Poor Things

Executive Summary

Pass/Consider/Recommend/Highly Recommend
Engine: Claude


Explanation: The screenplay for 'Poor Things' is a compelling and complex narrative that explores themes of identity, morality, and the human condition. The script demonstrates a strong understanding of character development, particularly in the portrayal of Bella's transformation from a naive, sheltered woman to a more worldly and self-assured individual. The introduction of the menacing character of Alfie adds a layer of suspense and tension to the story, while the unique premise of Bella's creation and her relationship with Baxter adds depth and complexity to the narrative. The screenplay could benefit from more consistent and grounded portrayals of Bella's experiences in the brothel, as well as more development and exploration of Alfie's backstory and motivations. Additionally, the screenplay could use more closure and coherence in the resolution of Duncan's storyline and the relationship between Bella, Prim, and Felicity. Overall, the screenplay for 'Poor Things' is a well-crafted and thought-provoking work that is recommended for consideration.

Engine: GPT4


Explanation: The screenplay 'Poor Things' offers a rich narrative filled with complex characters, particularly Bella, whose journey from naivety to empowerment forms the crux of the story. The script effectively uses humor, emotional depth, and a touch of surrealism to explore themes of identity, autonomy, and transformation. While the screenplay is bold and innovative, it could benefit from tighter pacing, deeper character development, and a more nuanced exploration of its themes.

See Full Analysis

USP: This script stands out as a gripping and thought-provoking exploration of moral complexities, societal inequalities, and the boundaries of human relationships. It fearlessly delves into the harsh realities of poverty, prostitution, and the struggle for identity, offering a raw and unflinching perspective through its unique blend of compelling characters, evocative settings, and a distinct narrative voice characterized by raw emotions, incisive wit, and philosophical depth. The script's exploration of psychological conflicts and ethical dilemmas provides a rich source of material for actors, inviting them to dive deep into the complexities of the human condition.

Genres: Drama, Romance, Mystery, Adventure, Social Commentary, Erotic, Comedy, Tragedy, Psychological Thriller, Dark Comedy

Setting: Various time periods including modern day and historical settings, Primarily in Paris, London, and a brothel

Overview: The screenplay received a score of 7.8, indicating a well-crafted and engaging narrative with areas for further improvement. The score is influenced by strong character development, emotional depth, and unpredictable plot twists, while also highlighting opportunities to enhance dialogue, pacing, and secondary character exploration.

Themes: Identity and Self-Discovery, Power Struggles and Control, Emotional Manipulation, Social Injustice and Poverty, Forgiveness and Redemption

Conflict and Stakes: The primary conflicts revolve around Bella's struggle with her past, identity, and relationships, as well as the emotional manipulation she faces. The stakes include her autonomy, emotional well-being, and future decisions.

Overall Mood: Tense, emotional, reflective

Mood/Tone at Key Scenes:

  • Scene 4: Dark humor, surrealism, and melancholy as Bella navigates her encounters in the brothel
  • Scene 6: Tense, manipulative, and confrontational as Bella asserts her autonomy against Alfie's control
  • Scene 9: Suspenseful and dramatic as Bella's wedding is interrupted by Baxter and Alfie, leading to conflicts and revelations

Standout Features:

  • Complex Characters: Bella's evolution and struggles provide depth and emotional resonance to the story.
  • Emotional Manipulation : The portrayal of manipulation and its impact on Bella adds tension and complexity to the narrative.
  • Historical and Modern Blend : The mix of historical and modern settings offers a unique backdrop for the characters' journeys.
  • Exploration of Identity : The theme of identity and self-discovery adds layers to the characters and their interactions.
  • Twists and Turns : The screenplay includes unexpected plot developments that keep the audience engaged and guessing.
  • Social Commentary : The exploration of societal norms and issues adds relevance and depth to the story.
  • Character Relationships : The dynamics between characters, especially Bella and Alfie, provide emotional depth and conflict.
  • Visual Contrast : The contrast between luxurious settings and poverty adds visual interest and thematic depth to the screenplay.

Comparable Scripts:

  • Les Misérables
  • Moulin Rouge!
  • The Handmaid's Tale
  • The Shape of Water
  • Cabaret
  • The Night Porter
  • Pretty Baby
  • The Piano Teacher
Market Analysis

Budget Estimate:$15-20 million

Target Audience Demographics: Adults aged 18-45, fans of drama, romance, and historical settings

Marketability: The screenplay offers a mix of drama, romance, and historical elements that can attract a diverse audience.

The unique blend of genres, complex characters, and emotional depth make it appealing to a wide range of viewers.

The exploration of societal issues, emotional conflicts, and character development adds depth and relatability to the story.

Profit Potential: Moderate to high, depending on marketing and critical reception. The screenplay's unique elements and emotional depth can attract audiences and potentially lead to awards recognition.

Scene Level Percentiles
Script Level Percentiles
Writer's Voice

Summary:The writer's voice is characterized by raw and emotional dialogue, vivid descriptions of contrasting settings, a focus on moral dilemmas, dark humor, and a blend of cynicism and idealism.

Best representation: Scene 4 - Dramatic Revelations and Independence. This scene is the best representation because it encapsulates the writer's unique voice through its intense and uncomfortable themes, raw and gritty dialogue, and vivid portrayal of the characters' interactions in a brothel setting.

Memorable Lines:

  • Duncan: YOU ARE A MONSTER. A WHORE AND A MONSTER! You are a demon sent from hell to rip my spirit to shreds to punish my tiny sins with a tsunami of destruction. (Scene 2)
  • Bella: I'd rather you shot me in the fucking heart. (Scene 10)
  • Bella: A terrible thing has happened Swiney. I feel almost nothing, and my empathy is creeping towards something I would describe as contemptuous rage. (Scene 6)
  • Bella: I arrived home and I smelt the formaldehyde and I knew what is next. I will be a doctor. (Scene 7)
  • Bella: As God my father says, it is only the way it is until we discover the new way it is and then that is the way it is until we discover the new way it is and so it goes until the world is no longer flat, electricity lights the night and shoes no longer are tied with ribbons. You see. (Scene 3)

Writing Style:

The screenplay exhibits a diverse array of writing styles, blending elements of drama, dark humor, and philosophical exploration. Complex character dynamics, unexpected twists, and emotionally resonant storytelling are prevalent throughout.

Style Similarities:

  • Charlie Kaufman
  • Quentin Tarantino
  • David Mamet
Other Similarities: The screenplay also draws inspiration from other notable screenwriters and directors, including Paul Thomas Anderson, Martin McDonagh, Lars von Trier, Gaspar Noé, David Lynch, Guillermo del Toro, Jane Campion, Sarah Polley, and Neil Gaiman. This diversity contributes to the rich and layered writing style of the screenplay.
Story Shape