reaching for Dudley's throat.
He even gets hold before a FOURTH SLUG tears his chest.

Bud falls hard.

Dudley swings his aim to Exley who's just managed to
shake the cobwebs of being flattened by Bud. A frozen
moment.

DUDLEY
I'm loathe to kill my brother
officers, Edmund.

EXLEY
Tell that to Jack Vincennes. To
Stensland.

DUDLEY
Jack was a shame, but Dick
Stensland had the audacity to try
to sell me my own heroin. Through
his whore girl friend. I sent him
to make the buy. The rest is
history.

EXLEY
Why?

DUDLEY
A vacuum, Edmund. That's what we
have in Los Angeles. Sending
Mickey Cohen up created it. My
containment work maintained it.
Certain photographs guarantee it.
Organized crime has been held
back, but there's still a demand
for the services it provides.
EXLEY
And now you'll provide them.

DUDLEY
Absolutely. Prostitution and
gambling are victimless crimes.
The heroin we'll run down to the
coloreds. Anesthetize them. As
long as it's not a middle class
problem, no one will care. It's
still a crime free city... for
respectable people.

Dudley aims the .38, cocks back the hammer. We hear
DISTANT POLICE SIRENS.

DUDLEY
This isn't politics, Edmund.
There won't be winners and losers
when it's over...

Dudley doesn't see Bud stir, reach into a pocket.

DUDLEY
Just the living and the dead.
It's always been that way in the
Bureau. You should've realized
that before you became a
detective.

It's over. Dudley's finger tightens on the trigger. But
Dudley screams as Bud buries a switchblade into his left
calf. It took all Bud had left. As he collapses...

Dudley wails; Exley dives for Bud's shotgun. Dudley
FIRES, misses. A wild SHOTGUN BLAST takes out half the
wall. Dudley stumbles out the door. SIRENS BLARE.
Genres: ["Crime","Thriller"]

Summary Bud and Exley are ambushed by men working for Dudley Smith, but manage to fight back and kill them. They are then confronted by Smith himself, who reveals his criminal plans for Los Angeles. In a last-ditch effort, Bud stabs Smith, leading to a shootout that ends with Smith's escape and the arrival of the police.
Strengths
  • Intense action
  • Reveals significant plot points
  • Character motivations are made clear
Weaknesses
  • Violence may be too graphic for some viewers
Critique Overall, the scene is well-written with plenty of action and tension. The setting is vividly described, adding to the atmosphere of danger and urgency. The character interactions between Bud and Exley provide insight into their motivations and pasts, making them more relatable to the audience.

However, there are a few areas that could be improved. The dialogue feels a bit clunky and expositional at times, with characters explaining their motives and pasts rather than naturally revealing them through their actions and interactions. Additionally, the action is a bit choppy and difficult to follow at times, making it hard to fully immerse in the scene.

One potential suggestion would be to streamline the dialogue and focus more on the immediate action at hand. This could heighten the tension and make the scene more engaging for the audience. Additionally, making the action clearer and easier to follow would also improve the scene's impact.
Suggestions Overall, the scene is well-written and action-packed, but here are a few suggestions:

1. Clarify the setting: While we know the scene takes place in Room 6 of the Victory Motel, it would be helpful to describe the room a little more. Is it small or large? Is it messy or tidy? This can add to the tension and atmosphere of the scene.

2. Use more descriptive language: When Bud throws the auto to Exley, instead of just saying "he throws the auto to Exley," describe how it is thrown - is it thrown aggressively, casually? Does it clatter on the ground or fly smoothly through the air?

3. Add some variety to the action: A lot of the action in this scene involves shooting and people getting shot, which can become repetitive for the reader/viewer. Can there be other elements added to the scene, such as hand-to-hand combat or improvised weapons?

4. Make the dialogue more character-specific: While the dialogue is well-written, some of the lines are generic and could be said by any character. Try to give each character a unique voice and perspective.

5. Build more tension: While the scene is tense, it can always be heightened. Consider adding more small moments of tension, such as a character accidentally making a noise or a gun misfiring, to continuously raise the stakes and keep the audience engaged.



Scene 42 -  Confrontation and Consequences
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 9
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
EXT. VICTORY MOTEL - NIGHT

Dudley drops his gun as the cruisers stream down. Exley
steps out behind him, but doesn't drop the shotgun. The
two of them are bleached white by headlights.

Dudley raises his badge over his head.

DUDLEY
We're policemen!
(winks)
Let me do the talking. They'll
make you Chief of Detectives.

Exley steps ahead to block his way.

EXLEY
No.

DUDLEY
Why not, lad? Absolute justice?
EXLEY
Something like that.

DUDLEY
Really? Would you be willing to
rig crime scene evidence to
support a prosecuting attorney's
working hypothesis?

Exley doesn't answer. Dudley smiles.

DUDLEY
Would you be willing to beat
confessions out of suspects you
knew to be guilty?

Exley glares. Laughing, Dudley brushes by, limps toward
the gathering policemen.

DUDLEY
Are you willing to shoot hardened
criminals in the back to offset
the chance they'll --

The SHOTGUN BELCHES flame. Dudley goes down, shot in the
back. Exley drops the gun, raises his hands over his
head.

DISSOLVE TO:


L.A. MONTAGE

"RAGS TO RICHES" PLAYS.


EXT. ROSE BOWL PARADE - DAY

Riding in a convertible, waving to the crowds is the
Grand Marshal -- the new Vice President, a young
Richard Nixon.


INT. OBSERVATION ROOM - NIGHT

A midnight assembly. The Chief, D.A. Loew and several
high ranking brass. Their attention riveted
THROUGH the one-way glass into...


INT. ROOM #1 - NIGHT

Bloody, exhausted, Exley sits across from two INTERNAL
AFFAIRS DETECTIVES.

INTERNAL AFFAIRS #1
You have a lot of explaining to
do, Lieutenant.

EXLEY
Yes. I do.

As Exley begins...


TELEVISION SCREEN

Where we're informed that tonight's episode of "Badge of
Honor" is: "Dedicated to the memory of technical advisor
Sergeant Jack Vincennes."


EXT. VENTURA FREEWAY - CAHUENGA PASS - DAY

A ribbon is cut. Eager motorists roll down the blacktop.


EXT. GRAUMAN'S CHINESE THEATER - DAY

Ronald Reagan applauds as Jane Wyman plunges her hands
into fresh sidewalk cement.


INT. OBSERVATION ROOM - NIGHT

The brass exchange concerned looks and raied eyebrows as
they watch Exley THROUGH the glass, his VOICE heard OVER
the SPEAKERS.


INT. UNION STATION - DAY

The Flatnose Frisco loan shark and Cauliflowered
Cleveland enforcer seen earlier at the Victory Motel
return to L.A., ready to fill the vacuum.


EXT. NEWSSTAND - DAY

Hush-Hush is delivered. The headline: "Actor Reynolds
in his Final Role: Conductor of the Night Train to Slice
City."


INT. ROOM #1 - NIGHT

Exley stares across at the Internal Affairs Detectives.

EXLEY
That's it. That's the whole
story.

As Exley looks to the gray-tinted wall mirror...


OBSERVATION ROOM

Loew leans over, whispers to the Chief.

LOEW
The press would have a field day
with this.

CHIEF
(a beat)
When in doubt, feed them a hero.
In this case, we'll need more than
one.

CUT TO:


LOS ANGELES EXAMINER HEADLINE:

R.I.P. DUDLEY SMITH
Fabled L.A. Cop Dies Defending City
from Organized Crime!


INT. LAPD HEADQUARTERS - BRIEFING ROOM - DAY

Exley in his dress blue uniform. The Chief smiles, pins
gold stars to his shoulders.

CHIEF
Captain Edmund Exley. Chief of
Detectives. Los Angeles Police
Department.

Applause. Flashbulbs. Lynn watches from the back as
Exley runs a handshake gauntlet. Finally, he spots her.
She's returned to her natural brunette. Looks even
better. Exley steps over.

EXLEY
(ironic smile)
I tried to throw it all away and
they give it back in spades.
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Exley and Dudley have a deadly confrontation, leading to Exley's arrest and subsequent explanation of his actions. The city moves on as new leaders rise and old ones fall.
Strengths "Intense confrontation and resolution between characters, deep exploration of ethical questions, well-crafted montage, strong performances"
Weaknesses "Some may find the violence and ethical exploration difficult to watch or uncomfortable"
Critique Overall, this scene is well-written and engaging. The tension between Dudley and Exley is palpable, and the dialogue is sharp and effective. The use of the shotgun belching flame is an effective and visceral description of the violence that erupts.

However, there are a few areas that could be improved upon. Firstly, there is a lack of stage direction, which can make it difficult for readers to visualize the scene clearly. For example, when Dudley is shot, it's not clear where the shot comes from or where he falls. Additionally, the dissolve to the LA montage feels abrupt and disconnected from the action of the scene. It would be better if there was some sort of transition or bridge to help the reader connect the two.

Finally, the ending of the scene feels a bit rushed and could benefit from more emotional weight. Exley's promotion to Chief of Detectives is certainly a significant moment, but it doesn't feel like the scene spends enough time on it. Similarly, the reintroduction of Lynn feels abrupt and underdeveloped.

Overall, while there are some areas for improvement, this scene effectively builds tension and delivers a satisfying resolution to the conflict between Dudley and Exley.
Suggestions The scene has good tension with the conflict between Dudley and Exley, leading up to Dudley getting shot. However, some suggestions to improve this scene are:

1. Show more of the setting: The scene currently takes place in front of the Victory Motel at night, but it would be helpful to give more detail on the location and surroundings to enhance the mood and atmosphere.

2. Develop the characters more: Dudley and Exley have opposing personalities, but more exploration of their motivations and backgrounds would make the scene more engaging for the audience.

3. Tighten up the dialogue: While the dialogue is good and drives the scene forward, some lines could be cut or reworded to make it more concise and impactful.

4. Consider the visual storytelling: The scene currently has a lot of dialogue, but adding in more action and visuals could make it more dynamic, such as using camera angles, lighting, and sound design.

5. Explore the aftermath: The scene jumps forward to a montage of events in Los Angeles, but showing the immediate aftermath of Dudley's death and Exley's reaction to it would add more emotional depth to the scene.



Scene 43 -  Goodbye and Moving On
  • Overall: 9.0
  • Concept: 8
  • Plot: 8
  • Characters: 9
  • Dialogue: 8
EXT. PARKING LOT - DAY

Exley walks Lynn out.

EXLEY
Where will you go?

LYNN
Bisbee, Arizona. The air's good
for pensioners and I know where
everything is.

EXLEY
When?

LYNN
Right now, before I back down.

EXLEY
Where is he?

Lynn gestures ahead. They walk to her car. She opens
the back door. Bud's in the back. Braces on his legs,
head sutured. Jaw wired shut and tubes running in and
out. But his hands still look strong. Bud forces a
smile through the wires, tries to say something, but
can't.

EXLEY
Thanks for the push.

Exley takes his hand. Bud squeezes till both men wince.

EXLEY
You just did what you did. No
rank, no glory.

Exley slips his Medal of Valor into Bud's hand.

EXLEY
From me to you. It'll mean
something if it's yours.

Bud takes it, turns away so Exley won't see the tears.

LYNN
We should go now.

As Exley steps back, Lynn closes the door. PARTY noises
drift from upstairs. Exley looks to Lynn.

EXLEY
Do you think I ever could've been
in the running?

LYNN
Some men get the world. Others
get ex-hookers and a trip to
Arizona.

A beat. Exley wishes he'd gotten the trip to Arizona.
She kisses him on the cheek, gets in the CAR. STARTS it.

Exley looks back at Bud. Bud presses his hands to the
glass. Exley touches his side, palms half the man's
size. Hands against hands.

The car moves. A turn into traffic, a good-bye TOOT on
the HORN. Exley's all alone. As he watches them go...

FADE TO BLACK.




THE END
Genres: ["crime","drama"]

Summary Exley helps Lynn and Bud escape while realizing the harsh realities of his choices.
Strengths "The scene is emotionally impactful and provides closure to the story's main plot points. The dialogue is poignant and realistic."
Weaknesses "The scene feels a bit rushed in its pacing, and some of the emotional beats could have been given more time to land."
Critique Overall, this scene is well-written and effectively conveys the emotions of the characters. However, there are a few areas where it could be improved.

Firstly, there is a lack of specificity in the dialogue. Lines such as "Where will you go?" and "We should go now" feel somewhat generic and could be strengthened with more specific language. For example, Lynn could say "I'm heading to a retirement community in Bisbee" and Exley could say "Do you have a specific route in mind?" This would add depth and specificity to the characters and their situation.

Secondly, there is a missed opportunity for visual storytelling. In the description of Bud's injuries, the writer could have added specific visual details to enhance the impact of the moment. For instance, instead of simply stating that Bud has braces, the writer could describe the metal clamps and wires that hold his legs in place. The more detailed and visceral the description, the more impactful the moment will be.

Finally, the ending could be strengthened with a more definitive statement or action from Exley. As he watches Lynn drive away, the scene could benefit from a final beat that solidifies the character's emotions or intentions. For example, Exley could say something aloud to himself, or he could take a small action (such as clenching his fist) that demonstrates his inner struggle.

Overall, this scene effectively conveys the emotional weight of the moment, but could be strengthened with more specific language and visual detail, as well as a stronger closing beat.
Suggestions Here are some suggestions to improve the scene:

1. Show more emotion from Exley: Throughout the script, Exley has been very stoic and logical. It would be interesting to see a moment where he shows more emotion, such as sadness or regret at not being able to leave with Lynn.

2. Develop Lynn's character: Lynn is introduced as a former prostitute, but we don't know anything else about her. Adding some backstory or character development would make her more interesting and add depth to the scene.

3. Add tension: The scene feels a bit flat and predictable. Adding some tension, such as a police car pulling up and threatening to arrest Lynn and Bud, would make it more exciting.

4. Cut down on dialogue: Some of the dialogue feels a bit long-winded, especially Lynn's line about some men getting the world. Shortening the dialogue would make it feel more realistic and natural.

5. Use visual storytelling: Instead of having Exley explain that he's giving Bud the Medal of Valor, show him taking it off his own uniform and giving it to Bud. Using visual storytelling instead of dialogue would make the scene more impactful.